Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

Posts

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#51

Re: Robt. Sorby..

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used Sorby turning tools since 1981. I got a chuckle from reading that they are soft. Maybe it depends on who is doing the turning or who is doing the sharpening. I have had no trouble turning dogwood, persimmon, Osage orange, rosewood, and other woods. Reminds me of the time I read on this forum that my carving tools were too soft for anything but pine or cherry.

Some think they can judge the quality of an edge by the number on the sharpening stone; some think they can judge the quality of the edge by looking at pictures. These are helpful guides, but what is most important is the performance: ease of use, ease of sharpening, quality of surface on the wood, longevity of the edge.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#52

Re: Robt. Sorby..

david weaver

Perhaps it's the tools made after 1981 that are softer. Mine were made in about 2006. They are, unfortunately, not any better than tools that were being sold from china at the time.

The bench chisels are a soft alloyed steel that is spongy/greasy feeling on the stones.

The iron that came in one of the late norris planes that I just got is marked norris on the front and "robt. sorby" on the back. It's actually quite good, so I'm not sure if it is only the recent stuff that is problematic.

(and I have a pretty high tolerance for soft tools - a preference in some cases).

I mentioned this to George once, and he said that he rehardened the turning tools they used at the museum in recent years.

FWIW, I have turned everything with those turning tools, I'm certainly not going to buy more of them just because those are a bit soft. That includes turning a mortising mallet out of verawood, which the turning tools didn't really like. For the price, I was disappointed, though - they are seemingly not that concerned about making tools as good as their competitors, but still charging as much or more.

People would've turned those things just fine with cast steel tools, anyway - it's a desire for them to be better than they are (the newer sorby tools), but not a need. The same people who think you can't turn hard woods with them probably also think every turning and carving has to be finished with sandpaper.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#53

Re: Agree. I look instead of test

North of the Border

Interesting for a day-to-day approach with a scope.

But I must say I have never come across any woodworkers in person who check an edge with a scope after sharpening on a day-to-day basis. I think I saw David Charlesworth check his edge in a video (?), but wonder that is his regular routine; no other teachers I could recall from Paul Sellers to Rob Cosman to Frank Klausz checking a freshly honed edge with a lens.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#54

Re: The instructors of beginners...

david weaver

....they tend to use very methodical methods that involve steps that most people won't need once they have a bit of sense and touch. But they need to be able to bestow their methods upon people who have little or no experience and have them work.

I learned to sharpen with charlesworth's method a dozen years ago, and it worked the first time. I wouldn't have the patience for it now. I don't remember the last time I sharpened something and it failed to be sharp. Once in a great while, an almost invisible amount of a nick will remain in an edge on a smoother and I'll have to uncouple the plane and give the iron a little bit more. But I'd rather err in that direction than over-grind and shorten the life of a good iron.

Such a tiny remaining nick doesn't stop a "test" from looking successful, anyway.

(I never check the edge, either, it's not necessary at this point)

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#55

Re: Pictures from the $12 scope

Brian Holcombe

That is one of the reasons I found it strange, one would expect that the edge would need refinement to survive in that instance. Every other source of info WRT Kezurou-ski tells me they're driving at super fine edges.

Makes sense on the washita to let it work the roughness out over time. Your back flattening is very good, my try is about 2" of nearly perfect surface now and the jack is not far from that.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#57

Re: Pictures from the $12 scope

david weaver

Life is easier flattening backs and such once you've got all of the crap around that you'd need to have to build planes.

I'm sure I just did those on the 80 grit long glass lap, too, and maybe worked them a little more than I'd work them for myself (as in the stone follow up). A blade holder and long lap makes that task quick and no bloody fingertips (used to get bloody fingertips all the time from the shapton 1k). Blade gets hot, though.

I'm glad you've used my planes this long, it's the mark of someone actually doing something with their tools - being familiar, etc. I hope talking about them doesn't make you feel obligated to use them, though. I'm not offended if you find something else you like more. Even I am fiddling with infills again, and will probably do some sticking work this weekend with a panel plane because I have to reflatten my try plane if I thickness too many narrow sticks without doing any panel work.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#58

Re: Pictures from the $12 scope

Brian Holcombe

I know the feeling, and some of the backs I'm sure can be a real mess from the vintage market. I picked up a chisel out of boredom (my wife loves vintage markets) and fixed it up....mostly, the back is the majority of the work now that I have a Baldor grinder and a CBN wheel which fixed the radiused and cambered bevel that seller applied to the chisel (along with likely ruining the steel near the end of the blade).

I really enjoy these planes, I don't use them to the same day-in-day-out degree that I was at the beginning of last year, but I'm not far behind. Bandsawing to thickness has cut down on a lot of the really heavy thicknesses.

I'm working on another chair at the moment, this one with a very thinned out seat, and the bulk of the thinning was done (very quickly, I might add) by jack and try plane.

Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#59

Brand for a quality 10x loupe?


Re: Criteria for deciding when to sharpen

#60

BelOMO 10x Triplet Loupe

Denny

Google will find several sources.