New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

Posts

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#26

Chris Scholz

Re: assumption..

Chris Scholz

Pretty close,...close enough.

Ok, getting a bit off woodworking here...

xin, zin, zhin, totally different. If you click on the little speaker icon in google translate a friendly voice will give you the proper pronunciation. We just don't make this kind of sound in the English, simply does not exist in our language. The closest I could describe it is with the "ch" in the German "Ich".

Try if this link works.

https://translate.google.com/#auto/en/%E8%BE%9B

if not, copy and paste the character 辛 into google translate.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#27

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

TomD

Watched number one. You have a pleasant voice, which is great if you are planing the long way around. I could listen to you talk for a very long time, which is apparently the plan.

You are driving me crazy dropping your tools on tools. I know there are tons of tools to show, but I felt pain with every blow. Actually as an interesting aside, I came across some research recently that said that walking on climbing ropes, a huge no no in my religion, is actually of no harm. And this includes walking on various surfaces, and even with crampons, which I don't believe, except in some fictional case where they are like needles sewing. But any who, maybe clanking tools doesn't mater?

You did learn your plane making from someone, whoever made the plane. But there isn't any point in worrying about it since there is no way to guard the information gate on 18th century technology. I'm sure you are making a lot of people really happy. The most important thing is that the first person out knows what they are talking about, and you are on that case.

Loving it so far!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#28

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

TomD

Thanks Steve, I appreciate the effort on my part. I'm a member at SMC, but rarely get over there, and seem to miss most of the interesting stuff.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#29

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

TomD

I have metal machinery so I can make floats, but I get a lot done with various sized saws. I don't find files cut well enough. I get various hack saw blades, and gang them or use them on diagonals, they cut just like a float, and you don't need an absolutely in contact back, you need sufficient points. Same deal with keyhole saws, some are tapered, and they have wide set teeth, some of the ones I have are almost 1/8" in spacing.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#30

Re: assumption..

TomD

Thanks Chris!

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#31

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

What, you don't like my tools clanking together? :D Next time, I'll do a video and bang the ends of two chisels together and see if I can get them to hook together like shoji :)

I don't like my foods to touch each other, but I'm OK with the tools doing it for a video. I don't know how many times I've dropped those round handed paring chisels all the way off the bench.

You are exactly right that I learned the plane making from those planes, and steve spurring discussion on SMC helped a lot, despite some trolling from people getting threads closed. To the best of my recollection, all I can remember reading about plane making is the pages in WPINCA or one of the NY planemakers books, but I can't remember what was in it other than some jigs and discussion about putting the wood bark side out.

Not many people are going to make it all the way through these videos, only the ones who really want to build this type of plane badly. But that's OK.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#32

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

Well, my goal was that I hoped at least ten people would watch this actually wanting to build a plane (rather than tune into youtube just to watch other people work, which is fairly pleasant to do, I'll admit).

So you're #1, 9 more to go! :b

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#33

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Chuck Bjorgen

I watched episodes three and four tonight and was very interested in how you started the mortising. Looking forward to the next installments. I'll probably never try to make a woody but I did acquire four of these last year and am still trying to make them work right.

That was a nice touch stopping to help your daughter with her safety helmet while you were making the video. :)

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#34

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

I know there are some people who are a bit iffy about kids being in the shop, but mine never has power tools plugged in, and it's a nice flat space for my daughter to ride a scooter at night.

As far as the other planes go, I think you'll find the bedding of the iron, the making of the wedge and the abutments and the discussion of the fit very useful. If I have any feeding problems to troubleshoot, you'll find that useful, too.

