New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Posts

Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#1

Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

don stephan

Just curious how many people chisel out the waste when making dovetails and how many remove the bulk of the waste with a coping saw. I've done it both ways and never became comfortable with the coping saw.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#2

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Darren Brewster

I used the coping saw when I taught myself to dovetail. A while back I broke the blade of my coping saw and didn't have a spare, so I just chiseled, and haven't gone back. I'd be curious to time myself in different woods to see which way is more efficient for me.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#3

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Brian Holcombe

I cope out the waste recently.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#4

Chisel... never tried the saw


Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#5

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've tried coping, but chiseling just seems to work better for me.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#6

Ellis Walentine

Begs the question...

Ellis Walentine

... of what you have been trained to do or how you have practiced. Ian Kirby is a good friend of mine who swears by coping out dovetail parts. And, IMO, in many woods it is a preferable approach to chiseling. But Kirby was trained in the English A&C/Barnsley traditions and that was how they learned.

I guess my take is that you should do what gets the job done best for you.

Ellis

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#7

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

BrianMonumentCO

When I cut tails and pins with a dozuki, a coping saw looks like using a huge excavator to dig a trench when I could use a ditch witch to drag a cable. Or perhaps a tractor trailor to carry a simple wheel barrow.

It just feels like overkill.

But then again I learned to chisel out the waste.

When I watch videos of those that use a coping saw, I still see them chisel out waste anyway.

I wonder how I would feel if I used an english style dovetail saw to cut the tails and pins.

The coping saw blade might not feel so huge.

But I am still learning...... As one says learning continues until we die.

May we ALL continue to learn!

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#8

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Just curious how many people chisel out the waste when making dovetails and how many remove the bulk of the waste with a coping saw. I've done it both ways and never became comfortable with the coping saw.

Hi Don

Avoiding the "coping" saw term, in brief I saw away the waste and then use a chisel to pare back to the line. This is preferred because:

1. The wood is bloody hard and would be more effort to chop.

2. Extra chopping is hard on chisel edges.

3. There is a constant risk of taking too large "bites" when chopping, which will threaten that the wood breaks away uncontrollably and, if done close to the base line, push this further back than desired.

By contrast, sawing out most of the waste enables one to pare the remainder in thin shavings. This is gentler on the chisel edge, and is a more controlled method.

When sawing out the waste, first undercut the baseline for a knife line. This will ensure that the baseline does not move back.

Now about the "coping" saw. I prefer a fretsaw. The blade is thinner and it turns more easily in the saw kerf, which enables one to saw closer to the baseline. A coping saw requires two saw cuts to the one of a fretsaw.

Coping saw cuts (in a breadboard end) ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#9

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

David Charlesworth

Agreeing with everything Derek says, except that the tool I use for sawing small waste is a piercing saw.

Fretsaws tend to be far too deep.

Excuse the pedantry!

David

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#10

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

TomD

I found when teaching people that they learn faster with coping. It requires less skill and knowledge. I put the blade in backwards, and then bend it 30 degrees, it goes into the kerf backwards and you can take off in your intended direction on any size board.

I have a technique that is half power that is like super charged coping and goes straight to the line that I keep threatening to write a mag article on.

But choping is normally more efficient, and since a lot of the chisel practice the average newbie will get is on dovetails it is a pity to waste in.

Either way you have to cut the full width of the board with a chisel, so why saw it also?

"1. The wood is bloody hard and would be more effort to chop."

Can't help you there, but either way you are chopping through the same amount of wood, and the problem isn't the chopping, the coping approach shows how easily a chisel goes through your wood (which may be easy or hard). If one can't get through it without the coping, the real problem is a lack of space for the bevel. There are a number of ways around that, but mostly it comes down to planing one's cuts.

2. Extra chopping is hard on chisel edges.

There isn't much extra chopping. I said it was the same, but there are a few notching cuts extra, but they are easy because the chips pop out. Get some real chisels, you must have a set of every kinds by now Derek, not sure what the problem is.

3. There is a constant risk of taking too large "bites" when chopping, which will threaten that the wood breaks away uncontrollably and, if done close to the base line, push this further back than desired.

Again, that is mostly an organizational issue.

Really, the best thing to do is run the FK tape, and really really look at how he chops out, and repeat in every single detail.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#11

Re: Certainty or risk.

TomD

Basically using a coping saw is like training wheels on a bike, good plan, but eventually it holds one back. I have watched this craft progress over the years, I think it will be very surprising if the average weekend guy doesn't progress to chopping. In the last ten years there has been huge progress in technique, most people seem pretty solid with saws, sharpening and with planes. The only reason a person wouldn't chop dovetails is because their chisel work isn't up to snuff. Joinery is just sawing chopping, and planing to a line. My sense is that chopping is still the weak point for some in the wider world. Basically both planes and saws, organize chisels or knives to make cuts that are the workmanship of certainty. Chisels can be either risk or certainty, as with most tools, but certainly less jigged that some others.

Look at the rapturous popularity of the shooting board. The training wheels are popular. Not to say that all these tools aren't great, but the rapture surrounding the more certain tools is indicative of the mentality that still lingers.

A few years back I was restructuring the floor under a toilet, the original floor was tongue and groove softwood and had sagged under the toilet. I needed to get the floor out, drop it, restructure it, and put in some tile. I didn't have my regular tools, and I had to take out the boards without destroying the rest of the floor, all I had was a chisel. 36ish inches of making a crosscut into the wood and making it crisp and clean, to receive the tiles. Easy. Another time I did this experimental bracing system in a guitar, out of hard structural foam. It turned out to be too stiff, as one never knows when doing something entirely novel. So I removed a whole inch on of the foam, around the perimeter of the lower bout with a chisel. really hard but accurate work. If you never practice chisel work, it doesn't get better. Then when a chisel is the only practical way, one can't handle it.

