New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Posts

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#51

more needless (eventually) fiddling

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Again, for the undecided others to consider, it is quick and reliable to use the guideline of the existing saw kerf to pare away the side waste. I mount the board vertical in the vice and with a few thrusts of the chisel I reliably pare to the plane established by the saw kerf, and this waste is gone. Everyone I know removes this waste without the aid of deepening. No additional tool to buy and no extra step to completion. It all can be done with a single chisel wider than the socket is tall.

In the path from beginner to professional (see definition below) it can make good sense to employ aids to ensure success. What I see and experience is that these aids eventually become unnecessary. When they add extra steps they get abandoned as soon as they become unnecessary. It would seem a worthy goal to be rid of extra steps as soon as one is comfortable doing so.

Definition "Professional" by Curtis Buchannan To paraphrase for the occasion, you are professional at a task when you become assured of the result. For example, I am professional at making butter milk pancakes and Pizza. I am not professional at making French Bread.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#52

Re: For others to judge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If it is faster to use a router than a chisel, it makes me wonder about a guy's chisel technique.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#53

Hmmm....

John in NM

How is this better than simply using a dovetailing jig and a dovetailing bit?

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#54

Dag nab it, Bill......

roger lance

there you go getting me into a position of showing an alternative method that calls into question our chiseling ability, premature router bit wear, and advocating that this is somehow better than using a dovetail router jig.....

What ????......you didn't mean to do any of that.....just show another method.....

Never mind......

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#55

Re: more needless (eventually) fiddling

TomD

Let's not screw up more words, the word for that is competent. Professional means mostly paid, or organized like a profession as with say lawyers.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#56

Re: A more efficient and less risky means to this

TomD

The Headley shop method I like is the one where he cuts dovetails with one blow from each side, or maybe one side, using a very fine wedge shaped chisel, though not useful of the blind example here.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#57

Re: Hmmm....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi John

The router is just a means of speeding up the removal of waste from pins in half-blind dovetails. A router jig is limiting insofar as the tail sizing is fixed.

In the example I showed it was used with hard Jarrah when I had 24 drawer ends to excavate. I was experimenting at the time. It turned out to be an excellent method ..... if you wish to use a router, which I do not. I have not used this method since that particular build (some 4 years ago now).

What the alternative method is - which I do use - is to drill a series of holes along the baseline (use an eggbeater or any other hand drill). This still enables one to split out most of the waste. A chisel cleans up the remainder.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#58

Re: Hmmm....

John in NM

Well yes, I understand all that.

I just find the picture Bill posted to be rather odd because it is, I think, at contradictory with the claim of more efficient and safer. Use of a jig and a dovetail bit can make that claim, at the expense of a machine made look to the work.

What I'm saying is that freehanding with a router requires learning a skill just as does cutting precisely with a saw and chisel. Removing the jig removes the efficiency of using a router at all, unless there is an extreme in wood hardness to overcome, as in your example.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#59

Re: For others to judge

Dan Rode

I don't have much experience with half blind dovetails but I've done a few.

I've used a drill press to remove some of the waste and that made the chopping go faster. However, I don't think it saved me any time overall.

With a router, my concern is not only the setup time, but hand guiding a router near my baseline seems fraught with danger. I've used routers for years and they are my least favorite power tool.

For through dovetails, I've been removing the waste with a coping saw. It's fast and helped me learn to saw perpendicular with a coping saw (by eye). I can do it either way, but I like the coping saw.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#60

Re: For others to judge

Sgian Dubh

"With a router, my concern is not only the setup time, but hand guiding a router near my baseline seems fraught with danger."

Dan, actually, there isn't really a need to do the routing fully freehand. If you set up a plunge router to plunge into the board's wide face with the side fence positioned to run along the end of the board, this defines the shoulder line between either the tails or the pins. The plunge stop defines the depth of cut, particularly useful for the sockets between the pins of a drawer front.

Set up this way, you can use the fence as a pivot point, pivoting off the corners of the board you're working on. Used in this manner, you can't go beyond the shoulder line of either the pins or the tails, but you can remove the bulk of the waste from the sockets, again, primarily useful for the sockets between pins of lap dovetails, e.g., drawer fronts.

It's just another method of working, being neither right nor wrong, but useful from time to time for those that like to work that way, which I do every now and then. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#61

Re: A book/WoodCentral idea

Sgian Dubh

"Maybe an arrangement could be made with the WoodCentral Store to sell autographed copies."

