New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

Posts

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#26

Interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That someone would pay more for a parallel iron implies that they were more desirable, for some applications anyway. In an era of wooden bodied planes, what applications would those be?

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#27

cleaning chemistry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The black is carbon from the high carbon steel. You cleaning chemistry will only be "skin deep" so no harm will come to the bulk of the metal.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#28

Re: Interesting

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This is getting into uncharted territory, Bill. Bill Tindall asked this question this morning and I answered his other questions and let this one slide. Bill T rightly points out that an iron without taper together with a cap iron has at least as much total taper as a tapered iron. A tapered iron with cap iron has even more. I don't know what the ideal taper is. I have used a wedged plane with a "parallel iron"/cap iron combination.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#29

Why the blade is tapered- Ockham's Razor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

According to this theory the most simple theory is likely the correct one. Faced with welding some thickness to a blade there are three choices- partial length with a step, full length with no step and partial length with a taper. Option 1 is incompatible with how the blade is wedged.

The only significant advantage of the tapered forged blade may be that shape is easiest to make when the thickness of the blade is increased by forging on some more metal.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#30

Re: Question

steve voigt

"Parallel irons show up in 18th century inventories. They were more expensive than tapered irons."

Hi Warren,

This morning I combed through the 1791 and 1800 Gabriel inventories, by far the largest and most complete tool inventories (as far as I know). I don't see any reference to parallel irons. Whelan doesn't mention them either. The only mention that I can find is in Garret Hack's book, but he gives no reference, just states that both (tapered and parallel) were available; it's not clear what century he's talking about or whether they're for wedged or infill or cast planes. Joel M. mentions the parallel irons in a blog post, but only in connection with infills, and he claims they are less expensive than tapered irons (but no reference for that unfortunately).

Do you know of references, inventories, etc. that discuss these parallel irons?

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#31

Re: Why the blade is tapered- Ockham's Razor

steve voigt

I wish Dave Weaver were still posting here (but I think Axe-Ghazi may have driven him off). He'd point to your post, Bill, as a classic example of the engineer's approach--the idea that we can sit down at the kitchen table and in a few minutes of hard thinking come up with the solution, without any historical context or practical experience, because we're so much smarter than those 18th century idiots (who somehow managed to make Goddard-Townsend secretaries and the like without any power tools, in less time than it would take most of us to do it with table saws and Dominoes).

If I remember right (and apologies if I don't), you have little to no experience with wooden planes. Which is fine, but then I'm not sure how you can confidently assert that "the only significant advantage…may be that shape is easiest to make…"

Derek, who both uses and makes wedged planes, already explained some of the advantages in use, as did I. I would suggest, at a minimum, that someone should at least be practiced in using and adjusting wooden planes, as Derek is, before confidently stating that the only reason for tapered blades is that they were easy to make. Even better, try (as I have) making some planes with and without tapered irons before claiming to know the answer.

Historical context is important, too. If there's one thing that's constant in 18th c. work, it's that labor is cheap and materials are expensive. Toolmakers routinely went to insane lengths to make tools work even a little bit better. Taper grinding of saw blades is a good example. It's modern makers who do it the easy way. Seen in that light, it doesn't seem very likely that such a major decision would be made only because it saved workmen a few minutes.

Ockham's razor is a useful concept. For example, when someone asserts that double irons were a massive conspiracy to foist an inferior product on a gullible public, I like to cite Ockam's razor and suggest that maybe the simpler explanation--that workmen actually preferred double irons--is probably correct. But if the simplest solution is a simplistic solution, I wouldn't think that it's automatically correct.

The fact is, for at least 300 years, nearly all irons for wedged planes were tapered. It's hard to believe that through all that time, and all those changes in manufacturing methods, makers would have kept doing that only to make the work go a little bit faster. It's been asserted here that parallel irons were also made, and were more expensive, but I've seen no evidence supporting that. If someone can supply evidence, I'm happy to consider it.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#32

Another question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

To all,

Somewhere along the line I have picked up the notion--and it's only a notion--that parallel irons came about concurrent with changes in steel-making, maybe the Bessemer process, but in any case a time when standard steelmaking produced sheet steel in quantity, and heat-treated it in larger batches than before. In otber words, it became cheaper or more efficient to produce and heat-treat solid steel blades than laminated ones.

