New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Cast Iron

Posts

Re: Cast Iron

#26

Nothing breathless here....

John in NM

Just occurred to me that you and Roger might be looking at different products, both of which LV sells - thus the pictures.

What Roger asked was consistent with one of them, what you said was consistent with the other.

Re: Cast Iron

#27

Re: Nothing breathless here....

roger lance

John.....you are correct, I was thinking about the newest LV offering.....the steel plates which you showed. Thanks.

Re: Cast Iron

#28

actually its adhesion not vacuum

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is being observed is how adhesives work.

If any liquid is placed between two flat plates and the liquid wets the plate surfaces the plates become stuck together with the strength of the liquid. This phenomena is adhesion. To get the plates apart the intermolecular forces holding the liquid together must be overcome. A liquid , being a liquid, has little shear resistance and the plates can be slid apart. If the liquid polymerizes, think CA glue or epoxy, now the intermolecular forces become great. To get the plates apart the toughness of the cured adhesive must be overcome, or the forces holding the plate material together must be overcome.

Adhesion should not be a problem sharpening as the bevel is small. When I sharpen on a diamond charged cast iron plate polishing the back it is not a problem either because I only have an inch of so of plane blade on the plate.

Re: Cast Iron

#29

Re: actually its adhesion not vacuum

Steve Elliott

Hi Bill,

You and I may be the only ones interested in looking at things from this point of view, but since we're interested I'm going to reply.

Starting with your correct assertion that "a liquid, being a liquid, has little shear resistance and the plates can be slid apart," I'd like to point out that stiction is exactly difficulty sliding two surfaces parallel to each other. Adhesion would prevent the blade from being lifted easily from the surface of the stone (or lapping plate), but stiction is resistance to sliding the blade along the surface of the stone.

As a kid I assembled model airplanes and the finishing touch was to put decals on the sides. I'd wet the decal and slide it into place on a thin layer of water. Adhesion held the decal in place but it was still possible to move it around.

I don't know if you've used Shapton stones or other non-porous ceramics, but when the non-bevel side of a blade is being worked (also known as "flattening the back of a blade") the blade will suddenly lock down on the stone and refuse to move. Years ago I added shallow U-shaped grooves to the surface of a Shapton 8000 grit stone to make it easier to work on the backs of blades. The grooves in lapping plates perform the same function. The adhesion due to the liquid is barely changed but the ability to move the blade around increases significantly. I think the difference is due to letting air pressure equalize where the slightly dished stone and the somewhat flatter blade no longer quite touch in the middle.

Regardless of the mechanism, grooves on a lapping plate can perform a useful function and aren't just a place for abrasives to gather and do no good. That said, the only cast iron plate I have with grooves is one I stopped using years ago because it was such a mess to keep clean.

Re: Cast Iron

#30

Gotta agree with Bill...

John in NM

Stiction is a contraction of static friction, as opposed to kinetic friction which is the resistance to sliding once the two surfaces start to move.

I've not looked into it, but at a guess, I would think that the resistance to separating two wetted surfaces has more to do with the surface tension of the lubricant than anything else. The grooves cut into that iron plate would help break this up some, but I'm not sure I'd say it was worth the effort.

Re: Cast Iron

#31

Re: actually its adhesion not vacuum

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I suspect Steve and Bill can each be right, depending on the exact situation. Adhesion is a phenomenon, and atmospheric pressure is another one (aka 'vacuum').

Bill could tell us more about adhesive force.

But if one manages to rub two flat surfaces together--which is what Steve was talking about--until they are pressed so flat together that all the air between them is expressed, the effect is as if 14.7 pounds per square inch (psi) is pressing down on the sandwich, which in turn is the same as if a column of water 34 feet high were standing over the sandwich. This is quite a bit of pressure acting for example on two 8" x 3" (guessing here) Shapton stones. It can indeed seem to lock them up against sideways motion, let alone lifting one directly off the other.

Wiley

Re: Cast Iron

#32

Inappropriately named; doesn't involve air pressur

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...pressure. The annoyance being described would be a problem on top of Pikes Peak equal to Death Valley and it is not correctly named "stiction", which is a sloppy term for static friction, which involves a force to get something moving or dislodged from a stationary state.

Whether the problem is sucking a plane sole to the plate or the effort to move the plane across the plate the phenomena causing the annoyance is adhesion. What I am unsure of is whether the adhesion is solely a result of a wetting liquid between the surfaces or whether there could be metal to metal adhesion in places (probably not if the plate is well lubed). The phenomena is the same as the "tack" we get when two well jointed edges are brought together with glue between them, and the force that pushes a liquid up a capillary where the liquid wets the capillary walls.

I am unclear about the role of the grooves. The force holding the two smooth surfaces together is proportional to area. The grooves reduce the contact area, but not by much so I don't see the grooves reducing the force to pull a plane sole from a plate. But there may be something I don't understand that reduces the sliding force when the grooves are there. I have never used a grooved plate so I don't know how noticeable the effect of the grooves is to the user.

In the case of sharpening, the fact that the bevel sticks to a cast iron plate is desirable for keeping registration of the bevel on the plate.

