Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Posts

Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#1

Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"My intention is that you should be sharpening much more often, alloy or no alloy. There is no other way to get the best use out of your plane."

First, thank you for the thoughtful response. But I need more to make it functional. Let us focus on some practical task that I do. To repeat I don't plane surfaces for appearance. I am after wood removal without tear-out. If wood goes away reliably I am content, ...maybe too content? Whatever surface is left will get sanded, stained and finished with a finish that builds- conversion varnish, conventional varnish, a substantial build of shellac, etc.

Example- I assemble a M&T frame. I reach for my trusty #5 Stanley to level the slight irregularity at a joint intersection, or leveling a drawer divider. Can't remember what I last used plane for because it was a week or two ago. I plane and a shaving develops. I am happy and continue. If I am still picking up a shaving when I am done I put the plane away for another day. When the plane doesn't pick up a shaving I presume it too dull and sharpen.

So, you advise me to sharpen more often. Ok, you have credibility because I know you face similar planing tasks. You got my attention and I am listening. But you have not advised how I determine when to sharpen to achieve the unexplained benefit from doing it more often. My definition of a plane working is wood going away without tear-out. Is there a reason that I should have another standard?

Not picking up a shaving or tear-out are signals I can see. So far I have not seen the signal you use that comes before these signals that you say are too late for me to "get the best use out of your plane".

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#2

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

david weaver

What you said pretty much covers it, Bill. Aside from Brian's superb surface finishing (where he sharpens before final passes to confirm that there are no defects in the edge), I think he's referring to sharpening before or at the first clue that you are having to influence a plane to keep it in a cut.

I've heard warren say that he sharpens before the plane is dull.

I am not as good of a woodworker as Warren or Brian by a long shot. I sharpen when I notice I have to influence the plane or set the shaving unreasonably deep to get it to take a hold (I notice this most on the jack).

Efficiency and safety are both achieved when you don't fight the plane. Not safety for us as users, that's pretty easy to obtain with a hand plane - but safety of not bulling a plane and ripping up wood.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#3

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"or set the shaving unreasonably deep to get it to take a hold "

Ha, I soon found that is not a course to take for a happy day. :( Even as a slow learner I grasped this fact.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#4

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I read something like this (waiting for the plane to stop cutting before sharpening), I have to wonder if a guy gets a tune up when the car stops running, or waits for a blow out to get a new tire. Does he feed his dog regularly or wait until the animal can't stand up any more?

I think it is a very clumsy and slow way of working. Constantly working with dull tools encourages poor habits and poor technique. I can't imagine learning to discern subtleties of sharpening when almost all of one's experience is with poor quality.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#5

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

I feel that waiting for the plane to stop cutting is bad policy. The blade is very dull at that point and takes quite a heavy amount if grinding to remove the wear. At a bare minimum I would cut that time in half. This is a touch and sense, when you feel the plane is beginning to require force then it is time to sharpen.

Beyond that, you should be sharpening prior to critical work like planing over end grain (even with a chamfer). Or planing delicate surfaces.

Sharp is a factor in minimizing tear out.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#6

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

"My intention is that you should be sharpening much more often, alloy or no alloy. There is no other way to get the best use out of your plane."


I believe Brian wrote this after I had written the same thing ..



I still sharpen early rather than when the edge is already failing, however generally this is further away with PM-V11 and A2.

I mention this not as a statement of possession of an idea, but to emphasise that it is simply fundamental to good sharpening practice. Further, that it makes no difference what the blade steel is - regardless of how long it holds an edge, one needs to hone frequently and early.

I have no doubt that there are those that imagine that steels such as PM-V11 are a way to avoid sharpening. I choose it because it holds its edge longer without chipping in the abrasive woods I work. It's all relative. PM-V11 is to me as O1 may be to you.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#7

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

roger lance

The wit and wisdom that sometimes gets expressed in these exchanges can bring a smile to my face.....this and other recent postings (which were edited or deleted) certainly merit a grin.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#8

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Sgian Dubh

Bill, the moment I reach into my pinny pocket for a lump of candlewax to rub on the sole of the plane to reduce friction, i.e., effort in pushing is, for me, generally the sign that the iron either needs a touch up now, or will do very soon. It doesn't matter much if I'm hogging off lumps of wood or undertaking some final skimming prior to sanding and polishing, the candlewax trick is a pretty good indicator that the iron's probably getting a bit duller than I'd like.

