New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Latta Bench Assembled

Posts

Latta Bench Assembled

#1

Latta Bench Assembled

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Quartered Wormy Oak Steve Latta Auxiliary Bench

PIC 1


I made the bench in what seemed to me to be the most reasonable way to make it. The legs are dovetailed into the sides and the stretchers are M&T into the legs. I don't understand the I-beam construction Latta advocates. I may add an "apron" across the front to provide a clamping surface. If so I will just screw it on so I can remove it if it gets in the way of my preferred F-style camping of stuff to the surface.

The joinery came up snug. The joints are not glued and won't need to be unless something shrinks and loosens. In this state I can disassemble and alter leg length if needed (see below M&T detail).

I wish I had not used oak. It is miserable to work with hand tools. While it saws fine, I had no problem sawing dovetails, it does not scribe mark and chisel fine. If someone decides to build a bench I would recommend maple. The first socket was too tight and paring to get a good fit was difficult with oak. By the time I sawed the 3rd I was able to judge where to saw relative to the scribe line and the last two joints fit without modification.

I sawed the tails with a Lee Valley saw, 12 point rip. This saw was way too aggressive for oak. The teeth were so grabby that my several hundred pound bench shook while sawing. I used the vintage saw shown (filed by Tom Law cross cut) for socket sawing and it did well. The LN dovetail saw was too dainty for this job.

PIC 2



The picture shows how I positioned the legs perpendicular to the top for dovetail socket marking. Anyone got a better idea? This worked but it seems a bit strange.

PIC 3


Oak pares poorly and I could not chisel the bottom of the sockets smooth. The router plane came to the rescue.

The stretchers are M&T into the legs. The tenon is half the thickness of the stretcher and it is not centered but rather it is at the top surface of the stretcher. If I want to shorten the bench I will just turn the stretcher upside down and reinstall. An inch of leg with stick below the stretcher in this position and can be cut off.

Vise is back ordered

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#3

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Looking good, Bill. I think your leg design makes a lot of sense. Your reversible stretcher is an ingeneous solution to the height problem.

Are you planning to use F-clamps or holdfasts to secure it to the bench it will sit on?

I'll be a couple days delayed before I can get any pictures to accompany the descriptions of my Latta bench. I think you might find my Moxon vise adaptation interesting. I was supposed to fly home today, but PHL is getting snow, sleet and freezing rain, and our flight has been cancelled. No room on any flights tomorrow, either, so I'm "stuck" in Tucson until Tuesday.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#4

Re: For elves?

Bruce McCrory

It's a nice one.... :\

Are those worms dead?

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#5

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

TomD

Super nice looking.

I have to say I never really understood the idea of dovetailing legs into benches. The top is basically a beam, and the dovetails always look like what happens to your joists after the plumber or electrician visits and leaves a trail of cutouts. The last part of the bench I would want to have the fiber discontinuous is on the forward edge.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#6

Bench in use

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


For my current needs there is no need to fasten the auxiliary bench to the main bench

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#7

In defense of the engineering

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This auxiliary bench is designed to raise the work surface for better ergonomics and visibility for doing string, or other, inlay. The only engineering requirements are that it must not be wiggly, and there needs to be a place provided to affix it to a bench below as needed.

A well fit dovetail provides a locking joint that is rigid. Were it not for the requirement that it might need to be affixed to a bench below there would be no need to add the stretchers. In its current dry fit state it is as rigid as if it had been glued together, and in fact I will likely not glue it for a while, or until needed. Hence, I feel that I have met the engineering requirement in a straightforward way, with the minimum of parts, and with a design that was easy to execute. Materials used- one nominal 2 x 6 barn rafter severely bowed and full of worm holes. Cost $4.

If you are going to criticize a design then you owe it to the reader to provide a superior alternative. Show us a picture of how your bench is constructed and explain how its engineering, or ease of construction, would be superior for the task at hand- string inlay.

