New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Perth Wood Show furniture competition

Posts

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#26

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

TomD

I'm picky, and I wasn't there. Your piece looks to be better than the top three by a fair margin. The second step ladder is of a type (marquetry aside) that was pretty common in early editions of the Fine Woodworking design book.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#27

Re: PS

TomD

Raffan used to claim that all wooden bowls eventually look/turn black, so don't just prize the wood, sweat the form.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#28

Re: Guitars...

TomD

Guitars are difficult since there is little steel string consensus on what makes a good one. Many of the woods embraced are actually poor choices, like ultra tight tops and decayed backs and sides. People want what they can't get without going custom. And nothing is better business than overcharging for wood. Back in the late 90s, one could get 500 extra in a stock guitar just going to rosewood, and it cost less to purchase the materials than domestic hardwoods.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#29

Re: A few more entries.

ian neuhaus

Agree that the Woman in Gold deserves 1st place, and based on the other entries you've posted, I'd give it best in show as well.

as others have said, the marquetry table is so far over the top as to be off putting. Excellent execution, but a crap design

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#30

Re: Guitars...

david weaver

Ditto that on the lack of consensus. Banjos are the same. There are more suppositions about tone and sound, especially since there are metal parts in those, too, to speculate on. But on guitars, it's like a disease, supposing this or that will make for a better guitar.

The stripped down instruments are loss leaders, I'm sure. they remind me of pickup trucks. I'd bet Carvin, even with all of their automation, doesn't make much money on a $1000 mono-wood guitar, but nearly the same thing with some binding, inlays and figured wood for $2000 and they're a little better off. Bump up the numbers for an independent maker, and the same thing - need to sell $100 of wood for $500 upcharge. Bind a peghead and neck for a few hundred, etc.

The seller has to take what the market gives or they won't be there long to take it.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#31

Re: A few more entries.

Ray

The winning marquetry table made something within me tighten up. Similar to seeing someone wearing striped pants with a polka dot shirt.

Design and craftsmanship should be equally excellent in a winning entry. Not one without the other.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#32

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

Brian Holcombe

Worth mentioning that the second library ladder barrows very heavily from Wharton Esherick's ladder. That may be one reason why it did not win 1st place, as it is a wonderful work.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#33

Marrying execution and design

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The guy who built this is seriously talented with veneer, with which he works exclusively (using torsion box construction and bendy ply). Last year he built (and won) with a really terrific long sideboard, which had a wonderful curved front. I could easily live with it. Still, I do not think he is a designer, and he says so. The table was built, he said at the meeting, "because I wanted to try out this technique". Later he said, "I was so relieved that someone bought it at the Show, because I could not live with it!".

The year (2014) my Wegner "The Chair" failed to place in this same competition ("because it was a copy"), he won with this coffee table below. Again, the starburst veneer is simply stunning up close. The legs and undercarriage, however, look like an after thought ..



He also came second with this piece (which he was not sure what it was, but built as a project) ...


I agree that design should marry with build skill, and vice versa. The veneer work of the winning table is quite outstanding. The design, however, is chunky, and totally in-your-face. Even the builder said so.

At the end of the day I am still left unsure what the Judges look for: perfection in the execution of the work? That is all I can come up with. (The bookcase was also beautifully built - with routers and dominos and tablesaws and sanders ... no handtools outside the brief use of a card scraper).

That is why I was not expecting much with my piece in the competition, itself (yet was not altogether surprised when the club members voted for my piece). It was 90% made by hand and there are signs of handtools when you look closely. Perhaps I should push for a Handtool section - I would be assured of winning as I am possibly the only handtool woodworker in the club! :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#34

Re: Marrying execution and design

John S

I like that second piece. As display shelving for plants, knick knacks, books, I could live with it.

It's a 3D doodle, offset but symmetrical, simple but complex, he picked the right three to put a back on for the open and closed look.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#35

a comment on how its built

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the contest is for the furniture it should not matter how it was built and outside the woodworker circle, who would care? Would the winning entry be any better or worse if it was hammer veneered?

As I have recently discovered with these bedside chests of drawers, and discovered in building Krenov inspired pieces, modern techniques are best, if not essential, for some designs.

