Re: forging counteracts..
david weaver
..but the best smiths, at least those most critical of the classic process always describe that keeping the tool closer to forging failure will make one that is just heated to high heat.
I've talked to George before about heat treating, and once the steel is rolled or forged, if it's annealed (and hopefully very closely to critical temperature, or even sub critical annealing), an overheat erases much or all of the forging effort.
Stu tierney said something to me once long ago about the better makers having a box for their steel to rest in, but I don't know if that was before or after forge welding.
In the video that ouchi has making chisels, he forge welds, but the chisels are left at a very very high heat, and then he puts them back in a gas forge. We don't get to see what the finish hammering is, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were in a die, and at that point he would be much more careful about temperature.
An experienced blacksmith 200 years ago would've known not just hammering, but temperature control, too. Academically, it was apparently not well known until recently that you could eliminate your forging gains pretty quickly with an overheat.
George also recommends a much lower heat color than many do when he discusses heat treating (for instance, larry discusses seeing flux bubbles before quenching, which is a level that george will not approach).
it's all interesting, but it's so difficult to understand that most of us (me included) really have no chance of fully understanding it without putting it in practice and evaluating results.
I have seen many people talk about how inconsistent old steel was, but they discount the ability of a skilled craftsman to view the grain structure in a steel and evaluate its appropriateness. I have gotten two dud vintage irons, but they were much later (one was an ohio iron and another a prison labor iron from new york - they exhibited the characteristic of an iron that has too much carbon in it, though they well could've been starved of it, too).
I can only say that whatever ouchi does, at least the older chisels (I think I have some of Sr's efforts bought on MJD auction a while ago) will completely re-adjust your expectations of what common white II steel can do. The only drawback is that at their hardness level, they are slow to sharpen on natural stones (all makers claim 64-66 hardness or somewhere in that range, but only the good makers do it. An iyoroi mortise chisel that a buddy and I had tested in a lab only gave strikes ranging 60-62, and I would say that my iyoroi mokume chisels (not cheapies) are in the same range. They can be sharpened on oilstones, whereas only a very small amount of dullness can be sharpened off of the ouchis - same steel, same maker of steel, much different result.