New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

Posts

Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#1

Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

david weaver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qjHMwL-dj4

I've started making a series of videos, that I think are a comprehensive view of making a double iron plane (admittedly boring and fairly long, but should be interesting if someone actually wants to make a plane).

It's no secret that I have a fascination with these, and I've had one for a while and we hashed out the details some on another forum. I made a post when I was making my first couple, but the work was a bit substandard.

It'll probably take me a couple of weeks to get this plane finished, and the videos will be uploaded as I move along.

I had a little bit of a hitch in my giddyup on this idea, because a few months after I put the instructional on SMC in text, someone released a for-pay video from PWW on 18th century planes. These are not that style, and I haven't seen that video, anyway, nor have I read any books on the subject (there was a WPINCA book that had some pictures about planemaking - brief and incomplete, I guess I did read those, but what they describe is not how I lay out or build planes. These compositions are of my own intellectual property with my own thoughts. I don't intend them to be interesting, i intend them to be instructive/archival for anyone who gets a burr up their rear and suddenly decides they want to build a plane, and doesn't want to build three or four just to get the first decent one. If someone isn't interested in building a plane, I'm pretty sure they'll be too boring and detailed with the exception of making and fitting a wedge later, which is useful to know just to recondition old planes.

So, they're here. If five people learn to build their own plane from these videos over the next decade, that'll be good enough for me. I have low aspirations!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#2

Suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Offer a video for sale. Not everyone in the world has the capacity to download movies. I encountered a recent example of this sort of endeavor. I wanted to paint a chair like Curtis does. But his videos are such large files it exhausted my monthly rural internet download allotment in short order. I had to get someone to put them on a TV, record the TV image and copy to disk. (He since has begun selling a DVD).

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#3

Re: Suggestion

david weaver

We'll see if there's a demand.

To say the production value in my videos is low will be an understatement, they are just recorded as I do the steps with no editing. When I get to the stuff like chopping a mortise, I will exclude some of that because it takes about an hour to make the mortise and open the mouth. But not edit otherwise.

If there is a demand, I will have to figure something out. I think these for now can be watched at low resolution without losing any value.

If they need to end up on mailable media, I'll put them on a DVD or some DVDs and make them available for free other than the cost of recordable media.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#4

Curtis has something very special...

david weaver

...I think Curtis should sell his video, he does something very special in the level of work that he does. It is so good and so interesting that it draws you to watch it even if you have no intention to make chairs. I will never be a woodworker at the level Curtis works.

These are more like a glorified shop tool video (just more elaborate than something like making a scratch stock), and I have no idea what is "accepted trade" or widely practiced trade for anything, it's just what I've come to from experience.

I also have a lot of opinions, some of them will be expressed in the videos (none vulgar, and none come upon cheaply - they are genuine and well thought out, even if everyone doesn't agree on them)..when you offer something for free, nobody has a stake in what you do or say - you can say what you think people should hear, and that to me is important. (and they are perfectly free to ignore it, and that to me is important, too).

I make these planes and now that I've got mine, I've been giving them away to people who use them. As strange as it sounds, I make the planes exactly as I want to make them, and offer them for free so that nobody else feels like they have any input on the design. That sounds ridiculous, and i know, but I've stopped trying to make excuses for ridiculous things that I do.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#5

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Kees

You've got my attention David. Allready watched 1, 1b and 2.

I like this realtime format.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#6

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

roger lance

David.....I'll probably never make this type of plane.....but, I'm the type of person who likes to learn visually as opposed to just reading text and I will be watching your videos thru the entire series.....some of us comprehend much more when we can see it being built and explained. Thank you for your efforts in this regard and I hope you enjoy the process of making your work available on YouTube.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#7

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

TomD

The standard for video on Youtube is incredibly high these days. That said, I actually like a real time video, I suppose it could get a little boring if it is taking too long. It used to really irritate me when people would review say the Krenov plane video as though they were reviewing an art house movie, to me we were lucky to get the information, the rest is just those who can't do, raining on those who can. But I guess the original grousers have got their way, there are random Youtube videos, that are as good or better than, say FWW stuff, and their stuff was pretty good.

