We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
hello Steve, I found this forum via David Weaver, who also posts on the UK forums, and I have been reviewing the many lively discussions you've all had about cap irons over the years. Very informative and entertaining - so thanks to you all!
I actually came across this post when looking at options for replacing the worn out blade on a jointer plane I recently acquired and, having just read in an old woodworking book by William Fairham that recommends parallel blades over "ordinary" tapered irons, I thought to search for opinions here.
Anyhow, I digress. I realise your interest is primarily in making 18 C planes, but I thought you might be interested in a couple of 19 C catalogues. The Howarth catalogue has a parallel iron as an option on all the bench planes, but the Nurse catalogue offers it for smoothers only. You can see similar options in the early 20C Marples catalogues too.
There is one beech species native to North America, Fagus grandifolia. The heartwood is often a little pinker or darker.
European beech, Fagus sylvatica, is frequently planted on yards and in parks. It has smaller leaves and often buttresses around the trunk. There are also horticultural varieties (mutants) of European beech like copper, cut leaf, etc.
Hornbeam is sometimes called blue beech; hornbeam is in the birch family, not the beech family.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
The plot thickens! Thanks very much for the scans! Good stuff. Do you think you could post a scan of the page in the Fairham book where he talks about parallel irons? And do you know when the book was published?
So this is the first hard evidence I've seen that parallel irons were offered for woodies, and indeed, exactly as Warren said, they were more expensive than tapered irons. It's worth noting the dates, however--1884 and 1891. This is very late in the wooden plane era; the last American maker, Sandusky, closed its doors in 1925. By 1884, Stanley was already beginning to dominate the U.S. market.
I wonder if the introduction of parallel irons was a reaction to the growing threat posed by Stanley? It's pretty clear from the Nurse catalog, with the discussion of the "regulator" making woodies "equal to the best American iron planes" (lolz), that they were desperately trying to keep up.
Last week, I got the 1872 Greenfield and 1877 Sandusky catalogs. Lots of great stuff, but no mention of parallel irons anywhere. I wonder if that's a Britain vs. America thing, or if it's because the Greenfield and Sandusky were earlier? I'll have to keep looking…
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
Woodwork Tools and How to Use Them - William Fairham was, according to the forward, published in 1925.
In the spirit of scientific research I followed his advice and got a parallel blade to replace the worn out tapered iron in my wooden jointer.
The used up blade is from Thos Wales - the last date I can find for this maker is the Midland Tool works, Sheffield in Whites Directory of Sheffield & Rotherham - 1911.
The previous owner had created a small leather packer to close the mouth of the plane somewhat.
The plane itself was made by Thomas Turner, a maker that apparently traded up until 1912. Here is an example of their trademark (from another plane, the trademark on the jointer is a littler hard to make out)
The replacement iron is made by I Sorby - co-incidentally it came with a cap iron made by the same T. Turner.
Extrapolating from the worn out Thos Wales blades' taper I calculated that the it would have been 3/16'' at its widest point, assuming there was around 2 1/2'' inches of useable iron originally. In it's reduced state the iron is 5/32''.
So it seems Mr Fairham had a point - the parallel blade is also 3/16'' and therefore closed the mouth by 1/32''.
I then wondered how much of an effect this has compared to the inevitable widening of the mouth that comes from the wearing and flattening of the sole. I worked out that, had the plane originally been 3 1/4'' square (rather than the 3/14 x 3'' it is now) then the distance between the blade edge and the front of the mouth with a full length tapered or a parallel blade would have been half what it is now (leaving a gap of about 1/16'' - does that sound about right for a new plane?).
So assuming this plane is about 100 years old, we could say that the mouth has widened about 1/32'' every 50 years, and that Mr Fairham's suggestion buys you the equivalent in mouth widening avoidance of half a century of wear and tear. Top tip and not bad for a for 6 pence upgrade (c.f Marples catalogue 1928).
