New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Perth Wood Show furniture competition

Posts

Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#1

Perth Wood Show furniture competition

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As promised, I will report on the results of the Perth Wood Show furniture competition. This was completed last weekend.

Well, I did not place, again ... sigh. I'll get that out of the way.

My piece (I forgot to take a photo of it at the show) ...


The turnout was not up to the usual numbers this year. Lots of side tables. Probably counted for half the entries. There were some amazing boxes, really stunning stuff. Carvings too. I'll try and post these another time.

The winning piece was this coffee table. Stunning inlay. Design ...?



The second prize went to a bookcase in Jarrah. It had curved top frame stretchers and shelves ...



Third place went to a side table. This one was in Marri wood with interesting figure. The design featured a floating top ..



Our woodworking club also ran a competition for a three-step ladder. The winning ladder was this one ...


Other than the bent top section, I really felt it was not in the same league as the step ladder that came second. This one showed some thoughtful design and really nice inlay ...



A consolation came at the end when my chest of drawers was voted People's Choice by the public.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#2

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

david weaver

I guess taste isn't part of the judging. It looks like the marquetry table is well executed, but I can't imagine looking at it on purpose. the bookcase is unitersting, too curvy and modern (no offense to the maker, that's just an opinion) and the alternating black back makes it look modern and possibly not wood. It would've been far more tasteful with well selected wood, mouldings with crisp lines and perhaps something like a bead in the boards on the back for attractiveness without overdoing it.

The side table would've had a chance of being attractive if it didn't look like it was made out of something from a firewood pile...with a large knot front and center. It makes it look like something that belongs in a cabin.

Your piece is the only one I'd actually put in my house, it is a nice combination of lines and taste, with enough crisp detail and uniformity to catch your eye, but no strange elements to offend it.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#3

Art vs furniture

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"A consolation came at the end when my chest of drawers was voted People's Choice by the public."

The public likely was judging furniture, that is something they could imagine living with and using. I don't know anyone that would have the winning table in their house if it was given to them.

I do agree on the ladders. I can imagine actually using the winning entry while the other is an art object to be set somewhere and admired and dusted. In fact I would like to know enough more about the winning entry to approximately reproduce it if its creator was willing.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#4

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It seems that studio furniture has gotten to be all about the wood and much less about the rest. The 3rd place entry is a case in point. I recall something Curtis Buchannan said on this topic. He advocated imagining what the piece would look like in pine, that is to say something plain that focused on the shape. #3 strikes me as a pedestrian table with what some would regard as arty wood.

I do like #2. The shape, wood and utility come together nicely. Elegant is a word that comes to mind. I can imagine most anyone finding a home for it in their house. Ditto for your piece.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#5

Re: The table..

david weaver

...the table with the fairly gross looking wood really doesn't have anything else about it when I look at it that would draw me in. I'm sort of curious as to why it's so preferable. I think, as you say, the modern thing seems to be less about design aesthetics and more about odd with strange wood. "different" or slightly offensive is apparently better than good.

I like good better. Derek's furniture is good to the eyes.

With the skill that the first place maker has, something of good design with the marquetry could've been made that was quite nice.

It reminds me of the discussion on here about 18th century typical dovetails being "sloppy" if they are not perfect. Design is 95% of the piece, it can carry mediocre execution, and sometimes even relatively poor. Perfect execution cannot solve mediocre design.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#6

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

roger lance

Derek.....you live in an area with some very talented woodworkers.....sometimes a guy has to be content with knowing that his own work is good even if it goes under appreciated by others.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#7

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Roger.

Going in I really was not expecting to be in the running, but I was nevertheless puzzled with the judges choices. I just would love to know how they evaluated the pieces, to know what they look for.

I had a fun time at the Wood Show - spent some time on Chris Vesper's stand (he stayed with us over the weekend), and I put on a few demos for Lie Nielsen (setting up and using handplanes). Mainly, it was good to see old faces, and be part of the energy - which is why I entered the competition in the first place.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#8

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

Brian Holcombe

Sorry to hear that it didn't place, which is baffling to me as it is nothing short of a masterwork. Subtle work always seems to be something that can be enjoyable for life where flashy work may catch the eye but does not retain attention.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#9

Re: Art vs furniture

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Agree entirely with Bill. I much prefer The People's Choice'.

The foot steps are an interesting challenge. I really like the one with the handhold.

Wiley

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#10

Amen to that statement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Perfect execution cannot solve mediocre design.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#11

Re: The table..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I went back and looked and everything about that table is truly unattractive. Apparently the trendy knot carried the day.

