Re: too wide
Lars Parrington
As I see it, the bench can be as wide as you want if you are going to place it against the wall, but it is better to limit the width if it is going to be out in the open. This is contrary to what most people here are saying, so I'll explain myself a bit.
Against the wall, imagine for example a 48" wide bench. Clearly that's too wide to reach across, so you'll end up working only on the front half or so. The back area will either get cluttered with tools or organized into an efficient storage space. Not a problem.
My bench is out in the open. I work from both sides of it, and frequently need to reach all the way across it and often even beyond the opposite side. That is why I recommend limiting the width. Here are some examples of when I need to reach all the way across:
-- flattening the top of the bench, using a #7 plane, taking diagonal strokes.
-- flattening a wide panel clamped between dogs. here i alternate sides of the bench so i am always working with the grain.
-- clamping a board to the front of the bench by clamping across the whole width of the bench. often i want the handle of the clamp on the back of the bench so i am not bumping into it.
-- flattening the bottom of a drawer.
The only time I find myself wishing for a wider bench is when gluing up wide panels in pipe clamps. Not a problem if you already have an assembly table.