People will argue now, but this too will be absorbed.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#12

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

JDK

Exclusively chisel here. I've tried the coping saw route, but for me it adds extra time.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#13

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Hank Knight

Me too.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#14

Tried both use neither

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It takes some practice to use the coping saw to get the kerf close to the line on BOTH sides of the board. And I found it slow. And my coping saw blades don't fit my dovetail saw kerf (too big). And then you have to remove the board, mount it and chisel anyway. Just didn't seem like something worth learning to do for as often as I make dovetails.

I can chisel quickly and if you have a chisel with good steel the chips can fly once the baseline edge is established, especially so in a soft wood typically used for drawer sides. I chisel when the task is short.

But for a chest of drawers chiseling all that waste becomes tedious. I chisel it out with a band saw using a coarse blade, with a combination of sawing and using the coarse teeth as micro chisels. I finish up with a paring cut to the base line.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#15

English dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I spent a day with Alan Batty who worked in an English factor making a quota of drawers each day. The dovetail was defined and the waste in the hard white oak sides was removed with three dovetail saw cuts. Then the base line was pared.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#16

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

But their teeth are tiny and the sawing is slooooo. Or did I have the wrong blade? It was the coarsest blade in the pack.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#17

Re: Tried both use neither

Brian Holcombe

I use a dozuki and so I can't fit a coping saw blade in the kerf, instead I saw diagonally from one corner to the other, then saw just above the baseline, take the rest out with a paring cut.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#18

One pass coping

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I cut with a coping saw in one pass. I have used a coping saw for about forty years. Before that I used a chisel.

It happens so quickly that I have trouble analyzing what is going on. Here is what I think happens. I make a short stroke to get the saw near the bottom of the dovetail saw kerf. The coping kerf is a little wider, but I am not really sawing here just giving enough movement to ease it down. Then I take one or maybe two strokes without moving the saw very much. This allows a very tight radius, certainly less than 1/8 inch. So I am nearly cutting straight across. Like I said this all happens quickly, maybe 2 seconds for a pin socket. Then I am able to cut the remaining waste out with one pass of the chisel, occasionally two passes if I have been sloppy.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#19

Note on dozukis + fretsaw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

A note for those who use dozukis, and are interested in sawing the waste with a fretsaw. The main advantage I see in a fretsaw over a coping saw, when using a dozuki, is that you can work the blade down the kerf, and make one single cut straight across (as Warren describes above). If you happen to use thin or single-entry pins, the fretsaw works better also.

The usual thickness of a dozuki blade is 0.012" (plus a tiny amount of set). You can mic yours to check if in doubt. It happens that a No. 2 fretsaw blade is also 0.012" thick. You can work it down the kerf, then make the turn at the bottom by sawing in place a few quick strokes as you rotate the saw frame. To repeat, it's a No. 2 blade, not a 2/0. Usually 20 tpi. Get the skip tooth. I'm still working through a gross of Olson blades, but they are pretty dull, even from the factory. I have read on this forum that Pegas is better, and would try them before Olson.

Wiley

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#20

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

Michael Brady

Derek nailed (or should I say "dovetailed") it. I think many of those who responded negatively about sawing out waste were using coping saws, which are too coarse and hard to turn to be effective in the narrow kerfs left by dovetail saws. A fret saw is ideally suited and can cut to less than a 1/16 of the baseline in just seconds. Chisel work after that is very quick and this method prolongs chisel edge life greatly. Even if I don't saw the waste for some reason, I chop with a lesser chisel and then switch to my best chisel for the final pass at the baseline.

Although I hate recommending expensive tools, the fret saws by Knew Concepts are fantastic in this application.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#21

Re: Tried both use neither

AZ in Colorado Springs

Interesting, the comments about the coping saw not fitting into the dovetail saw kerf. I don't worry about that. I define the edges of the pin or tail using a dovetail saw, then make two cuts with the coping saw to remove the waste. First, from left down to the right corner, then a second cut across the bottom to the left corner. Then pare with a chisel. I don't worry about the width of the first kerf.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#22

Re: Tried both use neither

Steve Voigt

It takes some practice to use the coping saw to get the kerf close to the line on BOTH sides of the board. And I found it slow.

Yes, it does take practice. Most things worth doing take some practice to become proficient at them. When I first tried the coping saw technique, I too found it slower than chopping, but I was already reasonably adept at chopping. Once I got passably good at coping, it was no contest.

Of course, people don't have to choose the faster option. It's not a race. Do whatever floats your boat. But if the question is "which is faster," there's no doubt that sawing is objectively faster.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#23

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

david weaver

Coping saw. Without a doubt. What Steve said about them.

Except I started with a fret saw, even got one of the expensive ones and then sold it when I found the coping saw to be faster, especially in large tails.

And what warren said about the chisel use. One pass.

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#24

Jack Guzman from Maine

Jewelers saw

Jack Guzman from Maine

I use a jewelers saw,which is a small fret saw. It turns easier than a coping saw. I don't like sharpening and chopping dulls a chisel faster than if you use it mostly in paring waste.---Jack

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw

#25

Re: Dovetails - Chisel or Coping Saw