New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

Posts

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#26

I agree on all points


Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#27

Re: quick release

david weaver

my end vise on my bench is a QR vise, and a decent quality one (the import version LV sells from eastern europe, it's quite nice, really). With what I do with it, I'd have been better off with a vise that wasn't QR, but I couldn't find a good quality non-QR that would fit in the overhang that I have past the bench legs, and I didn't want my bench to have a huge overhang because i'm working in that area on planes.

I think the detriment on the front vise is that too many of them have 6 tpi metal screws. The wooden screw I have is 2 threads and some change, and it is no trouble at all for quick adjustments because you don't have to turn the handle much. It's lighter to use than a QR vise, too.

I could get used to either, I guess, but the leg vise is where I want a vise. I wouldn't like it as much with a fine thread pitch, but I could get by fine. I'm in hank's boat, forced to build a bench by necessity because it's a fad I've never had interest in. I am glad that I built it after 9 years of woodworking rather than 9 months. That ensures it'll probably be the only one I build, and at this point, I understand the principle that something like a chisel mark in a bench isn't the end of the world. at 9 months into woodworking, I was still diligently trying to make sure my lie nielsen planes didn't rust. I'm sure I would've fretted over every mark that went into a bench surface back then.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#28

I HATE quick release vises..

Paul in NJ

At least all the ones I have tried. I am usually working on pieces the same thickness, like when building a drawer. With the QR vices I have used, you back off the handle and nothing happens until you yank backwards. This seems counter-intuitive to all the years I have been working with a normal screw. You just turn the handle a little, the jaws release, and you can re-position your work. After trying shoulder vises like on a German bench, leg vises, metal vises, I have settled on a twin screw. I use tail vise screws from Lee Valley and a wood jaw. I removed the heads and epoxied on my own from maple so that there would be a bigger bearing surface on the jaw. The screws pass through sloppy holes in the jaw so that I can intentionally rack the jaw for tapered pieces. Wooden screws would be nicer since they have a courser pitch to the threads and would move the jaws more quickly. I had these screws from my previous permutations, maybe when I feel flush I will spring for some wooden ones. I can clamp a 24" panel between the screws or any thing in between. I can also clamp outside of the screws at the end of the jaws. The jaw is flush to the left end of my bench. I usually just squat a little when sawing dovetails in thin boards, no need for a extra Moxon vice for me!


Here is the link to the Lee Valley screws:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=41664&cat=1,41659,41661,41664

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

P.S. Over the years we all develop personal preferences, I am not saying what others do is wrong just what has worked for me.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#29

You illustrated my point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I began life with a quick release vise and developed my woodworking techniques around this capability. I use a vise for a much greater variety of holding applications, hence the advantage of quickly adjusting the span of the jaws. You obviously solve the holding needs I use the vise for by other means.

For example, I have two quick release vises on the front of the bench. When I am breaking down say 12' lumber I lay it across the fully extended vises with the end to be cut off projecting past one of the vises. Others might use a saw horse, or what ever, for this task. I use the quick release vise in so many tasks that I bought the second one for the front of the bench. It is common that one is holding a jig and the other a board to be sawed or shaped.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#30

Re: You illustrated my point

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you a showing some ignorance here, Bill. With a heavy wood screw one can loosen and tighten the vise with a 30 degree rotation of the screw. I can loosen and tighten the vise 30 times in 15 seconds, or reposition a board in the vise in under a second. I have used a "quick release" vise in a professional setting: slow and clumsy.

As far a "breaking a board down" it is much easier to lay the board on trestles, the traditional method, than to secure in two vises the way you suggest. For many boards the sawing can be done by the time it takes to set up the vises.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#31

Re: I HATE quick release vises..

William Duffield

From your comments, I'm guessing you've not used a Record. They do not have the problems you describe. They are much easier to use, whether opening them a little, a moderate amount, or a lot. The vise Bill shows in his photo is a Record, and I have had one on the front of my bench for over 20 years.

I have also worked on benches equipped with the type of quick release vise you describe (e.g., Jorgensen), and I also am not at all fond of them.

