New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Latta Bench Assembled

Posts

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#26

Re: In defense of the engineering

William Duffield

I understand, and agree with you, about the advantages of hardware bonding, but I don't think the additional robustness is needed for this application. Others may want to refer to documentation on these techniques in the Epoxy documentation produced by Gougeon Brothers. Chapter 14 of this extended text explains it:

http://www.westsystem.com/ss/assets/HowTo-Publications/GougeonBook%20061205.pdf

It is, however, even further removed from the experience of most furniture makers building using traditional techniques of joinery than even Kreg screws or the Festool Domino :) . It does work well for installing threaded inserts into particleboard and plywood bench tops for applications like these holddowns.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=jigs&file=articles_144.shtml

I don't use these very much, anymore. Grammercy holdfasts (and others) work much more efficiently.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#27

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

William Duffield

I don't agree with your analysis of the through dovetail's strength. It is equivalent to a wedged through tenon (or a fox wedged tenon, in the case of my half-blind dovetail), or a stopped sliding dovetail, or even to the half through dovetailed stretchers used under the steps on the classic Shaker three step stool. It also has a practical advantage over the half blind dovetail that I implemented in that it is easier to execute.

It is my understanding the Roubo was a joiner and cabinetmaker who had gained considerable respect in his day, especially in his design and execution of the dome for the Paris grain market. The reason for Roubo's joinery is to counter the forces on the joint between the leg and the top that is applied by a leg vise. It is unnecessary when using a vise that is wholly attached to the top, especially a Record or Emmert or similar metal vise. The top of my joiner's bench (my sub-bench in this context) has functioned perfectly for almost two decades using only the force of gravity to join the base to the top. I wouldn't certify it for California, but the Mineral, VA quake had no adverse effect on it ;^) I also do not fully comprehend the reasons for some of the details of Roubo's joint, but just reversing the orientation of the pin and the tail does not compromise its strength. I think a double tenon, without the 45° angles, would be sufficient.

In this application, a glued tenon would be sufficient, as evidenced by the one Kaare built, but the dovetail allows it to be assembled and used without glue, which is a significant advantage while in the prototype development stage.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#28

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

William Duffield

I'm working on adding a removable tool tray to mine. :D

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#29

Re: Rubou Rebellion

William Duffield

When I built mine, I addressed that problem by joining the pair of legs with a web of hard maple, the same as the top, but 3/4" thick and dadoed into the legs. Unlike Bill's bottom stretcher, when the top expands and contracts, the web expands and contracts with it. If you were very concerned with keeping the top flat, you could make the top and the web quarter sawn.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#30

Andre Roubo

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Andre Roubo (not Rubou, not Roubou) illustrates some benches that do not have through tenons. Here is one being used for floral marquetry inlay. Note that the worker is sitting on a stool, feet on stretcher, fairly erect posture, hands well away from face. Planing stop, no tail vise. (After posting I see the joint does not show very well; there is about a half inch between the top of the tenon and the top of the bench.) This plate was engraved by Roubo himself.


I have used a bench with through tenons for over 35 years. I had not noticed the suggested difficulties of working with this type of bench. I don't think anybody would have used this system in the 18th century if there were problems.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#32

Re: Andre Roubo

Steve Voigt

I have used a bench with through tenons for over 35 years. I had not noticed the suggested difficulties of working with this type of bench. I don't think anybody would have used this system in the 18th century if there were problems.

Yes, this.

…

Very nice carving bench, Bill. I'm sure it will make a great addition to your shop.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#33

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Functionally, is this thing going to offer enough to be better than sitting on a saw bench? "

I sit for some woodworking but I never found that I could sit for this kind of inlay. There is an amazing amount of moving around required to optimally position tools and work.

The bottom line is that it is a cheap experiment.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#34

Re: Andre Roubo

Steve Voigt

Er, forgot the quote marks around Warren's quote in the previous post, and can't seem to edit any longer.

Wouldn't want to imply that I've been using a Roubo for 35 years…I was in grade school 35 years ago.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#35

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

David Charlesworth

Bill,

I am quite sure it will work very well indeed.

David

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#36

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

david weaver

I don't know anything about stringing, just curious.

I'm sure the bench will work fine. If it doesn't, you can build another one exactly the same except cut the legs out of lengths of boards in the same orientation as the top. Won't be able to dovetail it that way, but you could use half blind tenons.

I doubt it'll ever be a problem. I worry less than some about shop hardware and furniture - if it fails, you can fix it. If the fix is ugly, it's not a big deal, it's a tool.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#37

Re: Better picture

david weaver

I don't know anything about marquetry or whatever is in that picture, but it appears to be toolless construction.

What am I missing. No sand pot to burn the edges of inlay, nothing but a glue pot and some other small tool. What does the text that goes along with it discuss, is it assumed that it's just basically assembly after all of the other fitting, etc, is done?