I find it easy to not get caught up in the trendiness of "live edges" knots, splits and rotten wood that seem all the rage in studio furniture. They don't compensate for high school shop class design.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#12

Re: The table..

david weaver

I've never seen furniture like that in someones' house, but I have seen people with design taste to put chainsawed blocky stuff in their houses under an assumption I'm not sure of.

I guess if I knew more people who had a lot of money *and* who spend it, I might see where a lot of that stuff ends up.

For a while around here, there was a studio furniture guy building multiples of pieces out of purpleheart and curly maple. It was such an overused look that I wondered who bought it. It was made to a level that anyone on here could've made it.

I've seen other live edge-ish stuff in art shops around here where a small table has some metal pieces affixed to it for three or four grand, and same thing, nothing that any of us couldn't make easily, and nothing striking about the design. As a relative of mine (who sold furniture) used to say, I guess it was just waiting for the right buyer.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#13

Subtlety takes time

Brian Holcombe

...to grow on a designer.

I've become more attracted to what is truly allusive in sourcing material....perfectly straight VG lumber.

Done well, I enjoy intensely figured table tops, but I think the table top alone is enough. No need to extend that to the structural members which just begins to make the piece visually jarring.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#14

Re: PS

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

The maker of the table entered two identical pieces, the other being an un-figured Jarrah ...


I preferred this version which did not place (although I thought the top too thick, or needing a bevel edge).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#15

agree the top is too "thick"

ian neuhaus

and needs a bevel edge to lighten it.

also, being long and narrow I'd add a subtle curve to the underside of the front and back aprons

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#16

Re: 3 step ladders - Perth Wood Show

ian neuhaus

I think I can see the judges opinion in choosing between the ladders.

I'm sure the one with the tall handle and inlay is a copy of one that appeared on the cover of Popular Woodworking. But it is well executed.

However the winner appeals to me due to its simple clean lines and appearance of a being both low cost and capable of mass production. The plain timber only emphasizes the workmanship

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#17

Re: Guitars...

david weaver

This discussion brings to mind what the market for guitars is like.

I always have a problem of acquisition with hobbies, and then I have a problem of disposal once the acquisition is over. My acquisition period with guitars started before I was a woodworker. I wanted good guitars with uncommon woods on them, and I did get those.

I did reasonably well buying guitars that were well made and comfortable to play (as opposed to a lot of the stuff out there now being dressed up CNC machine fare - it looks like legos with figured wood pattern).

When I look at what I'd like to have for a guitar, I'd like something straight grained and plain with good contour and understated details.

(long story short, subtlety is lost on people looking for shock value, I guess. The table with the marquetry reminds me of an arpeggio being played over and over - busy, technically difficult, repetitive and after a while overdone)

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#18

Agree with others

Hank Knight

Derek,

I'm late to the party, as usual, and have little to add to what others have said. I agree that subtlety is apparently lost on the judges. The quality of the work in your piece alone deserves a prize. The quiet lines of the piece will wear long after the novelty of the other pieces has faded. Except for the library stairs, subtlety and grace are absent from all the other pieces. Granted, the intricate inlay of the winning piece took some time and effort, but the end result is awful, even for a studio piece. I do like the library stairs; I could easily live with them in my house. Some skill and work went into making them, but nothing like the skill and effort that went into your piece. I'm sorry you didn't score a prize, you should have.

Hank

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#19

Correction

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I attended my club meeting this evening. It turns out that my award was for best piece (from all pieces submitted) at the Show, voted by the club members (100 or so), and not the public.

I'll post some of the boxes a little later.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#20

A travesty

David Charlesworth

Derek,

I was on the selection committee for the Devon Guild of Craftsmen for three years a while ago.

In my opinion your piece wins hands down.

Elegant, restrained and technically very difficult.

Fire the judges.

David Charlesworth

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#22

A few more entries.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

These are just a couple of boxes and "miscellaneous" entries ..





My favourite piece at the show was this music box, which won first prize in this category (the maker has twice won Best of Show in the past, including last year. A great deal of work, creating the sound section, and then the amazing marquetry based on Gustaz Klimt's Woman in Gold painting. My apology for the poor quality of all these photos - they were taken with my iPhone.




Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#23

Re: A few more entries.

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Derek, that music box is wonderful and I think your entry should have won *something* at the least if not first. That second table from your first post did nothing for me and the marquetry table was just completely overpowering --- just too much to consider it a winner.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#24

Re: Correction

Hank Knight

I don't know who your judges were, but the members of your club have a better appreciation of the significance of your piece than they do. Glad they rewarded you with their votes. It is a well deserved honor.