New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Workbench Question

Posts

Workbench Question

#1

Workbench Question

AZ in Colorado Springs

I recently came upon a large stash of douglas fir and I want to build a new work bench. The bench I've been using for nearly 30 years is 3'x5', a 1x6 grid with a 5/8" plywood top. The legs are 4x4s, and they are attached in the armpits (?) of the 1x6 grid w/ lag bolts. It also has a lower shelf, a 1x4 band that goes around the legs about 4" from the floor with a 1/2 plywood shelf. This is intended as much to add rigidity as to provide a shelf.

I made this bench early in my Air Force career, and early in my woodworking experience. I made it "easy to dismantle" for moving. And it's served me well. I retired from the Air Force several years ago and don't move around aymore (and hopefully never again).

My work is lrgely power tools, but I'm doing more and more with hand tools. But I don't see myself becoming fully immersed in hand tools.

I got a copy of Christopher Schwartz's Workbenches from Design & Theory to Construction & Use. What a treasure trove. I've read lots of other articles about benches or accessories for benches, but they leave a lot of gaps. And sometimes you're unsure how big the gaps are in your knowledge, since articles don't tell a whole story.

Well, now I'm a little better equipped to ask a few questions. I'm leaning towards (way towards, if I'm honest) the Roubo style bench.

1. A leg vise seems like an exotic device. But, it seems also that it's like giant tires on a 4x4. You get only half the utility, since there's a screw in the middle (just as giant tires provide ground clearance only as high as the axle). I realize that that gives more than the usual woodworking vise (where the jaws are three to six inches high). What am I missing?

2. So, there's the shoulder vise. That seems to me to be the way to go. Now that makes one end of the bench ten to 12 inches wider, but it seems like a better vise. Of course, it grips the stock differently than a leg vise does. I don't recall seeing a shoulder vise in any of the photos of the benches posted here on Woodcentral (in these message threads, anyway -- I haven't searched any of the other resources on Woodcentral).

3. Christopher Schwartz seems smitten by his crochet. Seems simple and useful, but I don't recall seeing that anywhere else either.

4. My last question (for this evening): I'm thinking 28" x 78" for the top. I'll still have my other bench as an alternate work surface, and I have a nook at the back of my garage/workshop that's a bit over eight feet wide. I built some cabinets for that space a few years back, and that provides a lot of storage and a "countertop" of cabinet grade plywood about 32" x 106", so a lot of clutter ends up there. The point being that I don't think I need a Roubo style bench in the proportions shown in Roubo's book.

I welcome any advice you can provide.

Cheers, Andy

Re: Workbench Question

#2

Re: Workbench Question

roger lance

Andy.....I would highly recommend that you get a copy of The Workbench Book by Scott Landis. IMHO, it is one of the best written woodworking books out there.....period. There are discussions in Landis of all types of benches.....traditional and modern with many specialty benches built by craftsmen to handle their type of woodworking.

By shoulder vise, I'm assuming you are referring to the Scandinavian style bench which has a chapter in Landis with Frank Klauz showing how to build this bench and why he likes that type of vise.

I think that you have to define for yourself the type of woodworking you will be doing and what your needs are.....then the bench design will follow that.

A bench build is always fun to follow.....looking forward to hearing about yours.

Re: Workbench Question

#3

Re: Workbench Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Leg vises are a little like those wooden handscrews - the give in the wood jaw gives a particular kind of grip that's really nice. If you slant the vise so that the jaws aren't directly above the screw, you can grip vertically way better than with a conventional vise.

People get all wiggy about various kinds of ways to keep the jaws parallel. My grandfather's vise, which was on the bench I used for years, just had an oak 1x2 with holes in it for a pin. Worked fine.

But: the various vises, leg, shoulder, regular, etc., all work. Each has its tradeoffs, but you'll get used to them.

Be sure, as you consider bench location, to have room on each side. You'll build things longer than your bench, and you need room for stuff to hang past the end of the bench. Two feet on at least one end is a good idea, and you need to be able to get yourself beyond the end of the bench for certain processes.

That's all that comes to mind right now, but maybe it'll move the conversation along.

