New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

Posts

An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#1

An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

CJ in MPLS

Woodworking magazines tend to be rather cyclical in their subject matter. One of the topics that comes up periodically, as well it should, is the order of operations for fitting doors and/or drawer fronts into an opening. However I do not ever recall seeing the same type of article on the trimming of tenons or mortises to ensure a good fit. This topic is generally handled as an aside, i.e. 'take a whisper off of the tenon to achieve a good fit."

I have seen an article on undercutting the bearing surfaces of joints to ensure that the mating pieces pull up tight and I have seen the tip on spotting a joint (usually dovetails) with pencil lead to find high spots. However neither of these appear well aligned with fitting a tenon to a mortise as there are a few problems, the main one being that the surfaces being fit are not easily viewable. I can tell that the tenon does not fit, but I cannot easily discern which surface needs to be trimmed to free it up.

It is a given that a good practice is to first ensure that the joint has been properly marked, mortised, and sawn. In one sense, doing this properly may avoid the problem entirely. In another, it limits the nature of the problem to ones that are addressable in an organized fashion. If one is haphazard in layout or execution, the problems are likely to be much more complex. So to set the stage, I am really only talking about an organized approach to tweaking the joint and not a treatise on fixing the kind of cock up where the mortise is 1/8" too large or the tenon has an unintentional 5 degree complex angle to it.

I presume that one would start as one usually does in that reference surfaces are designated (male and female portions of the joint) and then inspected for any obvious defects. But from there I'm starting to rely on pecking away at the parts until something works, which in the end often results in a sloppier fit than I'm happy with.

To complicate matters, if one is dealing with through tenon (which is why I'm thinking of this), the distal end of the tenon cannot be willy-nilly trimmed until it fits as the distal end may well then be made smaller than the exit opening of the mortise. In this instance, my inclination would be to verify that the tenon tip and the exit of the mortise are indeed the correct dimensions, whereafter i would start to enlarge the mortise from its opening side. Throughout all of this I take long moments to breathe deeply and to banish from my mind the idea of swinging a mallet a bit harder to see if that works.

CJ

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#2

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

Brian Holcombe

With regard to through tenons I find that my gauging and reference surfaces must be accurate.

If I know my gauge lines to be accurate, then I know my problem must be elsewhere in the fit, a convex surface is the most likely culprit. So I hunt for those first.

Some other diagnostic tools I use; I measure the outside dimensions of the mortised part, if it has bulged at all than there is an interference causing the bulge and that must be rectified. If the part is bulging at any spot, than the mating surfaces are not likely in full contact.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#3

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

TomD

I prefer to just cut them properly in the first place as I share you disquiet over chasing the parts that need to be altered. I have a hollow chisel mortiser, it is interesting how many mortising projects proceed in 4s. Before one knows it, there are some stratospheric number of parts to cut. But when making the mortises by hand, as I have often done, through mortises at least allow you to accurately measure the dimensions from both ends, and then simply ensure all the material was removed in a straight line from the layout on either side. If that is done, or the mortises are machined, they should not need to be spotted in.

The tenons are then roughed either by hand or by bandsaw, or TS. If you are making enough, you can go directly to dimensions off the TS. That rarely happens for me. My method to optimize the tenons, is to trim them freehand on the router table. This allows minute adjustments, very quickly. I picked this method up from Kelly Mayer. The hand tool equivalent is a router plane mounted in a table. This method is way more positive than the various methods of messing around with hand planes. I want tenons to almost feel like they would hold without glue, certainly not be loose. I use the spear point bit and find the downgrain side, and just slice off the excess from that side.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#4

I'm lost in the description

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A summary of the question or example of the problem would be helpful. While I find it common that one doesn't initially fit satisfactorily, adjusting to getting a M&T joint right has never been something I have found taxing, which likely means I am not understanding something about your question. The cause of the misfit is typically obvious which leads to an obvious fix.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#5

Simple enough

CJ in MPLS

What I am doing is cutting angled through tenons in a small foot stool (from an FWW article from a few years ago). I struggled with getting a couple of the double tenons to fit and it made me wonder if anyone had developed a simple method of addressing mis-cut tenons. The glue is now drying so I'm past the problem but I couldn't really describe the approach I used other than to say I figured it out.

