Re: Rubou Rebellion
TomD
One of the challenges of a system that relies on oral history, as the apprenticeship system did, is that it creates a closed loop. You learn what the master teaches, as her learned it from his master. Much of the techniques and knowledge were learned by wrote memorization and copying exactly what you saw being done. Experimentation, evolutionary and progressive thought were NOT encouraged, especially not on the boss`s dime. "We do it this way because that is the way it has always been done. Who are you to question a journeyman or master. Now get to work" was the prevailing motivational speech of the day. We still see this line of thought in manufacturing today, especially if unions are involved.
This trend of asking "why" , provided with an in depth explanation of the mechanics behind a process and then being encouraged to explore in order to find a better answer is a fairly recent development. The sharing craft related skills outside of your own shop, especially through group collaboration/exploration is VERY recent and almost unheard of just several decades ago.
"Nice to know what history teaches us, especially what has proven to be both useful and efficient in the past.Better to know and understand WHY it has done that way."
Makes sense. We would all agree. One thing about the past was they often didn't ask why. Then we come along in the present and assume there was a why, and they new it, and based their practices on it. Invent a reason based on our modern situation, and it becomes a new myth. That probably doesn't hurt, but simply noodling a why from a modern mindset can be a problem in understanding also. I think you have some other strong examples in your response of some of the hazards.
On the roubo bench, in the back of my mind is the thought that somewhere along the line they were cutting timbers like that, and it just caught on. When you look at the Japanese "bench" that caught on from students of Imai, I think it was mostly just an extrapolation of working in a timber shop. I have been in that situation where we were making planes in a timber shop, and we all just started working on the nearest timber, that was sitting on a trestle. Instant Japanese bench, or even the European bench we know. So people ask why they should do R. legs, or trestle type legs, these systems work, but often not because NASA engineers were working from first principles. Sometimes the question is "how", or "when".
"The proper role of the "chipbreaker" as well as the single vs double iron debate are excellent examples of this type of in depth understanding in action."
I don't know. Thousands of people, major corporation, etc... all knew this information. I guess it took newbies to know what newbies don't know. It seems to be a very significant piece of reporting. People seem to have needed to been told. I don't think it speaks to looking deep into the past with "why" in mind, when the past was in active practice all around.