Re: Workbench Question

#4

Re: Workbench Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Andy

I, too, went from a small bench - roughly the same size as yours - to a longer Roubo-style. Mine ended up a little over 78" in length and is 22" wide. I could have made it longer, but space is needed at each end as well - you are probably thinking as a power tool user if the idea is to fit a bench exactly into the available space where one works in largely a stationary position.

I also think that you are going to make it too wide if the plan is to place it against a wall. Again, with hand tools, chiseling or planing when stretching over a wide bench is going to be awkward and dangerous. Then, again, you could be 7' tall with arms like a gorilla. :)

My reason for moving from a metal Record vise to a wooden leg vise was that the latter can hold a wider board, and is simpler to use. It is only for clamping to plane the edges of wide boards. The benchtop is used in conjunction with a tail vise for the faces, and I have a Moxon dovetail vise that sits on the benchtop to raise work higher for that purpose (thanks to Chris Schwarz for bringing this to our attention). Until the latter became a fixture in my shop, my plans had been to use a twin-screw vise.

There is a write up of each stage of my bench build on my website. Just scan down the Index to the lower end of the page for the chapters: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/index.html

I good bench makes a huge positive difference to the ease and pleasure of using handtools.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Workbench Question

#5

Re: Workbench Question *LINK*

Lars Parrington

The roubo is a great bench. I built one a couple years ago and documented the process. See the link below.

1.) I put a leg vise on mine, and a wagon style tail vise. The tail vise immediately revolutionized the way I work. The leg vise less so, but I do find it more useful than my previous vise (which matches your description of "usual woodworking vise"). The screw on the leg vise definitely gets in the way, yet the vise still works OK for holding boards vertically. I would not say that is true of the "usual" style vise because of its guide rails.

2.) I'll often hold 3' long-ish boards horizontally in the leg vise to joint their edges. A shoulder vise wouldn't be able to do that.

3.) Haven't tried a crochet. Seems like it would provide 50% of the usefulness of a leg vise for 10% of the work. But, you still need to figure out a way to hold the other 50%.

4.) Will you put the new bench up against a wall, or will you be able to walk all around it? 28" wide sounds fine for a against a wall, but too wide for out in the open. My bench is out in the open, and when I hold things like panels or glued-up drawers and cases in the wagon vise, I find that I want to work on them from 3 sides of the bench: front, right side, and back. When working from the back, 24" is a lot to reach over; 28" would be torture. I'd recommend 20".

I think your 78" length is fine, especially since you have a longer bench as a backup if you need it.

How wet is your doug fir?


http://lllars.appspot.com/the_workshop/roubo_workbench/index.php

Re: Workbench Question

#6

Re: Workbench Question

Steve Voigt

My first bench had a typical face vise (w/guide rods). When I built my 2nd bench, Roubo style in southern yellow pine, I switched to a leg vise. In my opinion, there is no contest; the leg vise is vastly superior. You can edge-plane wide boards (like 1 x 12s) without having the board uncomfortably high. You can hold pieces vertically, no problem, because you have about 3" of jaw on either side of the screw. You can grab slightly tapered or irregular pieces because there are no guide rails to rack. Oh, yeah, that's the best part: no racking and tons of force.

I used the pin and skateboard wheels system described by Jameel Abraham (http://oudluthier.blogspot.com/2008/06/bench-3-leg-vise-breakthrough.html) but the glide hardware benchcrafted sells for this is cheap. I used a tail vise screw from LV and the whole leg vise set back only $50.

I agree with Derek and Lars that 28" is too wide. As Schwarz says in the book you have, your bench can't be too heavy or long, but it can be too wide or tall. I made mine 88" x 24" and have been very happy with those dimensions.

Good luck!

Re: Workbench Question

#7

Incidentally: Douglas fir

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Douglas fir can be a marvelously unappreciated wood, hard, heavy, solid. Or it can be a splintery mess. Much depends on the particular board. My grandfather's bench was made from plainsawn Doug fir, and it tended toward the splintery mess end of the range. So select with care. The closer you can come to than fine-grained, expensive grade called vertical grain, the better.

