New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Mounting a chisel handle

Posts

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#26

Re: The extra labor cost would have you

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Warren and all,

Thank you for your specific comments. I would like to pursue one of them a bit, if we can:

"The steel on older chisels is extraordinary: sharpens very easily, very fine edge, excellent retention."

It must be that the best of the vintage steel (and modern steel as well!) was characterized by small grain size. There are forging techniques I have read about that do produce fine grain steel. Do we know of old publications on heat treating and forging? Especially regarding multiple heats combined with creating dislocations within the steel by mechanical deformation (e.g., hammering)?

Is there a smith or metallurgist in the house who understands how fine grain is produced? I have also read that finer grain impedes through-hardening, especially in straight high-carbon steel; hence keeping the cutting steel section thin could be related to keeping grain size small. I put this forward strictly as a query or notion....

I'm B.S.ing quite a bit in the above--talking beyond what I know--but am curious whether someone more knowledgeable than me could validate or invalidate any of these notions.

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#27

Re: some links

Steve Voigt

By the way, here is an old woodcentral thread with a description by "chichi" about making a laminated chisel:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3108/md/read/id/130955/sbj/how-to-make-a-bolster-or-socket-chisel-laminat/

And here is a thread from Iforgeiron (blacksmithing site). You need to sign up to see the pics.

http://www.iforgeiron.com/topic/13442-making-woodworking-chisels/

If you scroll down to post #13, you can see some of the dies he uses to form the bolster. I don't know if he planned on making the bolster more octagonal or grinding a taper on the tang, but obviously that could be done.

In any case, not all that simple.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#28

Re: Looks like there are tanged and bolstered

Steve Voigt

Hi Wiley,

I don't have any opinion on the steel quality of the two cherries or AI. But in terms of both appearance and, presumably, ergonomics, they are quite far from the sort of chisel that (I think) David and Warren have in mind. Take a look at the third post in this thread of some chisels Larry made:

http://www.forums.woodnet.net/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Number=6617072&page=&view=&sb=5&o=&fpart=1&vc=1

(am I allowed to post links to other WW forums here? If not, google "larry williams chisels woodnet" and go to the first page)

Anyway, I'm sure you'll agree the difference is quite striking! I really want to pick Larry's chisels off the screen and start paring! The others look clunky by comparison.

It's also interesting to read Larry's comments on the unavailability of such chisels.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#29

Re: The purpose of the half moon pieces

William Duffield

I've done it the same way, myself, for the same reasons Bill does it. Here are a couple pics of a marking knife I built and posted on Badger Pond fifteen years ago.


Assembled


Disassembled

This blade is really kind of large for a marking knife. With a blade this big, infilling with the dowel means you also use a lot less expensive epoxy. :D

Another trick, but it only works with the point on one face of the blade, not centered. You can lay the filler dowel up against a thin flat board, lay the blade on the board, strike a line the length of the dowel, flip the blade over and strike another line. Mark the end of the dowel using a center head on a square, rotate the dowel 180° and repeat. Then saw between the lines and plane down to the lines with a block plane, for a perfect fit.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#30

Grain size

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When steel is heated above the critical temperature the crystal structure changes. If it cools slowly large crystals can form. If it is quenched the crystals form rapidly in a jumble and small sizes. Other things equal you might expect water to cool the steel faster than oil because it has about double the heat capacity. Maybe certain alloys inhibit crystal growth and don't need as fast a quench.

In the 18th and early 19th centuries in England, edge tool manufacturers were sometimes making their own steel. There was much more interaction between user, blacksmith, steel manufacturer. And there was a tradition and a slow evolution of technology.

The famous Loree oboe factory was shuttered in Paris during World War II. One year the owner made eight instruments in his kitchen. After the war they got going again, same building, same tooling, a lot of the same guys. But it took 20 years to really make a good instrument. Reproducing chisels from a golden age would be quite an undertaking. And most manufacturers are not even discriminating enough to notice the value of these chisels.

The late 17th century was a golden era for violin making. It was not because violins were made according to some scientific analysis. It was because the makers were very devoted and very discerning. And there was interaction. Five of the best makers ever all worked in the same Amati shop in Cremona at some time in a 20 year period. You can't do this stuff in a vacuum. There is a great violin maker in Brooklyn today. He could live in Vermont or Bermuda and make a good living, but he lives in Brooklyn because he treasures the access he has to the world's great violinists and the world's great violins coming through New York.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#31

Re: Those are attractive chisels...

david weaver

.. but I get a chuckle each time i see that post that no japanese chisels that they have hold an edge was well as O1 chisels that were cut from bar stock and heat treated properly.