Disclaimer- I have not studied historical bench building. It was not my intention to emulate any current or historical construction. I have never seen Schwartz's book. I did what I did because it seemed a robust and easy to execute means to an end. If it remains not wiggly, as I expect it will, it has met my need. If someone has a better means to this, or another end, post a picture and explain the engineering. We all can learn.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#8

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

My bench-on-bench uses the same construction method. I've had it and abused it since 2009. I put a lot more stress on it than just stringing, including carving, planing, and throwing it the back of cars and trucks, dragging and wheeling it up and down stairs and across gravel parking lots. I also secure it to lower benches and other substrates with holdfasts and/or K-body clamps. I have secured a mini-lathe to its top. The only minor construction difference is that I used half blind dovetails instead of through dovetails, to make the top easier to reflatten when necessary by providing about 5/16" of continuous top surface. The joiner has shown no signs of failure. It is a much stronger joinery method than used in any of dozens of these appliances I have examined. Using through dovetails for attaching bench legs to tops is also an accepted, traditional practice, as evidenced by the 18th century bench design of Andre Roubo, which is still widely used. While my top used rock maple instead of oak, because that's what was available, oak is more than appropriate. Reference the French Oak Roubo Bench Project for an example.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#9

Re: In defense of the engineering

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You mentioned the oak as being difficult. I have to work oak a fair amount for reproductions and church work. Churches have used oak heavily for 500 years and more. I think the problems would go away with familiarity: knowing just how hard to hit the chisel to avoid deformation of the edge, how much to take off in one bite, just how to handle the saw. These are subtle things that improve efficiency when you know the material well. That said, for me it would probably take less time to make tenons on the legs and through mortises in the top.

I use the same bench surface for all my work. I tend to stand upright with the work near waist level. I occasionally use a stool.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#10

Looks great Bill

John in NM

The first shop I worked for had something similar to go on benches. Much more simply made of course, but same idea.

I know what you mean about the oak. I made some of the only wood jigging parts on my duplicating machine out of oak and it was a big mistake. Scribed lines wander, even the points of the tailstock like parts tended to wander off center, following the grain. Almost everything has now been replaced by aluminum parts, next up on the list are those oak pieces.

I'm sure one can get used to the stuff, as Warren has done, but I too find it tricky wood to work with hand tools.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#11

correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I most assuredly DID need to secure it to the main bench as proven in todays practice session making some loop de loop inlay patterns to be used on spice box doors. I used two clamps from my extensive collection of F-style clamps.

By the time I finished the 100'+ feet of stringing on the chest of drawers I made some years ago I was proficient. That proficiency has been lost and will need to be regained with some practice patterns underway. This problem is an occupational hazard of the amateur woodworker. The dovetails on the bench went uneventfully, but only because I have been doing a bunch of them on some drawers. A month from now the muscle memory will have somewhat faded, in my case at least.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#12

Re: In defense of the engineering

TomD

"If you are going to criticize a design then you owe it to the reader to provide a superior alternative. Show us a picture of how your bench is constructed and explain how its engineering, or ease of construction, would be superior for the task at hand- string inlay."

Depends what you mean by "a design" I didn't criticize your bench, or it's use for whatever you currently intend it for. I'm not convinced that cutting transversely into the top of a bench, or using dovetails to attach legs to tables is a good idea. I would be interested to hear why this is done. The fact that the legs are firm does not answer the isue of cutting into the top.

Not sure why a comment requires a detailed suggestion of alternatives. Not cutting into the top seems easy enough to figure out. The list lengthens again to comment on this forum: It needs to be scientific and fact based, at least for some of us, not others; it needs to be backed up with reams of unrelated photographs; and now we need to submit what we consider a solution, which to be frank based on prior experience, I highly doubt there is really any interest in. When exactly did the situation change to one where more theory is demanded.

But not to disappoint. I think your design but with tenons into the top would be a lot stronger, particularly if they did not emerge to the surface. Maybe some drawbored pins, given your recent research. Dovetails are particularly recommended where they align with some force. While I do not have your experience in inlay, well I suppose guitars have a ton of inlay, but who is counting. I am not aware of how you would generate the load the dovetails are aligned with. Normally loads press down on a table; a very common detail, which appears to be present in the Latta version, is that the table top rests on a crosswise support. This is obviously stronger in several ways, and also conceals gaps that may show from the top working. The idea of half blind also seems superior, in concealing gaps, retaining integrity of the top. Many people have space constraints, so having single use pieces that do not work for other functions due to showboating fragility may be a point to consider. A more challenging task might be to come up with any method that is actually worse than the dovetail chosen. None spring to the mind immediately.