Also, the Records don't rack. As I have not used any Groz or Eclipse clones of the Record design, I can't tell you whether they are made to the close tolerances of the Records.

You will have to search eBay or other Used Tool sources to find a Record built in England. I don't know whether someone is now manufacturing Records in some other country, but if they are, I would be wary.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#32

Apparently my communication skills are failing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I do understand perfectly that the vice you describe can quickly grab and release a succession of 1" parts, say drawer sides for dovetailing. It is obvious even to me that if that is what the vise is mainly used for that it is a preferred vise for the task, especially if you already have one. It would probably take several more degrees of handle rotation to accomplish catch and release on a Record vise.

Apparently what I failed to communicate is that I use a vise for a great variety of grasping tasks that require in succession a great variety of jaw extensions, so much so, that cheap as I am, I bought a second vise for the bench.


I appreciate that you have taught me how to break down long lumber. In spite of the many hundreds of bdft of lumber I have done the way my son in law illustrates in the picture it never occurred to me how much time I could save by employing the saw horses that are stored just a few feet from the bench. I have mostly used them just for holding shorter lengths of lumber in process, or long lengths before hoisting to the extended vises for shortening.

No doubt I have failed to discover the best saw for my needs too. I used to use a chain saw when I broke down lumber out in the lumber storage shed. But I am into quieter woodworking now and I am not working the volume of lumber I used to. At the time I was too cheap to buy a radial arm saw and I never found the chop saw convenient because I never had it permanently set up.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#33

Re: Apparently my communication skills are failing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is nothing wrong with the way you work, Bill. However it is somewhat tiresome to hear that your methods are "arguably" as fast or as secure as another when they are not, or faster than traditional methods when they are not. It is like someone invented an octagonal wheel and pronounced it the best. No, we don't need two quick release vises to cross cut a board, and no it is not faster either.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#34

Vises in a Period Furniture shop

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


A few years ago I took a class in the Mack Headley and Sons shop in Winchester VA. This shop only makes and repairs Period Furniture and has now for 4 generations. Mack Sr. had recently died when I took the class. One son and a partner, Steve Hamilton, carried on building and repairing, and the other son was a cabinet maker at Williamsburg.


It happened that I was assigned Mack Sr.'s bench for the class. It was a humbling experience, contemplating the hundreds of pieces of Period Furniture that had been built and repaired at this bench. I think the vise is a Jorgenson (worked like one) and a smaller version served as a tail vise.



This next picture is the vise on Steve's bench. Steve was showing us sharpening a scraper. I did not take a picture of Jeff's steel vise and I don't know what kind it was.

I am not suggesting that steel vises are for everyone, but these examples suggest one is not necessarily ignorant for using them.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#35

Re: Vises in a Period Furniture shop

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, the point to take note of is that Mack Snr worked on a bench with a face/shoulder vise (regardless of type), tail vise into dog holes, and a sliding deadman. How does your set up compare?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#36

Re: Vises in a Period Furniture shop

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The Headley shop has good woodworkers, but they are not so interested in hand tool work. When a few years ago they demonstrated at the annual Williamsburg conference they were a little like fish out of water. They kept saying things like "This is a lot easier on a bandsaw" or "We have a jig for this at home."

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#37

Work from the Headley shop

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.




The first piece is the restoration of the window cornice from the Lincoln Bedroom, White House. The second some Chippendale chairs. Readers can be their own judge of the shop's hand tool skills demonstrated in these photos.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#38

You reinforced my point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To summarize: If you are a hand tool purist then look to a 1720 shop for guidance. However, if you are like the vast majority of people that build furniture today, building in a mixed hand tool-machine tool shop, you might find more useful guidance in a modern mixed tool shop.

Re: One doesn't need a fancy bench for hand tool work

#39

Absurd

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used three different methods for holding wide boards for cutting dovetails. All three are faster to use and more secure than the method you have outlined. You don't even know what the methods are, and you are condemning them, arguing that people who use machinery should not use them? It is absurd. And there is no reason that workers who use machinery should not use the most efficient methods for hand work when they do hand work. They are not restricted to use quick release vises, or to avoid cross cutting in the most efficient manner.