New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Latta Bench Assembled

Posts

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#51

Re: Thank you!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Sir Wm,

I spoke too fast. Yet another reminder not to make unqualified statements!

You raise an interesting point about through vs. half blind, and the effect of geometry. One thing I note in your design is the broad shoulders on each side of the tail, which I imagine greatly increase the resistance to racking. The effect of the shoulders, as they get wider, is that any longitudinal racking force is more and more up against pulling the tail straight down out of its socket. The racking force is losing leverage against the joint, as the shoulder gets wider.

Thanks for your comment; I hadn't thought it through.

Wiley

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#52

Re: Rubou Rebellion

TomD

One of the challenges of a system that relies on oral history, as the apprenticeship system did, is that it creates a closed loop. You learn what the master teaches, as her learned it from his master. Much of the techniques and knowledge were learned by wrote memorization and copying exactly what you saw being done. Experimentation, evolutionary and progressive thought were NOT encouraged, especially not on the boss`s dime. "We do it this way because that is the way it has always been done. Who are you to question a journeyman or master. Now get to work" was the prevailing motivational speech of the day. We still see this line of thought in manufacturing today, especially if unions are involved.

This trend of asking "why" , provided with an in depth explanation of the mechanics behind a process and then being encouraged to explore in order to find a better answer is a fairly recent development. The sharing craft related skills outside of your own shop, especially through group collaboration/exploration is VERY recent and almost unheard of just several decades ago.

"Nice to know what history teaches us, especially what has proven to be both useful and efficient in the past.Better to know and understand WHY it has done that way."

Makes sense. We would all agree. One thing about the past was they often didn't ask why. Then we come along in the present and assume there was a why, and they new it, and based their practices on it. Invent a reason based on our modern situation, and it becomes a new myth. That probably doesn't hurt, but simply noodling a why from a modern mindset can be a problem in understanding also. I think you have some other strong examples in your response of some of the hazards.

On the roubo bench, in the back of my mind is the thought that somewhere along the line they were cutting timbers like that, and it just caught on. When you look at the Japanese "bench" that caught on from students of Imai, I think it was mostly just an extrapolation of working in a timber shop. I have been in that situation where we were making planes in a timber shop, and we all just started working on the nearest timber, that was sitting on a trestle. Instant Japanese bench, or even the European bench we know. So people ask why they should do R. legs, or trestle type legs, these systems work, but often not because NASA engineers were working from first principles. Sometimes the question is "how", or "when".

"The proper role of the "chipbreaker" as well as the single vs double iron debate are excellent examples of this type of in depth understanding in action."

I don't know. Thousands of people, major corporation, etc... all knew this information. I guess it took newbies to know what newbies don't know. It seems to be a very significant piece of reporting. People seem to have needed to been told. I don't think it speaks to looking deep into the past with "why" in mind, when the past was in active practice all around.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#53

Re: Thank you! ROFL

TomD

"I think Bill called it right, through dovetails have a significant ease of construction advantage"

I got the biggest laugh out of that one (at the time DTs vs MTs)l. Isn't this the gent who just purchased a mortising machine fit for Goliath? Oh yeah, maybe for now, dovetails are waaay easier than M&T.


Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#54

Re: Thank you!

TomD

And another small point to add to yours Wiley, he didn't cut through the top to get there. A good working number is 20%. If the retained fiber on the top of a beam is 20%. the deflection is downward, and the kerf is filled with an inflexible filer, you are going to get substantial strength in the resulting element.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#55

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

TomD

Or one could ask if the chair functionally superior to the floor. I haven't seen cross legged in decades so my answer is clear.

