New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Mounting a chisel handle

Posts

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#76

Re: I agree on the packing...

david weaver

....it's the grain structure changes that I'm not too sure of, though.

Packing, as I understand it, is something that occurs after the heat treat when metal is cold, or at a temperature below the tempering level.

It's a term I remember hearing in a materials science course about packing, but it was in a different context than tool making, and I think it's only something that could be reasonably done with HSS or some other tool with a high temper temperature.

It's the relaxing or subcritical tempering or whatever it may be called that confuses me, which leads to what wiley mentioned - that the grain structure before any heating occurs needs to be proper or you get garbage in, garbage out.

It seems to me that the classic blacksmiths worked even when forging at as low of a temperature as possible to avoid overheating the steel (which also feeds into wiley's description of keeping the grain structure unharmed as much as possible).

I have no trouble believing that even if the chemical composition of a chinese piece of tool steel is the same as austrian, that the treatment of the metal before you get it could lead to the austrian being superior (actually, I knew a supplier at one point who gave me a tour of their tool steel operation and showed me sheets of austrian steel that looked like large plywood sheets, they cut them down to stock that looks like what we buy from industrial supply. I'm sure it was more expensive, but he said some of their customers -those being professional customers, they didn't sell to individuals - demand and will pay extra for it. Maybe they were diemakers or something, I don't know. The conversation didn't go that far.)

Anyway, it's the process before the quenching and tempering that I'm curious about, the effect of packing is lost when steel is heat treated as far as I understand.

It's entirely possible, though, that die forged steel is every bit as good or better on a sample to sample basis than steel that is hand hammered. Razors are die forged and they are *awfully* good steel.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#77

Book suggestion

Bob Hackett

Larson`s book Tool making for Woodworkers would go a long way toward shedding light on the mysteries of steel in relationship to wood. He talks about the process of packing in his book.

Packing has more to do with working at a lower than forging heat and mechanically manipulating (some would say aligning) the grain structure of the tool in the edge area.Stone masons also used this technique to add toughness to the chisels they called "fire sharps" as the edges were both formed and roughly sharpened during forging and then packing. The claim there was that packing made the edge more dense, durable and resistant to abrasion.

The cold forming of a working edge might be better illustrated in a scythe. Many who used these tools extensively brought both a small anvil which could be pounded into the top of a fence post and a hammer to thin and reform the edge as needed. In this case the increased durability came about through work hardening the steel at the edge.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#78

Re: Book suggestion

david weaver

We're on the same page. I may not have communicated it that well.

The only person I've seen talk about practical packing is George Wilson, who mentioned that he had carving tools that lacked toughness or some performance aspect.

I can't recall for sure if he heated them, but I think he said he did heat them (they are ideal because the temper doesn't get affected until they are heated to a high temperature, and even if you do affect it a little, you have to go higher yet to ruin it for use). He mentioned hammering it.

I said something about packing to him (from recollection of a materials science course) and he advised me that all benefit from it is lost if you heat to critical temperature (which you will have to do if you heat past temper temperature).

It's easier for stone masons because their tools are not the hardness that our tools are (nor are cold chisels), and they are less brittle and tolerate some hammering.

As an aside, the peining of the edge of the scythe may be similar to this, except that is also thinned. I didn't grasp at first why people would say their edges would get to a point from stoning that they were no good and they needed to be peined, but some of it may have to do with toughness from packing, and others from thinning.

The relaxation that I'm talking about is entirely different from packing, it is something to refine grain structure before final hardening, but nobody is telling us all of the secrets.

(I was kind of disappointed to hear that packing the grain is lost if the metal gets above critical temperature, early on I thought maybe I could improve some thing I was going to harden by hammering it first, and that may be true, but it won't be true due to packing.).

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#79

Join a bladesmith forum

Bob Hackett

You`ll find a ton of info on all aspects of this sort of work there.

