New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Mounting a chisel handle

Posts

Mounting a chisel handle

#1

Mounting a chisel handle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

From Thanksgiving to Christmas was hectic in the shop building the coffee table and carving board, Christmas ornaments, etc. Before I resume the Spice Box jewelry boxes (targeted for this Christmas, didn't happen!) I am recovering by tidying up some loose ends that have been dangling for a few years to many years.

Some years ago we made chisels from CPM 3V steel. In keeping with the modernness of this steel I mounted a modern handle on one of them. One must admit the handle is striking!


It isn't a very functional handle (too heavy). I need this size of chisel for the Spice Box drawers. I make handles from Dogwood branches. The resulting handle is exceptionally tough. I have not damaged one even driving one poorly fitted one on with a steel hammer.



I turn the handle, drive a piece of brass pipe (known to the State of California to cause cancer because it has 8 parts per million lead in it) on for a ferrule and then drill a hole for the chisel slightly smaller than the diagonal across the rectangular cross section of the chisel tang, in this case 3/8". I then turned a dowel 3/8" diameter and sawed a slot down its center line the thickness of the chisel, in this case a bit more than 1/8". The two half moon dowel pieces and the steel tang are slathered with epoxy and the assembly slid into the hole and tapped to set the chisel In the hole, as shown in the picture.

The result is a handle that has proven to hold up. These chisels are multitaskers for paring and dovetail chopping and for me they do well.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#2

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

TomD

That will work. On the other hand my preference is to put the chisel in a hole if that is what I have excavated, then fill the whole thing with epoxy. The reasons for this are that hardware bonding is the strongest way to bond wood to metal. So given that, why dress it up to look like it was done the old fashioned way, when the all epoxy way is better (though possibly no actual benefit in this application, strong enough being, strong enough). In the classical sense of revealing structure, I prefer to show what is actually doing the work in all it's glory. Splitting wood isn't cool because it radiates the sense that one might be embarrassed at using the epoxy method and is trying to make it look like something else, though in fact one might just do it because one prefers it. However the all out approach is stronger aesthetically.

I like to use stainless that has been heat treated to a bronze shade, very handsome.

That said, I am pretty sure that for all but the most radical bending one could do without the ring at all since the hardware bonding methodology is so strong. The band is mainly there to deal with splitting stresses that are present when one uses the classic method, which we aren't. But woodworkers don't really have much knowledge of structural joinery in wood. We are the guys who use 1/4" ply in sock drawers, not the hulls of 30 foot boats.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#3

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a more traditional method for mounting chisel handles for 40 years. A tapered tang, a bolster, and a tapered hole. The handle is secure but can be removed without heating anything or damaging the handle. Lately I have stopped using ferrules, which are completely unnecessary for cabinetmaker's chisels that have well formed bolsters.


Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#4

It would be nice if someone...

david weaver

... would make a chisel of that style, even if they offered it without handles.

It wouldn't have to be anything spectacular, I know the makers don't like to make things with steel that is anything less than perfectly behaved in hardening and tempering, but something like oil hardening steel at 59 or 60 hardness in that style would make a really nice chisel.

Razors are forged in dies to a very close tolerance before finish grinding (close at least for chisels) and I can't believe that a rough tang and bolster couldn't be created in such a die along with the rest of a chisel that would really only require some finish grinding and then heat treatment.

Or they could do what a lot of small makers do, which is just to grind them out of bar stock.

I'd assume that most of the market is to have individuals buy heavy carpenter's type chisels, and beginners like chisels like that because they think the weight is some sort of crutch.

(well, and there may be nothing like the press used to die forge these razors at any american chisel manufacturers).

I have nothing against Bill's making a chisel without a bolster, because it's a shop made chisel, but there are high dollar boutique chisels sold without a bolster and they look crude and amateurish to me (and there is more than one maker doing it). Most of the people buying them will probably never use them enough for it to matter, but an intermediate woodworker could just buy some bar stock and grind a tang on it and make something just as good.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#5

Re Wobbles...

TomD

"How can you trust a man who wears both a belt and suspenders? The man can't even trust his own pants."