Is this more or less right, or more or less wrong?

Wiley

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#33

David Weaver

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Steve and all,

I certainly miss David's comments, and hope all is well with him. I didn't follow that ax thread, so don't know what happened there other than that it terminated in a Moderator caution.

So I hope to see David again here :) .

Wiley

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#34

Re: David Weaver

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, David is fine. I was not aware that he no longer posted here. He is a regular on the UK and Australian fori.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#35

Re: Another question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wiley, I have a question that goes along with yours.

In my understanding, there have been two reasons for laminating steel blades. The first is the method used by the Japanese (and others), where the blade is made up of a very hard thin cutting layer and a soft iron backing. This design is not intended to maximise the use of expensive steel, but is an integrated package that relies on the soft iron to control the hard steel.

The other method is the Western steel blades we have been discussing above. These may be tapered or parallel. They may be planes or chisels. The design motive here appears to have been economy - that is, a softer steel backing is used to extend the harder, purer steel for reasons of expense.

If it is so that the Western laminations came about as a result of their being cheaper to produce, why would they be considered any better than later non-laminated blades using the same steel? I am thinking of the Stanley laminated blades as a more recent example of this (I am not comparing vintage and modern steels here). The only advantage I can think of is that they would be easier to sharpen on the full bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#36

Re: Another question

steve voigt

Derek,

Since I am on a kick for evidence today, what evidence is there that Japanese toolmakers had a totally different motivation than Westerners, for what is a very similar product? I don't have any evidence either, but what little I know about Japanese toolmaking and culture doesn't support your claim. The process for making tool steel, no matter where, was extremely laborious before the late 19th c. And as an island nation, Japan has had to be frugal with natural resources…so my best guess is that they had the same motivation as Westerners to make laminated tools--to save valuable material.

But the original motivation--whatever it is--doesn't prove anything about whether laminated tools are better, worse or the same. I'll stay away from that question as I don't want to stir up any more hornet's nests, but it's a separate question from "why did they do it in the first place?" Maybe something done for economic reasons has additional benefits, maybe it doesn't--but there's no necessary link between the two.

I have to chuckle though; I'm reminded of the expat on SMC who likes to wax poetic about the wood used for Japanese planes, while insisting that Western makers only used beech because it was cheap and plentiful. Why Japanese planemakers were so altruistic, while Westerners were so venal, has never been explained to me.

But man, those early Western planemakers must've been some lazy, selfish, shiftless bastards! They used crap wood because it was cheap; they used tapered irons because it was "the easy way"; they used laminated irons only because they were cheaper; they oriented the grain on their wedges all wrong, and they ripped off the public with those nefarious double irons! What assholes! Jeez, only an idiot would want to use a traditional wooden plane! :D

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#37

Re: More Questions

steve voigt

William,

Sorry I didn't see your reply until now. You can strike the heel, or in front of the mortise, whether there's a strike button or not. I don't think it matters, and there is plenty of evidence, as you note, that people have done it both ways for a very long time.

I'm glad you liked my bench. I don't have plans, but I can describe it, it's very simple:

- the tops are roughly 8" x 3.5" x 60". They were laminated from SYP 2" x 10" x 10's from the home depot. The center divider was laminated from 3 layers of 3/4" thick material, also SYP.

- the base is just two leg assemblies and two stretchers to connect the leg assemblies. It differs from a traditional roubo in that the leg assemblies have both upper and lower stretchers. The upper stretchers are there so I can screw through them into the top. The legs have tenons that fit into the tops; the screws are just insurance. The leg assemblies bolt to the long stretchers with the Benchcrafted hardware, which I highly recommend.

Hope that helps.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#38

Actually, I have a passing acquaintance

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



Shown are the wooden planes I own and use, except a for long one I sold recently. Not surprisingly, given my reputation for cheap, I make the wooden planes I use. I used to have a wholesale account with Hock and got my blades at a large discount.

