New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Mounting a chisel handle

Posts

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#51

Re: Yeah, making kills looking for others..

david weaver

..when you have something you're working with and it's fine, but you think there's better, there's an urge to always look for better.

When you make it, you think to yourself - am I going to discard the ones I made? No. Definitely not.

I asked George Wilson at one point what chisels he used because he's a toolmaker and he has made a glom of carving tools (like most fine workers, if he needs a tool that's hard to find it, he makes the tool). He said all of the work that he's shown (which is a lot and extremely fine) was done with a set of marples bench chisels, but they are older boxwood handled type that he said are hardness 60. I guess they were looser at colonial williamsburg about appearance of chisels than they were about appearance of planes (which needed to be 18th century style and single iron by mandate).

I've had two sets of the newer ones (marples), and there definitely weren't any in either set that were hardness 60.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#52

Re: If "Golden Age" chisels were violins

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill it seems like you are forever telling us who the best turner is, who the best carver is, and who the best period furniture makers are. Then you proceed to show them in a poor light and make them look like hacks. How does an amateur in Tennessee become the judge of these matters?

When I look at your picture I am left wondering how long it takes Will Neptune to make a half blind dovetail joint; it does not look like an efficient method.

Early in my career I used two yellow handled No. 60 chisels that I was given for free in 1973. I knew then that they were not as good as my other (older) chisels, and replaced them decades ago. I don't know why Neptune uses these chisels; I hope it is not because he cannot tell the difference.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#53

Re: forging counteracts..

david weaver

..but the best smiths, at least those most critical of the classic process always describe that keeping the tool closer to forging failure will make one that is just heated to high heat.

I've talked to George before about heat treating, and once the steel is rolled or forged, if it's annealed (and hopefully very closely to critical temperature, or even sub critical annealing), an overheat erases much or all of the forging effort.

Stu tierney said something to me once long ago about the better makers having a box for their steel to rest in, but I don't know if that was before or after forge welding.

In the video that ouchi has making chisels, he forge welds, but the chisels are left at a very very high heat, and then he puts them back in a gas forge. We don't get to see what the finish hammering is, but I wouldn't be surprised if it were in a die, and at that point he would be much more careful about temperature.

An experienced blacksmith 200 years ago would've known not just hammering, but temperature control, too. Academically, it was apparently not well known until recently that you could eliminate your forging gains pretty quickly with an overheat.

George also recommends a much lower heat color than many do when he discusses heat treating (for instance, larry discusses seeing flux bubbles before quenching, which is a level that george will not approach).

it's all interesting, but it's so difficult to understand that most of us (me included) really have no chance of fully understanding it without putting it in practice and evaluating results.

I have seen many people talk about how inconsistent old steel was, but they discount the ability of a skilled craftsman to view the grain structure in a steel and evaluate its appropriateness. I have gotten two dud vintage irons, but they were much later (one was an ohio iron and another a prison labor iron from new york - they exhibited the characteristic of an iron that has too much carbon in it, though they well could've been starved of it, too).

I can only say that whatever ouchi does, at least the older chisels (I think I have some of Sr's efforts bought on MJD auction a while ago) will completely re-adjust your expectations of what common white II steel can do. The only drawback is that at their hardness level, they are slow to sharpen on natural stones (all makers claim 64-66 hardness or somewhere in that range, but only the good makers do it. An iyoroi mortise chisel that a buddy and I had tested in a lab only gave strikes ranging 60-62, and I would say that my iyoroi mokume chisels (not cheapies) are in the same range. They can be sharpened on oilstones, whereas only a very small amount of dullness can be sharpened off of the ouchis - same steel, same maker of steel, much different result.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#54

Re: If Will Were a Symphony Performer..

david weaver

..he wouldn't be using the violin equivalent of a 60 chisel.

Speaking of, along the lines of the discussion of the prior masters' ability to make very good instruments because they had been immersed in the trade, even if they didn't have a microscopic understanding or CNC, etc.

I asked george (who does have some violins in circulation in metropolitan symphonies) what he did with the dud instruments. "you know, the ones that you make but they are a bit dead or don't have great volume or timbre" and he said...

.. wait for it...

..."What do you mean duds? I didn't make any duds. All of them were good"

I'm not sure whether or not the purchasers of his violins knew who he was, or if they just wanted one hand made in a professional instrument shop in CW, I get the sense that he made the violins and they were purchased through CW, and that has been to his detriment as he's got two very open and capable violins that he retains because he's no longer at CW and nobody knows who he is. I would bet they are better than most in urban violin shops that cater to the local symphony.