Most old planes I've used don't need any bedding work, but a lot of them would benefit from a rework of the cap iron and and a new wedge.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#35

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Steve Voigt

Yeah, the bike helmet interlude was pretty darned adorable. :)

Your mortising technique is very efficient. A nice aspect of it is that you avoid a lot of flipping the plane end for end, which can be time-consuming and rhythm-breaking.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#36

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Larry Barrett

David - it is really nice of you to post these videos. I am learning alot from watching and listening to your thinking. In the 4th video, where you are roughing out the mortise, you were surprised that the holes you drilled into the mouth were not approximately parallel - the ones in the center were close to the wear face. I noticed that at the outer edges of the hole, you took pains to make sure the angle was shallow enough to not get near the wear. Although it is a little hard to tell, it looked to me that you changed (raised) the angle of the drill when you were drilling in the center of mouth, which would explain the holes coming close to the wear. In my own experience drilling angled holes, I find that I need a visual aid, like an adjustable bevel, to avoid inadvertently changing the angle of attack.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#37

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

You're right about the visual references, I should have two, one on each side of the plane to look at. I just get a little lazy drilling the holes. Since there's 35 degrees of difference between the bed and the wear, I can afford it - that and I don't generally leave a mouth tighter than a 16th or so on these because of some past experience with plane feeding tighter than that...that comes up later.

But I should be more careful. I'm already not the neatest woodworker in the world, and I've got a couple of boo boos in this plane to this point that I wouldn't have without the camera distraction.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#38

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

All I can say about it is that laziness brought me to it :)

Mortising is probably my favorite part of the whole process, because you don't have to pay too much attention to everything going on other than staying between the lines.

I do need to pay more attention to details ,though. I let the mouth get away on this one a little bit due to a marking error, and I knew it didn't look quite right marking and then forgot to stick short of the mark. That's not an error that anyone should make on their eighth or ninth plane.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#39

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Chuck Bjorgen

Today was one of those days when I had no outside obligations and found myself viewing episodes five through fourteen of your plane making videos. I will probably finish out the series tomorrow.

One part of the process that caught my attention was your making the wedge for this plane and some of the critical areas in the process that demand attention. I will certainly be looking over my four double iron woodies to see if they need any improvement. The process seems fussy but seems worth doing if my old woodies are in need. I think I might even have a chunk of beech I acquired some time ago.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#40

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

I'm not sure how much of it you have to do the way I'm doing it (in terms of the level of wedge fitting going on). I screwed myself a little by guessing poorly on how tall the fingers of the wedge were right at the point where the double iron bend occurs, way more work than I wanted to do to get the thing thicknessed.

One thing that I did early on was cut the wedge stock at the angle I wanted, but then almost to a point, and then I could just cut the end off little by little until I was close to having the end of the fingers be the right thickness. I might go back to that.

It's easier for me to get the right length of the wedge and width at the same time if It's cut a little over thickness. Once the fingers are there, it gets a little harder to plane it to width, though I guess someone could sand it.

As far as precision, my try plane has a wedge that's just a hair narrow at the fingers, but it still doesn't have feeding problems. I've had other wedges in old planes where the fingers were way in from the sides, and it was a clogging point. And others that had fingers of significant different lengths and they worked fine.

You just never know what you'll get away with. Doing what I did is time consuming, but I like to stack the deck in my favor on anything related to tight bedding and feeding. Plus, I cut the wedge stock from the same blank, directly above the plane stock itself. I assume over a long period of time that the plane itself will shrink a little bit and the wedge will shrink about the same amount or just a little less based on its origin. I really like a plane where you can take a full width shaving and have it never clog even on the thinnest shaving and stop you in your tracks with a shaving so thick you can't move it before there's ever any chatter.

The two things together, the set of the double iron, and the good bedding and wedge fit makes it so that you can use a double iron plane as hard as you can possibly work physically (with as heavy of a chip as you can tolerate), and without any risk of tearout any greater than a smoother can remove.

I've really liked my corrected vintage try planes just as much as my new ones in use, and some of them were $20 with a nice full double iron.

I'm glad there are some people watching the videos. I think there's as much value in them for people who just want to spend a couple of hours bringing an old plane back vs. the considerable cost involved with sourcing irons and wood and building from scratch.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#41

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

Chuck Bjorgen

You're beating yourself up pretty harshly for what you are calling a too large mouth on this plane. I'm a bit puzzled by this because one of the supposed virtues of the close set cap iron is that you don't really need a tight mouth...at least on a Stanley. Naturally my small assortment of vintage woodies all have relatively open mouths through use over the years. Does this concept work differently on wood planes vs. a Stanley type plane?