Interesting idea Bill. I'm not sure of the economics though, what with all the shipping backwards and forwards between the US and the UK, and I guess Ellis would need to be up for it, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#62

Shared your concern.....

roger lance

thats why I included a "fence" against which that shop-made router base runs and limits the cut short of the dovetail baseline.....



Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#63

So

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you have a drawer front about five inches tall or a little more, and you are making four dovetail sockets on each side, how long does it take to set up the router, rout out the bulk of the waste, and clean up the eight sockets with a chisel?

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#64

Re: So

roger lance

Don't know as I don't time myself.....when I'm woodworking, I'm not in a competition with the clock or some other woodworker seen or imagined.....but I am trying to do the very best job of what I'm doing.

Again, this method was not offered as my concept of THE WAY to do this joint.....use it.....don't use it.....go chisel only.....whatever you choose to do for you is fine and fine by me.

Also, to be clear, I'm not married to this method.....I do, at times, use it.....but I also use the traditional methods as well. Just trying to do good work.

I don't exactly recall how I came to make this jig.....I believe it was in response to Derek years ago regarding something he was working on.

My hope, when I show these kind of things, is that someone will work on the idea and make it better.....improve it.....or at least, be challenged to apply their minds to solve some issue in their shop.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#65

there is a secret

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Before speculating why it will be difficult/imposible try it so your reservations are based on experience. The proof is in the pudding. I do it successfully and have done it on a large number of drawers. I actually build stuff so my reports are not theoretical. And, I am not exceptionally skilled or coordinated. It takes at most a minute to adjust the depth to the baseline. This technique is so useful to me that I keep an lightweight inexpensive router set up with a 1/4" carbide bit just for this kind of work. Roger's experience seems to support my claims.

The secret is to make arcing cuts as shown in the picture and not bury the bit in wood. If the bit is not buried in wood it will not self feed. As I clearly stated in my first post if you route as I describe the cutting force is pushing the bit out of the cut and control is secure. I think I could rout right to the baseline and have done so. But that creates a problem. If I don't quite get all the waster there is not a trough for the chisel to sit in to pare to the baseline.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#66

fence unnecessay ...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...for anyone of below average skill. All the rest of making a dovetail requires way more skill.

For the skeptics.....try it, but do it as I describe or it will self feed and you will loose control. Failure will result form not following directions , not lack of skill.

The ability to "carve" with a router will be handy when you see it can easily be done.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#67

The rest of the world hasn' t missed a discovery

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be revealing to know why you think I route out half blind waste with a router. I actually make drawers, quite a few in the past year, and lots more in past years. So, in making these drawers do you think I have failed to discover chiseling, have not tried it, am too inept to do it efficiently?

If I am making one drawer I chisel it as I did recently for someone. If I am making 18 drawers in thin stock, as I did recently, I chisel too. But, if I am making 8 big ones for a chest of drawers I route the half blinds, not because I am stupid but because I have found that with my skill and experience level of chiseling and routing, routing is faster. On a big project faster usually wins, but not always.

The bottom line of it is that I (and I presume most others) do what they do because their experience (key word here) has proven that what they do is best for their situation. The persons actually making something gets to make the "best" judgment, not the bystanders. The bystanders get to judge whether it is relevant to their work.

That said, when offering a technique one owes the reader some additional information on experience and situation. For example- Alan Batty, English tradesman, told me his quota for drawers in an English factory where he worked was 6 per day. The tools were chisel and saw. The choice of wood and style helped productivity. Making 6 a day keeps one proficient. I can assess from all this information that 6 a day with hand tools will be the best that can be done. And I can conclude that a part time woodworker working N. American wood and N. American style dovetails is going to do substantially fewer with the same tools.

Based on what Alan told me I could post that one should be able to "make 6 drawers a day with a chisel and saw". But without context this statement would be greatly misleading and irrelevant to most people.

In my case I document what I build in posts and in the gallery. Anyone can judge my suggestions and recommendations against what I document that I actually do.

You claim that your way is the best way for many woodworking operations. What led you to your conclusion- built drawers this month, watched drawers being built in some shop, read about drawers in a book? Provide some context. What have you built this year that involved several half blind drawers? ( Pictures please) Only when we know what you actually build will we be able to assess how your recommendations and criticism fit our work.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#68

Re: Hmmm....

TomD

I don't know if a router is faster, but I cut my first large set of dovetails using the vertical router, because I knew it would give a cleaner line than I could chop at the time, and where the HBs are concerned getting a clean line parallel to the drawer front is critical to a nice fit. Of course this does make one wonder if the person couldn't just learn to chisel, but then some pretty super craftsmen undercut all these line because it gets them the clean line, so perhaps one ought not to be too embarrassed.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#69

Re: Hmmm....