I just did up the structure on 3 tables a few weeks back, 2 for sewing machines and one for an ironing board. Not a Latta thing, but it might meet the requirement for unrelated photographs... The approach I used was hardware bonding which is enormously strong, and brutally not technical to execute, I considered posting it here, but figured there was little interest since it is principally practical, a consideration for those of us who design structures people's lives depend on, occasionally professionally. You may not survive but the joinery likely will. It does fit in nicely in any situation where a person might be tempted to do a captured nut, or other hardware.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#13

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

TomD

"The only minor construction difference is that I used half blind dovetails instead of through dovetails, to make the top easier to reflatten when necessary by providing about 5/16" of continuous top surface."

That is actually a significant advantage relative to retaining the structural integrity of a top. Your point about flattening is also good. I see no real advantage to a through dovetail in this application. Would anyone actually cut a shouldered tenon, then fit it into the edge of a table top. That reeks of Popular Mechanics in the 60. The addition of a few degrees a side, in the wrong direction doesn't really seem to change much.

"Using through dovetails for attaching bench legs to tops is also an accepted, traditional practice, as evidenced by the 18th century bench design of Andre Roubo"

- Was he a joiner, or just the guy with the books. Books are so often wrong it barely merits comment.

- The "Roubo" Dovetail is paired with a tenon, and oriented in a 90 degree different direction. I don't really know what good that joint is either, but there is some point to a dovetail in that orientation if one wants the vertical piece to come to the surface and be level with the edge of the bench.

"which is still widely used".

- It is widely used... "still", I am not so sure about. Nobody had seen such a thing for a long time until FWW resurrected it, and Roy, then CS really lit the fire. I am not the expert on such matters but as far as I know the "Roubo" had died out and no serious pro had kept them around. The pros who resurrected it in the FWW days, prior to the fanboy period, soon grew tired of it. Any heavy bench with a vise is pretty good, I know of no reason why the Roubo, or in particular the joinery, should be considered anything but a fad in modern times.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#14

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

Sgian Dubh

I can't see a good reason for such a large overhang at either end. Can you explain the reasoning for that to me please? I ask because there must be many occasions where all that's wanted is a sturdy raised surface that can be used without clamping down, and working heavily near one end might result in the far end lifting.

The joinery choice also seems a bit odd to me - through dovetails at both edges could lead to some stepping at the joint line top surface. I think I'd have made two enclosed frames (two rails, two stiles each) with the top slot screwed in place. This way, if the top ever got mankier than I could live with a new one could be fashioned up and attached to the existing supports.

Maybe this is all just because I've never before heard of and don't even get the concept of this 'Latta Bench' thing. It seems a fair amount of faddle just to get a raised surface to work on when I've achieved much the same for years simply by utilising things like old boxes and other objects that always seem to end up sort of abandoned in a workshop. Slainte.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#15

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"don't even get the concept of this 'Latta Bench' thing. I've achieved much the same for years simply by utilising things like old boxes and other objects that always seem to end up sort of abandoned in a workshop. "

Version 1 of the Latta bench failure. Other than raising the work surface it fell short in other attributes for the task at hand. At this point I decided to sped 3 hours and make what Steve uses.

PIC 1


Guiding principle: When I don't know what I am doing, copy someone that does. I have worked with Latta. He is a practical sort that doesn't do stuff just because it is novel and will result in an article in Fine Woodlworking. If he concluded the bench in question was useful for Line and Berry inlay, such a bench would be a good place to start. I'll report back on my personal opinion after I have used it for a while.

"can't see a good reason for such a large overhang at either end" Don't know yet. But if I decide the bench is longer than my needs it provides the opportunity to cut it shorter. So far the overhang has provided a place to clamp a Spice Box door panel without the legs being in the way of the clamps. To most handily cut the border stringing two edges need to hang over the edge of the bench.

" through dovetails at both edges could lead to some stepping at the joint line top surface." don't understand the stepping term/concern. But if it shows up I will report the deficiency.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#16

Re: answers

Sgian Dubh

"" through dovetails at both edges could lead to some stepping at the joint line top surface." don't understand the stepping term/concern. But if it shows up I will report the deficiency."

I mean that if the top surface shrinks in thickness a bit the end grain of the dovetailed legs might sit proud. Conversely, if the top swells, they'll sink below the top surface. I suspect the first scenario might just require a skim or six with a hand plane, so a small inconvenience, and the second scenario probably causes no measurable inconvenience at all. Still, I think I'd have preferred to make the top completely replaceable, and framing underneath (as I mentioned in my earlier post) to fix down to would help reduce the chance of cupping.