I did some testing on my 16-inch wood jack plane and, yup, the iron would wobble a bit when placed on a flat surface. I'm wondering if these double iron cutters all had to be individually fitted to each wood body or were these pretty much mass produced under the concept of interchangeable parts?

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#42

Fit of the double iron:  observation and question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Chuck, David, and all,

I have an observation, but will put it in the form of a question. First, the observation: I have a Mathieson 17" jack/fore plane. It has a double iron blade set, all original, as is the wedge and plane. The iron and the cap iron are not flush with each other: the cap iron is arched over the iron, and it takes multiple screw turns until you make the cap iron 'bottom out' against the iron. I don't do that--I leave a little air between the two, so that the cap iron is exerting lots of pressure on the blade tip, but the two pieces together form a very stiff spring.

Now. You put the wedge and blade set into the body of the plane, and the blade set is 'sprung' in the body. It is not a zero-tolerance fit; due to the spring of the cap iron and cap, the wedge will engage with finger pressure, and can be driven a little further by hammer taps. Thus, there is a little 'tolerance' in the fit of the blade set and wedge to the plane throat.

That's the observation from my one plane. Now the question: Is this typical of vintage cap iron/iron fits? Are the two pieces sprung against each other, with the cap iron fairly strong arched relative to the iron. I have more modern double iron blade sets--any LN for example--and the cap iron ends up flush against the iron, and exerting relatively little pressure or tensioning on the iron. [Of course, the lever cap on the LN provides additional pressure and makes the blade set fit the plane.]

So what about it. On your double iron woodies, is the blade set sprung in the throat, alleviating the need for zero-tolerance fitting with the wedge? Incidentally, Japanese planes feature this effect--the iron is slightly curved by 2 or 3 thousandths along its length, so that when fit, it is sprung in the abutments, so that you need a close fit, in the low thousandths, but not dead zeroed though practitioners shoot for that.

Wiley

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#43

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P

david weaver

Yeah, the disappointment with the mouth is a cosmetic issue - disappointing only because it's not what I was aiming to do. From a functional standpoint, it's no problem at all. It eliminated any of the fitting problems I've had before when I cut the mouth at zero intentionally and then floated it open until I had a good feed. I think I probably said it in the video that that has been my general MO, which is safe, but floating a mouth open evenly is a lot of work. because you have to clean up around the abutments then, too, and it's easy to get carried away with the work and ruin some angles.

I've had planes where the abutments were cut straight through, which leaves a mouth of a quarter inch or a little more. And they worked fine. The only possible problem with a mouth like that is that if it gets twice that size, it can be easy to catch it on the end of boards if you don't discipline yourself to keep the nose of the plane flat on the work at the start of the stroke.

I just expect that at plane #8 or #9, I'm not going to get a plane that's just good working, but that all of the aesthetics are right, too. Everyone has their irks, and attempting to do one thing and then having the result be different is one of mine.

Once I get a handle sunk in the body, it will be clear just how capable the plane is, though.

As far as the iron goes, I didn't know it was warped when I started the video, and I could've grabbed another one, but that would've been a copout. I also could've built another plane body with a tight mouth and pretended it was the first one, but I think that kind of stuff is unrealistic for the average person and the point in the end will be how well the plane works despite those things.

Judging by the beds on my old planes, I don't think the bed was worked on a lot of them. On the griffiths plane in the background, everything is super tight and the iron is a ward marked iron, and it is perfect in every way. The cap iron gives the maker a little bit of wiggle room, too. Poor bedding but a tight wedge would probably only manifest itself in not adjusting as evenly as you'd want, but the iron itself in those old planes is always going to bed on a flat surface because they are very concave and the bevel sits on the bed at the bottom of the mouth. It's just (dealing with an iron that's not perfect) one of the things that folks may come by when they're making a plane.

