Re: Latta Bench Assembled
TomD
"I don't agree with your analysis of the through dovetail's strength. It is equivalent to a wedged through tenon (or a fox wedged tenon, in the case of my half-blind dovetail), or a stopped sliding dovetail, or even to the half through dovetailed stretchers used under the steps on the classic Shaker three step stool."
That barely deserves comment. Structural engineers are gobsmacked. So if you built a timber frame house, it would be ok no mater what joint was substituted for what joint. Tradition or the laws of nature be damned. Even aesthetically form follows function. To make meaningful exposed joinery furniture where one's understanding of the forces at play is laid bare for the world to see, the wrong joints are in addition to everything else, ugly. There is something perversely delightful about a scene where a master craftsman is working on classical stringing, on a bench that completely belies that status. Like those scenes in the movies where a guy is working a plane intently, and no shavings are coming out.
"It is my understanding the Roubo was a joiner and cabinetmaker who had gained considerable respect in his day, especially in his design and execution of the dome for the Paris grain market."
Thanks for the information. A quick further look at Wiki indicates he had a formidable background.
"The reason for Roubo's joinery is to counter the forces on the joint between the leg and the top that is applied by a leg vise. It is unnecessary when using a vise that is wholly attached to the top, especially a Record or Emmert or similar metal vise."
The loads in a leg vise are isolated unless you have a dog in the jaw and are pressing against a dog in the top, say. The vise could be tightened even if it was not attached to the top. Further the joint is also used where there is no leg vise.
But my point was not a critique of the joint in Roubo's bench, as much to say it could not be used as justification of the design under discussion. I still think it is valid to question the Roubo approach, and to ask why it fell out of use.
"The top of my joiner's bench (my sub-bench in this context) has functioned perfectly for almost two decades using only the force of gravity to join the base to the top. I wouldn't certify it for California, but the Mineral, VA quake had no adverse effect on it ;^)"
My prime concern in making the initial comment was not the strength of the joint, but the degree to which is cuts into the top and weaken the top. This has not be seriously answered, other than to say that Bill (who's bench I am not questioning) would never use it in a way where that would be a problem. That of course, is not how we design in the 20th century where if someone wanders into your shop stands on the edge of the bench and breaks it off, it is OK, that a poor joint was used; or just in general why weaken it like that.
" I also do not fully comprehend the reasons for some of the details of Roubo's joint, but just reversing the orientation of the pin and the tail does not compromise its strength. I think a double tenon, without the 45° angles, would be sufficient."
I am a big advocate of the principle that strong enough, is strong enough. I still would like to know why such a fancy detail was used. It cries out for an explanation. Reversing the orientation of the pin is huge! I can't fathom that remark, particularly when later on the explanation given is that it had to be thus because it was a dry fit glueless joint. BUT, again, my point about Roubo was not to enlargen the conversation to new particulars, but to reject the idea that his bench was a relevant model, when the joinery is not the same.
"but the dovetail allows it to be assembled and used without glue, which is a significant advantage while in the prototype development stage."
"prototype"? That's lipstick on a pig, I thought one of the main arguments was that it was just a personal thing, and the details should not be discussed even in abstract.