Marrying execution and design
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
The guy who built this is seriously talented with veneer, with which he works exclusively (using torsion box construction and bendy ply). Last year he built (and won) with a really terrific long sideboard, which had a wonderful curved front. I could easily live with it. Still, I do not think he is a designer, and he says so. The table was built, he said at the meeting, "because I wanted to try out this technique". Later he said, "I was so relieved that someone bought it at the Show, because I could not live with it!".
The year (2014) my Wegner "The Chair" failed to place in this same competition ("because it was a copy"), he won with this coffee table below. Again, the starburst veneer is simply stunning up close. The legs and undercarriage, however, look like an after thought ..


He also came second with this piece (which he was not sure what it was, but built as a project) ...

I agree that design should marry with build skill, and vice versa. The veneer work of the winning table is quite outstanding. The design, however, is chunky, and totally in-your-face. Even the builder said so.
At the end of the day I am still left unsure what the Judges look for: perfection in the execution of the work? That is all I can come up with. (The bookcase was also beautifully built - with routers and dominos and tablesaws and sanders ... no handtools outside the brief use of a card scraper).
That is why I was not expecting much with my piece in the competition, itself (yet was not altogether surprised when the club members voted for my piece). It was 90% made by hand and there are signs of handtools when you look closely. Perhaps I should push for a Handtool section - I would be assured of winning as I am possibly the only handtool woodworker in the club! 
Regards from Perth
Derek