Re: Ooops
Brian Holcombe
It's about 1/2 the price of cherry for me, and 1/4 the price of high quality walnut. I can also get good boards, 12' long entirely straight grain in 4/4 and 8/4. I find it similarly baffling that it is so cheap.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Ooops
Brian Holcombe
It's about 1/2 the price of cherry for me, and 1/4 the price of high quality walnut. I can also get good boards, 12' long entirely straight grain in 4/4 and 8/4. I find it similarly baffling that it is so cheap.
confirmation
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Surprised by the apparent resolution of a Pilot 205 0.5 mm pencil line I began to use this pencil instead of a marking knife for the rest of my M&T layout on the demilune table. In my lighting the scribe line is easier to see on walnut, however the resolution of the pencil line is no less as confirmed by another experiment.
I was driven to cut a board to length with a hand saw (table saw occupied with a complex set up). I marked a pencil line across the board and then scribed over it with a Blue Spruce marking knife, one of the thinnest on the market. The scribe line obliterated the pencil line which means the knife line is as wide or wider (certainly not by much) than the pencil line. I continue to be surprised by this revelation but convinced the two means to marking are equivalent in resolution.
question
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
what kind of pencil are you chiseling? I presumed that the lead in a mechanical pencil turns in use which would render chiseling useless. But maybe not...another experiment in order. (and how do you chisel the point-sand paper?)
Re: I'll second the float..
david weaver
..except I don't have a joinery float, but instead a plane bed float (lie nielsen, but that doesn't matter, either).
It is the easiest thing I have used for small adjustments to a tenon. To the point that I can place my thumb on the float where it contacts a tenon and count on the float to remove about a thousandth per stroke.
Literally make the wood disappear to the mark if there is one, or very carefully remove it if there isn't one.
There is plenty of market for the bed float if you decide it's not for you, the trial would probably cost $10 in the exchange, but I doubt you'd want to give it up once you have used it.
Re: question
Steve Elliott
I use my ordinary yellow #2 pencil and start with it freshly sharpened. To make the mark I pull the pencil down the square several times until the point has taken on the square shape of the inside corner.The result is a wide line that stops exactly where the square was positioned. I actually use this technique more often when marking off a workpiece than with a square. It's my preferred method for cutting a piece to length to fit between two other pieces, say a rail cut to fit between two stiles in a face frame. It's MUCH more accurate than measuring.
Re: I'll second the float..
Bob Lang
God bless Larry Williams and Tom Lie-Nielsen for bringing back the float. You can also get them from the Liogier website. Both are excellent but the Lie-Nielsen is a bit beefier. With a plane, chisel or rasp I need to be very conscious of keeping the tool flat while using it. The float seems like it wants to stay flat and it is my go-to tool for shaving off a tiny bit of wood in a predictable way, both for tenons and mortises. Probably overkill if your tenons aren't so big or you work with a softer wood. For three inch long through tenons in quartersawn white oak, they are just the ticket.

Almost as good are the "Japanese milled tooth files" and "Japanese milled tooth plane makers floats" from Lee Valley. A lot less money, but they are a bit grabbier and in some of them the teeth don't go all the way to the edge. One of the advantages of the ones like in the photo is you can work into a corner without doing any damage to the adjacent surface. You could experiment with the 5/8" wide medium flat file from LV for about $20 + shipping. I bet you like it.
Bob Lang
Re: maybe not
Sgian Dubh
I didn't know there was another way Bill. Dovetail rakes (when cut first) are normally marked with a pencil (if marked at all), then sawn - I don't think I know anyone that habitually marks the rakes with a knife of some sort. The sawn rakes of the dovetails are, of course, transferred to the pin board - for that I do use a knife, a bird's beak knife. It can be a bit tedious or tricky doing this on coarse woods, such as oak, ash, wenge, etc, because the knife tends to want to follow the open grain, and this job is far less tricky in fine textured woods such as maple, tulip poplar, cherry, etc. Slainte.
Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?
Charlie
Set your gauge to the chisel so that the tenon is a perfect fit with just a bit of the line left in. Once you lose the lines, you've lost all your signposts to accuracy.
Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
It is nice to see someone using hand tools like saw and chisel.
I had one idea that might help CJ. That is to use a fixed point mortise gauge. You have a set of points on the mortise gauge fixed for a specific mortise chisel. That way you eliminate the variable of setting up the gauge. The gauge marks the same width every time you use it. If you find that you consistently are sawing tenons that are two fat or too thin, you can make a very small adjustment to the width ofthe gauge by filing the pins a little.