Re: Workbench Question

#8

Re: Workbench Question

TomD

The Landis book was not only the first, but it remains the best at showing what some top woodworkers (admittedly at one time) used for their benches, and for a variety of crafts. At the time this book was written the european bench was dominant (trestle bases, etc...), now due to Schwartz the pendulum has swung a mile to the Roubo style. As far as I know no craft at the height of western woodworking used the Roubo bench, particularly for cabinetmaking. I rather fell in love with the roubo bench in the Landis book, which was truer to the original type than the ones we now see with their 2x4 tops and 1 thousand dollar plus hardware packages. Roubo no longer describes a type of bench, almost anything can be called a Roubo, if it makes a nod to certain fashionable features and accessories. Some of these, like the dovetailed leg joints are questionable, if interesting to look at.

Let's say you did make a wide Roubo, then locked the legs to it with an M&T structure. Does that really sound like a great idea? I'm not sure that for a wide bench the breadboard ends pegged to a trestle, aren't a better design. Maybe just build them anyway, and call it a Roubo, anything goes.

I just walked by today, without looking at it, a book called the ultimate workbench book. In large measure a good bench is made up of everything that is not what makes it the ultimate. The basics. Incredibly solid; great wood; the correct dimensions both for working height, and length. The form of the vises, while important to the plan, is largely secondary; as are matters like a lot of dovetailed storage drawers, etc... The inclusion of a great 500 dollar wagon vise is not going to help if the length of the bench won't handle the work you do or is too large for your space. I think you will find greater rewards from working on the fundamentals than working on the details.

If you find the Landis book, you might look at the Imai bench, which isn't really a bench. Making the top of your dreams, and the cheapo imai trestle, would allow you live with the bench at several heights, or planforms, for a while. Then once you are ready you can scab on the roubo base of your dreams, and add the doo dahs that please you, but you will at least have the basics correct for your use.

Re: Workbench Question

#9

Re: Workbench Question

don stephan

I love the Klaus bench, but I had to flip back and forth between drawings in the Landis book and the Walentine article to get better understanding. Agree wholeheartedly with earlier comments that the type of woodworking helps determine the best bench design.

Re: Workbench Question

#10

Re: Workbench Question

AZ in Colorado Springs

Thanks, Derek. If I recall right, you posted some messages here as you built your bench. I didn't read them all, but you have a nice bench.

Re: Workbench Question

#11

Re: Workbench Question

AZ in Colorado Springs

Lars, I don't know the moisture of the fir. I need to get a moisture meter and check that.

The bench will NOT be against the wall. I have a router table, drill press, mini lathe, and so there isn't open wall space for the bench. I figured that 28" is six inches narrower than the 36" I currently have, but I'l reconsider if it should be narrower.

Thanks

Re: Workbench Question

#12

Thanks Everyone

AZ in Colorado Springs

Thank you for your comments. You've given me some things to consider.

My bench will not be against the wall. Other things are against the walls, so the bench will sit in the middle of my work space. Being narrower than my current bench will be a plus.

The problems with my current bench are 1) not enough mass, so it slides around occassionally; and 2) clamping things to it. The 1x6 rim is both too tall and too narrow to clamp to. When I was making simple projects and finishing unfinished furniture it worked fine. But not so much for building furniture.

I've adapted the idea of a deadman to my current bench, but with a small face vise, the lower edge of the board is just inches below the bench top. I understand what you all said about the leg vise, and that makes good sense to me. And few panels are so wide that they have to sit near the floor to be at a reasonable working height.

I've not heard of the Landis book. I'll look for it.

I'd be skeptical of "the ultimate ... " anything book. An author who thinks he has the last word on any subject -- well, enough said on that.

Thanks again.

Andy

Re: Workbench Question

#13

Times move on......

roger lance

Andy.....check with the local library for copies of Landis' books.....he also has one on building a shop.....well worth the read.....there was a time when these books were all the "rage".....


I now have some young neighbors who recently moved into the hood and when we last talked, they did not know who Glen Campbell was ??!! Wichita Lineman ?.....Galveston ?......Nope, nothing, nodda.....