If your chisel needs a bolster and a tang, and a ferule, it may be because the basic design is flawed at least by today's standards. What the shoulder or even socket seems to do is cause makers to mess around with the diameters and fancy look of the chisel to the detriment of the actual use. Pigstickers and Japanese chisels being exceptions. I completely agree there seems to be something missing from the chisels that don't put more effort into the transiton, but it is probably something that arose at a time when we didn't have the advantages we have today. What is needed is for someone to do as Bill has done and leverage the advantages of modern metalurgy, and adhessives, but come up with a pretty design. It has been done to the extent of shouldered forged chisels in plastic handles, but not for the stock removal guys. It is a bit odd because there are stock removal knives of every imaginable aesthetic concoction out there, and they sell for hundreds of dollars. But I have yet to see anyone really do something lovely in a chisel.

By the way, "bolster", on chisel versus knife, googles up some very confusing cold chisels.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#6

Re: Re Wobbles...

david weaver

Yeah, it's not the wobbles I'm thinking of, it's more the art of making a functional and aesthetically pleasing tool. Even once chisels got a bit more modern, they still retained the bolster, it was just round on things like marples paring chisels, probably because it was easier to forge it close to round and finish it in a lathe (who knows?)

The skill of the chisel is in the forging, but somehow we've gone and gotten that backwards and started focusing on handles (which a user would've made in the first place).

The japanese certainly don't get focused on handles too much, they're stock items that are made by a separate maker at a very low cost.

I'm getting to the point with tools that I don't like to buy anything I could easily make, and I'm not particularly skilled at anything. I couldn't smith a nice 18th or early 19th century chisel, and they look better than anything I could make (i'm envious of that). They have obviously stood the test of time, evidenced by how uncommon the narrow chisels are now and how short they often are.

I could very easily turn an extremely crisp tropical wood handle, put a bolster on it and stick a piece of flat stock in the end of the handle and call it a paring chisel.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#7

Re: FWIW

david weaver

George Wilson mentioned to me that Peter Ross (I think it was Peter, it may have been another master in the blacksmith shop at CW, though) had figured out how to forge chisels that have a forged bolster.

George silver soldered on a bolster on carving and cabinet chisels instead, after fitting a bolster onto the tapered tang (which still would've looked very nice and served the same purpose).

I suppose this is just a matter of once you get experience with things, you'd like something different than what's marketed to beginners. However, all of us still don't like the same thing and as a collective group we don't come close to spending as much or as easily as beginners do - what's on the market is what we can expect to see on the market.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#8

The extra labor cost would have you

Chuck Nickerson

complaining about the price.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#9

Re: The extra labor cost would have you

david weaver

If the skills were available to do it, it probably wouldn't be that bad. But the skills aren't out there to do it.

If someone *had* to make those tools the way people did 200 years ago to survive, I think they could be made with dies and labor for $30 each (out of oil hardening steel, rod just like the razors started with).

The razor industry has an advantage, though, that being that the setup they're using has been in constant use for over 100 years and they haven't changed much (so they can do all of the forging and trimming before the razor has to go to grinding. Their trimmed razors (before grinding) are probably accurate enough to be near finished chisels, at least for a skilled user.

Anyway, continuation makes it so that Dovo has skilled labor good enough to keep going (though Dovo has complained that the supply is shrinking in terms of master cutlers, which isn't a surprise since the skilled labor can only like it or lump it with one company).

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#10

Re: Cost

david weaver

http://toolemera.com/catpdf/lijwhite1905Cat.pdf

This 1905 catalog (as well as bartons) has a 5 or 6 chisel cabinetmaker's set of tanged chisels (unhandled) costing a little less than a day's wage. Productivity has increased since then, so it's hard to make a comparison, but figure that would be something like $200.

I'd pay that, I guess not many would. It wouldn't take me or most experienced woodworkers very long to create handles for these chisels and get them mounted (in the style warren showed, though someone could apply a ferrule if they'd like).

It's not like nobody could do it if there was a market, there's just no market - the market is beginners now.

