New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

Posts

One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#1

One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Indeed there are features on a bench designed and dedicated to hand tool work that make fixturing parts straightforward. However, these features are not essential to get the job done when the focus is to get the job done. A case in point, dovetailing the false top for a chest of drawers.


I built this bench decades ago when the one hand saw and one plane I owned gathered dust on a remote shelf. I am unwilling to invest the time and materials to build another. It is a large 4" slab with two woodworking vises and one machinist vise. The large overhang and my collection of clamps enables stuff to be fastened for any need that has come up to date. In this case it is easy to secure a wide panel for preparing dovetails. Arguably I can mount and dismount a panel in this arrangement as quick and secure as on a traditional bench.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#2

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

Ron MacLaren

Bill,

That is exactly how I hold 19 inch wide boards for blanket chests when making dovetails. I also add a spacer of the same thickness as the board I am working on between the vise jaws at the left end to prevent wracking. I have made 5 blanket chests using this method. Quick, strong, and easy!!!

Ron

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#3

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

TomD

You don't really get low-style points for having an enormous bench that is heavier than most, with a premium vise, and the same secondary clamping points we all use in a pinch. The average bench has a similar vise for that kind of work, yours is comparatively fancy with all it's size. A person could make krenov's bench for less than what you have in that thing. While I think we all know what you are getting at with fancy, given all the bench porn I see these days, but fundamentally a big slab of wood on a stand with two vises is a pretty primitive thing, People have just been over-complicating it.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#4

... then again ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

.. one does not need fancy tools to do any woodwork either. Does it really matter than you need to re-sharpen your chisel or plane blades every three strokes? Or that the plough plane takes about 15 minutes to set the fence, which then slips out of alignment? Oh, and never mind the RSI for working at an awkward height.

Good tools do matter - not shiny or premium, per se - just thoughtful and decent designs that take the unnecessary extra effort out of the process.

About 3 years ago, after 20 years handtooling with a bench I put together when mainly using power tools, I built a Roubo-style with a leg vise (that I built - cheap) and an expensive wagon vise (from BenchCrafted). I have a Moxon vise for dovetails.

What I like about my bench, compared to the old one, is that work holding is a million years easier. Plus it is such a pleasure to work at this bench, because it is a good design and because I made it.

While the aim of building is the end product, there is also a part that is about the journey and not just the destination (just as long as

My garage queen ... :)


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#5

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, is this intended to be a thread on work holding methods? Or a critique of benches?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#6

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Reread the first two sentences of my post and the answer should be clear.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#7

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

north of the border

"I am unwilling to invest the time and materials to build another." That exactly is the same reason why I have used a multi-layered plywood top as my workbench for so many years, building many more projects by hand than most visitors to woodworking forums who may have built (and rebuilt) more than one workbench.

It is our choice to spend time (how many hours, sir?) on building shop fixtures or a workbench or on building a finished piece. These days, we see videos and books on building workbenches and I know at least two fellow woodworkers who have built or are in the process of building one just because building workbenches is the 'in' thing. They are not wrong (even they have used their workbenches for years like me, one bought from a woodworking store), but building a workbench is on the bottom of my list that will never get visited. Life is too short for that kind of project.

Admittedly, there are many woodworkers who follow whatever it is "hot" out there, like the tool chest thing, without giving a serious thought if that is what they need. Same thing with new tools. A guy I know at work has had his new shooting plane on the shelf for months and he has yet to build a shooting board. Most of his work doesn't even need the shooting plane; his low angle jack plane would have done what he needs to do.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#8

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench......

roger lance

but, one sure likes it........


this is my first bench too.....and, although I could now do better, my last.

I'd recommend to any woodworker, especially in their early ww years, to build their bench.....you're going to be using whatever you have for a long time and you will learn a lot building a bench.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#9

It would seem ....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...that I am the last person to have discovered how to hold a wide panel in an ordinary vise.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#10

Amen


Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#11

Ellis Walentine

My bench *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Frank Klausz and I built a batch of five of his classic Eastern European workbenches about ten years ago for a huge workbench article I wrote for WoodWorker's Journal. While I like the relative simplicity and rock-solid feel of this bench, it is not the be-all and end-all of workbenches, but no bench really is.