Point is, he had to learn the trade of making violins as it would've been learned by a hand maker, and the idea of close tolerance duds doesn't exist. As a buyer of guitars, I *have* bought very precisely made close tolerance duds, and fortunately for me, they were from some of the well known factory makers, as I was able to recoup most of what I paid for them - and I was glad to get rid of them. If I had the choice even price, I would go with the hand maker every time, regardless of appearance.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#55

I left the door open

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If there is something to these chisels I agree that just like fine musical instruments the finest craftsmen will use them, for example people that win the Society of Period Furniture Makers Cartouche award, or whoever else one judges to be their idea of an expert in the field. The observed data will answer the question for anyone interested in observing.

And since you got personal, I didn't need to tell anyone about Will Neptune's standing in the field of Period Furniture making. He doesn't hide the work he has done. Anyone can search him and judge from the data they find where he stands among his peers. Ditto for my friend Curtis Buchannan, or Fred Stanley, Alf Sharp or the people I have taken classes with- Latta, Cook, Headley, Byrd, etc. They all have a body of work in the public eye upon which to be judged. We don't have to rely on claims of expertise; their work speaks for itself however the observer wishes to interpret it.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#56

Re: The purpose of the half moon pieces

William Duffield

Now, you've got me thinking about relative strengths, and whether the method I used is strong enough, and how much colloidal silica to mix with the epoxy. Also, I'm beginning to realize that the fancy cocobolo handle and shiny brass ferrule are just "window dressing".

Of course, my comment about the expense of the epoxy was tongue in cheek. The time spent preparing the split dowel more than makes up for the cost of the epoxy. There is still the issue of how much filler to add. With more filler, there is less chance the blade will sag before the epoxy kicks, but also the more difficult it is to get the epoxy all the way to the bottom of the hole without trapped air bubbles.

I have another trick, which obviates the issues with matching the hole size to the blade, at least up to 1/2" Ø. I have a set of HSS drill blanks by 64ths up to 1/2". It is easy to grind the end of a blank to the shape of a spur center and drill a matching Ø hole in the end of the handle blank, and turn the handle using the drill blank as a mandrel. I should take some photos for a tutorial. I had photos a long time ago, but my procedure has significantly evolved since then, so they are worthless.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#57

Re: Neptune's work does look nice..

david weaver

...I looked him up, and his work is very nice. Like professionally nice, not like amateur nice.

I think if he were a violinist, he'd play a Wilson :)

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#58

Re: The purpose of the half moon pieces

TomD

I just poor in regular epoxy (WEST like). It is the case there is a special blend for hardware bonding. But I doubt it matters here. There are a variety of ways to get the part in straight. Sometimes it fits OK, sometimes the tail goes in a small hole and wedges, and/or the rest wedges up high. You can spot glue it with some 5 minute first. You can use a reamer to get the shoulder the right width for the wide part, so you start with a small hole then widen it out so you have top and bottom in a nice fit. You can wedge it with whatever you want like toothpicks.

I was interested to see that Larry's chisels while refined, did not use hoops either, but we are to believe they are good quality, and that is presumably a style pre-epoxy.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#59

Re: Yeah, making kills looking for others..

TomD

I made up a set of marples for my Dad. There were the blue chip, but with the wood handles. I cut the blades short so that they would be stiffer. They are fine. I find chisels like that OK for say cherry and softer. I guess one could harden them to 60 if one felt like it. Jim Cummings had a section on his video about doing that to blister pack specials. But once I am at that point, I might as well make my own. I guess people like them because they don't chip when you open paint cans with them. I get to use my Dad's tools at times, and occasionally I pick a chisel up and see a lot of paint on the end. :)

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#60

All the Cartouche winners......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....do work as good as it was ever done. Well, that is why they are Cartouche winners.

Additionally, Will is clever at finding geometric principles that can be applied to complex woodworking tasks that render them much easier. I wish he would write a book some day. Attend a lecture, demo or class if ever you can.

I attended a lecture he gave on building a domed lid, or any other domed structure. It was so clever and labor saving that I went home and made a domed trunk just to experience the technique. The technique results in a curve so fair that it appears to not be hand shaped.


Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#61

Re: Grain size

TomD

"The mechanical process of beating a piece of hot steel with a hammer has an effect on reducing grain size and in more evenly distributing the grains throughout the tool."

