Re: machines and hand tools
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
David,
The article I was looking for is, 'Period Productivity' by Patrick Edwards. Unfortunately, he doesn't list it in his articles on his website any longer, and I can't find it elsewhere.
Wiley
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: machines and hand tools
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
David,
The article I was looking for is, 'Period Productivity' by Patrick Edwards. Unfortunately, he doesn't list it in his articles on his website any longer, and I can't find it elsewhere.
Wiley
Credit where credit is due
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If there were two 18th century reproductions in a show or Gallery and one had a shell and feet machine carved and the other hand carved the difference would be apparent to anyone with a passing knowledge of this style of furniture. The two pieces should and would be valued and judged accordingly. I will remain skeptical that anyone but the maker would or should value a furniture part sized with hand tools any different than one sized with power tools and ditto for a hidden joint such as M&T.
some contrary evidence
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Attached is a picture of a piece Alf made a few years ago. It is a commissioned piece rumored at six $figures. It has a bit of hand work, apparently good enough to be instrumental in Alf receiving the Cartouche award. The reader can judge whether the client should have consulted Warren to choose a better craftsman to execute this piece. It would be enlightening to see Warren's portfolio of superior hand work.
I am willing to believe that anyone that could make this piece could cut a board to length with a hand saw if they chose to or needed to. It would not detract from my appreciation of the piece if they chose to dimension on a table saw instead.
more data
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Steve Hamilton taught a class in my shop a few years ago. I asked Steve to demonstrate the common techniques for building stuff.
Using a piece of walnut and cherry scrap I had on hand Steve mater of factly executed a half blind dovetail. It didn't take him long to do one. The objective was to demonstrate the steps and what steps he used, not make the most precise dovetail that he could make. Never-the-less the result looked good to me. My inexperienced eye did not detect any awkwardness with the hand tools used. The ease with which he demonstrated joinery suggested quite the opposite.
In addition he demonstrated how to do a coped door frame and panel. Again it was done mater of factly, I suppose as he would be doing this joint on a piece for sale. This joint is just pushed together. It comes together what seems to me perfect with a bit of clamp pressure. Steve reported that the audience at Williamsburg was quite smitten by the coping technique the shop uses. It does make a nice joint if you are handy with a carving chisel.
If I ever got to the point where I could do joints this well, as effortlessly as Steve, I would be pleased.
Complete Miss
Warren in Lancaster, PA
You certainly missed my point. Are you going to argue that this piece would have been several times more expensive had it been made completely by hand? The machine work in this piece is a small portion of the work and that work would be a small portion if it were done by hand also. But when the guy made it his overhead of machinery continued even while he was doing hand work. Actually this piece, with its high ratio of hand work to machine work would be a good example of something that is cheaper in an all hand tool shop. Fine machinery and the space it consumes would go idle while the guy did carving. I would be surprised to find that Sharp made it as quickly as the original was done.
The truth is that the number of workers capable of executing this piece at high quality (hand or not) for "six figures" greatly exceeds the number of people who want to buy one.
We don't need guys who have never made a piece of furniture by hand telling us how much work it is.
Not really...
John in NM
Your point was that those guys were "Fish in the desert" when it came to hand tools. The picture demonstrates otherwise, as does your reply to it, inadvertently.
Re: machines and hand tools
William Duffield
Curious. I assumed you were referring to "The Account Boij of John Head, Joiner."
Quota-6 drawers a day
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
When I discussed English drawers with Alan Batty he told me his quota at the factory was 6 drawers per day assembled from already dimensioned material. Obviously doing something day in day out led to proficiency as did the way the drawer was dovetailed together.
Poke about in hand made Period furniture and you will find that the hidden parts were typically not made to the Gallery standards of our time. Even show surfaces may not be highly refined. And, I suspect the pieces were engineered to be efficient with the techniques and materials that were available.
Re: some contrary evidence
Paul in NJ
I have never seen Jeff Headly or Steve Hamilton demonstrate so I can't comment about them, but I was at Williamsburg at the last conference and watched Alf Sharp. I have to say I was a bit disappointed. He was slow, hesitant, and apologetic. Maybe he was nervous or off his game. Clearly he was not up to the (carving) skills of the Williamsburg journeyman cabinetmakers or some of the professional carvers I have seen. Just like in the 18th century, many high end shops like Andersen and Stauffer sub the carving work out to professional carvers. I don't know if that is what he does or if he has a dedicated carver in his shop.
Paul Dzioba
Re: Quota-6 drawers a day
david weaver
I would assume negotiated guild factory work was done at a slower rate than what would've been done in a private shop. What would happen to you if you made 8 a day? or 10?
Re: some contrary evidence
Brian Holcombe
Public performances always add an element of self consciousness that is otherwise not there. Even making youtube videos, which is funny because you can just delete them and not upload, but even them for the first 5 or 10 made me self conscious.
So, if he works by himself and does not need to teach anyone while he works that could account for it. Guys who teach while they work or get a lot of public exposure are going to look very natural in public performances.
I used to do a lot of presentations and looking like you know what you're doing is a separate challenge from actually knowing what you are doing.
Thanks again Hank.
Re: Complete Miss
Charlie
"Machinery Overhead?"
Quality machinery would have economic depreciation of 50 years or more, i.e. a useable life of 50+ years. So, overhead in the form of original cost depreciation is practically negligible on an annual basis - for a reasonable set up would be well less than $1,000 a year. Tax depreciation is obviously a lot faster but represents something desirable, not undesirable.
What you SEEM to be referring to is some sort of machinery idle capacity issue (an 'idle capacity variance' in cost accounting) and this simply doesn't apply to a small operation and certainly not a one or two man operation.
Re: Complete Miss
Charlie
In other words there is no rational scenario in financial or cost accounting that would have the ownership of a tablesaw, jointer, planer, bandsaw, etc. be some sort of drag on profitability -- in the long run and definitely not in the short run.
In the instant case, Alf Sharp's highboy, he would have recovered the cost of probably of every machine and hand tool in his shop (and still have shown a profit) after just that commission alone.
Re: some contrary evidence
TomD
It was easier back when I did the presentations because quite often the people who were in attendance had never seen a dovetail cut or a handplane made, or used. No youtube. They had probably all seen FK, but nobody holds you to that standard if they are paying 40 bucks. I remember this one presentation I did where I ripped a plane blank cheek, for a Krenov plane, and got significant murmurs of approval for following a line with a bandsaw, which I can do pretty dang fast, but it is a stationary tool for Pete's sake. It is a whole other world these days, with a lot of people able to do pro quality work if they have enough time and having enough time is what hobbies are about. With enough time people do incredible feats of craftsmanship.
Re: machines and hand tools
Ellis Walentine
Pat would probably be happy to send you a copy, Wiley.
Cheers,
Ellis