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#38

Amen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"if it fails, you can fix it. If the fix is ugly, it's not a big deal, it's a tool. "

....or burn it. .

It is not important if it remains flat (why would it not?), the legs stick up or down, what ever. It only needs to be not wiggly, enable fixing the door or drawer or leg to it and be the right height.

Material cost $4. time 3 hours To repeat, a cheap experiment, to be built as cheaply and easily as one could imagine. Others' imagination may differ.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#39

Re: Better picture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is the entire plate; I wish I had better quality. The text discusses trimming the pieces for better fit and using a burin to score the work for better texture, definition. The previous plate shows a burin and a fellow doing sand shading. I really just wanted to show a worker on a stool and that not all benches in Roubo were the same.


Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#40

Re: Amen

david weaver

I only wish I had access to salvage stock like that!! I could make myself a decent bench with it without wringing my hands over the cost.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#41

Re: Better picture

david weaver

Thanks!! It makes much more sense on context.

I can identify with his desire to sit while working on stuff that doesn't require a lot of movement. I'm sure the desire would be doubly so if I were doing it for pay and couldn't just stop when I was tired of it.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#42

Re: Rubou Rebellion

Bob Hackett

One of the challenges of a system that relies on oral history, as the apprenticeship system did, is that it creates a closed loop. You learn what the master teaches, as her learned it from his master. Much of the techniques and knowledge were learned by wrote memorization and copying exactly what you saw being done. Experimentation, evolutionary and progressive thought were NOT encouraged, especially not on the boss`s dime. "We do it this way because that is the way it has always been done. Who are you to question a journeyman or master. Now get to work" was the prevailing motivational speech of the day. We still see this line of thought in manufacturing today, especially if unions are involved.

This trend of asking "why" , provided with an in depth explanation of the mechanics behind a process and then being encouraged to explore in order to find a better answer is a fairly recent development. The sharing craft related skills outside of your own shop, especially through group collaboration/exploration is VERY recent and almost unheard of just several decades ago.

Nice to know what history teaches us, especially what has proven to be both useful and efficient in the past.Better to know and understand WHY it has done that way. Knowledge like this gives us both reference points and a springboards from which we can move forward and advance out craft. Unless you are a staff member in a working museum you need not be a slave to that kind of knowledge. Understand your craft in depth, both the history and the present day application of technology yet remain open to other sources of follow on knowledge/wisdom even if they don`t seem to conform to or be directly connected to the "old ways".

One of the best explanations I heard about the difference between knowledge and wisdom is; "Knowledge is the collection of information. Wisdom is knowing when it`s appropriate to share that information, the ability to communicate it and how to apply it in order to move things forward".

The proper role of the "chipbreaker" as well as the single vs double iron debate are excellent examples of this type of in depth understanding in action.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#43

Thank you!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I had never heard of the Latta auxiliary bench. It appears so useful that its actual origins probably go back forever. Have a feeling many of these are going to get built as a result of this thread. It's an excellent platform to get any kind of fine work up in one's eyes.

On the great issue of the through dovetails, I think David Weaver called it right. And Warren's experience is most valuable. i.e., it's not a problem. I'd rather have the greater mechanical advantage afforded by the through design than the aesthetics of an unbroken surface afforded by half blinds.

Much thanks for a most useful contribution!

Wiley

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#44

That was some insightful observation & analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well written

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#45

add lazy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

through dovetails are easier to make, especially in stringy red oak. Don't underestimate my quest to minimize time and material investment in this experiment. Stick the legs on however one finds easiest to implement, or most beautiful, or what ever floats your boat. If it don't wiggle, declare success.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#46

Re: Thank you!

William Duffield

I think, if you choose the proper geometry for the dovetails, a half-blind is stronger, or at least as strong. For example, here is mine, photos from about 2-1/2 years ago. The tails stop within 5/16" of the top. I think Bill called it right, through dovetails have a significant ease of construction advantage, and insignificant adverse effect on your work (probably less than the extra dog holes I put in mine). If the top ever needs to be reflattened, planing the tail ends is no more difficult than planing a board with knots in it.




But, I'm not sure it makes any difference. Both of them are more than strong enough, as are the M&T employed by Karre Loftheim's carving bench, for example, especially if you are doing work with mostly downward forces, like they were designed to be used.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#47

Re: While I understand your point....