This is the packing hypothesis, which as far as I know from the literature is not what happens.

"Older methods of making western chisels involved a lot of hammering. More recent methods reduce or eliminate that part of the process. Japanese chisel manufacturing retains the hammering, due to the need of forge welding the two layers of steel together. I think it’s not a coincidence that descriptions of how Japanese chisels feel and behave often parallel what people say about vintage western chisels."

It doesn't take all that much hammering to weld the steel, I have a video somewhere, and it isn't hundreds of blows or anything.

I agree with the conclusion though, I like Japanese steel, and cast steel, I don't know what accounts for their characteristics.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#62

Re: All the Cartouche winners......

TomD

I think you are doing a good job proving these guys have expertise, but what it proves about chisels, is probably nothing. So far.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#63

Neptune

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I watched a video of Will Neptune doing hand work last night. He was clumsy with a plane. He was clumsy with a saw. He was clumsy with a chisel. At one point he was doing a trivial operation with a backsaw and I thought "it seems like he has hardly done this before." I went back and watched it again: it was seven seconds from the time he started lining up the saw until he was actually taking full strokes. When questioned later in the video, he admitted he usually does this particular cut with the table saw.

There is nothing wrong with being a table saw artist. But that does not make one an expert on chisels. I would guess that a lot of those participating in this thread are more capable of making judgements about chisels.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#64

Re: Grain size and nucleation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tom and all,

Just a quick note--a more full response later to Warren's post.

I don't think Wilbur was referring to the packing hypothesis, i.e., that hammering actually increases the density of steel. I think he is referring to mechanical changes in the crystal lattice caused by hammering (or any other mechanical deformation).

Here is what I--definitely not an expert--understand. Hammering and other mechanical deformations of steel, creates dislocations in the crystal lattice. Energy or stress is built up at points of dislocation, as the lattice is broken in places and driven against itself. These points of energy buildup will be sites of 'nucleation'--the places where the next generation of grains will seed from. There will be a new generation of grains whenever the steel undergoes a phase transformation, such as when it goes from ferrite/cementite or pearlite/cementite to austenite upon heating, or where it goes from austenite to martensite (and other competing species) upon quenching. The density of these mechanical dislocations affects grain size in that there are more points of nucleation and therefore more grains in the same lump of steel.

Much more can--and has been--said on phase transformation and grain reduction/expansion in steel.

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#65

Re: Grain size

joel moskowitz

I can tell you what accounts for the sometimes incredible quality of 19th century chisels. It's actually documented by at least one contemporary expert in the steel industry.

They had no idea - or very little idea what the chemistry of steel was, and very little formal specifications. But they did know that the steel from furnace X run by Mr. Y was better suited for chisels. And the steel from Furnace Z run by Mr. A was better suited for springs. So they sold steel ingots based on application and as we can see it worked.

Flash forward a century and the smaller furnaces disappeared, steel became a science, the goal was to make and hit specific alloys within tolerance, and steel vendors no longer differentiated by application.

So what you have in that chisel is a material chosen by people who knew what made a great chisel, and suppliers who were interested in supplying that market (which was a lot larger than now).

That all being said a few years ago Karl Holtey, the plane maker tested dozens of samples of A2 for his plane blades, each from different mills. He said that in spite of all of the samples being "A2" there were noticeable variations in blades produced - using the same heat treat, etc. He only sold A2 blades for a short time - but they are awesome.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#66

Re: Grain size and nucleation

david weaver

Wiley, do you know if this point is where (what is probably) a subcritical annealing is occurring with the top shelf makers? More or less a relaxation of the hammer work to reduce stress without increasing the grain size?

Much is left out of the ouchi video between when the blade is laminated and a rough shape of the chisel as forged is shown later when ouchi is making a tang.

All of this is a process I would like to understand at a good level, but it's really not as important for us to understand it as the evidence can be observed (the great tokyo makers, the folks like ouchi, etc, and the reputation of their tools), and if it can't be observed (in my experience it's pretty easy to see the difference in use), then it probably doesn't matter.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#67

Re: Grain size

Steve Voigt

I can tell you what accounts for the sometimes incredible quality of 19th century chisels. It's actually documented by at least one contemporary expert in the steel industry.

They had no idea - or very little idea what the chemistry of steel was, and very little formal specifications. But they did know that the steel from furnace X run by Mr. Y was better suited for chisels. And the steel from Furnace Z run by Mr. A was better suited for springs. So they sold steel ingots based on application and as we can see it worked.