I don't know if the rough work could be done in china and finished here, given that the chinese can make a set of very good high speed chisels - 5 for $20, just without a bolster. they're crude, but very capable.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#11

Looks like there are tanged and bolstered

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

chisels available new. Here are offerings by both Ashley Iles and Two Cherries, available at Tools for Working Wood:

https://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/item/IL-100-30.XX

https://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/item/EE-5009050

These look to me like they're tanged, but not certain--maybe someone knows for sure:

https://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/item/IL-100-40.XX

$30 a piece for the Ashley Iles seems very fair.

You may have had something else in mind, though....

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#12

Re: Looks like there are tanged and bolstered

david weaver

I think that they are all chisels with a tang and bolster type setup, like japanese chisels.

The american pattern iles chisels are probably the closest thing to what I would like. I had 2 cherries a while ago, and they're more of a carpenters chisel, buffed to death, rubbery steel with a lot of chromium or something in them.

I think the iles are a nice interpretation, though, and not expensive.

I've been buying vintage tang chisels on ebay instead, but it's a slow process to find some of the smaller sizes.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#13

The purpose of the half moon pieces

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They aid in assuring that the chisel tang is parallel to the hole axis. After mounting numerous handles I became convinced that this step is useful.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#14

Disagree on Two Cherries

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Yes they once were polished to death, a practice I have been told has changed. But, by my testing and experience the steel is equivalent to the Swan and Witherby I have in hand. They sharpen well and hold and edge well with no chipping and minimal deformation when chopping.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#15

Re: The extra labor cost would have you

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The extra labor cost did not make me flinch at all. I have ordered chisels from two elite 18th century style blacksmiths in the last five years. Both are capable but have not filled the order. Both are very busy; perhaps I could have been badgering them.

There are nine chisels on my bench right now. All handles hand made. My total cost for the nine is $73, but I would not trade any one of them for all the chisels in the LV catalog.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#16

Re: Disagree on Two Cherries

david weaver

I'd say in durability, it was a lot like the two you mentioned.

The qualities of the steel between witherby/swan/2cherries is vastly different, though. It's probably not something noticed with a fine final step on modern abrasives, but on a sharpening medium that raises a wire edge with gradual scratches, the difference is very large.

My problem with them is that for the gummy wire edge they provide, they offer nothing in return in edge holding over a decent vintage chisel.

I'd expect that the reason they don't use steel like the vintage chisels do is because it's cheaper and easier to not use water or even oil hardening steels as they are not quite as well behaved in stuff that doesn't look like a blunt edged die.

(when I first started, I bought a hirsch set of chisels and I remember at the time many things about "the fantastic two cherries steel" and this or that, and I think that reading catalogs, that's something that two cherries promoted, where in reality their steel is similar to most decent carpenters chisels. I had witherby chisels, and liked those for the looks, and also have a couple of swan chisels and in general for all of those old sought after chisels, I couldn't ever see what made them sought after other than that they had cool names vs. something like pexto - which sounds like a brand of paint thinner or something, but makes for a chisel that is every bit as good).

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#17

Re: The extra labor cost would have you

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Warren,

Could you elaborate on the decisive advantages of your chisels? I'm not looking to argue, just interested in what you consider the key points. You've spoken of the handle/bolster arrangement, but I'm guessing that shape, lightness, taper, and so forth may be key properties to you.

Are your chisels laminated or solid?

Your thoughts on the above would be appreciated.

Wiley

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#18

Re: FWIW

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Peter Ross told me that for the bolster they use a small worm of iron and wind it around the shank, then forge weld it, shape it, file it. Usually the square shank is nearly the same on each side of the bolster, which suggests that it was made just a square shank and then the bolster added.

Some blacksmiths today would make something like this with some kind of die, and some chisel manufacturers today forge with a die rather than machining.

Most commercial chisels today though have very poorly shaped tangs: short, blunt, very little taper. A fine tang has a straight taper to a very fine point. This makes fitting a handle much easier. Much easier to remove also.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#19

Re: FWIW

david weaver

I would assume that all of the hardware store chisels are forged in a die (and then fairly coarsely finished) rather than machined.

I think it wouldn't be a stretch to say you could do die forging in progressive dies like the razors, because those razors are at least as delicate as chisels and similar steel.