Ellis


Klausz bench

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#12

It would seem so

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... I am the last person to have discovered how to hold a wide panel in an ordinary vise.

Bill

There will always be a need to find a way to hold some pieces ..


The fact is, that there is no single bench that can do it all.

There will also never be a single bench that is better than any other bench, since the whole idea behind building a bench (well it was for me) was to create a work-holding tool that was suited to my specific needs. Since there are many different priorities in woodworking - benches and choices of vises - these would be expected to differ widely.

I appreciate a leg vise and sliding deadman. I do not have to find a way to work on the edges of boards ...


While many go without a tail vise, I would not. It is just so useful for face planing ...


... and many other tasks, such as rebating ...


What would be meaningful in this thread would be that you discussed what is important to you in a bench, and how you meet these issues. Ditto for others here.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#13

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You asked....

"What would be meaningful in this thread would be that you discussed what is important to you in a bench, and how you meet these issues."

The question was obliquely answered in my post...."I am unwilling to invest the time and materials to build another." I originally built the bench to provide a sturdy work surface for fixing lawn mowers and routing dovetails. What is important is to figure out how to not have to build another to meet my changing needs.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#14

Re: answer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What is important is to figure out how to not have to build another to meet my changing needs.

What are your new needs, and what changes do you think are needed to your current set up?

Your time may be better spent modifying what you have, and not building afresh. There are many ways to do this, and many minds on this forum to help you.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#15

Functional vs. Pretty

david weaver

I think that it would take a competent woodworker about three long days to build a good bench. I never have three long days in a row, but I was able to put a bench together in about 30 hours from the time I brought wood in the door to the time I put the bench on its legs and skidded it into place in the shop.

I had a major problem, though - my prior bench weighed 112 pounds (about 200 ballasted) and it was coming apart. There was nothing I couldn't do on it furniture-wise, though, that I would otherwise do on the one I have.

That said, if you feel like you don't need a new bench, you don't need a new one. I didn't like the idea of building a bench, and I still don't, but I had to either build one or pay for one, and in something that is akin to timberframing more than fine cabinetmaking, the value isn't there for me in the benches that are sold.

I skipped face jointing boards (just went right to the planer) to save material and time, and I lag bolted the end caps on. Everything else is as rudimentary as I could do it. I rough planed the bottom of the bench and smoothed it only where the legs are mortised in, and I bored and counterbored the dog holes freehand with a cheap spoon bit in a milwaukee holeshooter (we can see straight enough for that kind of stuff no problem).

After fiddling away trying to learn to make planes, it was nice to do something more mindless (and the bench works fine).

Point being, you could make one very quickly, probably more quickly than me as i'm sure your setup of machines is a lot better than mine (thickness planer and contractor table saw on the ground).

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#16

Nicholson

Ron Harper

I have become a very excited convert to the Nicholson bench Simple, Cheap, easy to build, highly effective as a work holding instrument See Mike Siemsen's video on youtube Viseless woodworking

Have built two of the for the alternative school where I volunteer and getting ready to build my own at home. Will Meyer and Bob Rozaieski and the Schwarz all have blogs/videos up about this bench

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#17

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench......

roger lance

Bill.....the photo above was made to reasonably replicate your set-up......actually, I'd use a clamp to secure a panel in this way.....


I know your feelings on shop furniture......but you do periodically bring up the bench subject......with all the guys you know I'm sure you can find bench features you'd like......and I'm sure you could easily make a bench with the features your evolving work might require.

Of course, there are factors like shop space, etc. that have to be taken into account.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#18

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

Hank Knight

I think many of us reach a point at which we decide that our current bench isn't meeting our needs. I did. The decision becomes whether to modify it, figure a "work around" like Bill did, or chuck the whole thing and start over. After struggling with my too short, too high, too everything bench for years, I decided it was time to go back to square one and build a new bench. In the years I worked on my old bench, I thought about and cataloged the features I'd like to have on my "ideal" bench. When the time came, I read all the books I could find; and, rather than choosing a traditional design, I designed my own bench and incorporated as many of my cataloged features into it as I could. I spent a lot of time on the design and the building, and a fair amount if money; but I am completely happy with the outcome. It has met my every need; and, in the almost ten years since I completed my bench, I've not been tempted by another, although I still love the traditional designs like Ellis's Klaus bench and the Roubos that come out if the FORP. Yes, there is something of a bench-building fad going on. Chris Schwartz has made a living from it. I know people who have built several benches. But in my case, my bench build build was motivated by necessity. But I didn't jump into the project because of the fad appeal, I thought about it for years. I'm glad I did it and I'm totally satisfied with my bench. Like Derek and others have mentioned, there's a lot of pride and satisfaction that goes with working on a nice bench, one that you built yourself and one that works well for you.