I suppose somewhere in there there's a mix of the KISS principle and the 'don't fix what ain't broke' motto. If so, I guess it doesn't matter much so long as I sharpen often enough and well enough to continue working, i.e., planing effectively. Slainte.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#9

Hey, I'm good!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't use wax. Paranoid it will affect finish. So I must be sharpening often enough. That said, a drawer blade doesn't offer much resistance no matter the dullness. About the only full width shaving I ever encounter is when fitting a drawer. I sharpen when I can't easily pick up a shaving or on the rare occasion that I am worried about tear-out. I think I am going to declare good enough for now and move on to some other task to master, or master better.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#10

Re: Hey, I'm good!

Sgian Dubh

"I don't use wax. Paranoid it will affect finish.

I've never encountered a finish adhesion problem caused by candlewax applied to the sole of a plane. After all, we're talking about a process that is frequently followed by things like scraping and sanding, and the amount of wax that's likely to transfer from a plane sole to the wood is tiny anyway.

All the same, you seem to have the judgement about right for when to sharpen and your planing needs so I'd just carry on. I've long stuck to the simple "plane's blunt, better sharpen" mantra. Then do it (quickly) and move on. Slainte.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#11

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Ron Harper

Please believe tgat this is not a troll or in any way a value judgement. You said " it has ben a week or two since I planed something". If I were describing my work , it would be "it was an hour since I last planed something". I do believe that does color your attitudes about honing My honing method is so quick that I hone often and with chisels, especially, I strop very often. I am pretty much " old order neanderthal" , so my planes and chisels must be very sharp. Before I sold my power tools, I did not hone my hand tools as much as I do now

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#12

Simple experiment

wilbur

How about trying this? Whenever you're in your shop, and you know you plan on using your plane that day, take the plane blade out and touch up the edge on whatever your last sharpening step is (strop, high grit waterstone, etc.) regardless of whether you think you need to do so or not. I'm really talking about a minimal amount of time: 1-2 minutes, tops.

I think you'll find that you'll go longer until you're unhappy with the plane's performance, which is one way of maximizing edge longevity. In addition, since you'll be doing this task repeatedly, you'll get faster at it. And then you won't fear sharpening as much.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#13

Agree, except....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Globally a good suggestion. Except in my case I would be greatly over sharpening. Brian talks about planing a half a day. I don't plane 4 hours in a year fitting parts. It might take 2 minutes to level the drawer blades in a chest of drawers, 5 min to level a M&T joint or two on a case and this 5 min might only involve a few linear feet of shavings.

The only "extensive" planing I do is fitting drawers and even there it's minutes, not tens of minutes. My planing is so intermittent that I can't feel dulling increasing. Sharpening ever time I pick up a plane is way too often. I'll just stick with what I have been doing but I am sure the discussion has benefitted others.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#14

Re: Agree, except....

Brian Holcombe

I'm glad that it has spurred discussion. Though it would be nice if some of the many suggestions were employed. Or you could simply lie to us and say that you are doing so. :D

I'm surprised that you do not smooth panels with a plane after working them through a planer. It's significantly easier than sanding in most cases and if even you decide to sand then the sanding will be quick.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#15

Re: Agree, except....

Kees

Yes Bill, you should extend your planing repertoir! It is so usefull, after sending panels trough your planer, to level glueups that weren't quite as flat as you liked them, to work on boards too large or too small for your machines, etc etc.

In fact, I am so out of touch with the machine woodwork world, that I would have no idea how you can easilly smooth a panel after it came through my very simple thickness/jointer combo machine. Beltsander?