I'll do a postmortem at the end of the series after I get the handle sunk this weekend and use the plane for some heavy work. That way, when Chris gets it, it'll be dirty :). I think one of the points I'd like to make is that none of my planes have turned out perfect, but all have been better working than any plane I bought used. That suggests that some of the fitting steps could be applied to old planes (most notably, refitting or remaking wedges and refurbishing the cap irons and cleaning any accumulated crust out of the wear).

All of the shortcomings the planes of this type have were in my mind, and the things that larry talks about in posts and on his page in terms of design flaws ouf double iron planes (limiting shaving width, creating traps by design, etc) are just not true for a properly made plane. They only occur in a finished or refurbished plane if you don't know how the plane is supposed to be made. Most planes were made properly enough to function well, they just have signs of age after 150+ years. Planes that I have that would be considered cheaply made in the US have worked fine after not too much attention, certainly a lot less than rebuilding a plane. They are suitable for everyone who can touch up the fits and set a double iron (which is everyone in my mind).

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#44

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

david weaver

Wiley, I tighten the cap iron and iron together as far as the screw will allow me to, but not because of the fit. I do it because it prevents the iron and cap iron moving relative to each other, so I can set the cap iron once and adjust the plane a lot and never lose the cap iron set. Your observation that they are sprung is correct, they don't fit together flush. Every single one I've ever used is sprung, and the mujingfang continentals and emmerich planes with wedges kept this sprung design.

It does flex the iron and make the iron look very curved on a lot of planes when the whole setup is tightened the whole way, but the bias is in favor of the bed since the area behind the bevel the low point and that is what you want to touch with the most pressure by the mouth, anyway.

There still remains a lot of the sprung feel even with the cap iron tightened all the way on, and you are not required to have a perfect bedded fit like you would be if you had a totally flat tapered single iron plane that had no hollow in the back. To my knowledge, nobody is making an iron like that these days, which is a shame. I'd imagine they were smithed that way so that a flat plane bed could be cut and the planemaker would have a good fit, and without the maker of the irons trying to make things perfectly flat. Adjustment is another thing - the sprung cap iron makes it so that the plane is sometimes reluctant to adjust finely on a heavy plane, but that's easily overcome by using a metal hammer that is smooth and has a convex face - which seems to send the adjustment message straight to the plane. I know you must have many (japanese) hammers that would fit the description. they don't really mark the plane much, they just burnish the end grain a little.

I'm sort of into territory of not addressing things you asked about, but the iron thing and cap iron I think is useful. It's unsettling at first to see how far the cap iron will bend the iron under full tension, but it's perfectly fine in the plane.

As far as standardization of all of this discussion, I don't know how much there is. I only have about 3 dozen irons and I cut up most of my old planes because they were basket cases with good irons. So I have 5 subject planes left, and some of them have aspects that are not the same. The griffiths plane bed is perfectly flat, perhaps it was machine cut and just finished for cosmetics. I have another american plane, the maker I cannot recall, and it has the bed flat across at the bottom, but it is convex at the top (so that the iron more or less beds at three points instead of four). I've been trying to get an even bed at four points, top left, top right and bottom left and right...I'm getting into the weeds here, I'll put that in a video.

Also, as to the cap iron and iron sets that are made now as "improved" that have lost that spring because they are just cut out on a surface grinder, I don't think they're improved at all. The feel of lie nielsen's "improved" cap iron is inferior to the feel of a stanley plane locked down. If lie nielsen wanted to improve the cap iron some, they should have just made a slightly heavier version of the sprung stanley type. Same with current wood plane cap irons, they are not an improvement, they are a convenience for current makers. the old ones were superior for an experienced user.

Whatever you do, if your plane is set up well, it should adjust nicely, keep its set, not chatter, and literally stop you in your tracks with a deep shaving before it gives up its good characteristics (the old adage that a plane will chatter with thick shavings is not true).

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#45

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

Every vintage cap iron I have is sprung in the way you describe, but the amount of spring can vary by a lot, and the ones I like the most have a pretty small amount of spring. If I get one with a lot of spring, I reduce it by grinding a 1/16" or so off the front of the cap iron (which also involves reshaping the profile a little).

