New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

Posts

Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#1

Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

Brian Holcombe

Good morning! Our own Steve Voigt shared his story on my blog. Steve details the trials he went through in becoming the first contemporary commercial maker of double iron wooden planes. Please have a look, Steve and I look forward to your comments.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/10/14/reviving-the-double-iron-steve-voigt-planemaker/

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#2

Interesting.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a collection of wooden planes from a long dead cabinet maker relative. They are all "double iron". As far as I know all the metal planes in common usage over time were/are double iron. It never crossed my mind that the William's planes were not double iron. Given that for the last 100+ years "everyone" has used double iron planes why did Williams, or anyone else, recreate a single iron plane?

Back in the day when this kind of plane was used did the furniture shop make their own planes? If not, what sort of size or scope of business sold them? I am imagining a "Snap on Tool" equivalent traveling by horse back from shop to shop.......

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#3

Re: Interesting.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Given that for the last 100+ years "everyone" has used double iron planes why did Williams, or anyone else, recreate a single iron plane?

The problem was that many were unable to get the double iron to work. And that these people thought that they were such experts that nobody else had ever known more about planes. Here is a discussion from January 2006:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3106/md/read/id/82668/sbj/makes-no-sence/

Here is an "article" from Larry Williams. I read this in 2005 and made it a mission to have its many flaws exposed. I have made some progress, but the article remains.

http://www.planemaker.com/articles_single_v_double.html

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#4

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemak

TomD

Brian, think you may have stepped in it, though I didn't have the time to read what looks like an excellent article. What Steve actually said was:

"I’m one of a handful of contemporary makers who build traditional British/American-style bench planes. However, to the best of my knowledge, I am the only one making the double-iron variant; other makers have focused on single-iron planes."

I don't know if that is true, but it is possible. But there must be dozens, or hundreds, of commercial makers of wooden double planes, and the idea they were ever lost is just some nonsense from the born on third base thinking you hit a triple crowd.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#5

18th century qualification.

Brian Holcombe

I've looked around online, and I have also not seen any other maker of 18th century style double iron wooden planes.

There are quite a number of double iron wooden plane makers (Japanese, German, etc) but given the qualifications in Steve's statement I'm not sure there is anything objectionable about what was stated.

In that specific sentence he does not add 18th century, but I added it in my introduction and he mentions is multiple times as well.

Also, sorry, but who in this context was born on 3rd base and thinks they hit a triple?

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#6

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemak

steve voigt

By "traditional (as in 18th-19th c.) double iron plane," I mean a plane with (1) a solid one piece body, no laminations, including the sole; (2) a tapered iron; (3) an old style chipbreaker, bent at the bottom, not in the middle, and with a shapely convex curve, not a flat bevel. I don't think this definition is very controversial, though I'm sure you or someone else will quibble about it.

I'm aware of two people who have sold a handful of these planes: David Weaver, who's well-known here, and Darryl Gent, a fantastically talented Canadian who posts a lot on Instagram. I don't think either considers himself a commercial maker. But if either of them wants me to retract my claims, I will.

I'm really glad though, that you "didn't have time to read" the blog post, but you had time to write a gotcha post picking at a minor claim at the beginning. Thanks a lot.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#7

Re: Interesting.....

steve voigt

Bill,

Regarding your first paragraph: If I may be so bold, there's a three-part series on the double iron on my blog. That will probably answer your question, at least from the "pro-double iron" perspective. Larry's article (that Warren posted) gives you an alternative answer from the "contra double iron" perspective.

Regarding your second paragraph, certainly some craftsman have always made their own planes. For example, most (or all? I can't remember) of the planes in the Dominy workshop were made by the Dominys. The more rural and remote the location, the more likely that planes were craftsman made (and Long Island was pretty remote back then).

However, the commercial planemaking trade achieved critical mass right around 1700, and the vast majority of wooden planes were commercially made until around 1920 in the U.S., a little later in GB. Until the second or third decade of the 19th c., the market was mostly made of small shops, but after that, due to canals, railways, and the growing use of machinery, big planemaking factories increasingly dominated. There's a lot of good info on this in "British Planemakers since 1700," which is unfortunately out of print and very expensive. I'm still hoping Jane Rees will come out with the 3rd edition.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#8

Williamsburg

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

" Given that for the last 100+ years "everyone" has used double iron planes why did Williams, or anyone else, recreate a single iron plane?"

________

Clark & Williams, and now the successor firm Old Street (with Don McConnell as partner) for some years made planes for the Hay Cabinet Shop in Williamsburg, VA. Historic authenticity--including single irons--is essential to that client. I believe the Williamsburg account was the anchor account for the planemakers, with individual-user purchases an outgrowth.