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#16

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When you are doing routine planing and you decide it is time to sharpen can you see wear on the plane blade tip?

My style, though not skill, is most similar to Sgain's. I would conclude from his comments that I am sharpening about enough as I sharpen before I would need wax, which I don't use.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#17

Re: Question

Brian Holcombe

Always, and I remove the wear entirely with a 1k stone in each sharpening session.

Removing the wear is critical IMO, if the wear is retained you will not remove the burr entirely in your final sharpening stage and you'll find yourself resorting to excessive stropping or other method of working around a flat back.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#18

Amen to that statement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Removing the wear is critical IMO, if the wear is retained you will not remove the burr entirely in your final sharpening stage and you'll find yourself resorting to excessive stropping or other method of working around a flat back"

I keep a 10X high quality lens at hand and use it when sharpening everything. Even this relatively low magnification enables one to see details of sharpening and dulling which provide me with helpful information on what needs doing, and how doing is coming along. Wear that has not been ground away and pesky burrs are readily seen.

Off topic, the lens is indispensable when sharpening someone else's knife that has an unfamiliar (to me) bevel. In short order I can determine if my "standard" bevel has overcome whatever bevel I am dealing with. For a factory grind I am usually making the edge angle more acute which can involve a lot of effort.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#19

What's the downside of oversharpening?

wilbur

I don't get this fear of oversharpening. I agree with Brian when he said above that waiting for your plane to stop taking a clean shaving before sharpening is bad practice. That's why I suggested taking some time to refresh your edge before using your plane, whether you think you need to or not.

If the worry is that it's not an efficient use of your time, maybe this will help. As you know, I don't really use Stanley planes on a regular basis. I do have a #4. It's been ages since I used it last. I took my plane, took out the blade, disassembled it from the chipbreaker, refreshed the edge on my highest grit waterstone (about 20 strokes each on the bevel and back), wiped it clean, and put the plane back together. Total time: 2 minutes, 2 seconds.

The edge felt sharper to me compared to before I started. The edge was good enough that I could finish plane a piece of quarter sawn red oak without tearout.

I wasn't trying to rush the process to get this time. I also don't think I was able to do this in 2 minutes because I'm particularly talented with Stanley planes. If I used western planes on a regular basis, I'm sure I could improve this time. I'm sure anyone here that uses Stanley planes more than I do could do this more quickly than I did.

The time it took me to refresh an edge on a plane blade is trivial. For me, with Japanese planes, once I do this at the beginning of a shop session, the blade is good for the day. If the argument is that I wasted two minutes unnecessarily sharpening my blade, I can only say that I wish I was so efficient in my shop that saving two minutes had a meaningful impact on my productivity.

If you find that it takes you longer than I did to do this task, I can assure you that with some practice, you can do this too. That should give you another reason to adopt this sort of practice.

If you're really opposed to doing this each time you plan on using your plane, then try every other time instead. Or every third time. Just as long as you're not waiting for your blade to get dull to the point that your plane stops taking a shaving before sharpening it.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#20

I find it curious.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....that all the responses from experienced planers have been that the need to sharpen has been revealed by some tactile signal, if I understood correctly. So far nobody has said that they look at the edge and if it looks too worn they sharpen.

I asked Brain if he can see that the edge is worn before sharpening and he replied a definite yes. My planing sessions as so short and separated in time that I don't think I will ever develop the tactile signals that persons who plane a lot develop the ability to detect.

If I used just one plane I might acquire the discipline to sharpen before every time I used it (or some such regimen). For example:Son-in-law visited this weekend. He is wanting to learn woodworking. He has good hands and the patience of Job, so he can be good at it. Our goal was to build a set of shelves for my daughter to fit in a particular part of her kitchen. I used a low angle block plane to smooth the band saw cut on the arced shelves, a #5 to shoot an end grain that came out not quite perfect square from the saw, a regular block to chamfer an edge, and a couple other planes for specific tasks I can't remember. He left after 2 days with a set of shelves that only required one additional coat of wipe on varnish and he did most of the work as a training experience.