Maybe they just have some run of the mill harima type stuff (iyoroi hardware store chisels), because I haven't seen anything that holds an edge like the better japanese makers.

And sort of in support of what warren describes, many of the chisels by various makers look the same, but some makers do a better job of making a chisel that is superior in use (in terms of edge holding). I haven't seen anything western that matches ouchis (sr, I don't have a set that was made while jr was there) regular efforts, and I hear the tokyo makers efforts are further out on the edge of the envelope.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#32

Thanks for the link

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The tools were enjoyable to look at. Lots of talent out there.

Ellis does not seem to fear any ill results of participants looking at other web sites......a good reason in itself to support this Forum. Hence, as far as I can tell there are no rules against posting anything useful. Bravo!

Larry's comment that looking on Ebay for vintage chisels was ineffective is worth noting for anyone needing chisels. The key word here is "needing", like in your building stuff and need a chisel or a set of chisels to continue work. For most of us in need we must make a choice from something in a catalog or a store.

There seems to be a good market for an $80 chisel. Apparently the pattern made by Larry can't be made to sell for $80 or someone would be making them. I would have thought that forging this pattern would have been no more difficult that forging the Stanley socket pattern chisels.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#33

Agree and about the $80....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I share your sentiments, and thanks to Steve for posting that link, which I had not seen. Larry has posted photos here of very old chisels, but not those that he made himself. Also serves to remind what a consummate craftsman Larry is--he's been specially honored in Arkansas as a kind of 'national treasure' craftsman.

In terms of things being made commercially now, the closest thing I find to the old-style chisel are these Sweep 1, single bevel, carving gouges made by Pfeil in Switzerland:

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/05A16/pfeil-Swiss-made-1-Sweep-Single-Bevel-Straight-Chisel-5-mm-Full-Size.aspx

One could argue about what steel they're using (chrome vanadium special alloy), but then O1 is chrome-tungsten (1/2 percent each). I personally like the steel that comes on Pfeil's gouges.

Any case, Pfeil can put a fine-profile, bolstered chisel on the market for $30-40, depending on size. If they can blank these out, why couldn't they blank out Larry's style, if they thought the market was there?

Wiley....who admittedly doesn't know much about chisel manufacture

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#34

Chrome Vanadium steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

According to a steel manufacturing web site.........Chrome vanadium steels when heat-treated have excellent properties such as strength, toughness, and resistance to wear and fatigue. These alloying components also help control grain size during heat treat.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#35

Re: Grain size

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Warren,

That's a strong argument, that you can't reproduce de novo something that arose from a culture, evolved, and reached a zenith. Certainly, if a Cremona instrument could be spec'ed and manufactured indistinguishably from an original, it would be happening.

On the other hand, the chisels that Larry Williams made to suit himself seem an attractive alternative to the ones that can't be had any more.

Thanks for your thoughts and ideas!

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#36

Re: Thanks for the link

William Duffield

Ellis does not seem to fear any ill results of participants looking at other web sites......a good reason in itself to support this Forum. Hence, as far as I can tell there are no rules against posting anything useful. Bravo!

That's why I'm here, and conversely why I refuse to post on the PRSC, and have since Wayne drained Badger Pond, even if I knew that my knowledge or experience would be useful to them. OTOH, If I saw something useful over at the People's Republic that I thought we needed to know on WoodCentral, I would not hesitate to provide a link.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#37

Re: Thanks for the link

Steve Voigt

Well, thumbs up to Ellis. Cross-posting is helpful and I don't see how it's a threat to any site. Of course, they can set their own rules; it's their right. But it's good to know that cross-posting is allowed here!

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#38

If "Golden Age" chisels were violins

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I would expect that if Golden Age chisels had function superior to modern chisels, discernible by the most experienced woodworkers, the evidence would be that they would be in high demand by professional furniture makers, especially the SAPFM folks. The picture shows the chisel arsenal of Will Neptune, one of the most productive and talented of the current Period Furniture makers. Yes, those are Stanley butt chisels in the foreground that he uses for dovetail chopping and he is paring a housed dovetail with some ferruled affair.