Here is Roubo's mortise gauge. Benjamin Seaton made a similar gauge, but with four sets of pins, all at one end

Perhaps
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Perhaps if you cut a few more boards to length with a handsaw you might notice some benefits of marking with a knife.
Re: questions
TomD
Sorry been away a while. Normally if I am doing through mortises I shoot them from both sides. I have a wooden backer that would be just fine for supporting the wood and eliminating tear-out, but it is a large piece and something would have to be worked out to deal with using a larger chisel and then returning to a smaller one. Part of the reason for my only use one size strategy, but over the years I have used larger sizes. For me the simplest thing is to use the chisels from both sides. Of course one keeps the same face on the fence, no matter how well centred the chisel is. In a production setting it would be worth working out something so one could go right through. The other thing is that as one goes through, the chip escapement in a deep cut closes off, and the whole thing gets hot. Coming from both sides reduces that problem.
Re: question
TomD
I work on the tenon, and in a "production" situation it would be freehand on a router table. That would be a minimalist sort of one man shop production. If the piece is really big then hand tools are normally used. And I would use a hand tools in most situations. Normally I can't get a router set up in a decent amount of time. I just bought 2 more, and plan on several more to boot. But all for specialized jigs. I don't do enough tenons of one type and set-up for furniture to make that interesting.
I could certainly work the mortise, and there are some jobs like plane making where that is exactly what I do, but the tenon is easier to get to, and since the mortising machine should turn out perfect parts why mess with perfection. My Grandfather's shop had a mortising machine in it, that was the one tool they had. So the idea of a jigged mortising machine has a lot of history. I guess they could freehand the tenons easily enough.
Re: Photos of mortise and tenons
TomD
You know what makes gaps disappear? Doing it right the first time!
Just kidding, filing tenons or dovetails the right way during finishing, and you can hide a bus load of tourists. Krenov wasn't a fool, you can cut great joints, but if you finish with a file, it will look like you did either way.
I am not being coy here, I don't know which is the right way, but it is pretty obvious when you do it, like patting a cat, you want to push the endgrain into the sidegrain, I think. I just do it, I would have to stop and think next time I do. Speaking of which, obviously I don't leave any gaps, but you can make a nice joint look bad, so in self defence you have to do this even if you never, never, leave a gap.
Speaking of what to do when, The existence of double mortising chisels is a sign as to which they worked first or second.
Re: question on pencils.
TomD
I have a collection of small stubby pencils that Lee Valley hands out. I sharpen them, they get written with slightly, then the point is a little rounded, then I grind them on some sandpaper I have on the sharpener body. This cuts from the point out, a flat. The flat is then parabolic and the "point" knife edged. You can easily see the flat because it is stained with graphite. Having a piece of sandpaper on a backer is standard artist gear. One can lay out about a joint this way, and while I like to do it that way, it isn't necessary.
This is a little like what I do. In this case the parabola occurs because they intersect the cone to one side of the point. I like the end to be slightly rounded so that I can have the whole side in line, pretty much right up the wood, not just the lead. But the principle is the same.

Re: Perhaps not
TomD
Or as Franz Klausz put it, "If you are very-beginer, you can even mark the cut rather than cutting it by eye" (to paraphrase). I am generally, but not invariably, very beginner as far as that goes. I always try to do the cuts by eye when framing, one can get a good flow on a bunch of pieces. And then there are the folks with the really shiny saw plates...
Re: confirmation - Mechanicals
TomD
It is a bit like front sights. They may almost cover the target but the eye will naturally center them so the width and resolution are not entirely the same issue. In some forms of shooting, maybe most notably archery, the sighting is at a spinal level, or sub conscious, or so they say. Maybe related is the whole idea that in a defensive shooting you are blind, angry and surprised if you respond correctly within the training. The body has to be programmed to do a variety of things while you are only controlling the most important thing, because your mind can't be two places at once. That is why putting out takes so long.
By the way, they make .3 mm pencils if that gets the juices flowing.
And further, there is a second type of mechanical, the clutch pencil. It uses a lead that is 2mm thick. It is mounted in a sorta pin vice deal in the pencil. There is a special sharpener, that sharpens the lead only, via a sorta whirling grinder. Then you can work the lead with sandpaper for any effect you want. The leads are pretty tough so you can extend them to work in far off corners.
http://kevsart.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/Staedtler-Mars-Technico-2mm-Clutch-Pencils.jpg
I didn't embed it because it is huge.
Re: I'll second the float..
TomD
While floats are nice to have, the hack saw blade used at an angle is not to be underestimated.