The only plane used for more than a minute was the low angle block and in the end I could feel it getting dull, I think. Who knows what it had been used for before hand, but it went on the schedule to sharpen when it's convenient to do so.

I am thinking the best signal for me is to look at the blade. I can certainly see a blade getting ever duller because the wear bevel gets larger. In spite of your all best efforts I have not been convinced that your sharpening regime will work for me. I'm going to begin evaluating the "look at the edge" approach. I think it will give me an early warning that the need to sharpen is approaching. Come to think of it that is what I am already doing with chisels, which I use way more often.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#21

Re: What's the downside of oversharpening?

Hank Knight

For those who who relish the Zen of sharpening, and I included myself in that group, the 2 minutes it takes to touch up an edge is hardly wasted , even if it's completely unnecessary for the functioning of the plane. :D

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#22

Re: I find it curious.....

Hank Knight

Bill, like others, I rely on tactile signals to decide when I need to touch up an edge. I think there are a number of them that, taken together, tell me that my edge has degraded to the point it needs to be refreshed: the edge doesn't bite into the wood instantly, the shaving is not contiguous across its width -i.e., it comes off the iron in long shreds rather than one continuous shaving, the plane is harder to push, the surface it leaves is not crisp; and there are probably others that I haven't recognized or articulated. All of these are subtle and occur before the edge is terminally toast. They tell me that I need to stop and sharpen. I can feel and observe them while I'm working. I don't need to interrupt the flow and rhythm of my work to disassemble the plane in order to visually inspect the edge to see if it is worn and needs sharpening.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#23

disassemble?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I don't need to interrupt the flow and rhythm of my work to disassemble the plane in order to visually inspect the edge to see if it is worn and needs sharpening. "

The part of the edge wear that necessitates sharpening is readily seen by turning the plane over (bevel down).

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#24

Re: I find it curious.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I go by feel of the plane in the wood. When the iron is sharp, the plane pulls itself into the wood. I can feel in a stroke whether this is happening. When the plane is no longer pulling itself into the wood, I watch for a stopping place to sharpen. It melds into the rhythm of the work.

Like Hank, I enjoy sharpening.

Wiley

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#25

Re: Question

Sgian Dubh

" ... and you decide it is time to sharpen can you see wear on the plane blade tip?"

I was taught to look for the 'line o' light'. If you can see that at the cutting edge the blade's definitely dull! As to Brian's point about correcting the wear so that you can remove the burr, I think what he's suggesting is taken care of by what I do. When I sharpen I routinely start by working the flat side of the blade on the bench stone, the 'face' I think is what engineers would call it. Work that a bit, then flip over and work the honing angle, then back to removing the burr with the flat face held down on the stone. After that I do a bit of flipping on the palm of the hand - a 40 year old habit I learnt when I was first instructed in plane iron and standard chisel sharpening. Whether the flipping thing really contributes to a fine edge I suppose is debatable, but it's an ingrained habit so I guess I'll continue with it.

I tend to sharpen only to the level I need. That means that nine times out of ten I start and finish with my medium grit stone, which I think is probably about 800 or 1000 grit: I really don't know its grit size because when I bought it it was simply labelled 'medium'. If I'm doing something needing a more refined edge I'll go from my medium stone to a 'superfine' stone, where again I have no idea what 'superfine' really means, except that the abraded metal is definitely shinier than what I get off the 'medium' stone.

That's about it for my sharpening routine. It's pretty simple, takes very little time, and I suppose all mostly taken care of by muscle memory, instinct and signs in a tool's use that it's about time to sharpen, primarily a point in increased effort required to push the tool, the quality of the surface produced, and a squint at the cutting edge with the iron in place to look for that 'line o' light' thing and knicks, which are also revealed by raised lines or small ridges in the planed wood. Sometimes fingertips are better than eyes for assessing how good a surface a plane is creating in a piece of planed wood. I like the KISS principle, and not thinking too much about sharpening is part of that - I suppose I mostly describe myself as a 'sharp'n'go' type, ha, ha. Slainte.