New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

Posts

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#76

Re: Is it possible .......

TomD

I have had open mouths for decades. Just so they don't look weird I have closed mouths on finishing planes but not closed as far as the effect is concerned. As I have mentioned here on many occasions, some of my favorite planes are almost as good as axes. Most antique planes I have seen have very large mouths. Even plane we know used no breaker, like molding planes were pretty open compared to "tight" planes.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#77

Re: Nurse's regulator

TomD

I remember seeing this show about implements of torture. It claimed that the idea of thumb screws inspired awe in people of the day (I think we are talking at least one century ahead of this catalog) because the machined metal screw itself was a mater of awe. They may have regarded it with the same horror that a method of torture like electric shock causes today, partly because of it's effects, but also the idea of the ability of the technician to calibrate the effect, and the sophistication (sometimes) of the device. In other words screws were cool.

It does make one wonder, given the almost entire lack of practicality of screw adjusters why they took off. Could it be the cool factor?

Look at what the little lady, the non-technical fuzzy headed little wife would be slaving over at home:


Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#78

Re: summing up tapered vs. parallel

Nick Abson

I think it is a very plausible theory Steve, although I wonder if we will ever find any conclusive proof one way or the other.

I've included a snippet from Turning and Mechanical Manipulation Volume II by by Charles Holtzapfell which adds some (inconclusive) support, in as far as it implies that tapered blades are the only option for "ordinary" bench planes. We know this must have been written before 1844, since he refers to a patent for various bench planes from Jan 1844 as having been published after the original entry was created (c.f Appendix on page 978).


I have also read more than once that the original Spiers metal smoothing planes - made around the same time - came with tapered blades originally, and were superseded by parallel blades only at a later date, but I have not seen any evidence for that.

I realize there are different opinions about the relative importance of angle of attack/mouth size/cap iron setting re. tear out; but since there does seem to have been a lot of importance given over to mouth size in the old literature (and plenty of examples of planes with patched mouths suggest many users agreed) it does make you wonder what it is about the tapered blade that made it the default option when it will inevitably makes mouth size worse over time (no matter how slowly!). It seens to me that the only logical explanations are -as you suggest :

* blades are not used up quickly enough to make a difference for most users

* users naturally compensated with other measures, e.g the cap iron (but if so, why all the patches?)

* or, as suggested elsewhere in the thread, there was something inherently better about the tapered design (manufacturing capabilities, cost or utility) that outweighed this disadvantage.

I suppose one other explanation might be tradition - is there something about single iron planes that necessitates tapered irons being used?

cheers

Nick

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#79

Re: What are scantlings?

William Duffield

That's the way I've always used the term too, but specifically for furniture building measurements, e.g., tenon widths and lengths, drawer side thicknesses, dovetail dimensions, cock bead thicknesses, etc.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#80

A bit more regarding scantlings

Ian Neuhaus

"scantling" was still a common term as recently as 30 years ago in the bridge and general construction industry and also underground mining where it referred to any large piece of lumber that had a structural purpose but was not of a size to use as a permanent structural element.

Typically scantlings would be used for scafolding and to support concrete formwork, and in underground mining as part of the temporary roof support till the permanent supports, where needed, were installed.

On a timber bridge, the main timber elements might be 12 x 14 and larger, while the scantlings could be as large as 10 x 10. So definitely not off-cuts or shorts.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#81

Re: Forging plane blades, evidence of construction

Rum

I've only done a wee bit of forge work so take this all with a giant grain of salt..

It would be interesting to see the join patterns (both top and side) between the hard steel and soft iron on some more traditional tapered irons if you have them.

The couple i have have what appears to be a definite pattern of having been forged and drawn out at least some after having been welded. What I think _may_ have been done is that two thicker billets were welded together and then drawn out to final thickness. The evidence for this is a somewhat uneven thickness of the two parts and a non-straight line across the top of the join (likely the harder tool steel would be bellied out towards the tail end of the bladed)

This makes sense from a somewhat practical perspective in that its a bit more difficult to forge weld thin stock without burning it (especially if they are of disparate carbon contents), and you can fairly safely do the drawing at a somewhat lower heat. Drawing out does make keeping a consistent width a smidge more difficult but well within the skills of a competent smith. More problematic is keeping a 100% consistent thickness over the whole length. This is based mostly on my own experiences, a more qualified smith may well disagree.