TomD

It isn't really dangerous, any time both hands are on the router it is pretty nearly impossible to get hurt, unless you lower the whole thing into your lap or side. Dangerous to the work, maybe, but even when I was "very beginner" I never muffed a joint, actually I do have putty on my first case in one place. If you work with the rotation of the bit in mind, and don't use too large a bit, it is pretty safe. A soft start is nice, but I never had that when it would have counter.

I hate router mess, so to muddy the waters, if that was me, I would not be routing out all the waste I would bust it out and leave only a 1/16th to remove, further muddying the water of efficiency, etc...

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#70

Re: there is a secret - not that one the other one

TomD

"The secret is to make arcing cuts as shown in the picture and not bury the bit in wood. If the bit is not buried in wood it will not self feed."

The real secret is to go in anticlockwise. This does three things, no tear-out at the wood entry, because the cut is supported; no grabbing of the bit because one is climb cutting; easier to cut up to the line since there is pressure against the cut, though it is easy enough either way, and in this case the cut might be cleaner if that were an issue, if the cut to a baseline where clockwise.

I like using a small bit for more control, climb cutting with say a 3 inch diameter bit, or a lot smaller will get your attention.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#71

Re: The rest of the world hasn' t missed a discove

TomD

"If I am making one drawer I chisel it as I did recently for someone. If I am making 18 drawers in thin stock, as I did recently, I chisel too. But, if I am making 8 big ones for a chest of drawers I route the half blinds, not because I am stupid but because I have found that with my skill and experience level of chiseling and routing, routing is faster. On a big project faster usually wins, but not always."

That is self-fulfilling. FK says his speed breakthrough came when he made one of those apothecary chests (I think it was) with many, many small drawers. He did it all by hand and by the end had reached a new plateau. If one uses a router, there are two strikes: One is one is contributing to the belief that the router is faster, so there is a mental block formed. One is also loosing out on the opportunity to get better through practice.

I have used the router as a crutch when I wanted to be sure something turned out perfectly. On one occasion I made a desk where the front of the drawer was cut from the apron with only a tiny kerf, if I blew either the mortises holding the apron, or the half blinds I would loose a lot of money and time. At the time the router was a consoling option, and I used it for several steps. Speed wasn't the issue.

Another reason in my early days, was not having a bench or workholding that would allow me to do the hand tool techniques efficiently or pleasantly. The router does not transfer big loads into a bench or workholding.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#72

Re: The rest of the world hasn' t missed a discove

TomD

FK says in his video that when he does a quote he enters 20 minutes for a drawer. I think that is correct? There are drawers and there are drawers of course, but as far as hand vs router, 20 minutes just for the joints is OK in my book, and I do believe he means the whole drawer.

"You claim that your way is the best way for many woodworking operations. What led you to your conclusion- built drawers this month, watched drawers being built in some shop, read about drawers in a book? Provide some context. What have you built this year that involved several half blind drawers? ( Pictures please) Only when we know what you actually build will we be able to assess how your recommendations and criticism fit our work."

This is a place for ideas not bragging. Most people have, for instance, seen the FK tape. In my experience, despite often having been impressed by it, people rarely copy his methods, in full. So if people don't copy the FK method, what makes you think they will be impressed by your efforts involving a few dozen drawers or whatever, a year? I don't mean to suggest the work isn't good, just that it is very rare for people to be so impressed by a method that they adopt it based on someone's recommendation. This creates a lot of problems in tasks where the whole method needs to be accepted, not just some part, and mixing doesn't work. Drywall and epoxy joinery are a bit like that, or finishing in certain cases. Dovetails are open to mixing and matching. So I think most people will just fall back on their brains, not reputations, when making their decisions about what techniques to use. And the good news is that people asking for a vigorous defence of a method are not really being disrespectful, often just fishing for more information.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#73

Yes, poor choice of words on my part...

John in NM

The statement was less risky rather than safer, but either way danger to the work was all I meant. Nothing like a faulty memory :D

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#74

The rest of the world

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you want to use a router to waste half blind dovetails that is fine. But please don't pronounce it the most efficient method.

A guy learning to sharpen and use a chisel at retirement is very different from one learning as a teenager. Please don't place your own limitations on others. The rest of the world is not limited to the things that Bill Tindall of Tennessee (or anyone else) has discovered.

I do not own a camera. I will not be bullied to show my work on this forum.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#75

Another Chiseler, FWIW 

..