Re: Workbench Question

#14

Don't be afraid to defy convention

Hank Knight

With all due respect to Chris Schwartz and all the other bench gurus, build your own bench. Asking for advice is good. So is studying all the written material available on workbenches. They explain how and why bench design has evolved, what works and what doesn't and they are full of ideas. But in the end, it's your bench. It should suit the way you work. If you don't like some feature that the gurus say is a "must," don't use it. I thought about my bench for years before I built it. I decided how I wanted it and built it that way. I love it. It's 84 inches long and 32 inches wide - far wider than Schwartz and others find acceptable and functional - but it works great for me. I wouldn't want a narrower bench, although I understand why others swear by them. My only regret is that Benchcrafted hardware was not on the market when I built my bench. My vises work fine, but the Benchcrafted stuff really looks nice. :)

Several folks have recommended Scott Landis' The Workbench Book. I join in the recommendation. Not only is the book well written with great photos and graphics, its message is that woodworkers over the years have found utility in many different designs. My advice is to pay attention to that message. The gurus notwithstanding, there is no "one size fits all" when it comes to workbenches. Ask questions, do your research, learn what works and why and then build YOUR bench. You will be happy with it.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Workbench Question

#15

Re: Times move on......

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

I love both of these books, and find the Workshop one in particular more useful than many of the current books.

I was a little puzzled when the Roubo bench was lauded as something new and unusual - it gets a chapter in the Landis book, a pretty positive one.

It seems like both these books, despite their age, go pretty nicely with the current crop.

Thanks,

Simon

Re: Workbench Question

#16

What about convention?

Tony Wilkins

Hank, I'm glad you talked about knowing why convention developed. When C. Schwarz said there was a reason that these benches developed the way they did it made sense. Don't know that from experience but thought I'd throw it out for discussion.

For me, a bench is third to do on my current list. I'm trying to decide beside a 'Nicholson' traditional Brit joiners bench and the now popular Roubo. I'm also trying to decide between all the pretty Benchcrafted hardware or crochet, holdfast holes, and a metal planing stop only.

Re: Workbench Question

#17

craigd

A minor detail

craigd

If you floor is uneven, think about how to level the bench. I was amazed how much my 3" thick maple top twists, so much for my 4x4 "bomber" base. I have two leveling "jacks" (bolts) at one end (mortised so they are hidden) and they work well (but are a PITA to adjust).

My other bench is a small (18"x5') Roubo-ish made with 4x4 construction fir (that sat in a field for years) with leg and wagon vises. I really like it but only use it for hand tool work. This one I use a shim to level it, which is a pain as, at 100#, it tends dance about.

Oh yeah, think about how you are going to man handle a 200+# top. The fir one was pretty easy, the maple one tried to kill me several times.

Re: Workbench Question

#18

OK, I'll be the Devil's Advocate

Patrick Gibbons

I've read and heard that a bench can be too wide and many are advising you that 28" may be just that. The usual line is that it's too wide to reach across. Funny, I have always reached across the board I'm working on (rather than the bench), whether it was wider or narrower than the bench. A 30" or 36" wide bench seems just fine to me. As I get older I realize that a low bench is devastating to my back. Length is good, but you need space on both ends to work. A five or six foot long bench will probably be just fine. Depends on what you build. I have a metal front vise and when I work on a long board, the end of the board butts up against the enclosed screw and doesn't have to ride high on top of it. I have no guide bars. Even with guide bars the board could butt against one and still be in the jaw enough to be held in place. I use holes in my legs with supports to hold the far end of a long board. A leg vise is a good choice, however. Take a look at Peter Follansbee's crochet. He uses a small screw to hold a board in the crochet. As a last rec, I would have you read Paul Sellers' workbench build online.

Re: Workbench Question

#19

Re: Incidentally: Douglas fir

Patrick Gibbons

I agree with Bill. I got some #1 Doug Fir 4"x4" posts for the legs of my bench and they're hard, stable and not splintery. Light colored fir with few growth rings per inch are like a different wood entirely.

Re: Workbench Question

#20

Re: What about convention?

TomD

As far as there being a reason why:

- rarely does one see one as long or as low as in the Roubo picture with the worker

- there are many reasons why all the other benches grew as they did also

- Modern roubos also differ in many other ways that just dimensions.

The whole workbench thing is way out of control, and the good side of that is that one's first is unlikely to be one's last bench build. It is fun and once you get the first bench done you may well want to eventually build another. Keep your eye's open for free, or at the very least cheap, wood. Then when the time comes, you can express your own refined ideas in your next bench. While it is admirable to make a really beautiful copy of another bench, the whole thing can be a life long process.