I will leave it to others to investigate the chisel choices of other notable furniture makers.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#40

Re: Grain size

wilbur

There is a place where contemporary chisel makers have an unbroken link to past methods of manufacture, and who work closely with the steel makers and the users of their tools. All you have to do is to take a look at Japanese chisels.

(I love it when Warren makes the case for Japanese tools. ;) )

In all seriousness, there’s another factor in play when it comes to grain size besides the heat treatment/quenching process and the particular alloying agents in the tool steel. Whether a tool is forged or not, and if it is, how much forging takes place (think drop forging vs. repeated hammering). The mechanical process of beating a piece of hot steel with a hammer has an effect on reducing grain size and in more evenly distributing the grains throughout the tool.

Older methods of making western chisels involved a lot of hammering. More recent methods reduce or eliminate that part of the process. Japanese chisel manufacturing retains the hammering, due to the need of forge welding the two layers of steel together. I think it’s not a coincidence that descriptions of how Japanese chisels feel and behave often parallel what people say about vintage western chisels.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#41

Re: The purpose of the half moon pieces

TomD

The thing is the all epoxy method is a lot better as far as strength is concerned. Some makers use it also, like LMII, and it isn't a fake. It also can't seriously be claimed it is difficult to make the version with the glue and get the blade straight. It is also more direct to accomodate a wide range of sizes with the hole and epoxy method, as you don't have to worry about drill bit sizes and fitted dowels, but if one wants to go that way the effort is not such a big deal either.

Or maybe I said all this already.

Nice knife, by the way.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#42

Re: If "Golden Age" chisels were violins

TomD

You can't go by what people who do demos use. I did demos, and after the first one, I never brought my good stuff with me. There are two reasons at least. One is that the folks want to try your stuff. I could tell a story against myself, but I typped it out and it is too long. Point being, someone will wreck your stuff, and it might be a guy who is perfectly safe around his own gear.

The other thing is just that a lot of the workshop guys have seen the looks on the faces when they show up with beautiful stuff. A lot of people like to see the good gear, but they get put off trying the work themselves until they get the good gear, or just give up altogether. So you take stuff so crap that people will not use the tools as an excuse. A guy I know was famous for the canoe demo he did with a trashed Grummond rental canoe, and a shovel.

Plus there can be commercial reasons, not so much that you are getting paid to use stuff, more often someone doesn't want you to pressure people at the show, so I would take the lowest LV chisels I keep in my framing belt. Butt chisels, soft enough to sharpen with a file. I only own the 1/2" and the 1/4" Fine chiesels, but not the stuff we talk about, but OK for demoing a few sets of DTs, and if I have to sharpen, no extra charge for that demo.

And then beyond that, we shouldn't assume that the folks who drive the cars know how to tune the engines, or whatever works in that metaphor.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#43

Re: Looks like there are tanged and bolstered

TomD

What is all of a sudden the interest in Bolstered chisels? Well old thread with the pics so not so new. Lovely chisels there, but looks more than function from what I could see, delicate for what they are. And not a thing wrong with that.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#44

Re: Thanks for the link

TomD

I don't think it would be as difficult, let alone more, and the bolstered ones could be mostly ground if a person wanted to get there from here. But that said, people want expertly made chisels for what a guy who took up knifemaking last tuesday, is asking today for his little caper.

Or cheaper still, I just got a bucket of Chinese gouges for around 2 dollars each, both socket and tang. Should be OK, haven't got them made up yet, they came as I like them, unhandled and unground. Plus while US/Can have a free trade deal. Chinese stuff gets here normally untaxed and costs less in total, than just an in country letter stamp costs in Canada.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#45

Re: Agree and about the $80....

TomD

Because the market isn't there. Larry says they are great, so 5 people are in. There just isn't the market. I have the Chris Bech chisels, and my comments on what you can take from demos aside, I may be the only guy still using them. We are in the business of essentially meaningless distinctions. But we are selling them as though they mattered technically (which at some level they may). But the difficulty I see is there seems to be a large market for stuff that is just nice, but less for stuff that is marketed as being better, where the only people who can tell the difference are the few people who argue about this stuff and never agree.