The issue seems to be that as one builds experience, said experiences translates into fewer problems with the tasks at hand and a deeper, though at times unconscious, understanding of what went wrong and how it can be fixed. This eventually leads to a simple solution of doing things correctly the first time with a bare minimum of tweaking required to get things to work properly. I doubt very much that you still chant 'righty tighty, lefty loosey' every time you pick up a screw driver.

Other than doing this correctly the first time, do you have an approach you recommend for getting tenons to fit?

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#6

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

Martin S.

Can you explain what you mean by: "My method to optimize the tenons, is to trim them freehand on the router table. This allows minute adjustments, very quickly. I picked this method up from Kelly Mayer."

I don't understand the part about trimming them freehand on the router table.

Also, did you mean Kelly Mehler? I don't recall him ever teaching that technique.

I have a hard time getting tenons to fit snug, so I am interested in your technique.

Thanks,

Martin

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#7

Timely question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am fitting tenons in a demilune table.

I, and most of us, aren't making tenons often enough to get a satisfactory result every time. But there isn't a generic answer for how to make the fit. It depends on how the mortises and tenons were made and what the fit looks like. The bottom line is to remove material for what ever part is easiest to remove material from to solve the fit problem.

For example, I make mortises with a hollow chisel mortise. It leaves a less than perfect edge. Step 1 is to smooth the sides a bit. If the tenon is too tight I might do a bit more side smoothing with a wide chisel. But I don't try to ever significantly widen a mortise with a chisel for I am unsuccessful at this task. I would rather shave the tenon with a shoulder plane(because that is what I have) or for a smidgen I use a rasp.

If the tenon is too small I glue on a shim. I keep on hand trimmings of various thickness pieces of hardwood for shims as needed.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#8

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

TomD

That's the guy, I guess. He did a shaker table video for FWW, might be online by now. I can't remember exactly how he did it, but I copied his method, right down to the expedient router table in the garbage can, though that isn't important. But I do add things, so I am not certain.

What I do is bandsaw the tenons just proud of the line, I mark out with a gage, though one could eliminate that step in multiples. You then set up your router table so that a straight flute bit sticks up and the fence is set to the side so that the bit can't hit the shoulders. You set the flute to the line, and just freehand back and forth till all the waste is gone. I leave probably about a 1/8" at the shoulder. The amount being removed is hardly much more than the wobble in the bandsaw blade, so it is pretty minimal which makes this reasonably safe. I size the bit to the amount of wood I expect to waste, and what I feel I can easily control.

KM may have actually used his pin router for this step, and the expedient router thing might have been for those of us who don't have one. With a pin router and the pin sized to match the bit, one should be able to come in right to the shoulder. So long as the shoulders are even, and if they aren't, they soon will be.

The final eight inch, that I hang back from the shoulder is removed with a chisel. At this point one has the whole tenon to support the cut, so it isn't a feel or fit thing, it is just going to cut to the same level as the router did.

You can use a router plane in the same way as a corded router, but the router table is good when one has 80 to do, whether power or hand router.

For really large tenons, I normally do the router part on the jointer. What all three methods have in common is they are indexed off the face of the part, not didding around with the tenon for a reference. Which works best if the parts are clean.

With any of these if the tenon is a whisker too thick, you just raise the cutter and take another pass, you can waste microscopic amounts of tenon this way.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#9

Re: Timely question

TomD

I get perfect results off a chisel mortiser, and the one I use is a table to machine, though I have a larger chinese one. YOu have a superb one so if you need to play with them after cutting, something is wrong with the cutters or the set-up. By poerfect results I mean that I don't mess with the results, and that on through tenons they look square and neat.

Normally if the holes aren't nice and your machine is righteous, then the problem is the chisel isn't square, which is easy to read in the cut, or the auger projection is bad. Normally the auger is sticking out too far if you have some rounds in there. The auger should be as tight to the chisel as possible, while maintaining chip flow. There shouldn't be any scorching. Some say the auger should be spaced the thickness of a dime, others say it should be shoved all the way up and then it decends when the chuck is tightened, but whatever one does, it should have good chip flow and stuff should stay cool.

