New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Posts

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#26

Re: question, a matter of scale.

David Charlesworth

Bill,

I think you may have had fretsaw blades or even finer metal cutting blades!

Pegas, scroll saw blades will have no difficulty cutting 3/8" stuff, and maybe thicker.

Thick stuff, coping saw fine, though many blades are horrible. Vertical center cut turning left and right solves the fine kerf issue.

On big work one might use a small bowsaw.

best wishes,

David

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#27

Re: question

David Charlesworth

See Pegas 90650 No 5 DRP blades at

workshop heaven toolshop UK

David

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#28

Ellis Walentine

Re: English dovetails

Ellis Walentine

Hmm. Maybe coping isn't so much a part of the English method and Kirby was just demonstrating that technique to a less skilled audience.

I am curious, though, as to how those three dovetail saw cuts you mentioned were aimed.

Ellis

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#29

Re: and a tirade

TomD

"On big work one might use a small bowsaw."

Which brings me back to one of my beefs, that after all this time nobody, even Lee Valley on April Fools day has offered the Franz K. bowsaw blade in any, but preferably a variety of sizes. Come on!

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#30

Re: English dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I suppose as two to define the size and one down the middle, single entry kerfs. What's left would not be much and easily pared it was reported. I would need to look up the letter from Alan but I think he said the daily quota was 6 drawers. One would have to have efficient technique to meet that quota.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#31

Late edit

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I'm speaking of scroll saw blades in the above, not fret saw. Mr. Charlesworth's post reminded me.

wh

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#33

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Sgian Dubh

Don, in soft woods (whether soft hardwood or soft softwood) it's generally easy enough to belt the waste out in one go with a sharp chisel and the hefty blow of a mallet.

On the other hand, removing the waste between either tails or pins in the case of hard woods (again whether hard softwood or hard hardwood) sometimes benefits from removing the bulk of it with a coping saw, although this still means pecking away at the corners with a chisel.

I use a standard western style dovetail saw for cutting the rakes (rather than a Gent's saw or one of the thin Japanese saws), so there's plenty of room for a coping saw blade.

Yet another technique to consider (sacrilegious perhaps in a hand tool forum) is a plunge router to remove the bulk of the waste, using a side fence and plunging action between either the tails or the pins.

By the way, you may be interested to know that a book publisher in the US has purchased the rights to publish my timber technology manuscript. They are provisionally scheduling an autumn 2016 book publication date, and there's the possibility of some negotiations on the form of English used - British or American, with the former of course being the correct choice (ha, ha) - if it actually goes to publication, that is. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#34

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

mdclor

"By the way, you may be interested to know that a book publisher in the US has purchased the rights to publish my timber technology manuscript."

Congratulations! Even if they decide to publish in English English, I should be able to understand it after reading Robert Wearing's book. :D

Seriously, please notify us when it is available.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#35

good news of book should not be buried on page 9

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

..page 9 referring to the back page of the newspaper and the good news the anticipation that all your well illustrated good ideas and tips will be available in book form soon. Maybe Ellis can sell it through WC?

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#36

sounds risky....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....more so than using a band saw to saw and chop out the waste when a power tool solution is acceptable.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#37

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

don stephan

Great news on the book, Richard! Looking forward to it, and hoping there will be some of the charming Brit sayings within. Hip Hip, cherio, good show.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#38

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't know why Americans can be so resistant to the Queen's English. It's not that hard to learn what the terms mean.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#39

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't know why Americans can be so resistant to the Queen's English. It's not that hard to learn what the terms mean.

You've got Buckley's chance of getting 'Strine. Bloody oath!

Translation: You are fortunate that we, Downunder, take pity on you bunch and use your version of English :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

p.s. Richard, congrats on the book!!!


Great Australian Slang Dictionary: 33 phrases

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#40

Re: sounds risky....

Sgian Dubh

Bill, the router tip works best on larger dovetails, those you might use for a carcase or chest, where the gap between the tails or pins is relatively large. The idea is to plunge the router with its base on the wide surface of a board, using a side fence running along the end of either the tails or pins. With the side fence set correctly, the cutter precisely cuts to the shoulder line of both the tail board and the pin board. But, as I mentioned, there's still some minor chiselling to do at the corners where the cutter can't reach.

