Re: Making a Video Series - Making a Double Iron P
david weaver
Yeah, the disappointment with the mouth is a cosmetic issue - disappointing only because it's not what I was aiming to do. From a functional standpoint, it's no problem at all. It eliminated any of the fitting problems I've had before when I cut the mouth at zero intentionally and then floated it open until I had a good feed. I think I probably said it in the video that that has been my general MO, which is safe, but floating a mouth open evenly is a lot of work. because you have to clean up around the abutments then, too, and it's easy to get carried away with the work and ruin some angles.
I've had planes where the abutments were cut straight through, which leaves a mouth of a quarter inch or a little more. And they worked fine. The only possible problem with a mouth like that is that if it gets twice that size, it can be easy to catch it on the end of boards if you don't discipline yourself to keep the nose of the plane flat on the work at the start of the stroke.
I just expect that at plane #8 or #9, I'm not going to get a plane that's just good working, but that all of the aesthetics are right, too. Everyone has their irks, and attempting to do one thing and then having the result be different is one of mine.
Once I get a handle sunk in the body, it will be clear just how capable the plane is, though.
As far as the iron goes, I didn't know it was warped when I started the video, and I could've grabbed another one, but that would've been a copout. I also could've built another plane body with a tight mouth and pretended it was the first one, but I think that kind of stuff is unrealistic for the average person and the point in the end will be how well the plane works despite those things.
Judging by the beds on my old planes, I don't think the bed was worked on a lot of them. On the griffiths plane in the background, everything is super tight and the iron is a ward marked iron, and it is perfect in every way. The cap iron gives the maker a little bit of wiggle room, too. Poor bedding but a tight wedge would probably only manifest itself in not adjusting as evenly as you'd want, but the iron itself in those old planes is always going to bed on a flat surface because they are very concave and the bevel sits on the bed at the bottom of the mouth. It's just (dealing with an iron that's not perfect) one of the things that folks may come by when they're making a plane.
I'll do a postmortem at the end of the series after I get the handle sunk this weekend and use the plane for some heavy work. That way, when Chris gets it, it'll be dirty
. I think one of the points I'd like to make is that none of my planes have turned out perfect, but all have been better working than any plane I bought used. That suggests that some of the fitting steps could be applied to old planes (most notably, refitting or remaking wedges and refurbishing the cap irons and cleaning any accumulated crust out of the wear).
All of the shortcomings the planes of this type have were in my mind, and the things that larry talks about in posts and on his page in terms of design flaws ouf double iron planes (limiting shaving width, creating traps by design, etc) are just not true for a properly made plane. They only occur in a finished or refurbished plane if you don't know how the plane is supposed to be made. Most planes were made properly enough to function well, they just have signs of age after 150+ years. Planes that I have that would be considered cheaply made in the US have worked fine after not too much attention, certainly a lot less than rebuilding a plane. They are suitable for everyone who can touch up the fits and set a double iron (which is everyone in my mind).