I have a lot of free wood, and I can tell you, it all cost a lot. The cheapest wood is always the stuff you pay full price for in small amounts you use at the time. Found wood is pretty cheap for turning, but for cabinets, it needs processing, storage (often for decades), it isn't cheap.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#56

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

William Duffield

You're right about the lack of strength of the joint. I had considered that failure mode when I built it, and forgot about it afterwards. To a certain extent, I have addressed it as well as I could in this bench, by choosing a wood that doesn't split very easily, and by positioning the dovetails well away from the ends of the bench. In another post, Wiley points out the same consideration, looking at it from a different perspective. I hope Bill's oak isn't quartersawn. Elm or other interlocked grain wood would have been a better choice that oak or even the hard maple I used. I will need to remember not to do any chopping with mallet and chisel at the corners–Maybe black and yellow diagonal stripes, and "NO STEP".

It hadn't even crossed my mind that someone would use it as a step stool, much less be foolish enough to step out on the end, especially since I don't store it on the floor. I don't like the idea of the bottoms of the legs picking up stones and metal shavings and transferring them to the bench top, and I wouldn't appreciate someone walking on top of the bench, unless they removed their shoes. When it's not attached to the sub-bench, I use it as ballast under my lathe.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#57

Re: Thank you! ROFL

William Duffield

You are taking that out of context. I only meant they were easier than the half blind dovetails I used–just six saw cuts and one whack with a wide chisel. If I were building it again today, however, I think I would use a few of the largest Dominos I have. Even though this is the Hand Tool forum, I really don't enjoy chopping mortises in hard maple.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#58

Re: Rubou Rebellion

Steve Elliott

During the thirty-five years I've worked as a cabinetmaker the changes in equipment and materials have made the ability to adapt to new tools and techniques a survival skill. I never thought I'd need computer drafting skills until I started at a shop that had a CNC router.

While I believe there is great value in a system that allows younger workers to learn from those with more experience, rote learning of "the right way" to do a task isn't enough. It reminds me of a line by Robert Pirsig in "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" to the effect that self-taught mechanics are sometimes superior to institute-trained ones who "have learned everything except how to handle a new situation."

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#59

Re: Joint Strength Questions

William Duffield

So, should I have left 3/8" (1:4) of the top above the tail, instead of 5/16" (1:5)? The finished thickness of my top is 1-7/8".

Intuitively, why shouldn't the same rule of thumb apply to mortise and tenon joinery? If so, wouldn't the 1:1:1 ratio of thicknesses of mortise wall to tenon to mortise wall result in a suboptimal joint, and wouldn't 1:3:1 be stronger? Since there are two webs surrounding the mortise, instead of one as in my questionable dovetail, might thickening the mortise somewhat further, say 1:4:1, result in an even stronger joint?

I hope I haven't confused anyone by using the whole number ratios. They have been in use and widely understood for millennia, much longer than percentages, or the metric system.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#60

I'm concerned

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was considering making a second bench and two ramps so I could run the car up on it for oil changes. I do love multitaskers. But now I am worried about the strength of the joinery and believe I must limit its stresses to holding up doors and drawers and pencils. :)

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#61

Need more holes


Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#62

Re: Rubou Rebellion

Chip

If the top is made with boards oriented in a face lamination the movement is through the thickness of the top and not across its width. This could expose the through-joined legs slightly in the winter, though most workers would nip the ends off the first winter with a block plane and it would never be a problem again - they would always be at or slightly below the rest of the bench surface after the first dry season.

If the top is made with a solid piece of very thick timber the movement will of course be across the width but this won't expose the endgrain of the through-joined legs.

Re: Latta Bench Assembled

#63

Re: Need more holes

William Duffield

Where would I put them? I think it's full. :)

I found out I don't really need the holes in the sides of the top. They were a KD fastener experiment. It worked, but I rarely use them any more, because the Gramercy holdfasts perform the intended functions much more efficiently.

Regarding holes in the top, In Steve Latta's original, he decided he needed more holes, but instead of drilling more in the top, he put several in a sheet of thin plywood he screwed to the bottom of the end of the top, specifically for holding a few tools. I think my approach, using multiple rows of general purpose holes, has advantages, because you can use any of the holes for dogs, or holdfasts, or tool holders, or mounts for work lights, or for installing KD fasteners.