Hank

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#19

Re:  Bench vises

Michael Brady

Some very nicely executed benches in this thread, but mostly narrow vises and iron vises that, in my opinion, are a compromise that requires the the vise and clamp set up shown. A twin screw front vise eliminates almost all need for that. Unless a panel is wider than 18" a good twin screw vise has you in business in just seconds. Same for dovetailing..no need for a Moxon (which is the twin screw vise you could have permanently mounted in place of the born-to rack- iron vise. Yes, the cost is a couple of hundred dollars more. It's money well spent. I agree with the person who said that the bench is the most important woodworking tool.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#20

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

roger lance

Hank.....you know its hard to find a guy, who took the time to research features and then build his bench, who regrets having done so.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#21

Re:  Bench vises

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Unless a panel is wider than 18" a good twin screw vise has you in business in just seconds. Same for dovetailing..no need for a Moxon (which is the twin screw vise you could have permanently mounted in place of the born-to rack- iron vise.

Hi Michael

A twin-screw face vise is not a substitute for a Moxon vise. The purpose of a Moxon is not just to hold boards for dovetailing, but to raise it to a comfortable height for sawing ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#22

Re:  Bench vises

Hank Knight

The advantage of a moxon vise for dovetailing is that it raises the workpiece to a more comfortable working level. I have a twin screw end vise and find it is excelkent for clamping panels. It is, however, something of a compromise as an end vise. I use a similar method for clamping panels to the front of my bench for dovetailing. I imbedded a row of machinest's T Nuts behind the dog hole strips on my bench into which I can screw threaded studs. A couple of large washers and speed handles allows me to clamp panels up to 30" wide to the front of my bench.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/IMG_0083.jpg.html][/URL]

As much as I like this feature, I've been thinking about building a moxon style vise that I can attach to my bench with the threaded studs to elevate a panel for dovetailing.

Hank

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#23

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool w

Hank Knight

You're probably right, Roger. You certainly won't find one here. :)

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#24

Re:  Bench vises

Michael Brady

I find the twin screw front vise just fine for dovetailing. In fact, the handle hang of my dovetail saws is such that raising the work would would require a bend in the wrist instead of of the straight line with my forearm and saw plate. I tried a moxon vise and sold it almost immediately. If I do want a bit more height I just insert a second board behind the work piece for support. I also sit for all dovetail work except the end grain cuts.

To the poster who discounted the twin screw vise as an end vise, I totally agree.

I got into hand tools because I disliked all the jigs and fixtures that power tools dictate. To me, the moxon vise is just another thing to make room for in the shop. I sure many of you like the vise-on bench arrangement, but I suspect that may others have one because they read somewhere they need one.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#25

for me the most important vise attribute.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

is the "quick release" feature of most steel vises. For this reason I bought the largest quick release vise I could find. I would encourage anyone contemplating a purchase to carefully weigh the advantages against their woodworking style.

I used to occasionally use the vise on a friend's bench and it drove me nuts tediously screwing and unscrewing the jaws to accommodate clamping needs of greatly varying depth.

However, I think woodworkers adapt their work to what they have at hand, vise included. Because I can change the jaw spacing easily I use this feature constantly. If I didn't have it I likely would be using some other means to the end. I can't imagine those that don't have quick release enjoy screwing the vise between 1" and 10. On the other hand because my vise doesn't clamp a wide panel I use some other means to clamp a wide panel.

A Moxon vise is one of those pieces shop furniture that would be interesting to build if there wasn't some piece of house furniture more interesting, and useful, to build. Personally, I don't dovetail often enough to justify building and storing a Moxon vise for the small advantage it offers.