Making the dies, first to forge the shape, and second to cut it off so that the finish work is minimal is probably not something most boutique shops have, though.

I don't know if a volume manufacturer would work with W1, but some of the chinese manufacturers are still working with fairly plane carbon steel on plane irons and knives. Maybe they care less about labor and handling things. It just seems to me that it's stuff that's not made because beginners are taught to work pinching the blade on chisels and they are told carpenter's chisels with the sides ground gradually are what they should buy.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#20

Re: The extra labor cost would have you

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes I would say lightness, thin at the bevel for easy sharpening, and the tang is important to me. My half inch chisel is 10 inches long, 63 grams. Some of mine are laminated and I would say it is more important for a wider chisel, also because of sharpening. The steel on older chisels is extraordinary: sharpens very easily, very fine edge, excellent retention.

The style is also important to me. If I am looking at the stuff every day I don't want to look at something clunky looking or weird.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#21

Re: The purpose of the half moon pieces

TomD

You are getting a fine clean result, I just overthink stuff. I get mine centered one way or another, then freeze them. I just have to trust my eye. I have done the same thing with a boat hull. Just eyeball the shape, then pore the whole keel.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#22

Re: FWIW

TomD

"George Wilson mentioned to me that Peter Ross (I think it was Peter, it may have been another master in the blacksmith shop at CW, though) had figured out how to forge chisels that have a forged bolster."

You are talking the shoulder right? Why would that even be difficult? You just heat that area alone, and then do a vertical upset. About as easy as tapping a cane on the floor. There is a curved hammer that lets you get into the shoulder and square it. Blacksmithing is easy. I just get some plasticine and pound it out cold first. Like anything to have a real facility with it you need a lot of practice, and a lot of individual sub-routines down to a spinal level. But a beginer exercise like a dragon head is way more complicated than forging a chisel.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#23

Re: There must be...

david weaver

..something about it that is not as easy as you're expecting.

I am no blacksmith, but I have an anvil and W1 stock, which is a nuisance for a cutter and grinder like me to use because it's round. I was intending to cut close to the shape I wanted out and file it all out of solid and then heat it.

I'm thinking at this point I may gas up the torch and hammer it as flat as possible ahead of the bolster and avoid the trouble of cutting and filing all of that part, and thin it behind the bolster and then just cut the tang around the bolster and file the bolster to shape.

Warren described the process itself as told by peter, and I'd have to agree with the way it's described because every tang I've seen is as warren describes, the tang looks consistent and smoothly tapered in size on both sides of the bolster. Probably the biggest challenge is that you need to make that shape, it needs to be near to size and then the whole thing needs to be flat and straight to a fairly true amount.

If George didn't have the process for blacksmithing a bolster in his library of completed items, then its probably not that simple (he did make some extremely fine carving tools without bolsters, as finely made as anything I've ever seen, and I know he smithed out all of the moving parts in guns from scratch and made superb functioning examples).

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#24

Re: The weight..

david weaver

The weight of the old chisels is something I didn't understand at first. I held my chisels close to the blade for fine work, it seemed unattainable to work at a decent rate otherwise.

And I noted that warren mentioned several times that one should be holding the handle and not influencing the chisel in any other way other than to make sure it's stable in terms of straightness into the wood (paraphrased).

And I noticed that the japanese craftsmen who work doing hand joinery also hold the handle of the chisel.

Like the double iron, what seemed difficult only took a couple of weeks to get to a level that was functionally better than prior (faster and more comfortable), and suddenly the long handles and fairly short firmer blades on the older chisels makes a lot of sense. And the heavy carpenters chisels with short handles and long heavy blades make much less sense.

Re: Mounting a chisel handle

#25

Re: FWIW

Steve Voigt

You are talking the shoulder right? Why would that even be difficult? You just heat that area alone, and then do a vertical upset. About as easy as tapping a cane on the floor. There is a curved hammer that lets you get into the shoulder and square it. Blacksmithing is easy. I just get some plasticine and pound it out cold first.

Great, if it's so easy, maybe you can post some photos of the chisels you've made with this method.

Though I suspect if it were actually that easy, lots of people would be doing it.