Aside from all that, thanks for the explanations. Slainte.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#17

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

roger lance

Bill.....you have essentially built a mini-roubo style bench minus the long stretchers (which you could always add later if you wish).....yet, some folks are rejecting it for various reasons.....perhaps a mini-schwarz rebellion afoot ??!!......wonder if my Shaker style bench will come into vogue ??.....probably not, it has a tool tray.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#19

While I understand your point....

John in NM

I really don't think strength is a concern in this case, this is not the kind of work surface that will see a great deal of weight or bashing stuff with mallets. Richard's point about the joints staying flush or not would be most of my concern.

On the other hand, one could design a doubled skirt for a thinner topped version of this bench that incorporated blind mortises for the legs. While I like the dovetails, I think I would do the latter instead.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#20

Rubou Rebellion

David Charlesworth

I shall join the rebellion.

Legs going through the top cause unnecessary lack of flatness.

The disparity on a full size bench is going to be considerable, if the ambient humidity changes much during the year.

When I attempt to teach timber movement, I see the scepticism in students eyes.

Now, an off cut from a small american oak table top, hangs on the wall.

It is 400 mm (16") wide and changes its length by 5 mm (just under 1/4") during the year, in my workshop. ( The boards are plain sawn rather than quartered.) Students are now convinced that movement matters).

The only logic I can see is that perhaps metal fixings like our coach screws were very expensive in the time of Roubou?

David

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#21

Re: Rubou Rebellion

Sgian Dubh

"It is 400 mm (16") wide and changes its length by 5 mm (just under 1/4") during the year, in my workshop."

Is that a slip of the tongue (aka brain fart?) David? Did you mean to say width? Slainte.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#23

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

david weaver

I have a subjective comment, and I'm not trolling (or trying to discourage posting of anything), just asking.

When I need to do work in a plane mortise, which is about the only time I work laterally and close up, I slide my bench toward me and sit on a saw bench.

When the craze over the moxon (or someone) bench vises went around, I took a very heavy door sized router table fence that I have and created one so that I could use it on cabinet sides, etc. I have to admit that I don't make particularly long cases, the longest have been about 4 feet or so, so maybe that's why I never found much favor in that thing, either. It's more of a pain to put up and move around and then store than it is anything else, and when I did the dovetails on the last case, I did them just in the bench vise with a quick grip clamp, even though that contraption was behind me on my router table and could've been transferred over.

Functionally, is this thing going to offer enough to be better than sitting on a saw bench? I don't use a chair, I guess because the saw bench is already there. If I have to move laterally on it, I just do that (it's about 3 feet long). I'm curious as to whether you think the thing will just become very heavy and thus not that nice to take on and off the bench (don't know what the vise hardware is), or do you feel like it'll be an improvement?

I've thought about building more fixtures for various things, but the only thing I have in the back of my head at this point is a proper miter jack because I'm relying on some crutches to get mortises done each time I do them and they're a pain and imprecise.

I am a little bit stingy with wood, too, I guess because I don't have tons of good quality salvaged wood around.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#24

Re: Rubou Rebellion

David Charlesworth

Well spotted Richard! Yes the offcut was taken from the end of a table top, so the movement is in the width of the timber.

Also dreadful spelling. Is there no edit function?

David

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#25

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

William Duffield

Most people who build and use one of these install a tail vise on one end. That overhang is to provide room for mounting the vise. On a few of these I've seen, a shoulder vise has been installed on the other end. Even if a shoulder vise is not used, being able to cantilever one end off the end of the sub-bench facilitates hanging drawer boxes over that end when you are fitting them to a case. I think Bill posted a picture doing that with a piece of plywood clamped to the bench top. I've never used mine without clamping it to the bench, even though it is quite a bit heavier than Bill's.

Definitely, use boards and sturdy boxes if you have them in useful sizes, and especially until you know how high, long and wide you want it. I would not want to use mine without the convenience of its tail vise and dog holes in the top and front for use with holdfasts. Those are a bit difficult to implement on orange crates. ;^)

If you are using it with holdfasts on the front, or a Moxon vise, I think the shear forces will eventually lead to failure of your joinery. Steve Latta, for example, doesn't use his in that manner, and therefore, screws or dowels to attach the top are sufficient for his purposes.