Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw
TomD
I found when teaching people that they learn faster with coping. It requires less skill and knowledge. I put the blade in backwards, and then bend it 30 degrees, it goes into the kerf backwards and you can take off in your intended direction on any size board.
I have a technique that is half power that is like super charged coping and goes straight to the line that I keep threatening to write a mag article on.
But choping is normally more efficient, and since a lot of the chisel practice the average newbie will get is on dovetails it is a pity to waste in.
Either way you have to cut the full width of the board with a chisel, so why saw it also?
"1. The wood is bloody hard and would be more effort to chop."
Can't help you there, but either way you are chopping through the same amount of wood, and the problem isn't the chopping, the coping approach shows how easily a chisel goes through your wood (which may be easy or hard). If one can't get through it without the coping, the real problem is a lack of space for the bevel. There are a number of ways around that, but mostly it comes down to planing one's cuts.
2. Extra chopping is hard on chisel edges.
There isn't much extra chopping. I said it was the same, but there are a few notching cuts extra, but they are easy because the chips pop out. Get some real chisels, you must have a set of every kinds by now Derek, not sure what the problem is.
3. There is a constant risk of taking too large "bites" when chopping, which will threaten that the wood breaks away uncontrollably and, if done close to the base line, push this further back than desired.
Again, that is mostly an organizational issue.
Really, the best thing to do is run the FK tape, and really really look at how he chops out, and repeat in every single detail.