Re: The extra labor cost would have you
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Warren and all,
Thank you for your specific comments. I would like to pursue one of them a bit, if we can:
"The steel on older chisels is extraordinary: sharpens very easily, very fine edge, excellent retention."
It must be that the best of the vintage steel (and modern steel as well!) was characterized by small grain size. There are forging techniques I have read about that do produce fine grain steel. Do we know of old publications on heat treating and forging? Especially regarding multiple heats combined with creating dislocations within the steel by mechanical deformation (e.g., hammering)?
Is there a smith or metallurgist in the house who understands how fine grain is produced? I have also read that finer grain impedes through-hardening, especially in straight high-carbon steel; hence keeping the cutting steel section thin could be related to keeping grain size small. I put this forward strictly as a query or notion....
I'm B.S.ing quite a bit in the above--talking beyond what I know--but am curious whether someone more knowledgeable than me could validate or invalidate any of these notions.
Wiley




)



