The rest of the world hasn' t missed a discovery
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
It would be revealing to know why you think I route out half blind waste with a router. I actually make drawers, quite a few in the past year, and lots more in past years. So, in making these drawers do you think I have failed to discover chiseling, have not tried it, am too inept to do it efficiently?
If I am making one drawer I chisel it as I did recently for someone. If I am making 18 drawers in thin stock, as I did recently, I chisel too. But, if I am making 8 big ones for a chest of drawers I route the half blinds, not because I am stupid but because I have found that with my skill and experience level of chiseling and routing, routing is faster. On a big project faster usually wins, but not always.
The bottom line of it is that I (and I presume most others) do what they do because their experience (key word here) has proven that what they do is best for their situation. The persons actually making something gets to make the "best" judgment, not the bystanders. The bystanders get to judge whether it is relevant to their work.
That said, when offering a technique one owes the reader some additional information on experience and situation. For example- Alan Batty, English tradesman, told me his quota for drawers in an English factory where he worked was 6 per day. The tools were chisel and saw. The choice of wood and style helped productivity. Making 6 a day keeps one proficient. I can assess from all this information that 6 a day with hand tools will be the best that can be done. And I can conclude that a part time woodworker working N. American wood and N. American style dovetails is going to do substantially fewer with the same tools.
Based on what Alan told me I could post that one should be able to "make 6 drawers a day with a chisel and saw". But without context this statement would be greatly misleading and irrelevant to most people.
In my case I document what I build in posts and in the gallery. Anyone can judge my suggestions and recommendations against what I document that I actually do.
You claim that your way is the best way for many woodworking operations. What led you to your conclusion- built drawers this month, watched drawers being built in some shop, read about drawers in a book? Provide some context. What have you built this year that involved several half blind drawers? ( Pictures please) Only when we know what you actually build will we be able to assess how your recommendations and criticism fit our work.