As to why they ended up tapered, I can only speculate (probably incorrectly). The unfortunate truth is that a lot of the actual techniques used in most historical crafts were either poorly or incorrectly documented (the latter being more problematic but quite common as the literary class were rarely the ones doing the work). The timing of the flat blade seems to suspiciously coincide with larger scale automated/semi-automated metal working (and more advanced metalurgy) so I suspect there is something in hand work that made tapered blades easier to make.

There are certainly the obvious arguments:

Its more parsimonious of material (and even iron was historically expensive). this seems like a pretty fair argument across the board, becoming less so as you get to more modern times.

Its somewhat easier to forge a taper than something consistently flat (and if you're a bit off on the exact angle it doesn't matter to much). You could argue that this understates the skills of the smiths involved but I don't think that's entirely fair either, just because you _can_ do something (i.e. make a perfectly even blade) doesn't mean its the most efficient thing to do (and time is money). Narrower blades would be easier to keep consistently flat when hand forged (perhaps explaining molding iron blades more commonly being made thusly).

Evidence presented here suggests that it doesn't actually matter to much in use so my vote is more on some efficiency in the manufacturing process as above rather than any specific advantage or disadvantage to the end user (marketing aside).

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#82

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the context of the many Smiths now days that forge knives how difficult would it be for them to make a welded blade similar to the Period blades under discussion here?

First, could they get approximately correct steel/iron ? Would these people be able to weld it. I presume once welded it would be straightforward to beat it into plane blade shape.?.

I have a friend that goes to these forging events and it seems they like to make stuff. Maybe someone could get a blade made and see how it does. A Period Correct body and blade reproduction would be desirable it would seem?

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#83

Re: Question

Rum

Agree strongly. In fact it would be really interesting to have a couple dozen made by different smiths and compare the differences and similarities (between them and period examples).

The main challenge would be getting period correct steel and iron, although it is still available. I believe? most of the iron was wrought which there are caches of reclaimed material floating around (I don't think there are any modern manufacturers of it and it does behave a bit different than modern mild steel). I'm not sure on the specific composition of the iron, but I believe O1 is likely sufficiently close for recreation of process purposes.

I don't think it should be a super challenging task for most competent smiths (especially bladesmiths) although many may be using more advanced tooling (i.e. propane forges) for most things I know there are plenty of folks around with period equivalent tooling as well.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#84

Under the diection of Stephen Shepherd,

Chuck Nickerson

a SLC blacksmith made some laminated plane blades that met Stephen's high standards for quality and authenticity. This was three or four years ago and the price was $200 per blade.

I passed on it at the time but now I'd be tempted to buy one just to have something for experiments.

I'll search my saved favorites to see if I can find his website.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#85

Re: Forging plane blades, evidence of construction

TomD

"This makes sense from a somewhat practical perspective in that its a bit more difficult to forge weld thin stock without burning it (especially if they are of disparate carbon contents), and you can fairly safely do the drawing at a somewhat lower heat. Drawing out does make keeping a consistent width a smidge more difficult but well within the skills of a competent smith. More problematic is keeping a 100% consistent thickness over the whole length. This is based mostly on my own experiences, a more qualified smith may well disagree."

Forge welding without burning does not appear to be a big deal.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HOKQXBPYLzs

At 1:00 the welding is ongoing no white heat, no sparking, kinda the heat I would use for drawing out.

"The timing of the flat blade seems to suspiciously coincide with larger scale automated/semi-automated metal working (and more advanced metalurgy) so I suspect there is something in hand work that made tapered blades easier to make."

Easier in the sense of less wacks and heats maybe, skill wise they probably don't care. Making a plane blade is so simple compared to what smiths normally do that I don't see why they would be tempted to do a poor job. People had pride back then. The last of the Sheffield forgers said he could make 336 small knife blades a day in his prime, on an anvil. All smiths can make tongs for instance, or hinges way harder. The welding itself would tend to make a blade thicker at one end, so there is that; money, weight, function. Four reasons without much effort.

There are certainly the obvious arguments:

"Its somewhat easier to forge a taper than something consistently flat (and if you're a bit off on the exact angle it doesn't matter to much). You could argue that this understates the skills of the smiths involved but I don't think that's entirely fair either, just because you _can_ do something (i.e. make a perfectly even blade) doesn't mean its the most efficient thing to do (and time is money)."