I am not sure what we learned there, apart from the fact that I probably have too much time on my hands
the plane works lovely by the way
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
slightly older reference to the same recommendation for parllel irons, this time from Modern Practical Joinery, by George Ellis (1902):
Bench Planes.—The Jack Plane, f. 1, is the first plane used in preparing stuff, its purpose being to remove irregularities left by the saw and produce a fairly smooth surface. It is also used generally for reducing scantlings quickly. It consists of a beechwood stock 17 in. long by 2 3/4 by 3 in., with a 2 1/4-in. cutting iron and similar back iron. The cutter is better parallel or gauged, as once fitted, the wedge will then always sit properly, and the size of the mouth remain the same throughout. This applies to all planes whose cutters are fixed by wedges.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
I have a book that lists the inventories of Period Chester Co. PA shops and often scantlings appear in the inventory. From context I would guess it to be "secondary wood" .?.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
Did you perceive a difference in ease of adjustment or any other difference a user would detect? I remain inclined to believe that the taper was a manufacturing advantage or attribute in the day.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
Scantlings are pieces of wood with small dimensions of width and thickness. In a heavy timber frame building they could be something like a 2X2, in case furniture it could be something like a 7/8 X 1 1/2. We sometimes use the word sticks for these pieces.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
This item is frequently mentioned in the shop inventories. Are scantlings pieces left over from using larger boards like my pile of odds and ends that remain from making stuff from full sized boards? Or were these pieces originally sawed to be "scantlings". Or both? They clearly had value because they were inventoried as part of the "value" of the shop in question.
To wit in original spelling:
William Larkin 1783 Walnut Boards and plank 4:0:0 ( some unit of money); Eleven hundred staves boards and scantling at ye sawmill 4:10:0
Joseph Hibbard 1737 118 foot Wallnut bord 4:2; broken board of Wallnut about hund foot :12: ; Thirty foot of Wallnut Bord and Scantling :5:
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
Thanks for the Fairham and Ellis scans. That clears things up considerably. It's apparent that their preference for parallel irons has nothing to do with adjustment, but rather with some pretty silly (to me) ideas about mouth size.
To all: Nick's math is pretty spot on, but let me just add a few things. Most 19th c. irons taper from 3/16" to 3/32" over 7-8 inches. That's about .014" per inch. To find the effect this has on mouth opening, we divide by the sine of the bed angle to get about .020" per inch of iron length. For most people not named Warren, it will take a lifetime to use up two inches of the iron, thus adding .040" to the mouth. More reasonably, we could just be spendthrifts and spring for a new iron every 20 years or so.
On the other hand, suppose we remove 1/4" from the sole of the plane from repeated resurfacings, something that appears to have been done to Nick's plane.* In a double iron plane that will increase the mouth opening by about 7/32". So the effect of a tapered vs. parallel iron on mouth opening is trivial compared to the (necessary) act of flattening the plane once or twice a year.
Additionally Fairham is just flat out wrong about not being able to take fine shavings with a large mouth. It's been discussed many times here, that mouth opening has essentially zero effect on a double iron plane's ability to either take fine shavings or to control tearout. I can only conclude that Fairham and Ellis didn't do a lot of dimensioning by hand.
Summing up, it seems like parallel irons were something that was offered at the twilight of the woodie era, based on some misguided notions about blade life and mouth opening. Interesting, but mostly a historical curiosity, I think.
* I'll hit this topic in another post.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
I noticed that your diagram shows a 49 degree bed for your plane, and that you also said the height of the plane had been reduced by 1/4".
Quick suggestion: Have you measured the height at both ends? When you do, I strongly suspect you will find that the the plane is nearly full height at the heel; the 1/4" height differential from heel to toe has effectively steepened the bed angle, which was most likely 47.5 or 45 to start.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
....that we only have catalogs from the twilight of wooden planes and remain in the dark as to the situation XX years earlier when the technology to make and fabricate steel experienced dramatic changes?