One of the best insights I got when I started metal working was that just because you`re using W1 doesn`t mean that water (or brine) is the only thing you are allowed to quench it in. It also helps more than you might suspect if you control the temp of the quench, especially with thin cross sections.

One of the important phases of tool making, especially for relatively thin or complex tools, that should be addressed between forging and heat treating (hardening, tempering, annealing and normalizing are all forms of heat treating) is normalizing. I havent heard anyone talk about this since Todd Hughes stopped posting here. Normalizing will go a long way to eliminate things like warping, cracking and spalling during quenching.

PS- I`d steer clear of the blacksmiths, they`re a rough bunch. :D

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#80

Re: Book suggestion

Bob Hackett

As you are well aware, all steel is not created equal. You`re aware of this because your nature is to look deeply into the research end of things that catch your attention. I know this from years of reading your posts. I responded because I thought it might spark an enjoyable discussion about the nature of metal as applied to WWing and it has. Thanks for the thoughtful reply.

One of the things I most enjoy about reading your take on most things David is your ability to research in depth yet keep at least one foot out of the box when approaching your projects. I replied in part to shake the rust off my own ability to recall and apply what I think I know as well as to give you a gentle nudge toward keeping your mind open to possibilities besides those that are delivered in boxes.

If you are using known types of steel from reliable sources Crucible Steel`s website is the go to site for info on things like temps, times, quenchants and all other related info that is most likely to bring success in metal working.

I look forward to hearing more about your explorations into metalworking.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#81

Relaxation = recrystallization?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Bob's book suggestion sounds great! I want to go back to Verhoeven's book for a moment--he is a scholar who worked closely with smiths, esp. knife makers. Has publications assisted by knife makers on true Damascus 'wootz' steel, for instance. As well as high-powered metallurgical texts.

One of the ways steel is magic is the way it forms new crystals (grains). I didn't understand this until reading Verhoeven, though it may be common knowledge to others. Warren talked about the transformation of room temperature body-centered-cubic (bcc) pearlite/cementite to face-centered-cubic (ccc) austenite at critical temperature, and then back again after quench to body-centered tetragonal (bct) martensite. The martensite would like to be bcc, but the trapped carbon in the lattice forces it tetragonal, and the more carbon the more tetragonal--this is where the rigidity comes from.

Anyway, what I didn't understand was that these phase transformations are not just spatial rearrangements that the atoms make. No, an entire new set of crystals (grains) are formed upon each phase transformation. The new crystals 'nucleate' at points of strain in the lattice, along the boundaries of the old crystals, or especially at points of dislocation in the lattice caused by deformation (e.g., hammering). From these nuclei, or seeding points, the new crystals build, eating up the old crystals until they hit an adjacent grain. It's like polymerization, except that these are crystals forming anew, and in a different lattice structure (bct martensite, say, instead of fcc austenite). And the more seed points there are, the denser the nucleation, the smaller the size of the new crop of crystals formed.

Smiths can take advantage of the willingness of steel to form all-new crystals under specific conditions of heat and or deformation.

In Verhoeven's Chapter 8 of this book,

http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf

he describes two techniques for grain-size reduction--phase transformation and recrystallization. Phase transformation just involves austenitizing above critical temperature, followed by quenching--and subject to careful heat management. Recrystallization involves either cold work (below critical temp) or hot work (actually in the austenite phase). in p. 68 of the online text, he begins the section 'New Grains formed by Phase Transformation'; on p. 70 begins 'New Grains formed by Recrystallization'. In both cases, the new grains will be smaller than the old grains, and can be kept that way by heat management , for example, austenitizing at the lowest practical temperature for a short time.