Re: Workbench Question

#21

Re: Incidentally: Douglas fir

John in NM

Can't agree strongly enough! I worked at a douglas fir bench for a couple years (not my shop, not my choice), and even though I only ended up with 4 or 5 splinters from it in that time period, they were deep and painful enough to seem like many more! :D

With tight grain, douglas fir becomes a much different material, and probably quite nice to work with (I wouldn't know firsthand :D )

Re: Workbench Question

#22

Re: Don't be afraid to defy convention

Hank Knight

I used to point out to my English teacher in high school that Hemingway and others didn't pay a lot of attention to grammar rules. Her response was always, "Hemingway knew the rules and knew when he was breaking them. When you learn the rules, you'll understand why they're there. Then you can break them if you have a reason." I've thought about that a lot over the years; and it applies to lots of things, including workbenches.

As I mentioned, my bench is wider than most recommend these days. I understand that a narrow bench allows one to reach and work across the entire width of the bench top - something that's difficult or impossible with wide benches. I built mine wide because (1) have it situated so I can work both sides of it, and (2) I don't have room for a separate assembly table, so much of my assembly takes place on my bench where the extra width still leaves me some work space. I broke the width rules for those reasons, but I knew the disadvantages of a wide bench top before I broke the rule.

Similarly, I'm short, 5'5". The old rule about bench height at palm level with your arms at your sides would put my bench height at about 28". My bench is 34" tall. The rule was made for those who did (or still do) a lot of heavy hand planing to dimension rough stock. A low bench allows the worker to use back and leg muscles rather than arm muscles to plane the work. I dimension stock with machines. I do a fair amount of hand plane work, but it is usually fitting and finishing work, not the heavy duty planing required to fore square rough stock. My high bench top gets the work closer to my weak old eyes and it's much easier and more comfortable to see what I'm doing on a 34" bench top than having to bend over to see it on a 28" bench top. My arms occasionally get tired hand planing, but it's a small price to pay for better vision, and a price I was prepared to pay when I built my bench.

I can see where someone building a bench without much study or thought could end up with an unsatisfactory mess. Without knowing the whys and wherefores of traditional bench design, it would be easy to design a bench that was ergonomically or otherwise unsuitable. My remarks here have dealt with ergonomics and bench dimensions. There are other aspects of bench design that have, and continue to be, subjects of much debate here and elsewhere. Some people have very definite ideas about how a workbench should be built and can be very dogmatic in their advice to others. My original post was intended to be a caution against accepting such advice on face value. It's good to listen to it, study it, understand where it's coming from, then decide for yourself whether it applies to you and your bench. Like I said earlier, it's your bench. Build it to suit you and your style of work.

Hank

Re: Workbench Question

#23

Re: Thanks Everyone

wilbur

While you’re planning and building your new bench, there’s an easy way to deal with your current bench that slides around on you. Find something in the path that is immobile, like a wall or a pillar, and place a piece of wood between your bench and the immovable object. That’s an easy and surprisingly effective way of keeping a bench from sliding.

More info here: http://giantcypress.net/post/567995425/building-a-workbench-without-a-workbench-ii-or-who

FWIW, I built a Roubo workbench that was essentially a clone of Chris Schwarz’s. I love it. You can see how I built it here: http://giantcypress.net/tagged/roubo/chrono

One last thing: a leg vise with a deadman is a great way of working on large boards. Here’s a large board set up for cutting dovetails.


And here’s a long board set up for edge planing.


Re: Workbench Question

#24

Or, if your current bench is against the wall,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

screw it to the wall. My bench is solid as can be, partly because I screwed the top to a 2x4 that's lag-bolted to the wall, so I'm trying to move the entire building when I plane.

Re: Workbench Question

#25

Re: OK, I'll be the Devil's Advocate

AZ in Colorado Springs

Patrick, thank you. For the dimensions, I'm thinking my current bench isn't necessarily too big (3'x5' = 15 sq ft), but that longer and narrower would be a better fit in the shop. And, I'd really like a bench narrower than three feet.

My current bench is 36 tall. The new one will be close to that. I'm 6'1", so I'm not the gorilla speculated on elsewhere :) , but like you I don't like the strain on my back. My router table is 41" high, and that is great. At the Air Force Academy woodshop we have a freud router table, and that's like working at a foot stool.