The three smaller ones are bedded at 35, 45 and 50 degrees. Two are "missing' blades because for some reason they rust when kept in these woods, maybe another reason to choose beech. I have to store these blades separate from the planes.

All have blades with parallel faces except the one that obviously doesn't. I have never had a problem securing blades in these planes. This factor is not a matter of whether some configuration is better or not. Either the blade is secure or it isn't and it doesn't take years of planing experience to know if the blade slips. If Hock parallel faced blades slipped he would not have a Krenov blade business, nor Finck. Hence, for this kind of plane your claim that a tapered blade holds more securely is proven false.

I do have issues adjusting these planes in tiny increments and for this reason I remain curious if the claim of "easier to adjust" is valid for a tapered blade. I have presumed my adjustment issues result for insufficient persistence. I would be interested if others find that tapered blades on a chip breaker plane are easier to adjust. It would be some expense to grind the blades to a taper but I would do it if there was , to quote an earlier post, a "significant" difference.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#39

Re: Another question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I agree, Steve, that there are people who start with the assumption that Japanese tools are superior. It would never occur to them to look for ways in which French or English (or other) tools are more sophisticated. Many are making comparisons while wholly ignorant of 18th century technique with our tools.

I remember Todd Hughes reply to Larry Williams suggestion that double iron planes were less labor intensive: Todd had made double irons and he suggested Larry give it a try. It certainly looks like tapered irons are cheaper to make, but I am confident that woodworkers in the era 1770- 1820 demanded and received high quality. If the tapered irons were not adequate, whether cheaper or more expensive, they would not have been produced. Cabinetmakers in that era had no trouble paying extra for double iron planes and they did it because they were higher quality. And for myself, laminated irons are more desirable, even if they happen to be more expensive. I cannot imagine that 18th century workers would feel any differently.

I have produced a fair number of references over the years, but I am sorry I cannot recall the parallel iron references or even just what these irons were called in historic times.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#40

Another factor

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I think as a practical matter, the geometry of the wedge, including the way it is captured in the plane body—by cross-pin or abutments—will be more important than whether the blade or blade sandwich is tapered or parallel. And indeed in Japanese planes, where the main iron is its own ‘wedge’, it is tapered the other way.

A key factor which is not much discussed on these pages is whether the wedge is ‘sprung’ or not, and related to this, how much force is required to set the wedge (it shouldn’t be much). I took 6 or 7 Japanese irons from two different smiths, Mr. Kanda and one other, and mic’ed them for spring. They all had from 1 to 3 thousandths of spring, such that when the blade is tapped into cutting position, the blade flattens out in the abutments, and is held tightly with not much applied hammer force to set it, and held independently of the sub-blade which serves only as a chipbreaker. The slight spring means that one doesn't require a zero-clearance fit to have a good fit.

Similarly, many who use wooden bench planes featuring abutments, will scrape just a whisker biscuit of hollow into the underside of the forks of the wedge. The same technique can be used on plough plane wedges, or moulding plane wedges. You end up with a wedge which is easily set—almost with finger pressure—and can be extracted without beating big dents into the plane body (by the way, I admire Steve Voigt’s strike buttons).

The traditional plane made by Steve, featuring abutments, is conducive to a wedge whose forks can be 'tuned' for great ease of setting and extraction. It became traditional for a reason.

Bill, on your planes, the wedge is captured by a pin, and is sort of a short block in shape. Though the aspect ratio of length to thickness is not very permissive, I wonder whether some degree of spring can be worked into the wedge, to see if that helps the situation.

Wiley

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#41

Re: Actually, I have a passing acquaintance

steve voigt

Bill,

I'm glad to see you have some experience with wooden planes. My apologies for assuming otherwise.

But no, you haven't "proven my claim false." All you've shown is that your irons don't slip under the force that you apply to them. You haven't tested, in any way, shape, or form, whether tapered irons hold more securely. To do that, you would have to make two identical planes, one with a tapered and one with a parallel iron, push them both to failure, and record how much force it for each to fail. Have you done that?