To get to your point about 'relaxation', I think you may be referring to what Verhoeven calls 'recrystallization'. There are two modes: static recrystallization where cold work (rolling or hammering) is done below critical temp., and dynamic recrystallization above critical. Starting on p. 76 in the section 'Summary of Major Ideas in Chap. 8, Verhoeven states as follows:

"5. In a steel, the grain size may be dramatically reduced by a cyclic heat treatment where the temperature cycles above the Ac3 (and/or the Ac1) and below the Ar1 values. With each heating ramp a whole new set of austenite grains form and in each cooling ramp a new set of ferrite/pearlite grains form. The reduction in grain size is enhanced by using rapid heating and cooling rates such as is possible with salt pot quenching, It is also enhanced by keeping the maximum temperature as low as possible. Ultrafine steel grain sizes are easily obtained, compare the data of Table 8.2 to Table 8.1.

6. A new set of grains may also be formed by the process of recrystallization. The steel must be fairly heavily deformed and then heated. The deformation introduces defects (planes of atoms displaced from their low energy positions) into the grains which raises their energy level. Subsequent heating produces a new set of defect free grains because they have a lower energy content. The new strain free grains form at a temperature called the recrystallization temperature. The recrystallization temperature depends on the amount of prior deformation for steel as shown on Fig. 8.7.

7. When forging austenite at high temperatures, recrystallization often occurs during forging as the metal is deformed in the forging dies. The process is called dynamic recrystallization. The defects which form in steel grains on deformation cause the grains to become harder, stronger and brittle. The new strain free grains formed in recrystallization are softer and ductile. Hence, dynamic recrystallization allows the austenite to be deformed large amounts without becoming brittle, and at the same time refines grain size. "

NOTE: The static recrystallization occurs at temperatures lower than critical, but this is a function of the steel, the carbon content, the amount of deformation, the rate of heating, and probably some other stuff--and must be arrived at by trial and error. Practical smiths, western and eastern, could have figured this out, as well as dynamic recrystallization, by trial and error. Just as they figured out steelmaking in the first place.

____

Now, you mentioned that George said that all benefit of hammering is lost once the steel goes above critical temperature. It may be he was referring to the benefits of work hardening. Given correct heat management, Verhoeven says you could still preserve grain size reduction, even though work hardening has been lost due to the 'relaxation' of stresses in the steel.

FWIW,

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#82

Re: Book suggestion

david weaver

Bob, I appreciate the discussion even if I think I know what i'm talking about, and I see your suggestion below about blade forums and the books, and will take up the book suggestion and try to find the smiting discussions on blade forums.

I sure wish Todd was still around and posting!!

Wiley's references look like something I want to read, too. Maybe I can get a little better understanding of the stuff from the point of view of those books and not be so lost in the weeds in these discussions.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#83

Re: You know, I read your post so quickly..

david weaver

...that I didn't even notice the scythe part. I must've been in an extreme hurry when I read it at first, otherwise I wouldn't have mentioned scythes!!

Apologies for that!

(on the flip side, at least we're thinking of the same things)

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#84

Re: Relaxation = recrystallization?

david weaver

Thanks for the thoughtful reply, Wiley.

I'm not sure if I know enough to know what the relaxation might be doing, but I get the sense that it's subcritical (though I don't know for sure if it is).

I think I have some reading to do to learn more, because being curious and confused isn't a state that it's fun to spend much time in.

When George mentions that his packing work is lost if the tool is reheated, I'm not sure which property he's valuing at that point. I know he mentioned that his objective was toughness, but that may not be the only thing he was thinking about.

What still sticks out in my mind is the difference between the run of the mill chisels and the ouchis and such of the world, despite the same raw materials. They are all hammering and forge welding the same or similar materials together, but with such different results if the objective is for a chisel that chips as little as possible. It's probably something I'm not going to figure out, but I appreciate yours and Bob's suggestions for books - it's a topic that we pass over (I guess because really, anything even mediocre is perfectly good for doing fine work as long as the brain of the person doing the work is set to the fine work).

I hassled george for a while about chisels when I was on a binge, and he said "everything I did, I made with a vintage set of marples chisels. They tested at hardness 60 and were good enough for everything I needed to do" (that belies the fact that he has hundreds of carving tools and no shortage of things like paring chisels - he does have the tool bug despite not necessarily having it in areas that a beginner may have it).