Re: Cast Iron

#33

Re: Thanks for the Reminder (Grooves)

david weaver

Early on, I got that plate from Lee Valley and I have never been able to find anything that it's really good for. I almost forgot it in the bottom of my bench, but I'm sure it's rust free because it's coated with a heavy aged coating of mineral oil and silicon carbide.

I hope it will fit in some semblance of a flat rate box so that I can sell it on ebay.

(confirmation...it does!!).

Nice piece of gear, but something that never really made any sense in the shop - wish the grooves were smaller so that there was some place for the grit to evacuate, but not so easily and so fast.

Never use it wearing nice clothes!!

Re: Cast Iron

#34

Flat rates....

John in NM

Look into regional rate boxes. Slightly cheaper than flat rate if going far, much cheaper if in the same or adjoining region. I get them at the USPS website, but sometimes the local postmaster will order them for you.

Re: Cast Iron

#35

Re: Flat rates....

david weaver

I've got some regional rate boxes, but only the small ones. It looks like I need to look a little closer at the big ones as there are some large enough for the lapping plate (max weight is less, but high enough).

It never fails on ebay when I put flat rate shipping (that doesn't fit in a flat rate box), someone in california or washington state is the high bidder and i have to eat a ton of shipping cost.

Thanks for the tip.

Re: Cast Iron

#36

Re: Grooves....  And then there were 3

TomD

"My experience has been that the grooves are simply a place for abrasive to fall into ...which removes said abrasive from any further "work"."

I don't think they are necessary. The main thing they do is let the excess material drop into them so that the cut is correct as early as possible. For myself I only use one grit for lapping, and eventually work it down till it polishes a surface to a mirror finish. I guess I could recover some of the early surplus from the grooves, but I have never had too much trouble with the plain flat iron surface. The issue is that one is lapping on top of the mound of SC until it distributes or spreads out short of the edges, or falls over the edges. Until that process goes forward, the nominal flatness of the surface is nothing like what is actually happening as the particles are stacked up a little on the plate.

Lee Valley once sold an iron plate as used by Japanese tool users, it was flat, but did not have grooves, worked oK. Kinda tool you use on new tools, and those were set up decades ago, can't remember when we last used them.

Re: Cast Iron

#37

Re: Semantics...

North of the Border

As I see it, no apologies are needed from you. You correctly pointed out what many people misunderstand the meaning or of the word "precision."

Re: Cast Iron

#38

Chris Scholz

Precise is not accurate

Chris Scholz

Actually, precision and accuracy have nothing to do with each other. Something can be precise and accurate, precise but not accurate, accurate but not precise, etc.

It's not semantics, different words for different concepts.

For what I can tell, the folks at Lee Valley use the term precise in precisely the correct way.

Re: Cast Iron

#39

True....

John in NM

I see I misused accuracy in that post. I should have said something like "as long as that tolerance is maintained".

As I learned it way back when, precision means (paraphrasing) consistently holding results to within a defined tolerance. Accuracy means keeping that defined tolerance as small as possible around a target value.

An added wrinkle is that the two words tend to be interchangeable in colloquial English, whereas they are not in technical English. I tend to think colloquial English is a bit too sloppy this way, but that is just opinion.

Re: Cast Iron

#40

In shooting......

roger lance

If you are aiming at a bullseye and....

a) you get a close grouping of shots that are not located near that bullseye, you have precision but not accuracy.

b) you get shots closely dispersed around the bullseye but not in a tight group, you have accuracy but not precision.

c) you get a tight grouping of shots on the bullseye, you have both precision and accuracy.

Re: Cast Iron

#41

Re: In shooting......

TomD

You are correct, though it would gets more complex still as aiming can mean using the bullseye, or that little square below it as a reference point. But more comonly implies the intention to hit the center of the taget. If you were intending to hit the center of the target but got a good group to one side, then maybe you had a sight setting error, but it could be something worse still. I remember the earlier books on Benchrest one of which was called the accurate rifle, but I think current parlance is precision shooting.

-------------------------------

In the case of holding a tolerance on a block, it would need to be both precise and accurate as the buyer I am not indifferent to the fact that the surface tolerance was held, or that it was held at the correct level on the block.

---------------------------------

When people say somethig is just semantics, they seem to mean that it is a distinction without a difference. But since it has to do with the meaning of words, the distinctions can be key.

Re: Cast Iron

#42

Re: Grooves....

Alexander Grigoriev

Cast iron plates are used with abrasive embedded to the surface, not rolling around. Whatever falls to the grooves is swarf.

Re: Cast Iron

#43

Re: Grooves....

Michael Brady

I have the iron plate that is the subject of this thread. I find the grooves to be nothing more than a waste of lapping compound since it is impractical to try to recover the powder/ lubricant once it falls into the grooves, which happens immediately. For this reason, I don't use that side of the plate at all. It's too bad the plate isn't made with two plain sides, thus doubling its useful life.

Re: Cast Iron

#44

Re: For vintage stones...

david weaver

...the cast iron plate would be a great plate for flattening old oilstones. Probably the easiest way to flatten them without ingesting novaculite is coarse silicon carbide.

I sold mine on ebay a couple of days ago. The nice thing about LV and LN stuff is that if you list it for a reasonable price, it sells right away almost no matter what it is.

I couldn't find a good use for it with woodworking, though, and I use the hard drum on the end of a belt sander to waste off high spots on oilstones.