Obviously the chisels need to be good (mine are taiwanese), and everything needs to be sharp.

If I had to take a chisel to the mortise after machining it with Ks worth of machinery, I would toss that machine.

I know is off topic as far as hand tool purism is concerned, but the HCM is quieter, faster, and as clean cutting as hand tools. In many ways it is a hand tool, it is no more mechanical than a plane other than the way it removes the chips, which ideally is not the part that shows in the finished piece, any more than bandsaw marks. And stationary mortisers are traditional. I had one of the ones that used a single bevel cutter, but it was not as much fun, and I sold it to a historical site. It also took up too much space.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#10

Example?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Please post a picture of your mortises. I would like to compare my results to your perfect mortises.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#11

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

Tony - Memphis

Ha! Mine would probably work much better if I did! That's one thing that I find the magazines and such lacking in - the fine detail. The fitting and fussing part of joinery and such. I generally get the tenons real close on the tablesaw usiong a jig. I like to take the last few shavings off with a shoulder plane. Doing that, I find I get much more control and can even guide the fit if one side is fatter than the other. Nothing is truly flat, square, etc., so I like to fit by hand. Tools of choice for me are a Clifton shoulder plane and a Lie-Nielsen rabbet block plane. Very satisfying when the joint finally fits....just right! And sometimes, a little glued on veneer helps - oops! (just did that on my current project - also glad my dovetails are hidden on this one - worse worse worse half blinds I have ever done!)

Never done any serious through tenons. I was watching a RoughCut over the weekend and noticed their fit on the through tenon (exit side) was awful! I was really surprised. It came off the mortiser and had those tiny little steps in it. I was thinking of ways to avoid that and my last thought was to fine tune the outer edges and then wedge the tenon to make it fill in the opening nice and tight. In some applications, the wedges look nice too. Not always appropriate I guess.

Tony

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#12

just fit one.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


My hollow chisel mortises always require a bit of clean up with a chisel Tom's recollections not withstanding. Then it came time to fit the tenon. It was a tiny bit too snug in width and one prong of the tenon seemed a bit too tall. In this case I took a small shaving from the side of the mortise and pared a bit off the end I thought too short. The sides of a hollow chisel mortise are a bit wavy so it is easy to remove a bit from the side, using the profile as a depth gauge. The result was satisfactory so I quit. Had it been still too tight in thickness I would have planed off the side of the tenon with a shoulder plane. I find it easier to pare the height of the mortise than the tenon.

Bottom line...for me no set procedure. I adjust where it seems easiest to do so.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#13

Thanks!


Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#14

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

David Charlesworth

My method employs a simple stick, planed up to fit the mortices. (A dummy tennon sized stick) NB there may be some variation and the stick will pick this up.

Measure stick thickness with callipers.

Saw all the face side cheeks on my very good bandsaw, taking great care to get these positioned correctly.

Saw non face side cheeks a fraction full.

Use router or router plane to shave non face side cheeks (only) to size indicated by stick.

This should be a nice sliding fit with no slop.

David Charlesworth

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#15

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

TomD

Good tip! In my case, my tenon is my stick, once the first one is set, the rest will go right in. I can usually tell with the corner of a tenon if it is too tight.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#16

Re: Example?

TomD

Actually I was planing to do that. Who was it around here who said they didn't like the "If there aren't any photos it didn't happen" routine?

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#17

1/4" chisel

TomD

One thing I do do that is fairly rinky dink is I do almost all my mortises with the one chisel. I use a 1/4 inch chisel for everything. I guess if I had a lot of half inch or whatever chisels I would tune those up, but it seems that most of my stock is 3/4" and I prefer to march around on other large mortices. But it does get tedious for me, so I will move up. Just most of the time if I have a shot at doing it with a 1/4" I don't mess with the set-up.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#18

Hand Tool Forum

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it is kind of surprising how many respondents on this forum can't seem to operate a sash saw or a tenon saw. We have heard about table saws, band saws, mortising machines, routers, and leaving extra to be removed later. It sounds like few have learned to saw a straight line.