I can make a plane in about 45 minutes to the first cut. An then I can diddle around making it pretty for a while after that. Not sure how long it takes to make a mortised one, I only know the former number from my Krenov plane seminars. There are a few tricks to making mortised planes fast, though I don't normally bother.

The Japanese Seminar a few of us attended, the master, said it would take all morning to make the 6" wide super ceremonial bench plane, but it was like 45 minutes, or 2 hours, or both. Like maybe 45 to get the rough fit, and 2 to get it finished, aesthetically. So if it took someone 6 hours to make something, it would raise the question of whether the techniques shown are the real ones.

Speaking of haste. He had (back in Japan) one of those double shovel machines that makes the rough mortise, and with that he could make a half dozen planes before lunch. Probably an aprentice would have done that for him if he hadn't the machine. It cost him two fingers though, and based on what I saw, it probably only saved him a few minutes a plane. If he hadn't lost the fingers, it might have been worth it over a lifetime.

Anyway, as someone who has been waiting for the C&W's promised bench plane video, and has followed what you say you got from George, I will be watching with interest.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#8

Re: 10 hours..

david weaver

It takes me about 10 hours to make a plane like the one in the video. the first jointer took me 15, the time is slowly coming down and at the same time the work is getting cleaner. I could do some things faster, like get a heavier hammer for the mortising (or rather pull one out from under the bench), but I like the mortising and I don't need to shave 15 minutes out of it.

Someone who was "legit" and who had the same iron every time and patterns made for the wedge, templates, etc, could probably make 3 try planes in a work day. It would be a physical hustle, one that nobody could keep up.

There are a lot of things in making this type of plane where an inexperienced guy like me just can't work quite as close to finished dimension (and thus needs to pare, float or scrape a lot more) vs. a pro. A true hand tooling pro would pretty much cut the mortise almost finished with a chisel. I don't know of any makers doing that at speed (and by that, I mean having the mortise cut, open the mouth, good and clean, cut the abutments, have it all clean and then cut out toward the cheeks - all in about a half hour.). There are definitely items in my routine that could be refined into that direction, but I'd only worry about those if I were going to make these things for pay.

There are a lot of things in this that just physically take time, like cutting the contours on the handle, etc. And even for me, just jointing the billet, sawing it (even though I used a bandsaw for this particular one, I've got to have a reference side or two to get there) and then planing to size.

I've never made a krenov plane, so I don't know what to expect with that type, and I've cut one dai.

As far as patterns and everything, I have no pre-set patterns other than the block that is shown for abutment sawing. The rest of the stuff is just made to fit for each plane as I go along. My irons are all over the place, the cap irons are all different, the irons all have different thickness and taper. It would be easier to start from a pattern, still, and fine tune it, I just enjoy the whole process of making things to fit. And because I do, I can show it in a video here instead of suggesting that everyone make a bunch of patterns.

The beauty of a plane like these is there is never anything to clamp when building, and you can rely on your eyes for most of the work. I hate glue-up of furniture and clamps and all of that stuff!!

While I can't look like super-pro banging one of these things out in four hours, I can tell an intermediate woodworker things they will never guess at on their first plane, and that's really the point. I (and I presume Steve Voigt, too, because Steve and I were really the two most excited parties in discussing these) had to learn by trial and error. Steve finishes his planes to a higher level than I do, too - he has to because he has customers.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#9

Re: 10 hours..  Sawn planes

TomD

To make a real custom level handle I can spend a ton of time. I do think the western plane between the wedge and the handles is a different kettle of fish. For instance while it takes me a while to get the ramp on the Dai (for the most part I haven't had floats, and still only have some I made for myself, and the ramp isn't flat anyway), but the abutments, are a piece of cake. A huge time saver, and the whole thing works better. I made one for a jack using a Japanese blade and layout, and it is an amazing plane. Only thing is I did not plan it out properly, and I can't easily get the blade out. But the solution to that is simple, I just don't know when I will bother to make another one. I once showed the two planes here, and I don't think I got a comment, so if that ever becomes a fad, you can guarantee nobody will remember.