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#85

Re: Relaxation = recrystallization?

Steve Voigt

Wow Wiley, thanks for the concentrated blast of info! It's going to take me a few passes through the Verhoeven book, I think, to really get the implications, but it should be well worth it, even if only for intellectual gratification.

One question based on your understanding so far: Is a traditional (western or japanese) smith essentially doing static recrystalization, dynamic recrystalization, or both?

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#86

Limited attempt to answer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve and all,

There are a few demonstrations of forging by various smiths on Youtube. Sometimes they demonstrate forging using hammers only, with a helper wielding the large sledge (Japan Woodworker used to show the smith's wife wielding the hammer--a publicity shot if ever there was one). More typical is the use of power hammers, especially spring hammers. These public videos tend to leave out the crucial elements which would permit you to do what they do. In general, the Japanese smiths consider the exact details of what they do part of their intellectual capital (for lack of a better term) and you won't find out about it. Their close associates who do know tend to keep it to themselves in order to preserve their friendship or working relationship with the smith.

With that caveat, we know a few things. I came across a website at

http://www.bladesmithforum.com . Some of these guys are forging Japanese style swords, using Japanese style techniques, such as fuigo bellows blowing a charcoal fire, and combinations of hand hammers and spring hammers.

Here is a video from that site, showing part of the forging of a sword, using a fuigo, charcoal fire, and a spring hammer (go to second video, 5 min 10 sec):

http://www.bladesmithsforum.com/index.php?showtopic=23168&p=230460

It looks to me like the smith is above and below critical at different points, which if so would mean he's using static and dynamic processes--perhaps the terms become meaningless in practice. As I understand Verhoeven, he's reducing grain size as he goes through the heats, hammering all the way, with a further reduction to occur upon quench. I'm not sure whether this is his sword steel, to be differentially tempered to form a hamon, or whether he is forming a core, to which he will laminate cutting steel as an outer envelope.

This thread is about the build and initial use of a spring hammer. Fellow named Dan O'Connor from Texas, at this site

http://www.katanabuilders.com/katanablog/

is the man who performs and describes the build. The first video in the above link, approx. 9 minutes long, shows the build.

Wish I could provide a better answer, but I really don't know what the old-tyme western smiths or traditional Japanese smiths actually do. Perhaps one of the other folks can help....

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#87

Composition

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The other huge variable in this discussion is composition. Lee Valley got to the same place, or better, in performance with out forging. It may be that with ancient steel one needed the mumbo jumbo of the forging process to get performance. It would seem that now days one can more reliably obtain superior performance with composition (alloying) and processing (particle technology) and precise heat treating.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#88

Re: Composition

Steve Voigt

What you call "mumbo jumbo," I call art and craftsmanship.

I don't have enough experience with "wonder" steels to have an informed opinion on them. But I am struck by the number of people I know of, and I'm talking about hard core, skilled hand tool users who use their chisels a LOT, who all come to the conclusion that their Koyamaichis blow all the premium, modern chisels out of the water. I've seen it too many times to call it coincidence.

The Koyamaichis are not a product of "composition and processing." They are made of dirt-simple steel that has been forged. Maybe there's still a place for mumbo jumbo after all.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#89

Re: Composition

david weaver

I'm not what one would call a "skilled" hand tool user, but I'm an avid fan of plain carbon steel for everything. There's some work yet to be done with modern process, and that's to make modern process hold an edge as well as something like a japanese tool and sharpen as well, too.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#90

Re: Limited attempt to answer

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

Thanks for the answer and the links. That makes sense. Pretty much all the forging I've ever seen looks like that, starting at orange (ish) and continuing until the glow is almost gone.

That guy Dan is insane, and inspiring. How about that spring hammer?!? I've built machinery, but not the kind that involves pouring 4500 pounds of concrete!