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#46

Re: the balk..

TomD

Sorry those are Beech. There is some cherry in those woods. They just cut it for firewood, I offered to pay a little more but he figured it was OK to pay what he would normally get. The beech in this areas is pretty nice, I guess they didn't cut it for anything. I have family in the area, and did give passing thought to moving there slaughtering some beech and starting a plane a bench business, but not exactly a digital, efficient, 21 st century thing. Even for a retirement project.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#47

Re: the balk..

david weaver

I replied too fast. I should've waited for the picture!!

Southern ohio has a lot of nice american beech, but nobody likes to do anything with 16/4 stuff (I guess because of the kiln time and chance it will crack), and the 8/4 and lower thickness has a limited use because nobody makes anything of it.

That leaves horizon for 16/4, and I don't know if they have any right now. Figure it was 16 bucks a board foot for me to have it shipped here, it would be well worth trying to split, then saw and air dry a bunch.

I don't envy anyone who wants to make planes for money trying to find the wood and the irons/cap irons.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#48

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My feeling is that the wedging action is what sets beech apart from other plane woods. I just seems to have the right amount of hardness and sponginess to make the adjustment work nicely.

Even though the iron is somewhat flexed and somewhat springy, I think most of the wedging action is taken up by the beech wedge. And for the action to work well the wedge has to be very nicely fitted. If it is too tight on one side or too tight near the top or near the bottom, it just will not work well. As an example, if the wedge is just a little tighter on one side, when you hit the plane to make the iron retract a small amount, it will end up a little crooked. Knowing where to make an adjustment of the wedge is part analysis, part intuition.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#49

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

TomD

Picking up on David, and Warren. Beech took almost no time to dry. U have never seen a wood that dried that fast. I didn't have a place for the 7 foot bench balk I had cut, just in case I get another bench idea, and should have a place to put it. The balk was standing like a visitor in various places in my shop. One day less than a year into it's visit a went to move it, and it was weightless compared to it's usual weight, it was dry 16/4 7 feet by something, under a year. Not saying it is perfectly seasoned for a bench at that time, but it isn't any lighter today, maybe 4 years total. I also lost a few pieces early in the process when something I did caused a crack, but it happened way faster than it normally would. At first I thought the whole process was doomed, but no, it was just the accelerated drying was initially a problem, but it also went through that phase when one looses things, and when that was over it just sped to the finish line.

So as to David, they may well not like drying it, but it sure does happen fast. To Warren you are right about the whole spring thing. It may or not be mostly in the wedge, but when used as a wood for Japanese planes, where the wedge is steel, one might wish it was a little bit heavier/stronger, but it does have the bite where it holds onto wedged things, or maybe spring is a better word for it. However, C&W, and probably others, have said the wood is uniquely transparent to water, and equally tempered as regards moisture gain or loss, and that would seen possible as an asset also.

Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron Plan

#50

Re: Fit of the double iron:  observation and quest

david weaver

I think I read somewhere that the kiln schedule for beech is some large multiple at 16/4 of what it is at 4/4 or 8/4, and thus probably the drying nuisance. Given the way it cracks, and how you describe its loss of water, maybe it's that it dries too fast?

Steve (Voigt) and I have each gotten some kiln dried beech from the same place, and he warned me a couple of months ago that despite the wood being kiln dried, that a cold shot of winter dry air was making the wood on his piles start to check on the ends.

I went down to look at my billets and the exact same thing was occurring with mine. it's got bad behavior as far as moisture goes (at least when it comes to checking and cracking)!!

I wish I had some around here to air dry, I'd like to see how it works air dry. The dreamiest wood I ever worked was air dried apple, and I don't know if the difference is due to the drying or the tree, but the apple that I have (I used it in a couple of saw handles) worked as if it was infused with wax. You could rasp it back into the grain and never any grain separated past the line where you were rasping. I've got other apple that is kiln dried, and it's harsh and musical whereas the air dried stuff (that I had to air dry, it came soaking wet fresh from the tree) was a lot more "dead" (as warren describes it) and much nicer to work.