TomD

I thank you for that. As I said, I like Bill's bench, though at this point after all the discussion, I like it less having thought it through. But my point was never what Bill should have done for his own unique uses, or whatever. Only he knows whether he will want to use it as a step, or to saw a board on, or under a boat for support. or to rest a router table on to get it off the floor. Stuff like that happens in my shop all the time, but maybe not his. I was just musing on my general disdain for this construction, that as many have mentioned, is now popular post Roubo. The only use I have ever seen for it is to have an anvil type surface to pound on, but in the Roubo case the parts are to segmented to even give much hope for that.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#48

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

TomD

"I don't agree with your analysis of the through dovetail's strength. It is equivalent to a wedged through tenon (or a fox wedged tenon, in the case of my half-blind dovetail), or a stopped sliding dovetail, or even to the half through dovetailed stretchers used under the steps on the classic Shaker three step stool."

That barely deserves comment. Structural engineers are gobsmacked. So if you built a timber frame house, it would be ok no mater what joint was substituted for what joint. Tradition or the laws of nature be damned. Even aesthetically form follows function. To make meaningful exposed joinery furniture where one's understanding of the forces at play is laid bare for the world to see, the wrong joints are in addition to everything else, ugly. There is something perversely delightful about a scene where a master craftsman is working on classical stringing, on a bench that completely belies that status. Like those scenes in the movies where a guy is working a plane intently, and no shavings are coming out.

"It is my understanding the Roubo was a joiner and cabinetmaker who had gained considerable respect in his day, especially in his design and execution of the dome for the Paris grain market."

Thanks for the information. A quick further look at Wiki indicates he had a formidable background.

"The reason for Roubo's joinery is to counter the forces on the joint between the leg and the top that is applied by a leg vise. It is unnecessary when using a vise that is wholly attached to the top, especially a Record or Emmert or similar metal vise."

The loads in a leg vise are isolated unless you have a dog in the jaw and are pressing against a dog in the top, say. The vise could be tightened even if it was not attached to the top. Further the joint is also used where there is no leg vise.

But my point was not a critique of the joint in Roubo's bench, as much to say it could not be used as justification of the design under discussion. I still think it is valid to question the Roubo approach, and to ask why it fell out of use.

"The top of my joiner's bench (my sub-bench in this context) has functioned perfectly for almost two decades using only the force of gravity to join the base to the top. I wouldn't certify it for California, but the Mineral, VA quake had no adverse effect on it ;^)"

My prime concern in making the initial comment was not the strength of the joint, but the degree to which is cuts into the top and weaken the top. This has not be seriously answered, other than to say that Bill (who's bench I am not questioning) would never use it in a way where that would be a problem. That of course, is not how we design in the 20th century where if someone wanders into your shop stands on the edge of the bench and breaks it off, it is OK, that a poor joint was used; or just in general why weaken it like that.

" I also do not fully comprehend the reasons for some of the details of Roubo's joint, but just reversing the orientation of the pin and the tail does not compromise its strength. I think a double tenon, without the 45° angles, would be sufficient."

I am a big advocate of the principle that strong enough, is strong enough. I still would like to know why such a fancy detail was used. It cries out for an explanation. Reversing the orientation of the pin is huge! I can't fathom that remark, particularly when later on the explanation given is that it had to be thus because it was a dry fit glueless joint. BUT, again, my point about Roubo was not to enlargen the conversation to new particulars, but to reject the idea that his bench was a relevant model, when the joinery is not the same.

"but the dovetail allows it to be assembled and used without glue, which is a significant advantage while in the prototype development stage."

"prototype"? That's lipstick on a pig, I thought one of the main arguments was that it was just a personal thing, and the details should not be discussed even in abstract.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#49

Re: In defense of hardware bonding, not really...

TomD

"I understand, and agree with you, about the advantages of hardware bonding, but I don't think the additional robustness is needed for this application."

I couldn't agree with you more. Just accepting Bill's challenge to come up with other methods, or which I gave some woody ones as well. I like to confirm my initial impulse not to document this process on the forum was correct. I do think it has some very useful application in bench making. For stretchers, and endcaps. As you mentioned in your analysis of the Roubo leg. There are situations where a piece needs to be strong enough to resist a force from a vise. On my bench there is a cap that supports an LV twin screw. (Rob never calls, but I actually have two of his vises on my bench. A Christmas card maybe...) Anyway, I had to very heavily retain that endcap, and the normal method is captured nut hardware. Even with the LV parts I hate that method as structurally disruptive, ugly, expensive, and fiddly.

I have also used hardware bonding for stretchers on my Lee Valley legs, now on a table. One neat feature, other than the total superiority over the method shown in their literature (I gifted them my samples and jigs) is that you can do the joint without any continuity in the stretcher. You could have a stetcher shaped like a letter of the alphabet, and it could be joined no mater what.

Considering that the most celebrated woodworker of the last century, maybe, was famous because of a chair joint that was held together with lag bolts, I do think there are unexplored options available for structuring furniture using this technology. At the very least the famous rocker could be made without plugs.

Thanks for your comments.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#50

Re: OMG the bench is armed!