Workbench Question
AZ in Colorado Springs
I recently came upon a large stash of douglas fir and I want to build a new work bench. The bench I've been using for nearly 30 years is 3'x5', a 1x6 grid with a 5/8" plywood top. The legs are 4x4s, and they are attached in the armpits (?) of the 1x6 grid w/ lag bolts. It also has a lower shelf, a 1x4 band that goes around the legs about 4" from the floor with a 1/2 plywood shelf. This is intended as much to add rigidity as to provide a shelf.
I made this bench early in my Air Force career, and early in my woodworking experience. I made it "easy to dismantle" for moving. And it's served me well. I retired from the Air Force several years ago and don't move around aymore (and hopefully never again).
My work is lrgely power tools, but I'm doing more and more with hand tools. But I don't see myself becoming fully immersed in hand tools.
I got a copy of Christopher Schwartz's Workbenches from Design & Theory to Construction & Use. What a treasure trove. I've read lots of other articles about benches or accessories for benches, but they leave a lot of gaps. And sometimes you're unsure how big the gaps are in your knowledge, since articles don't tell a whole story.
Well, now I'm a little better equipped to ask a few questions. I'm leaning towards (way towards, if I'm honest) the Roubo style bench.
1. A leg vise seems like an exotic device. But, it seems also that it's like giant tires on a 4x4. You get only half the utility, since there's a screw in the middle (just as giant tires provide ground clearance only as high as the axle). I realize that that gives more than the usual woodworking vise (where the jaws are three to six inches high). What am I missing?
2. So, there's the shoulder vise. That seems to me to be the way to go. Now that makes one end of the bench ten to 12 inches wider, but it seems like a better vise. Of course, it grips the stock differently than a leg vise does. I don't recall seeing a shoulder vise in any of the photos of the benches posted here on Woodcentral (in these message threads, anyway -- I haven't searched any of the other resources on Woodcentral).
3. Christopher Schwartz seems smitten by his crochet. Seems simple and useful, but I don't recall seeing that anywhere else either.
4. My last question (for this evening): I'm thinking 28" x 78" for the top. I'll still have my other bench as an alternate work surface, and I have a nook at the back of my garage/workshop that's a bit over eight feet wide. I built some cabinets for that space a few years back, and that provides a lot of storage and a "countertop" of cabinet grade plywood about 32" x 106", so a lot of clutter ends up there. The point being that I don't think I need a Roubo style bench in the proportions shown in Roubo's book.
I welcome any advice you can provide.
Cheers, Andy