It was also really interesting to look at his forge. The box bellows are amazing! I also have a charcoal forge, though mine is tiny. Ron Hock's web page on heat treating talks about how charcoal helps avoid decarb by absorbing oxygen better than other fuels…but what I didn't know was that Japanese side-draft forges are (according to Dan) designed differently…the blast is directed at a slight down-angle to keep from blowing air right at the workpiece. Interesting…

Anyway, I've got some 1/2" W1 square bar, so clearly some experimentation is in order. This thread has given me a lot to think about.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#91

Re: Composition

wilbur

Mumbo jumbo? I fail to see why a skill that craftsmen were able to obtain back in the day should be referred to as mumbo jumbo. That description is completely unwarranted.

The processing of high carbon steels to obtain a tool that could be sharpened to a high degree with a durable edge was a mature process many hundreds of years ago. Take a look at this Japanese dagger. It passes any sort of test you would care to have in an edged weapon. This dagger was made in the 1300’s.


There are plenty of western examples of this as well. I just don’t happen to have photos of western swords.

As far as the alleged superiority of modern powdered metal technology over high carbon steel made with mumbo jumbo, consider the following excerpts from tool reviews of PM-V11 chisels:

Chris Gouchnor, in Fine Woodworking:

In the end, in terms of edge retention and performance, the PM-V11 chisel ranked second only to the high-end Japanese chisel, which is comparably priced.

And from Derek Cohen:

With the 3/4" chisel on the pin board, both the PM-V11 and the White Steel were able to do most of both sides. 22 1/2" (out of 31 1/2") of pin length for the PM-V11 and 27 1/2" of pin length for the White Steel.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#92

reply

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sorry I provided offense with the term mumbo jumbo. I use it to describe complex operations I don't understand, be it detecting the Higgs particle or Japanese forging.

That said, you made my point. One can arrive at properties for some applications by using a steel lightly alloyed, ( the alloying elements Si and Mn in the "white steel" are there in precisely controlled amounts for a purpose) coupled with physical alteration of the steel. Or, one can arrive at an equivalent, or superior place (PMV11 is not the most robust chisel steel) by altering the chemical composition without the complex physical alteration (mumbo jumbo).

To repeat my point, in talking about steel properties one can not ignore the effects of chemical composition, be it on grain size or whatever.

The alluded to difference in steel properties between this historical mill and that could as easily be a result of tiny differences in ore composition as in processing.

As I understand it modern steel knives are relegated to a special category in knife competitions because forged knives are not competitive. This apparent fact is not to detract from the accomplishments of some Japanese forge in 1720, or 2014. But in 2014 if you want to play Rambo you may be more competitive with a M4 knife, a product of understanding composition more than proprietary mumbo jumbo processing, high tech or otherwise.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#93

Re: Competitions Vs. Actual Use

david weaver

I don't know anything about knife or plane competitions, nor chisel competitions or anything of the like. Unless someone is boning elephants, I don't see how they represent reality.

the reality for me as I get further along into hand tool woodworking is that I much prefer steel that sharpens on a single stone. I've fiddled with leather and MDF coated green hones, and they do create a slightly keener edge, but at the cost of time and fiddling.

As we type this, the japanese chisels that exhibit the properties discussed are about $55 per. They're probably white II, and nothing special with the backing metal.

Koyamaichi's (courtesy of the favorable exchange rate) average about $50 each. If someone has issues with the handles, they're an easily replaced tang type.

I'm just not seeing it with the wondersteel chisels (and I cut the waste on the HBs with a chisel made of HAP40 just to play with it. It's a tough chisel, but offers no functional advantage over a $10 vintage buck brothers chisel unless one is chiseling nails, or if as is the case for beginners, the chisel is being abused and sharpening is a dreaded task).