By the way, you are distorting what I said. I wrote that "a tapered iron is easier to adjust, and it also affords some resistance to being pushed up into the mortise by the force of the cut." In later posts, I gave a whole raft of additional reasons for why I didn't think that simple economics explained why irons were tapered. You've ignored all those reasons, twice, and are cherry-picking (and distorting) one thing I said. So, I'll leave you to it. It's no concern of mine if you think that tapered irons are better or worse. Think whatever you want.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#42

Re: Another question

steve voigt

Thanks for the reply, Warren. If you should find any references to parallel iron, I would love to see them…I am happy to be proved wrong, as long as I learn something in the bargain!

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#43

Re: Another factor

steve voigt

Wiley,

Very interesting about the "spring" in your Japanese irons. I didn't know about that…

A double iron will always have spring on both the beveled side of the cutter and the top of the cap iron. A single iron may or may not be flat, but the bed will always be scraped so that the iron contacts the bed primarily at the top and bottom. Larry does that in his molding plane video, and I assume he does it in his bench planes. Every infill maker (Raney, Konrad, Ron Brese) that I know of does the same thing by different means.

I agree with you, though, that the more important factor is the geometry of the wedge. Also, Warren is right that an old-style cap iron mated with a parallel iron effectively functions as a tapered iron, whereas with some of the cap irons made today, this is not true.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#44

Re: Another question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Since I am on a kick for evidence today, what evidence is there that Japanese toolmakers had a totally different motivation than Westerners, for what is a very similar product? I don't have any evidence either, but what little I know about Japanese toolmaking and culture doesn't support your claim. The process for making tool steel, no matter where, was extremely laborious before the late 19th c. And as an island nation, Japan has had to be frugal with natural resources…so my best guess is that they had the same motivation as Westerners to make laminated tools--to save valuable material.

Hi Steve

My comments were suppositions based on logic. They fuel questions. I am inquisitive :)

You may be correct that laminated steel blades began in Japan, as they did elsewhere, for reasons of economy. However the design characteristics are different from any Western laminated blade I have. One could not use a Japanese blade made entirely of the cutting layer - it would be too brittle. The soft backing is not to make up bulk; it is to add support and flex.

Could we say the same for Western (USA and European) laminated blades? I don't know the answer. My use to date indicates that this cutting layer steel is not hard like the Japanese (and folded with a hammer), only that it is high carbon.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#45

Re: Williamsburg

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been studying double iron planes, both their use and their history since 1973. I made my first double iron plane in 1975. I have been visiting Williamsburg since 1963; I now go every year.

I think it likely that the Hay shop used double iron planes in 1775, which is their target year.

If one wants to talk about "historical authenticity" consider the fact that the Hay shop now uses moulding planes that look like they were bought as a set in 1740, too early, side by side with smoothing planes that look like they were made in the 19th century, too late. For a prosperous and sophisticated shop in a setting where there was easy access to English trade, this is kind of peculiar.

For myself I think the important thing (at Williamsburg this has improved quite a bit over the last 50 years) is the fact that they are actually making 18th century furniture by hand. They are putting themselves in the place of the 18th century craftsman. And attempting to rediscover and communicate 18th century techniques, aesthetics, and attitudes. And they are committed to studying the historic furniture and tools from their fine collection. Whether every i is dotted and every t crossed is not important in the larger scheme.

There are guys who make reproductions by machine and then go to some trouble

and expense to get just the right "period appropriate" nails to fasten the back boards. Of course the thing still looks like it was made by machine. And often 21st century aesthetics creep in. These people dot the i, but miss the larger picture.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#46

Re: Question

TomD

I don't personally find tapered Irons all that much easier to adjust, though it is commonly said. It is true they are easier if one goofs the initial set and just needs to keep whaming on them. Also easier if the plane isn't properly set up and you end up with a wedged up unit that there is little way to shift.

It would be odd that the parallel irons were more expensive if the tapered where better, and in most regards harder to fashion, or no easier anyway.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#47

Re: A few thoughts

TomD

I have a another rule which is if something is done in a spectrum of ways, often the middle way is as good as any. So we have canoes that are fattest ahead of, or to the rear of center. There are reasons for both, but sometime one wants a general purpose boat and fattest at the middle also works. The same with parallel blades, there are reasons they taper in either direction, but at a minimum it gets tough to argue one or the other ways is uniquely better.