I read CJ's original message several times. I got the impression he was doing hand work, not machine work, but may be I am wrong.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#19

Re: Hand Tool Forum

CJ in MPLS

Well, yes. I was doing hand work, though by the last couple of mortises, I did cheat a bit by using forstner bits to hog out the waste.

If I had to summarize what has been suggested, it would be as follows:

1. Verify that all layout lines are where they are supposed to be.

2. Verify that the dimensions of the tenon and the mortise are as they are supposed to be.

3. Look for any obvious discrepancies/defects in the tenons and mortises.

I suppose that it would be a good idea to NOT take action until the joint has been fully inspected.

Assuming that the layout is correct and the dimensions are nominally as they should be, one should proceed to correcting any obvious problems, with care being taken to NOT modify the layout or dimensions of the parts.

From this point I believe that corrections should be made on a more empirical basis, with an eye towards first correcting reference surfaces and then maintaining those as one proceeds. For example, if a rail is to maintain a set offset from the front of a leg, then one should take care to avoid modifications that would change that offset.

If, in the course of correcting the joint, the fit becomes loose, then one may use the old veneer trick to tighten things back up again.

Finally, keeping mind that one gets better with practice, avoid the temptation to start with the most prominent/visible joint. Start with the hidden one and the work your way towards the foreground.

None of this is particularly necessary I suppose. However I was curious and it is helpful to me to consider these things before diving in. It is this kind of thinking that converts a plan of attack from a W.A.G. to a S.W.A.G., if you know what I mean.

CJ

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#20

I like it.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I will suggest to Ellis that this wisdom be added to the Archives.

I have never been able to mass produce well fit M&T joints. I feel less inadequate that someone else has found this problem and developed an effective means to dealing with it.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#21

good summary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Having just fit the M&T for the demilune table I could compare your summery to what I more of less subconsciously did. Works for me. Good summary of the process.

As part time woodworkers making stuff we are wise to consider the process most assured of success and not necessarily the fastest or most Period Correct.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#22

missing the point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the question was about "an organized approach to tweaking the joint ". That is to say, how ever one arrived at a slightly misfit M&T joint, is there an organized approach to make it satisfactory. In many of the responses the process described to do the final adjustment involved hand tools.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#23

Re: missing the point

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't think you have experience making the joint by hand. Since CJ made his by hand, if he sawed away from the line by accident, he would still have the line visible to pare to.

With machine work you are measuring the distance of the mortise from the face, trying to duplicate that distance for the saw or whatever, and measuring the distance to the far side of the mortise (or adding the mortise width to the first measurement). A very sloppy method with compounding of errors. Many machine guys make multiple tenons in scrap to get a fit the are satisfied with. Which is alright if you are making 40 joints, not so good for four.

Hand work is very different. You lay out the mortise and tenon with the same gauge setting, which is much more accurate, and you work directly to the line.

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#24

Re: missing the point

Bob Lang

For what it's worth, I regularly set machines up to my layout lines, and use the same gauge (or combination square) settings to layout matching pieces. It's a method precise woodworkers use regardless of hand or power tool preference.

Bob Lang

Re: An ordered approach to fitting tenons?

#25

Re: good summary

Steve Voigt

As part time woodworkers making stuff we are wise to consider the process most assured of success and not necessarily the fastest or most Period Correct.

It's probably not a great idea to generalize from your own experience and assume that everybody else shares your goals and circumstances. For one thing, not everybody is a part time or hobbyist woodworker. I count at least 3 people in this thread alone who work wood for pay, either full or part time. Forums like this are read by all sorts, including instrument makers, toolmakers, and pro furniture makers, not just hobbyists.

But even if you assume that most are hobbyists, it doesn't necessarily follow that they should "consider the process most assured of success." I spent years doing just that, until I realized about a decade ago that I had made a lot of stuff but had few real skills. At that point I started trying, whenever practical, to choose the method that would build an enduring foundation of skills, even if the probability of making a lot of scrap was increased. Sometimes you have to break some eggs.

By the way, there are a small number of people, like Zach Dillinger or Joshua Klein (and presumably Warren?) for whom choosing the "period correct" method is an essential, non-negotiable part of the process. Surely their aims are as worthy of consideration as those of the guy who want to choose the lowest-risk way of making stuff.