Re: Tell me more
TomD
You can make your own float with a file and some O1. I don't heat treat them they last well enough, but obviously if you are buying one heat treating would be nice. The rasps I have used are not as accurate, nor do they cut square and to the edge. I occasionally come across files that look like a float. I use hack saw blades and also a keyhole saw. And they work fine on a lot of these things. You go corner to corner with the blades to detect flaws, as you would with a straight edge. When you find a high spot, you can take it out by a sort of lateral skidding action. They cut quite nicely.
LN, by the way, makes a thicker float, and then a thinner (1/8") one for planes. In my own efforts, I use 3/16 stock and just relieve the tip at an angle, that way it goes down into the mouth, yet it is overall stiffer. It's a twofer.
Re: confirmation - Mechanicals
William Duffield
The Pilots also have clutches, and also a tubular steel support in front of the clutch and a toroidal rubber brake around the lead. The brake holds the lead extended, so the clutch can be retracted when the finger is released, without pulling the lead back inside the tube.
Re: Conic Sections
William Duffield
To be picky, the conic section in your diagram is an ellipse, not a parabola. The diagram at the link below details the differences, depending on the angle you slice it.
In practice, it doesn't really matter, since it is only the sharpness of the point that makes a difference to the line we draw.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conic_section#/media/File:Conic_sections_with_plane.svg
Re: Example? Photos
William Duffield
On your Delta machine, to fix the problems with the stock lifting when you extract the chisel, and to improve on the accuracy of the angle iron fence, you could replace them both with a cross slide vise (or a milling table and machinist's vise, if you've got them). After using one, I wouldn't anymore use a mortiser without one.
http://www.harborfreight.com/6-inch-cross-slide-vise-32997.html
Even a cheap one, like the one in the link, works well enough.
Re: Conic Sections
TomD
Fair point, though it isn't an ellipse on my pencil it is more like a teardrop, the wood side trail off a lot. I wouldn't use the actual form in that picture.
Re: Example? Photos
TomD
Thanks but I like it just as it is. As you can see in the picture of my other machine, it has built in vise and handwheels. I find the Delta is faster to use, and the results are perfect, it is a really nice machine. But if a machine is any good, it should provide results at least as good as my bottom of the barrel technology. I even got great results with my original set-up which was a Taiwan version for a drill press. I still use those chisels. I don't like the drill press versions for a variety of reason, mostly on my unit which was pretty typical with a 5/8" chuck, it just felt pressed using the press to push into Maple. I don't like abusing tools. My current DP is a Buffalo Forge, and it could jack up a car. But by now I have my options. I also have two milling machines, and a shaper, the shaper can cut interior holes, which might be interesting at some point. One thing the horizontal mill is nice for is drilling out dowels that fail, as they can do. A mill cutter will go right through a dowel that is harder than surrounding wood, and then it isn't there.
I'm not sure why Bill had the problems he had, but his machine should be better than either of mine. I remember jealous feeling during the run of the acquisition thread
. The most likely reason might be the chisel is somehow loose, though that would be apparent on insertion. With a less capable operator, one might wonder if he had the proper bushing for the machine. Can't see that in this case. So it is a bit mysterious. I suppose it would be possible to have a "correct" bushing that wasn't a good fit regardless. That is why we have metal lathes in our hand tool shops.
The chisel doesn't lift the workpiece up if the workpiece is higher than the fence. If it is lower, I use a shim, but in some cases it isn't worth the set-up time. I guess I should just fix the hold down so it presses lower than the fence, but I get by.
Re: Example? Photos
William Duffield
I couldn't see the table on your big machine.
If it's anything like the table on the floor standing Powermatic machine, I think it works great.
I had two very annoying problems with my drill press attachment mortiser.
First, it was too much trouble to attach and detach it (removing and reinstalling the depth stop in the process), and I need the drill press quite often for drilling holes, etc. Once, I even broke the cast iron collar that holds the depth stop.
The second problem is the hold down fork wasn't machined flat on the bottom and square to the table, so I could never prevent the stock from lifting or being dented and scratched by the hold down. It wasn't even machined––just knocked out of the mold and spray painted. I was always afraid I was going to split the stock or break a chisel.
Both the DP and the HCM attachment are by JET.
Re: Example? Photos
John in NM
I have the twin of your bigger machine. Mine works about as well as you say yours does 
Friend of mine has the Bridgewood version, his works quite well. One route I am considering is making a Delrin gib to reduce slop in the ways - currently if I tighten the table up to reduce slop it becomes very hard to move.
Good info on adjusting the auger depth in the chisel btw.