This technique is much less useful (or no use at all) where the gap between tails is fine, e.g., drawer sides (particularly at the front), but can still be useful between the pins, whether through dovetails (rear) or lapped dovetails (front). It's just one technique people might consider - using a bandsaw, as you mentioned, is another valid method that can be useful for removing the majority of the waste. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#41

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Sgian Dubh

Bill, Don, and Derek, thanks for the comments on the book news. I can only hope the signed publishing agreement leads to publication. Apparently, not every such agreement leads to such a result! Anyway, if the book is released, I imagine I'll make visitors here aware of its availability one way or another. Slainte.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#42

I've used that technique ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Keep in mind, this was done to get through a LOT of half-blind dovetails in Jarrah.

Rout to depth and as close to the baseline as possible. I am using a 1/8" carbide bit here:



This makes it easy to remove the bulk of the waste my just splitting if away.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#43

A more efficient and less risky means to this end

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Hand tool purists, avert your eyes.....

I remove half blind waste in drawer fronts with a router too but in a way that I think is easier and less risky. The advantage of power tools is that they remove wood faster. The acknowledged problem of power tools is they remove wood faster from the wrong places as well as the right places.

When I observed the workers in the Headley shop using a router it was often a case of using it as a power carving tool. In the case at hand, set the depth of the bit, ideally a solid carbide 1/4" bit, put good lighting on the drawer front clamped flat to the bench and just free hand route away all the waste that is accessible. Arcing cuts of less than half the bit diameter will not grab and self feed into the work. Hence the routing force is always resisting penetration and control is certain. By this means the depth of the socket is accurately established and just a tiny bit of waste at the base line and socket corners remains.


Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#44

Ditto......

roger lance




Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#45

A book/WoodCentral idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

counting some chickens before they hatch.....Maybe an arrangement could be made with the WoodCentral Store to sell autographed copies.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#46

do I see notches?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Someone else (memory failing) spoke of making a tiny notch to aid saw starting in a dovetail. Is this a notch I see? Does it work for you? Should I try it next time? What are those outriggers on the router?

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#47

Re: do I see notches?

roger lance

Yes, little notches to help get the saw positioned and started......we probably heard about it here.....does help.....YMMV.

Thats just a simple router base that gives me greater control over what can be an awkward tool.....note that the base is cut away in the front of the router for better visibility.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#48

No, it is not more efficient.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, what you are doing is routing out a broad expanse of waste. This not only takes more time but creates more wear on the router bit.

My method just require one line to be routed out, and then the waste is split away with a chisel ...

The "splitting" (see my earlier post for more pictures) turns into paring the base line ...


... and then this is all you are left to pare away ...


… this is easily removed with a fishtail chisel …


This was the last of 24 sides. Not the best, but too bad ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#49

A little more information to make it easier

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What is not shown is the sawing and the kerf deepening.

Here is the sawing (along with the "blue tape" method I made up some years ago ..


Then the kerf is deepened with a "kerf chisel" (essentially the same idea that Tage Frid had with a scrape blade or band saw blade).


Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/HalfblindDovetailsinJarrah.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#50

For others to judge

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is great about this Forum is alternatives are proposed for all to consider. To the bystanders....try both ways and come to your own conclusion. To Derek, you won't know how fast and reliable the Headley shop way of doing it is till you try it. I can't try your way because I don't have a router fence or a plunge router. As I recall you used to be an advocate of routing out this waste with the router teetering on the end grain. That router orientation didn't seem to me to be better either.

As far as router bit wear and tear use solid carbide bits. They stay sharp seemingly for ever. The amount anyone will ever use one to make drawers will pale compared to their normal employment in a CNC machine. They can be resharpened inexpensively.

For those that don' t know, the carbide that must be used when the carbide piece is brazed to a steel body is different from the carbide used in solid bits. The solid bit carbide is more wear resistant.