One story that is told about Japanese tools is that there was a period around their greatest perfection when swordsmiths had moved into producing articles of general manufacture.Since swords were of the highest manufacturing priority ( up till that point). The idea that they were saving materials would not have been heavy in their culture when they already accepted the superiority of laminated construction. I think western workers are often attracted to this ethos in Japanese tools and culture. With Samurai being attached to every imaginable product, so it could just be their equivalent of "space age", though I never really bought into these explanations one way or another.

One thing today is that we have surface grinders to make tapered blades in any taper that one likes. Most of the antique blades I have seen do not hold the taper very accurately, and to boot are often pretty banged up on the trailing edge. Parallel blades that are dead nuts may be different than planes of older manufacture that were not held to tolerance.

One test that I am not aware of is that in which two groups are given vintage tools with odd features such as eyes and so forth. But the tools received by one of these groups would work really well but be faked up. Whether upon return to these groups several years, or decades down the road, each would come up with specific reasons for all the features and doo dahs based on rational analysis. If the trial was extended to other cultures would all the explanation take on culture specific aspects.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#48

Economics and wedges

wilbur

Answering here because Steve’s question is a good lead in, although there are other entry points:

“Since I am on a kick for evidence today, what evidence is there that Japanese toolmakers had a totally different motivation than Westerners, for what is a very similar product?”

My feeling is that both Japanese and western toolmakers made laminated edge tools because it was the better way to make a good tool. The better question, I think, is to ask why did the western woodworking world move away from laminated tools and towards making edge tools with just one type of steel.

I think the answer lies in the Industrial Revolution, and the mechanization of tool production. Making a laminated edge tool isn’t something you can automate very easily. If you’re designing machinery and a factory for cranking out chisels, it’s far easier to make them out of a single type of steel.

The wedge shape of a plane blade came up earlier. From a Japanese plane standpoint, the body of a Japanese plane is cut according to the taper of the blade. I’m sure that Japanese plane blade makers aim for a particular degree of taper, but I don’t think this is a precision operation. If the taper of the blade is off by a degree or so, it doesn’t matter too much as you’re going to cut the side abutments to match that taper of that particular blade.

For both western and Japanese planes, having a wedge somewhere in the mechanism holding the blade in place allows for a high degree of control when adjusting it. For Japanese planes, the wedge is in the blade itself, and in the taper in the side abutments. For western planes, the wedge is in both the blade and the wooden wedge that holds it in place. I have a few western wooden bench planes. I’ve found that it’s seems like I have more control when adjusting the planes I have that have tapered plane blades. With a parallel plane blade, it seems like if I’m advancing the blade, the blade likes to move just a little bit, and then it lets go fast.

Finally, it seems like making a parallel blade would take more work, in order to ensure that the blade was truly parallel. That’s probably why it cost more, even though I think there’s an advantage to having a tapered blade.

Re: Reviving the Double Iron: Steve Voigt Planemaker

#49

Re: Economics and wedges

steve voigt

Wilbur,

A very thoughtful post; I agree with your thoughts on mechanization, and also on wedges.

I have to nitpick about one thing. In the last paragraph, you wrote: "Finally, it seems like making a parallel blade would take more work, in order to ensure that the blade was truly parallel. That’s probably why it cost more, even though I think there’s an advantage to having a tapered blade."

As I have been saying, no one has offered any evidence that parallel irons were available for wedged wooden planes, let alone that they costed more. It's been asserted, but I've seen no proof.

I have looked through the Gabriel inventories of 1791 and 1800, I've looked through catalog scans available online, and I find no mention of them. I don't have a copy of British Planemakers Since 1700, but I've pored over the book several times and don't ever recall seeing any mention of parallel irons.

Maybe someone who own some of the complete catalogs, like the 1872 Greenfield catalog, can help us out here. Is there any mention of parallel irons? It is common to see references to spare irons, and I have seen "wider than usual irons" advertised, but never a mention of taper vs none. If they were available, they seem awfully elusive.

We can't interpret the facts until we know what the facts are.