New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

Posts

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#51

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

Kees

I have some airdried beech, but some of the sticks have been cracking like crazy in my garage too. Others are still allright. It's weird stuff, even European beech.

BTW, I am now watching episode 7 and am still liking it a lot. You have a sweet daughter. Enjoy it, when they turn 15 or so, they aren't so cute anymore :D

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#52

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

david weaver

I don't know for sure if this is true, but I think the euro stuff might be a little better behaved.

I only have a little bit of euro stuff, though (courtesy of george), and a lot of american beech.

I asked hearne about beech and he wrinkled his nose. I have a habit of going to their lumber shop on Christmas eve once every couple of years, and he's the only one there, or there's only a couple, and I can bend his ear and pet the dogs. when i asked if they had any, knowing they've got a lot of nice stuff, he said "utility wood!!" :)

I still would love to have a good straight log of it to try my hand at air drying it, but it would require (like apple) a visit once a day and sealing of any spot that looked like it was cracking or checking.

For the apple and wet cocobolo billets, I actually check them every day or two when they are very wet and put CA glue in any forming checks. That has stopped them from occurring, and I don't take the wax off of the end of the billets that are waxed for a year.

Once the beech is dry, though, it's so nice to use with hand tools. I know george likes (liked) to make his planes out of maple (despite having beech available), I found hard maple a bit less forgiving to use (though the result was fine). For various tools cut by hand, I have tried apple, hard maple, cherry, beech, birch, cocobolo, bois de rose (will never get to try that again) and probably a couple of other things, but really only liked apple and beech (the bois de rose was nice, but it's impossible to find in large pieces now).

Long way of saying that beech is poorly behaved when drying (or expensive if you're buying), but worth the trouble once you're making planes with it.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#53

Drying beech

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have had good results air drying beech. About three years ago a cabinetmaker friend dropped off some old edge tools for me to put handles on. We like tapered octagonal beech handles. I mentioned I was a little low on beech. It was Friday afternoon. Monday morning he called me up and said he had some beech for me. He had bought a log, taken it to the sawmill, and supervised quarter sawing. I stacked it in my barn loft.

I inspected the stuff today; some pieces have very small radial cracks on the ends, some have none. Some 4X4 stuff I got a year later is also in good shape. Possibly air drying under roof in an unheated building is best.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#54

Re: Drying beech

david weaver

Warren, what you describe is exactly how George Wilson described it being dried at CW. They put it in the attic of one of the shops. George never mentioned any problems with that method either, and he would've if they'd have had them.

I have just such an attic space in my house that would be pretty good for them (it's accessible and very dry), but I'm lacking the green wood to try it out :\

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#55

Drying beech

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In one sense beech is easier to dry than oak which gives up its water reluctantly so it is prone to honeycomb and case hardening. The issue is that beech has a large difference between radial and tangential shrinkage. This difference is irrelevant when drying quartered lumber. However, in flat sawed lumber where the surface of the board may range from radial to tangential exposure, this difference can lead to warping as it dries.

Commercial European beech is typically steamed which mellows it some. Packs of it that I have seen are dead flat and plain as paper. Seems like I have read of American plane makers boiling beech blanks before drying, which would have the same effect of lessening this shrinkage problem.

Beech is rarely harvested because there is no market for it except rail ties and this market is boom or bust (currently boom). You may find a local mill sawing ties if the market there is as hot as it is here ($500/ 1000bdft delivered logs to mill).

At least locally it is common in cut over forest lands. We have thousands of bdft of it, in the tree. I cut it for firewood. Some has interlocked grain, and some does not. You are welcome to all you can haul off. It would be a simple task to just block the log and split out billets like the chair people do. Through splitting you could quick tell if the grain was interlocked and reject such logs. (the rejects could be added to my fire wood pile. In short order you would have more pieces than you would use in years. Quartered it would dry quickly.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#56

Re: homework

david weaver

I probably need to do some homework. I have an appetite for making planes, but it's something that I can't continue to do forever and spend a grand a year just on the wood.

The 55 or so board feet that I got in my last shipment was $840 with freight, and it is beautiful wood, but a bit steep for a screw-around hobby if I start buying it once a year like that.

Especially when I know there are people burning the wood here and I should be able to find one of the local sawyers having access to a log here or there.

Thanks for the advice (i'm not sure if it was informational, or if it's advice). I'm going to try to find some to air dry my own.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#57

David you're terrible!