The krenov is simpler in a number of ways. No handle, and recent versions seem to have gone Japanese with the brick look. Actually a real brick look, with bandsawn surfaces left rough. It is a sawn plane. You can make any plane a sawn plane, and the time savings and ease of manufacture are huge. But then you get good at chisel work by chiselling, and while glued joints are stronger, they don't last longer than unsawn wood.

I like sawn planes, hey they are planes! But there are times when you need some planes, like I made a matched set to rough out bamboo fly rod roughing . Just to see if it would work. Not going to spend 40 hours on that, but 40 minute a plane is fine. LV is only 10 miles away, but it is still faster to make that plane than buy a bit for a router, and routers would only cut one of the shapes.

Another plane I made was out of a scrap of Osage. So happened I had a piece that wasn't wide enough, so I made it sandwich style. Another team win.

Realistically a Bill type user who wants to make stuff, could probably make a half set of hollows and rounds in a day, while even Larry takes a week to make a "real" set. Plus the real set takes a few hundred dollars of speciality tools to make just so. Some day I will end up with the speciality tools, I want to see how itis to do it "right", after 40 years making planes. But some people may balk at the cost.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#10

Re: the balk..

david weaver

..the plane (the griffiths of norwhich old plane shown) has a nearly unused ward and payne iron in it, the nicest iron I have ever seen. It's made superbly in the mortise, cleaner than I am capable of, and the mouth is still very tight but it feeds well.

Anyone with sense would balk at what I'm doing, because I'm using about $80-$100 of materials to make a plane that's in truth no better than that plane, and some parts are not as clean!!

That plane cost $80.

When I'm done with my planes, they have no real economic value. The griffiths is still worth $80!!!

When you find the guy who knows how to "do it right", let me know where his videos are!! Larry does, I suppose for single iron planes, but those things are not for me!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#11

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Steve Voigt

David, I've only had time to watch a little, but so far it looks great. Maybe I can convince my wife to watch the whole set for movie night! :D

I think it's going to be a great resource for people who want to get into this, and I commend you for doing it.

I haven't watched the other video you referred to, which I think is Bill Anderson, though he's not the producer or marketer. I'm a little allergic to websites with big banners that scream SUBSCRIBE NOW!!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#12

Chris Scholz

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Chris Scholz

Hi Dave,

thanks for sharing, this is awesome!

Not sure if you have seen this. There is a brethren sort of on the other side of the globe who is cranking out wooden planes using traditional methods (just like yours, his videos are free, on Youtube, too).

Different plane, different language but is looks like you both think alike. What do you really NEED to make a plane? Straight edge, chisel, hammer, rasp, frame saw, plane and pencil.

Part 1:

http://youtu.be/HnG3XKt4hMQ

Part 2:

http://youtu.be/YjugyVP0bbU

Part 3 and test drive:

http://youtu.be/Yvlo3XMv-70

Looking forwards to your next video.

Edit: Oops, forgot you need an ax, too but only for cosmetic reasons, so I guess one could do without (1:24 to 3:00 in the third movie)

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#13

Re: the balk..

Kees

We don't always do things for economic reasons. Having fun is important too, or trying to learn a skill or just out of curiosity.

I once tried to calculate the production of old time plane makers and came to a number of 5 to 8 planes a day. That includes all types of course and a tryplane would have taken more timethen a simple hollow or round.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#14

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

I can't imagine you'll get anything out of watching it!!

You've made several multiples more than me, you can do some video shaming watching with your wife and say "look at the way dave is doing that, it's stupid!!" :)

When I get about halfway through after opening the mouth and escapement, I am going to mention you if you're not offended by that. I think by then, some people are going to think "I don't want to make one of these planes but I want to have one".