Same with the knives. There are a lot of videos with people sitting in apartments using the terms "I need" and "Can't live with" for new vs old steel knives, talking about how many pieces of rope they can cut through and banging their knives into 2x4s. I don't know if they slice vegetables much, or open packages (or castrate animals, whatever the task may be), but I've got a couple of knives in wondersteel (including D2), and the knife I carry in my pocket every day is a standard chrome vanadium case stockman. It rusts, but that's OK. I use it on enough stuff and touch it up often enough that it's not going to turn into a pile of rust.

I have never seen any knife in the kitchen that is better than a run of the mill japanese knife with VG10 or Blue #2 (pick your poison if it's to rust). I'm sure there are harder knives, but the trade off in use in terms of sharpening just isn't there. Admittedly, those two types of rikizai knives (made from material that's laminated at the mill) are far better than the german knives in edge holding, but they are also just as cheap.

All of the wondersteel stuff is market making, and usually at a higher cost than the equivalent properly made tool. But it doesn't move the needle in woodworking, cooking, or pretty much anything - especially if someone knows how to sharpen.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#94

Agree on the knives, disagree on chisels...

John in NM

With knives, kitchen knives in particular, I vastly prefer regular old carbon steel. Dry it when done washing and rust is simply not a problem. Sharpens fast and effectively and holds the edge a long time.

With chisels I think there is definitely a place for engineered steels - whether they be engineered through forging methods or metallurgy. My preference is to not spend much time sharpening them - so one can either sharpen cheapies on a belt grinder often, or sharpen much better blades less frequently.

For the most part though, I've found that there is a distinct point of "good enough" with chisels. My "good enough" threshold will naturally be different than many others'.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#95

Re: Place vs. need..

david weaver

Sure, there's a place for everything, but that's different than a need.

I don't even necessarily need carbon steel knives. VG10 is stainless, fine grained, but is not a wondersteel otherwise, it just feels like a harder version of 440C (maybe it's just 440C harder tempered, I don't know).

I guess my point is that the assumption that the wondersteel chisels hold their edges better than something like koyamaichi is not the case in my experience. If I abused something like an M4 chisel doing something other than woodworking, I could probably find a situation where M4 was better or tougher, but for the things we do, I don't see it. I don't have any V11 chisels, I do have V11 plane irons. I don't think there's anything about them that makes them unpleasant to use in general, but the only advantage I can think of in practice is that they outlast a carbon steel iron in a thin shaving distance test.

The same advantage doesn't exist in chisels.

Comparing V11 to something like buck brothers, extrapolating what we know about a proper white #2 chisel vs. V11 from other peoples' tests, sure both of those more expensive types will outlast a $10 vintage chisel, especially if compared at the same angle.

To experiment with the familiarity issue with tools, I took a chisel that I thought was nothing spectacular, an old pexto chisel, and used it to mortise two cocobolo smoothers last year (wide ones, not little ones), and I sharpened the pexto chisel once at the start and one more time before the mortise was ready for floats.

What I found was that I needed a couple of degrees more for the chisels to last very well. I also found that after buying an expensive imai timber mortising chisel last year, that I spent a whole lot less time sharpening the pexto all in than I did sharpening the imai when I used it in hard maple.

The same thing is the case for HBDT or some other operation that we do that's fairly hard on a chopping chisel. Familiarity with the tool and how it is used was more important.

I suggested something to derek last year with chisels, that is that in the tests where the vintage western tools don't seem to fare well, increase the angle by two degrees and then try again. See if it makes a difference. I have found that most of the chisels that I thought were pretty mediocre were actually pretty spectacular in use once you cater to them rather than trying to have them cater to you. That kind of thing will be problematic for a jig user who has a specific board of angles for chisels, I guess, but it's not problematic for a freehand sharpener.

Given the choice, I like having both types of plain steel (vintage plain steel and a nice japanese tool that's very hard but also plain steel), but I won't use something that holds a stringy wire edge hard, because it necessitates another abrasive step that I don't need to have with plain steel.