Flash forward a century and the smaller furnaces disappeared, steel became a science, the goal was to make and hit specific alloys within tolerance, and steel vendors no longer differentiated by application.

Joel, it's nice to see you posting here again. This made me laugh, because whenever the subject of steel quality comes up on SMC, the same guy always jumps in to insist that 19th c. steel couldn't possibly be as good as steel today, because they didn't know the precise chemistry. This is the best rebuttal of his argument I've yet seen.

Only slightly OT, I have a question for you. Over the holidays, I picked up a small stash of W1 square stock, and I also have some 1084. I'm planning to take a crack at making a chisel or two.I recall you saying that you guys use water-hardening steel in your shop. Are there any tips you can think of, or problems to watch out for, that would help me avoid disaster the first time out? So far, my experience is limited to O1 and re-hardening laminated vintage steel. Thanks Joel.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#68

Re: Grain size and nucleation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

I can't answer your question--just don't know practical metallurgy. And as you've learned trying to analyze things, it's hard to find out exactly what the smiths do, because like the old western masters, they have their 'arts and mysteries' which are secret, and apprentices are pledged to secrecy. And furthermore, the steel carries its history with it, such that what it's going to do next depends on what came before. For example, upon heating from room temperature pearlite (talking high carbon now) to austenite, the grain size of the austenite will depend not only on precisely how hot the austenite is gotten and how long held, but also on the prior-pearlite grain size, since the austenite grains will nucleate on the boundaries of the pearlite predecessor. History is fate to some extent.

Yadda yadda. All that said, the best reference I can find is John D. Verhoeven, 'Steel Metallurgy for the Non-Metallurgist', ASM International, 2007. Book is expensive: $84 at Amazon or half.com. However, the manuscript is available free right here:

http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf

The title may lead you to think this is a dumbed-down text. Not so. I think it mainly leaves out the partial differential equations, but there's plenty of meat left.

A discussion of grain growth and grain size reduction through either of two processes--phase transformation and recrystallization--begins page 67 in the online text. I have to use the book rather than online text because I need to keep referring to other sections to clarify something or other.

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#69

Re: w1 square...

david weaver

oh no, you, too?

While the drill rod was cheap, I have come upon troubles in actually getting it marked accurately and set it aside for now. without a straight line on it somewhere, it's hard to mark it and see it to cut off the excess (so as to leave a bolster but thin the blade and tang areas).

You're looking pretty smart for getting the square stock from where I stand.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#70

Re: Grain size

joel moskowitz

Steve,

We use W1 on our hammers. We have professionals harden them. We have switched hardeners several times. We still lose a few each batch to cracks. Every edge tool maker I know of hates W1 because it warps in hardening and o1 is considerately easier.

While I have personally hardened W1 tools for years I haven't don't it on any scale to understand the theory or how the steel behaves. Also, since we do quantities at a time, having a proper oven etc can make all the difference. So we send it out.

So my only advice - is - I haven't any.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#71

Re: w1 square...

Steve Voigt

Dave--one suggestion. Lay the rod flat on your bench and do something to keep it from rotating--holdfasts on each end might be best. Take an ultrafine sharpie--which is not tapered for most of its length--and hold it tight to the bench top. You can mark a nice straight line on both sides this way. Now, you just have to shim either the rod or the sharpie to get the line where you want it.

Ideally, clamp the rod in such a way that you can scribe both sides without loosening your clamp. Also, clean the part with acetone first, or the marker won't take.

You can mark cones or frustums this way too, by using unequal shims. I marked the slot in my chair reamer that way.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#72

Re: Thanks for the tip!


Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#73

Re: Grain size

Steve Voigt

Hey Joel, thanks for trying.

I'm most interested in your statement that you've "personally hardened W1 tools for years." Presumably that went better than the batch hardening?

My hypothesis is that hardening W1 one at a time should be no harder than O1, that the problem only arises in production volumes. I guess I'll find out, when I finally get around to it.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#74

Re: Grain size

joel moskowitz

metal Lathe tools - grind them out of w1, harden them with torch - easy peasy

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#75

Re: Grain size and nucleation

wilbur

“I don't think Wilbur was referring to the packing hypothesis, i.e., that hammering actually increases the density of steel. I think he is referring to mechanical changes in the crystal lattice caused by hammering (or any other mechanical deformation).”

That’s exactly what I was referring to: the physical act of hammering breaks down the grains and more evenly distributes them throughout the steel, resulting in a better tool.