I think it is largely a myth of the unskilled that you can make rough work more quickly than smooth. I first noticed this with fly tying piece work. I could have made more money if I left the wings off, which then would have made the flies unsaleable, but tying them off badly so they didn't look right and wouldn't stay for the life of the fly was not faster. perfect work it tight, and all the forces are where they need to be. Very amateurish work has the thread crossing back and forth every which way. I worked out the absolute least number of turns I needed to set the wings, and that got the thread lower, tighter, the vectors in the right place, and it was fast. Think of dovetails, chopping them out, most of the pro tricks to make it go fast also work to make the work clean. Beavering away with a lot of cuts isn't going to keep the lines crisp.

"Evidence presented here suggests that it doesn't actually matter to much in use so my vote is more on some efficiency in the manufacturing process as above rather than any specific advantage or disadvantage to the end user (marketing aside)."

I doubt that Sheffield was set up to cause competition within firms individual "shops" (forge by forge) and with the other firms in the same city. The period of the late 19th century was defined by it's ornateness. Even in the US in the 20th century design and pride didn't hand off to an ironically soviet type of efficient ugliness until after the second world war. I know of two stages when ugly utilitarian design was advanced on purpose and in both cases they were arguably more costly. One was the change in beauty of industrial tools, the other was the no name grocery revamp of the 80s. Woodworking tools were at the plainer end of the spectrum for sure, but I just don't buy it would be all that normal for them to be goofed up. Beyond a certain point you have to work at that. For instance every wedge would become a a custom part. Drilling and taping, and fitting breakers would be clumsy where they were used.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#86

Re: Under the diection of Stephen Shepherd,

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Was that Mark Schramm?

http://www.woodcentral.com/chats/schramm_transcript120112.html

Bob in NJ

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#88

Re: Forging plane blades, evidence of construction

Rum

I believe that the disparity of metal types is somewhat less with the Japanese blade being demonstrated in that video than the historical examples I was referring to. I don't know specifically what they were using but I do know that wrought iron is its own special beast to work with.

My limited personal forge welding experience has been mostly with similar metals but even there I had to pay some close attention to the types (i.e. welding mild required a much higher heat than 1095 or O1).. and yes I've burnt up a few pieces of high carbon by accident even just welding similar to similar (not that I'm what could be considered a good or even competent smith lest anyone get the wrong idea there).

Here are a couple of threads discussing the class of problem I was talking about in some more detail.

http://www.iforgeiron.com/topic/18086-any-tips-on-forge-welding-high-carbon-to-mild-steel/

"The high carbon normally welds at a lower temp, and pushing high carbon into the bright yellow / nearly white range will wreak havoc on your grain and quite possibly cause cracking and crumbling."

http://primalfires.yuku.com/topic/4072/Forge-welding-wrought-iron-to-high-carbon#.WBzRTrXu3mE

"Normally you weld wrought to wrought at a nearly white heat, but you know that would sizzle the 1095."

Again I'm not claiming its impossible, nor that it would be beyond the skills of a good smith, just that it is more challenging and requires a somewhat more complex technique. My tentative hypothesis is that its _possible_ that that lead to some visible patterns that would help determine if that was the case in the resulting product and the actual methods of construction used and that actually examining more of those would be of some use in deducing what and why.

The (admittedly very minimal) evidence I have tends to lend some small amount of support to the hypothesis but definitely falls far short of any proof. Getting more direct evidence of welding patterns and possible evidence of how or if the material was drawn out afterwards would be very useful.

I have to disagree with the statement that:

"I doubt that Sheffield was set up to cause competition within firms individual "shops" (forge by forge) and with the other firms in the same city."

At least without more evidence of collusion in pricing between firms. There is at least some evidence to the contrary that wasn't to difficult to dig up:

http://rodney.marples.name/marples_tool_makers.htm

"In the meantime, in another part of Sheffield, Robert Marples, and his brother William set up in partnership in 1828 to make joiners’ tools, but the partnership did not last long for William does not appear as partner in 1838. As time went by Robert took his son into the business and they traded as Robert Marples & Son and then Marples & Co. into the 20th century.

There was much fierce competition between these two companies – they made very similar products and used very similar names for their products. I doubt there was much love lost between them!"

There was also competition with other manufacturing centres at the time, Sheffield wasn't the only place that made steel even in England.

Even if that was the case I think that falls short of saying they would have been parsimonious with the more expensive materials (and indeed given England’s expansionist tendencies at the time the better iron may well have been in short supply at times having been consumed by more martial pursuits).

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#89

Re: Forging plane blades, evidence of construction

TomD

Sorry, there is a missing coma there after the third word. I was saying there was competition between shops in the firms, and between the many businesses all located in the same city. As competitive as could be.

The normal wrought iron used by modern day Japanese craftsmen is old anchor chain. That is the last I heard. May be something else today.