Two things I do come from our conversations on SMC and I'm going to make mention of that - of course that conversation was you, me and kees, and the plane talk was you and me.

It's not like millions of people are going to watch these, so I don't expect that you're going to have your email lighting up with orders if I say that. You might get a small raft of tire kickers hoping that a plane will be $75.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#15

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

Ah, I've seen those :) I had them running in the background at work while they were on one day at lunch, but didn't pay close enough attention. I will watch them again at some point. Just in a short minute responding to this, I see him cutting the mortise in the side of a plane for a handle, and I'm baffled that he gets no chip accumulation in the mortise.

(I went through GE's channel before because he's a pro working by hand. And a very proficient one. One who keeps the tools moving efficiently, which is rare these days).

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#16

Re: By the way, I once...

david weaver

..said something to George Wilson, and I don't know how many planes george made at colonial williamsburg, maybe a thousand? And for himself, he has made some exceptional planes.

I said something to him about floats and he didn't say too much, I asked again, and he said he does the finish work on his planes with chisels.

He did rig up a drilling and milling setup to do the mortise work and cut the abutments, though.

I've made one plane so far with chisels and no floats and it took me a lot longer. If I was to make enough of these to be proficient, I could probably work faster with just chisels but I'll never make enough.

To your point, though, most of the things I use for convenience, you don't *need* them, and I wanted to make that point in the video so that if someone wants to just learn the design and the layout and complete it with fewer tools, that's no problem.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#17

Re: assumption..

david weaver

..I should probably not make the assumption that the woodworker in the video is named "GE Hong". That's probably the guy with the camera.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#18

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Steve Voigt

Dave, feel free to use my name if you want. I'm flattered.

I'm sure I will learn something from the videos. The thing about traditional planemaking, there's so few people doing it that there's no set of standardized "best practices." I doubt my methods are the most efficient.

The threads on SMC were hugely important for me, in terms of nailing down the crucial details of double iron construction. Later, I discovered that all that info was pretty much in the Seaton toolchest book, but I never would have figured that out for myself without the photos and discussion. As with the double iron itself, I can sometimes be staring right at the solution and not see it...

Anyway, good stuff!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#19

Re: assumption..

Chris

That's right. The woodworkers name is Xin Quansheng (family name Xin, given name Quansheng). Xin Shifu (Master Xin) would work and it's a lot easier for us (although we don't to the "x" all that well).

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#20

Re: assumption..

TomD

Is that just zin?

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#21

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

TomD

Do you have a reference for those threads on SMC?

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#22

Re: the balk..

TomD

Wood cost for my next 200 planes is 50 Canadian. Plus gas and tool wear, my wife ran the mill into some drywall screws. She thinks she should pay to have the chain sharpened... :)

It's OK, I bought a sharpener, well it is from HF, so I think it is a sharpener.


That is her contemplating all the new nylons she won't be able to afford with the cost of replacing the blade.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#23

Re: the balk..

david weaver

That's what, like, 3 dollars and 42 cents american?

:D

what kind of trees are they that you've got laid over everywhere?

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#24

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Lars Parrington

This is great! When I saw your earlier post about making the plane for your large-handed, power-tool-using, friend, I thought to myself "it would be nice if he put up a tutorial about how to make those planes". And now here it is!

I'll be following along, and keeping an eye out for some beech. I've got no floats or rasps or budget for new tools, so I'm glad you are saying it can be done without (although with extra effort, of course).

Thanks for making these!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#25

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Steve Voigt

Tom, the thread where we first hashed out all the details is here:

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?216319-Tapered-vs-Krenov-Hock-vs-Japansese-Style-irons/page7

Pages 3-4 are where most of the good stuff is, then it all devolves into the usual forum nonsense.

Dave did two build threads here:

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?217062-Cocobolo-Smoother-Build

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?218832-Cocobolo-Smoother-Build-2

and I did one here:

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?219429-Yet-Another-Smoother

That is a lot of reading, with a lot of forum garbage mixed in, but if you are interested…