A few years ago, Old Street announced it had a backlog that would carry Larry and Don through their working years, and they were taking no further individual-user orders.

Larry Williams is best known for his moulding plane builds, hollows and rounds, ogees and so on. He was named several years back a 'Living Treasure' of the state of Arkansas for those planes. The firm at one time made many other types of planes which are single-iron by nature--moving filletsters, ploughs, and others. All of these planes are noted for their exquisite construction quality.

Finally, though this does not touch on your original query, I consider Larry Williams a friend, a gentleman, and as honest and true as the day is long.

Wiley Horne

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#9

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemak

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

I enjoyed the article a lot! Thanks to both you and Brian--it's a fine addition and most useful for those looking to order a newly-made traditional British-American double-iron bench plane. Indeed, I don't know where they will get one other than you, unless David Weaver can be prevailed upon. I believe the statements in the article to be true and correct just as they are printed.

Wiley

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#10

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemak

TomD

I think your statement was true as you said it. I added it to the thread, because I was not sure the title was what you were saying.

Goodness knows how many makers of double iron planes there are starting with the Germans, and wandering on through UK, England. Also there is not much difference in making double planes from single planes in wood. Or double planes in artisan steel (the result is different, but the doubleness is not). It's what the customer or the wood wants. I would imagine a good many amateurs are making more planes than some of the one man pro shops. There are also the makers of blades, as with Hock, and how does one place the production out of College of the Redwoods. Not exactly commercial, but there is a brand, a supply chain, books, videos.

There are many parts of the world where double planes are being made, and as you point out the seminal wake the guys up on 3rd base to slide for home material came from Japan where there must be hundreds of makers, some of the hand guys do a dozen planes a day. And they have volume commercial production. Etc... Etc...

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#11

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemak

steve voigt

Wiley,

Thanks very much, I'm glad you enjoyed it!

Re your comments on Williamsburg, and historical authenticity, I agree on all counts. From what I can tell, the "colonial" period is considered to have ended somewhere between 1763 and 1776, depending on who you're talking to. The earliest documented reference to double irons is 1761, so certainly single irons are more representative of the period.

Regarding Larry himself, I'll just add that while he no doubt thinks I'm nuts with the double iron, he's been extremely generous to me with his knowledge. He's answered every question I've ever sent him about planemaking, usually with very thoughtful, dtailed responses, and I'm quite grateful for that.

By the way, do you follow those guys on instagram? Larry is @oldstreettool and Don is @uncle_chamfer (LOL). Anyway, they keep saying they are very close to being done with their backlog and opening up orders again. And they've been developing some new models…side snipes and side rabbets, and maybe others, I can't recall.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#12

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemak

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

Thanks for the instagram links. Confession: I'm circa 1750 myself when it comes to social media. As in, what's instagram?! :) I'll have to mend my ways and go see them.

Congratulations again on your plane-making; the planes are really grand!

Wiley

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#13

Re: Interesting.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"vast majority of wooden planes were commercially "

This fact suggests that the typical cabinet shop found planes difficult to make, or not cost effective to make, depending on how one wants to look at it.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#14

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There was a lot of reading provided in the references. This question may have been answered in these references and I missed it.....

Why was the blade tapered in these Period planes? Indeed all the blades in the old planes I have are tapered....never noticed before. The chip breakers are thick, well made and tapered also. I suspect this assembly was expensive to make.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#15

Re: Question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In the 18th century the irons had a small piece of steel forge welded to the iron. Once the steel was welded on, that end was thicker and it was easier and cheaper to make a tapered iron. Irons without taper ("gaged" or "parallel irons") were available in the 18th century; they sold for a premium. 18th century irons were roughly 1/8 inch thick tapering to close to 1/16. And they usually tapered a small amount in width, slightly wider at the bevel end. The double irons were roughly double the cost of single irons.

A tapered iron works somewhat better for ease of adjustment.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#16

so....and another question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Do I understand correctly....

The thin steel would be the "tool steel" (high carbon?) and it would extend the length of the blade. The "soft" (low carbon?) steel would be added to increase stiffness and the forging would taper this addition from the blade tip toward the top. If I polished the edge of the blade could I see the interface?

Was this arrangement easier to sharpen...I would think so?

"Once the steel was welded on, that end was thicker and it was easier and cheaper to make a tapered iron" Why is Steve going to extra expense to make a tapered blade? To be Period Correct, except if the blade is not forged it is not Period Correct?