On the other hand, you can sell as many zombie knives as there is neon micarta for the handles.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#46

Re: Grain size

TomD

"Certainly, if a Cremona instrument could be spec'ed and manufactured indistinguishably from an original, it would be happening."

I think there is some guy in NY doing that. Not just making instruments that copy the originals, but getting the top players to play them. We may be in a world where even these guys can't afford to take the legacy violins (which by the way have very little in common with their younger selves) everywhere they may want to play. Anyway, there could be a bit of a loop there, not sure I really buy the stories that circulate. Not sure there would be any change in concerts if all of a sudden the Strads all disappeared. The current situation is not particularly open to evaluation.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#47

Re: I suspect...

david weaver

That for larry, it's looks more than performance. I guess that's an obvious statement (to us). Maybe there's weight attributes, or whatever. Larry does very specific work (making planes) and you can get a specific view of good tools making planes, different than what you'd get if you were cutting half blinds all day.

That said, I just last week bought two gorgeous old tanged buck chisels for about $15 each, and neither has much wear or prior pitting to remove.

I'm still thinking about making some out of drill rod, and have partially ground down one rod, but it's far away on the list of things to do. There are enough of them out there to get a decent set pretty quickly.

It can be tempting once you start making your own tools to dream up what you want and suggest that nothing else will do, solely because you have the option to make what you like.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#48

Re: Grain size

Steve Voigt

The mechanical process of beating a piece of hot steel with a hammer has an effect on reducing grain size and in more evenly distributing the grains throughout the tool.

I'm a baby blacksmith, short on experience and long on book larnin'. But here's what I know, as context for what Wilbur wrote:

- Forging temps for tool steel are considerably higher than heat-treating temps. This one I've experienced first hand: bad things happen to O1 when you try to do much forging in the 1450-1500 range.

- When tool steel is held at or slightly above the critical temp (that 1450-1500 range), grain growth is minimal, even if the steel "soaks" for long periods. But when the temp goes up, grain growth accelerates exponentially. There are charts showing this somewhere on the intertubes.

- Therefore, if you get the steel hot enough to forge (or even hotter for welding), you're going to get grain growth.

- One of the main effects of forging is to counteract this grain growth, exactly as Wilbur said. Normalizing and/or annealing after forging also work to reduce grain growth.

Now, here's what I definitely don't know: After all of this work, is the grain as fine as it is in a virgin bar of tool steel that's been annealed in an extremely controlled setting?

I know that some would argue that it's not, that a piece of O1 that's been machined, rather than forged, will have the finer grain structure prior to HT. The explanation makes logical sense. On the other hand, as Wilbur and Warren point out, tradition makes a powerful contrary argument. I only have two Japanese chisels, both no-name jobs purchased on Ebay, but they are hands-down better than any other chisels I've used.

So, I'll echo Wiley: it would be great to hear from some metallurgists or other informed folks about this.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#49

Re: What a Marathon!

TomD

"It can be tempting once you start making your own tools to dream up what you want and suggest that nothing else will do, solely because you have the option to make what you like."

Well said, the other thing is that the best tool is the one where you stop looking for improvements. Not because you gave up or couldn't imagine making any, but you are just satisfied. And nothing satisfies people like us like making something ourselves. So you get a perfectly good tool, and you made it yourself, and you know you can make any other variation, at some point it just stops being a priority any more. The same thing can be true for people who just splash out cash, they reach a point of resistance.

I didn't realize when I said those chisels could be made stock reduction style that he had. Even there I was assuming they would upset the bolster and use basically flat stock, what a marathon!


Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#50

Hardening

Warren in Lancaster, PA

At the critical temperature the steel changes crystal structure. Below the critical temperature it is body centered cubic, above it is face centered cubic. After the tool is forged it is heated slightly higher than the critical temperature. The crystals formed during forging are changed into FCC. I can't see a mechanism for preserving forged crystal structure through this step. Then when the tool is quenched it very suddenly changes back to BCC, forming small crystals because large ones do not have time to grow. These small crystals with their irregular boundaries are what makes the steel hard.

This model does not explain why a forged chisel should act differently than a chisel machined from bar stock. It could be that the carbon or other elements are distributed differently in forged material. Even without a rationale, my experience pushes me to side with those who prefer the forged tools. Drop forging involves many hits with the hammer into the die, not just one and done.