How something is built would be best judged in a "skills contest".

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#36

My experience would prove otherwise

Brian Holcombe

Take the alternate view point and what is good when built by hand is now ubiquitous and boring when made by machine.

Good design is only enhanced when made by hand.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#37

Re: A travesty

Jim Matthewd

I've seen the piece in person.

It's exquisite, and unlike most art, built to a useful intent.

It rivals some of the masterworks I have seen from graduates

of the North Bennet street school in Boston.

I suspect the judhing committee confused more with best.

"Horror vacui"

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#38

Re: It's settled..

david weaver

We will travel from the united states to australia, and seize the ribbons and trophies and drive them to Derek's shop and put them where they belong.

Being americans, the australian judges will have seen the news and determined us to be violent hooligans because of our national origin, and they will certainly hand over any ribbons, trophies and certificates to us without resistance.

As a message to next year's judges, we will leave our graffiti stamp behind: a spray painted stencil of a double iron stacked on top of a hamburger.

:)

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#39

Re: a comment on how its built

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

If the contest is for the furniture it should not matter how it was built and outside the woodworker circle, who would care? Would the winning entry be any better or worse if it was hammer veneered?

As I have recently discovered with these bedside chests of drawers, and discovered in building Krenov inspired pieces, modern techniques are best, if not essential, for some designs.

How something is built would be best judged in a "skills contest".

I have mixed thoughts about this, Bill. On the one hand, you are correct - the end piece should stand on its own merits. At the same time, however, one cannot ignore construction details since they are part of a design. They provide important information about the integrity of the structure, its potential to survive changes of temperature, and its ability to be repaired.

Surely what is inside is as important as on the outside.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#40

That's too kind, Jim.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Many thanks.

Others here should know that I bribed you to say that with gifts of tools I made on your visit from the US to my shop in May this year. I hope they serve you well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#41

Re: It's settled..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

No Dave!

It's OK. Really. The vote by the club means so much more than the vote by the judges.

Anyway, I did not build the chest for the competition. I built it for my wife. And she loves it. What more can I ask?! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#42

Re: It's settled..

Hank Knight

Derek, your piece passed the true test and won the best prize of all!

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#43

Re: a comment on how its built

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Surely what is inside is as important as on the outside. "

No disagreement here. But that doesn't address the issue of how the inside or outside got made. A hand tool made mortise and tenon joint might be more highly valued among hand tool enthusiasts when it was revealed that the joint was made with hammer and chisel. This facet of a piece of furniture is less likely to be more highly valued among woodworkers that don't eschew machines and even less likely to be valued or even understood among customers (or judges).

I am reminded of a story told by Alf Sharp (SAPFM Cartouche winner). He was bidding on reproducing the furniture that had belonged to President Jackson to be used in the restoration of his home near Nashville. The committee overseeing the project asked that the furniture be built as it would have been in the Period. They choked on the bid and asked where cost could be removed. Alf said he could build it to look the same with the aid of machines and the cost would be substantially less. And that is how it was made. I believe that if the construction details were revealed t the public that a few would value it less than if made entirely Period Correct, but fewer would be willing to pay for using hand tools where machines could be equivalently employed. And most would not care or understand the difference.

I once watched Jeff Headly politely unbraid someone that was lessening the "value" of one of his reproductions because Jeff had used power tools to aid its construction and the same from Alan Breed at a SAPFM meeting. These master craftsmen don't consider using a machine to do apprentice work lessens what they create.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#44

Re: a comment on how its built

Brian Holcombe

I think you discount too quickly what a client or the public on the whole appreciate. From the experience of someone who does use entirely hand tools I can say that many do appreciate this method. Many who you would expect not to care actually seem to and for the same reasons why one orders a handmade suit or shoes.

I do not mean to denigrate those who make by machine and do so with quality but on the same but opposite note I think that the painstaking efforts should also not be quickly brushed off as novelty or likely to be unappreciated.

Frankly I thought no one would care, then it turned out so many did.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#45

Re: machines and hand tools

david weaver

I would imagine that Headley and Breed's opinions have much to do with what they can get paid for. If people were willing to pay them to do work the way it would've been done hundreds of years ago, they would probably prefer to do those things by hand.

