Relaxation = recrystallization?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi David and all,
Bob's book suggestion sounds great! I want to go back to Verhoeven's book for a moment--he is a scholar who worked closely with smiths, esp. knife makers. Has publications assisted by knife makers on true Damascus 'wootz' steel, for instance. As well as high-powered metallurgical texts.
One of the ways steel is magic is the way it forms new crystals (grains). I didn't understand this until reading Verhoeven, though it may be common knowledge to others. Warren talked about the transformation of room temperature body-centered-cubic (bcc) pearlite/cementite to face-centered-cubic (ccc) austenite at critical temperature, and then back again after quench to body-centered tetragonal (bct) martensite. The martensite would like to be bcc, but the trapped carbon in the lattice forces it tetragonal, and the more carbon the more tetragonal--this is where the rigidity comes from.
Anyway, what I didn't understand was that these phase transformations are not just spatial rearrangements that the atoms make. No, an entire new set of crystals (grains) are formed upon each phase transformation. The new crystals 'nucleate' at points of strain in the lattice, along the boundaries of the old crystals, or especially at points of dislocation in the lattice caused by deformation (e.g., hammering). From these nuclei, or seeding points, the new crystals build, eating up the old crystals until they hit an adjacent grain. It's like polymerization, except that these are crystals forming anew, and in a different lattice structure (bct martensite, say, instead of fcc austenite). And the more seed points there are, the denser the nucleation, the smaller the size of the new crop of crystals formed.
Smiths can take advantage of the willingness of steel to form all-new crystals under specific conditions of heat and or deformation.
In Verhoeven's Chapter 8 of this book,
http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf
he describes two techniques for grain-size reduction--phase transformation and recrystallization. Phase transformation just involves austenitizing above critical temperature, followed by quenching--and subject to careful heat management. Recrystallization involves either cold work (below critical temp) or hot work (actually in the austenite phase). in p. 68 of the online text, he begins the section 'New Grains formed by Phase Transformation'; on p. 70 begins 'New Grains formed by Recrystallization'. In both cases, the new grains will be smaller than the old grains, and can be kept that way by heat management , for example, austenitizing at the lowest practical temperature for a short time.
To get to your point about 'relaxation', I think you may be referring to what Verhoeven calls 'recrystallization'. There are two modes: static recrystallization where cold work (rolling or hammering) is done below critical temp., and dynamic recrystallization above critical. Starting on p. 76 in the section 'Summary of Major Ideas in Chap. 8, Verhoeven states as follows:
"5. In a steel, the grain size may be dramatically reduced by a cyclic heat treatment where the temperature cycles above the Ac3 (and/or the Ac1) and below the Ar1 values. With each heating ramp a whole new set of austenite grains form and in each cooling ramp a new set of ferrite/pearlite grains form. The reduction in grain size is enhanced by using rapid heating and cooling rates such as is possible with salt pot quenching, It is also enhanced by keeping the maximum temperature as low as possible. Ultrafine steel grain sizes are easily obtained, compare the data of Table 8.2 to Table 8.1.
6. A new set of grains may also be formed by the process of recrystallization. The steel must be fairly heavily deformed and then heated. The deformation introduces defects (planes of atoms displaced from their low energy positions) into the grains which raises their energy level. Subsequent heating produces a new set of defect free grains because they have a lower energy content. The new strain free grains form at a temperature called the recrystallization temperature. The recrystallization temperature depends on the amount of prior deformation for steel as shown on Fig. 8.7.
7. When forging austenite at high temperatures, recrystallization often occurs during forging as the metal is deformed in the forging dies. The process is called dynamic recrystallization. The defects which form in steel grains on deformation cause the grains to become harder, stronger and brittle. The new strain free grains formed in recrystallization are softer and ductile. Hence, dynamic recrystallization allows the austenite to be deformed large amounts without becoming brittle, and at the same time refines grain size. "
NOTE: The static recrystallization occurs at temperatures lower than critical, but this is a function of the steel, the carbon content, the amount of deformation, the rate of heating, and probably some other stuff--and must be arrived at by trial and error. Practical smiths, western and eastern, could have figured this out, as well as dynamic recrystallization, by trial and error. Just as they figured out steelmaking in the first place.
____
Now, you mentioned that George said that all benefit of hammering is lost once the steel goes above critical temperature. It may be he was referring to the benefits of work hardening. Given correct heat management, Verhoeven says you could still preserve grain size reduction, even though work hardening has been lost due to the 'relaxation' of stresses in the steel.
FWIW,
Wiley