Two years ago, I was on your side of the discussion, but then I discarded most of my power tools (only to rebuy some portable ones to use when forced to build something that I don't really want to build, but that's a different story). I have done 20 times as much coarse work in the last two years as I did in the previous 8, and it really puts efficient removal and familiarity into context.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#96

Re: Not that any of this is particularly critical!


Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#97

Certainly

John in NM

How one defines "need" for themselves is related to how they set "good enough".

I tend to define good enough as somewhere around the couple Narex chisels I got from LV. They strike a nice balance between quality and cheap. I would like prettier ones that perform better (perhaps), but I don't need those. One day, maybe I'll get some in spite of the lack of actual need. In the mean time, there is much work to do instead, and good utility chisels do it well and leave the $$$ to buy wood.

When I said engineered, incidentally, I was including the Japanese style forging. They practice a technique that has achieved a refinement in quality over simple hardening, and do so repeatedly and by all accounts consistently. I lean more towards the modern metallurgical solution to the same problem because it is not arcane - Japanese forge practices are famously and intentionally arcane - and that means it will end up being cheaper one day.

When it comes down to taste - as fancy tools often do - the whole "mystique" thing leave's me bored, and consequently I've never fallen for the Japanese tool paradigm.

Ironically, I've stuck with the oil stone schtick in spite of having found better ways. So much for disdaining mystique, eh? Who among us is perfectly consistent? :D

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#98

Re: Certainly

david weaver

Agree on the mystique. I don't mean to sound coarse, but I don't care if they strike ceremonial first lines, or if there are certain beliefs beyond performance.

I care only about the performance and the stuff that translates to someone at the bench (who otherwise has never heard of the mystique).

The mystique stuff does a disservice to the "just the facts, ma'am" type of user, and makes us (me particularly) guard my wallet as soon as product descriptions go into la-la land about some old lady swinging a hammer or someone else having a ceremony for a tree.

I do wish someone was making middle of the road plain carbon steel chisels (of a western type), but I recognize that it's not nearly as predictable in hardening and tempering as something like O1 or especially the air hardening steels and other more highly alloyed stuff.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#99

good enough

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have come to the conclusion that ergonomics trumps steel in my hands. I have a superior PMV11 chisel sitting in the chisel rack that I seldom use simply because I don't like the thick blade for wasting out dovetails. (Someday I will thin it). I have become used to my thin chisels and that's where I'll stay. With all the discussion about Japanese style I tried one and it's thick blade promptly dinged the side of a tail. Before the defenders of all tools Japanese get up in arms, it was not necessarily the fault of the chisel but rather my lack of familiarity using its thicker blade. I'm stuck being good enough with what I have and anything better is so little better it isn't worth relearning (or the $$).

Those starting from scratch have a harder decision to make, confounded by the opinions of those that have settled on good enough.

This discussion has strayed far from my original point that composition is a factor that cannot be ignored when discussing steel properties/performance.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#100

Re: I agree on the ergonomics: *LINK*

david weaver

..I had a fairly expensive set of koyamaichi dovetail chisels from LV. They are spectacular, really. They are light and hold their edges enormously well, and they can take heavy mallet work despite being light.

I sold them last week, and went toward something that agrees with my stones, which was the cheap buck brothers firmers sold by diefenbacher - they're about $10 each. I don't need the wide chisels to have such a gradual profile as the LV chisels (which have unusually delicate sides for japanese chisels).

The cheap buck chisels are just CV steel of some sort, and the initial cuts show a bit of a soft edge, which is resolving from subsequent sharpenings. I ground the bevels of those chisels down to make something that could be malleted in right at the base of a tail, and to be honest, I like them better than the japanese chisels just because they are longer and I can use them them to clean out half blind dovetails paring down the inside fat part of the tail (where some get rid of same with a card scraper pounded in, I don't do that).

And then I scored these shortly after (not sure why I went on a binge, and a risk with no pictures of the backs, but they are flat on the backs and were in professional use, and have super delicate sides):


Sheffield Chisels