Kees

What a mess in your shop, dropping tools on the floor all the time and overcutting all your marking lines! Oh, and you really need to make a better workbench :D :D

I really like the video series. It reminds me a little bit off the original rough cut show when Tommy Mac made that Boston bombay cabinet. To be honest, Tommy was funnier. :b

As soon as I get my current project finished I want to make a plane like that too.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#58

Re: David you're terrible!

david weaver

There's not much similar between me and tommy mac in terms of work!!

I have a sense of humor, but it's definitely inappropriate.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#59

Re: Finished Plane and some Use

david weaver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iuUBzkEZEY

(use of the actual plane starts a little after 11:00)

Coloration in this plane is a bit questionable!! It's my first plane entirely out of sap wood, and I indulged its appetite for oil for a little bit.

I'll see if I can find something more interesting than cherry to plane, I don't keep much "gotcha" wood around to test planes, but I've got some very figured maple somewhere.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#60

Re: David you're terrible!

Kees

I just watches the last one an dthat plane is performing very well on that piece of wood.

Congrats on the results.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#61

Re: David you're terrible!

david weaver

Thanks, Kees. It's kind of hard to build a bad one if you don't wonk the abutments, bed and wedge. I'll find something more interesting to plane.

The utility of thicker shavings without tearout doesn't really come across to folks who don't dimension by hand.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#62

Re: David you're terrible!

TomD

Correct point, but also, there is the removal of material with tearout. Most planers do it and people don't care that much. I would much rather take a 1/16 inch shaving at times, or deeper, even if there is a little tear-out. Of course often one saws closer than that so no need, but there have been time when it was nice to really rip a board a new one with a plane.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#63

Re: David you're terrible!

David weaver

That's jack work at that thickness, though, and I agree that I'm not looking for no tearout at that stage. I don't think most people ever struggle at year, though. Speaking from experience, the step between jack and smoother used to be where I lost time or blew marking lines due to having to either be careful (and slow) or be careless and have tearout beyond the mark.

I've never measured my jack shavings, but the ones I took in the last video of that series were pretty light because I didn't want to thrash the bench around in a video. Otherwise I usually take the thickest shaving I can for a given situation. I'd rather take 20 have shavings than 100 light ones.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#64

Re: David you're terrible!

Larry Barrett

David - you might be able to stiffen that bench by adding two diagonal braces on the back side of the benchbetween the legs - top of one to the bottom of the other, both ways (that is, if you can get to the back side ;) ).

Thank you for posting the videos; I enjoyed watching and learning.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#65

Re: David you're terrible!

david weaver

Thanks, Larry. I keep thinking that "soon", I'm going to build a bench to replace it. Strange as it sounds, I like the design of the bench, it just needs to be about 3x as heavy, and a foot longer would be nice. It has about as much stability as a card table.

I noticed on the video that every time I take a stroke with the plane, the bench runs into my machinist bench, which is in front and to the right of it. That bench weighs about 400 pounds, and it stops any movement immediately (that's why the quick blur on the video with each plane stroke - it bumps into the bench the camera is on). No such luck laterally, though. The bench has a cabinet style bottom, so access for bracing is a bit limited. I may cover the outside of the legs in the front and back with 1/2 inch ply for now until I actually get to make a bench.

The biggest thing in my way of making a bench of the same style and just transferring the hardware is that I haven't seen 8/4 hardwood locally for cheap.

As you can tell, I'm extremely tolerant of a subpar bench, more so than a lot of people who probably do a lot less heavy planing than I do. Someday, it will break, though - and that's a problem. There's about 150 pounds of ballast in the cabinet, but the legs are no stiffer for it. It has a skirt, otherwise I'd fasten a 2x4 under the front to the wall behind. Even with the ballast, it only weighs about 300 pounds or a little more, so it can be moved easily just by lifting one and and turning it.

Thanks for spurring the thought...maybe I'll add plywood as bracing this weekend.

Still waiting for one to show up cheap on craigslist, too!! If I never had to make a bench in my life, I'd feel that I haven't missed anything.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#66

Re: Plywood Did it...

david weaver

Thanks for the reminder :) Just screwed a sized piece of plywood over the legs with about 20 wood screws.

It was a fix that only took about 10 minutes. Now it skids across the floor before it racks. :)

I can probably do the same thing to the back of it this weekend so that it has the same rigidity lengthwise and doesn't rely on the machinist bench to stay in one place.