I gather from derek that it's less about machine vs. man made mortise and tenon, and more of a comparison of something like mortise and tenon vs. some sort of jigged fastener or dowel or something.

I would imagine a skilled furniture shop from a few centuries ago would work much faster by hand than Headley's or Breed's shops, but they would've had apprentices that didn't demand too much in terms of pay, and a different work ethic than we have today - especially as to how that relates to working through pain and working with swiftness.

I don't know how accurate the description was in video, but there was a narrator in a youtube video going through the hay cabinet shop, and in the background was someone planing mahogany by hand...and fiddling at it, I'd say. When they described the time components, they mentioned budgeting about one hour of time per board foot to dimension lumber to a finished dimension. Judging by the rate of speed the man in the background was working, you'd assume that maybe they could manage to spend an hour on a board foot working like that. Maybe it was a bad representation, I don't know.

But I don't think there are very many current woodworkers who can give a very accurate hand tools vs. machines cost, because the ones building old furniture couldn't afford to work with hand tools long enough to get quick with them, and at the same time, they wouldn't want to expose their bodies to the wear and tear.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#46

Re: a comment on how its built

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I once watched Jeff Headly politely unbraid someone that was lessening the "value" of one of his reproductions because Jeff had used power tools to aid its construction and the same from Alan Breed at a SAPFM meeting. These master craftsmen don't consider using a machine to do apprentice work lessens what they create.

Bill, I have no issue with machines being used for traditional joinery. I would assume that Jeff and Alan both used mortice-and-tenon joinery, etc. These look and work the same whether they are created by a machine or by hand. I rather doubt that they would have used Dominos or dowels. I also assume that they used hide glue for the same reason. These factors add up to repairable joints. I would consider that an important feature in fine furniture.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#47

Re: machines and hand tools

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"I would imagine a skilled furniture shop from a few centuries ago would work much faster ..."

David and all,

David's comment reminds me.....Years ago, someone estimated the man-days involved in making various types of vintage furniture--by hand. They started with the Philadelphia Price Book of Furniture for 1772 (which can still be had), then made assumptions to divide the 1772 prices between labor, overhead, and profit. They translated British pounds into American dollars, used known day rates for journeymen (e.g., $1 per day for a 10 hour day), and finally derived the man-hours or man-days to make a 3-drawer chest or a 4-drawer chest or a low-boy, etc, with or without stringing or cross-banding, etc.

I can't find that reference now. Does anyone else recall it, and know where to find it? It was amazing, how fast these pieces were made. I seem to recall there would be 3 or 4 man-days of actual heads-down work in a fully ornamented for-drawer chest, starting from rough-sawn from the mill.

Can anyone put a URL on this paper?

Wiley

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#48

Re: machines and hand tools

david weaver

Wiley, that's what I was thinking of, but I can't remember the list because I'm not much of a reader.

The debate that goes along with it is whether or not some shop members' hours aren't counted, but even if they were, I would imagine that a lot of those shops could make a piece of furniture by hand faster than a lot of paid woodworkers could make something as fine with machine.

And then add things like the length of their days, etc.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#49

Re: It's settled..

steve voigt

Derek,

Your work is lovely. I also like a number of the other pieces you posted, and I would hate to have to choose.

I'm reminded of the great composer Bela Bartok's famous quip that competitions are for horses, not artists. I'd add craftsmen to that line, too.

Re: Perth Wood Show furniture competition

#50

Re: a comment on how its built

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have watched Jeff Headley, Steve Hamilton, and Alf Sharp working with hand tools at the Williamsburg conference. They are all friendly, knowledgeable, and generous with their knowledge. However when it comes to hand tools they are like fish in the desert. Just not in their element.

It is easy to see why it would be expensive for them to try to make something by hand. Their machinery and fine machine tool skills would go unused while they would struggle with hand work, which they are not skilled at. That doesn't mean that it would be more expensive for someone with hand tools skills (and no investment in machinery, extra shop space, and no investment in machine tool skills) to make the same piece by hand.