I agree on the irrelevance of mouth opening, though this presumption seems to be a minority position. Once I realized this fact I opened the mouths on my Krenov planes as well as other planes and bindy shavings became a distant aggravation for my planing needs.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
Japanese irons are the exact opposite, tapering toward the edge rather than away from it. So one would expect that grinding the iron would close the mouth.
Yet the user experiences the mouth opening over the course of repeated sole flattenings, often causing the user to apply patches. For a favorite plane this is practically an annual patch.
So I also feel that wearing the sole of the plane away is far more concerning than wearing the iron away as far as the mouth opening goes.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
It was quite a job, some years ago, to convince David Weaver that the condition of the plane iron and the cap iron of some century old plane might not represent the practice of some skilled artisan. A lot of these planes have had a rough life.
For myself, I think I would wear out a dozen plane irons long before losing a quarter inch of sole on the plane. I can't see losing a quarter inch in three lifetimes of daily use without some strong abuse. If some worker is relying on a very tight mouth, perhaps he might want to resurface if the front of the mouth is not crisp, but for a double iron plane, the mouth can be a little wider and is not so critical.
I rarely flatten and I typically take shavings on the sole of about .0005. I have not lost .01 inches on my trying plane in 38 years of use.
A parallel iron with a cap iron usually has at least as much taper as a single iron. If it did not it would be easy to increase the bend in the cap iron. A double iron with a tapered cutter has considerably more taper than single iron; I don't know if this is an advantage or not.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
you are right to be suspicious Steve, but the plane is only very slightly deeper at the heel than the toe (3'' vs 3 3/64). The real explanation is incompetent measuring of the angles on my part - both of which I got wrong. I have measured again more carefully and do not think it alters the result significantly.
Incidentally, I do recall reading somewhere that bench planes were originally made square, but I can't find a reference to it now that I look. The 1/4 inch lost due to wear and corrections is just an educated guess (perhaps supported by the plausibly small mouth gap that would have originally be present , if my calculations are correct?)
Cheers
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
I think "scantlings" as used as a term in the inventories were boards that were sawed as part of the process of reducing a log to lumber that were not of some standard wide size. So for example, if the mill was sawing 10" flooring boards there would be more narrow boards produced that maybe were sold as "scantlings". The price was right and they could be used where narrow stock was used in the cabinet shop. The product of breaking down these scantlings into furniture resulted in an accumulation of shorter narrow pieces that would also be called scantlings in the shop environment, I surmise.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
"Japanese irons are the exact opposite, tapering toward the edge rather than away from it. So one would expect that grinding the iron would close the mouth."
Not for two reasons:
1) the back of the blade is always in the same relative position to the mouth, because as the blade wears it is it's position relative to the ramp that changes not to the angle setting "ear".
2) The escapement is supposed to be basically parallel to the blade, or in a double the bevel on the sub-blade. This ensures that as the sole wears the mouth does not open. In layout the top point for drawing the throat is taken to the rear of the mouth. Then the mouth line goes from where the tip of the blade intersects the sole to intersect the throat line by either a nearly perp to sole line, or a parallel to blade back line.
"Yet the user experiences the mouth opening over the course of repeated sole flattenings, often causing the user to apply patches. For a favorite plane this is practically an annual patch."
I have replaced the whole sole, but never made a patch at the mouth. In fact if you want to do that, you can simply apply epoxy and cut it with a file. There can be cases where one might have a slightly less than parallel escapement, but epoxy is fine for those cases.
"So I also feel that wearing the sole of the plane away is far more concerning than wearing the iron away as far as the mouth opening goes."
What I find concerning is the wear on our language, and useful words that get tossed into the rubbish heap periodically. i.e. I am a fuddy duddy.
Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker
I wasn't aware of that meaning. With boats, and I think planes, the word means either specifications for structural elements, or the rules that underly them.