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#17

Re: Question

steve voigt

Hi Warren,

I've heard this explanation before (in fact we discussed it at Hearne), but I have some doubts. One, Japanese blades are made the same way, but they are tapered in the opposite way. Two, trip hammers were used very early on for this work, so the time advantage for tapered vs flat would have been pretty negligible. Three, I'm not aware of parallel irons being used before the mid-19th c, and I *think* (could be totally wrong here) that they were only produced for infills with lever caps, not for wedged planes.

In general, I can't think of a single major design decision in planes that was done for sheer expediency, as opposed to function. So I'm skeptical about this one. I think the main reasons are that, as you say, a tapered iron is easier to adjust, and it also affords some resistance to being pushed up into the mortise by the force of the cut.

Bill, I guess this is an answer to your question, too.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#18

Re: Question

steve voigt

Bill,

I'd like to see some pictures of your family planes, if you feel like posting them.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#19

some comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I think the main reasons are that, as you say, a tapered iron is easier to adjust,"

This explanation is consistent with the tapered chip breakers on some of my planes. If a tapered blade is good adding a tapered chip breaker is better.?.

I actually thought the explanation would be something to do with the capture of the blade in its wood housing. Not knowing any different I supposed that a thinner blade enabled something thicker in the wood part that housed the blade for some beneficial reason. But this was a guess based on no data.

It would seem to me that you people that use these planes would know if the tapered blade is easier to adjust. If the Steve planes are easier to adjust than a Williams plane this fact would be a significant selling point, especially to someone that has avoided planes without mechanical adjusters for this reason. If the effect is so subtle to be in doubt then I doubt this explanation is correct.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#20

Re: Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Will send to your email. If you don't see them in a day or two remind me as I set the bar for absent minded

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#21

Re: some comments

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I doubt that an Old Street and one of Steve's planes will differ in adjustment. A well fitted wedge holding a tapered blade+chipbreaker vs a well fitted wedge holding a single tapered iron should be the same. The key element is the tapered blade. I have no doubt that Steve does an excellent job on fitting the chipbreaker so that, effectively, it works as a single unit.

The woodies benefit from a tapered blade when they are held by a wedge. The wedging action prevents them loosening.

The parallel blade is more typically used with a lever cap, such as on an infill. There is an advantage here in that the blade is more easily retracted with a few taps of a hammer. This is less easy on a tapered blade and wedge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#22

Re: More Questions

William Duffield

I also tried one of your planes at Hearne Hardwood's open house, and was suitably impressed with the quality of your construction and the plane's performance.

I noticed a difference in our methods of adjusting the plane with a plane hammer to reduce the exposure of the iron. You struck it on top of the toe, while I struck it on the heel. It seems that striking the heel would be more effective with a lower bed angle. That is apparent when I adjust my toothing plane, and on your planes with a striking button set into the toe, which way it should be done is also clearly indicated. However, many of my old wooden moulding planes had obviously been adjusted many times by someone striking the heel with a metal hammer.

On another, mostly unrelated question, do you have plans for your knock-down bench you were using to demonstrate your planes? Our organization is in need of such a bench at some of our meetings and especially at promotional events.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#23

Spotting laminated blades

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I find Stanley's laminated blades now and again, and find that, if I get the bevel polished well, I can indeed see the joint line where the higher-grade steel is laminated to the body of the cutting iron.

I clean rust off tools with white vinegar, and have found that the higher-grade steel in a Stanley laminated cutting iron turns black on exposure to vinegar, while the bulk of it gets shiny instead.

My metallurgical knowledge is too limited to know (a) if it's safe to soak iron (as opposed to steel) in vinegar overnight, and (b) whether the same phenomenon would occur in the older laminations.

I've picked up a few wooden planes (not terribly common around here, and thus seen as Exotic, Valuable Anteeks; so I've resisted unless they're really cheap), and in each case, the iron was tapered. I've assumed that it was an important part of the wedged fixing of the irons - two opposing tapers would tighten and loosen readily, and the taper would resist pressure from the cutting action, thus keeping the iron in place. But this has been speculation, not knowledge.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#24

Re: so....and another question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The steel is welded on to the front part of the iron. Maybe 1/4 to 1/3 of the length. That is why it is thicker at the front. On a slotted iron it usually doesn't quite come up to the slot. The weld line at the back is generally kind of irregular because it is hammered out to a taper after welding. You can generally see the weld line on the bevel, the sides and the back, but some are hard to see.

Yes, these irons are easier to sharpen because of being thin and only partly steel, and a fine steel at that. Many talk about O1 steel like it is the gold standard for easy sharpening. O1 is a whole lot more work than the tools I prefer.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#25

Re: Question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Parallel irons show up in 18th century inventories. They were more expensive than tapered irons.