New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Workbench Question

Posts

Re: Workbench Question

#26

Re: Times move on......

AZ in Colorado Springs

I wil look up Landis's books. I had not heard of him, but I do know who Glen Campbell is. I was watching an episode of Roy Underhill's show lastnight, and Curtis Buchanan was the guest. Curtis mentioned Scott Landis. Small world.

Re: Workbench Question

#27

Re: Or, if your current bench is against the wall,

AZ in Colorado Springs

The "countertop" in the nook at the back of my garage butts against the wall on three sides. I have hand planed a few small boards on that work surface -- solid as can be. I drilled a couple of holes for bench dogs, and used with a batten, it's great for small items.

Re: Workbench Question

#28

Re: Don't be afraid to defy convention

AZ in Colorado Springs

I agree heartily with the sentiment in the exchange under this subject line. I agree that conventions are there for a reason, but I also realize that while we here all share the same craft -- woodworking -- we are not running assemly lines or very often doing anything with that kind of repeatability. When someone at the wood hooby shop asks me how to do a task, I usually reply that there are at least three ways to do that task (hand tools and a couple of different machine techniques).

I'm not a professional woodworker -- jut an avid hobbyist -- so I don't do the kind of process engineering you'd exercise to maximize production. I do try to work efficiently, but that's not the same as maximizing productivity.

So I appreciate that the conventions provide a kind of practical boundary from which to depart -- thoughtfully. And you all have been through this yourselves, so I knew this would be a great place to get advice from people whose opinions I have come to respect.

Re: Workbench Question

#29

Re: A minor detail

AZ in Colorado Springs

I think the floor is pretty even. I've spent hundreds (?) of hours there on my feet and it seems to feel even. How far out of flat is significant? How many threads are showing on your jack screws?

Re: Workbench Question

#30

Re: Incidentally: Douglas fir

AZ in Colorado Springs

Thank you. I was totally unaware of this. I'll check the boards carefully.

Re: Workbench Question

#31

Re: Thanks Everyone

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have on occassion butted long boards against the countertop at the back of my garage. But then invariably I can't reach something on the far side, etc. It works in a pinch, though. The photos you posted -- that's the kind of thing I envision.

Cheers, Andy

Re: Workbench Question

#32

If you can feel the bench rock, it's significant

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

But, that said: one of my tool storage rollaways has two pieces of sheet metal shoved under one caster to level it. You may not need to build levelers in.

Re: Workbench Question

#33

craigd

Re: A minor detail

craigd

I think the floor is pretty even. I've spent hundreds (?) of hours there on my feet and it seems to feel even. How far out of flat is significant?

Me too. The two floors I use are living space and garage; My feets say flat, a long straight edge says +- 3/16, distributed, it seems, like potholes. It only matters when one leg is in a hole; with the small bench, it doesn't rock in its normal spot, when I move it (which I do often to work from the other side, to get tools, etc), it rocks enough to drive me nuts, out come the shims.

How many threads are showing on your jack screws?

No idea - I can't see them, just turned them until the top was flat and called it good.




Re: Workbench Question

#34

I like tall too...

John in NM

I have a bench drill press on a stand that is on a dolly. Puts the table right around 4' to 4.5'. There's no going back after using it at such a comfortable height just once or twice!

My benches tend to be similarly tall, 36" strikes me as a minimum, though in fairness I don't do as much hand planing as many others.

I like wide benches, since they tend to double as assembly tables. I never quite got the narrow bench notion... though I guess if it were up against a wall it would make sense.

Re: Workbench Question

#35

Re: A minor detail - thous

TomD

When I started to acquire machine tools the convention there is to shim them so they are accurately level to a thou. They sell these books of copper foil to level the tools with. It is remarkably easy to level a surface to a thou, assuming the floor is solid, and one has the appropriate level. Once the surface is level, then one can reference off the surface, or test a surface with a level to remarkably accuracy. I don't really do a lot of that with my bench, but I don't see why one wouldn't.

Re: Workbench Question

#36

Re: Don't be afraid to defy convention

TomD

I think the semantic issue here is that a narrow bench will not impede your use of it as a bench. But it is not inferior, unless there are structural, or wood movement, or flex issues, etc...

The bench could be 10 feet wide, it is just all the benchy stuff would take place towards the edges.

It is also hard to find solid pieces that are 38 inches wide, which dooms one to a butcher block. A solid piece is nice to have, but not necessary.

I think the assumption is that everyone, even large shops, have space problems so people will generally agree over more compact benches, just as money often settles an argument, since few want to waste it. So maybe we can't agree on western vs Japanese tools, but there are a lot more cheap western ones that work just fine, kind of deal.

Re: Workbench Question

#37

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My bench is a 3" slab of poplar 42" x 7' and I love every sq ft of it. For me the bench is all about a large work surface and a place to mount a vise (3 actually) and clamps.

I have two metal "quick action" vises mounted on the front( and a large machinist vise on another corner). This combination is handy for all sorts of furniture building operations. Both vises pulled out provides a rest for long lumber, either to examine or break down into shorter lengths. It is not uncommon to have a jig mounted in one of these vises and the other used for typical "vising " operations. The acreage of the bench means I can store tools in use on the bench and not have to visit the tool chest (or whatever) when I need something. The large surface also becomes useful during panel and case assembly.

Because I use power tools when they are more efficient some of the features and arguments for a traditionally appointed bench are about as useful as an appendix. Which leads to the conclusion that the details of the bench depend on the details of how you work. If one intends to work "period correct" then a period correct bench makes sense, for such a bench evolved for efficient production of furniture in that day with the tools and techniques of that day. In this case a bench book would be a useful guide. However, if on has been building furniture on a door mounted on two saw horses and a bench upgrade is desired studying a bench book may not provide useful guidance.

One item overlooked is that today we have a variety of inexpensive clamps available to us. With a large overhanging bench top an assortment of clamps enable fixturing of anything to or on the bench as needed. I have never failed to come up with some convenient clamping arrangement to enable holding parts for furniture making using traditional joinery, the traditional joinery being made with a combination of power and hand tools.

A final point, I like to sit at the bench on a stool. So for me a bench that looks like a table is desirable and one that looks like a cabinet is not.

Re: Workbench Question

#38

Why not...

John in NM

Cut a screw driver slot in the top of those, then drill a discreet hole in the bench foot for access? Might take a vise grip on the screw driver with some benches, but sure beats lying on the floor!

Re: Workbench Question

#39

craigd

Because!

craigd

Cut a screw driver slot in the top of those, then drill a discreet hole in the bench foot for access? Might take a vise grip on the screw driver with some benches, but sure beats lying on the floor!

It is a stupid design but I wanted the jacks to be totally invisible. Adjusting them is worse than lying on the floor; I sit, jack up one end with my head and turn the screw (which hard to do with a wrench), set it down, check, repeat. Glad I only had to do it once.

Re: Workbench Question

#40

Re: A minor detail

William Duffield

I built my own heavy duty jack screws from 1 foot lengths of 1/2" threaded rod, threaded connectors, hex nuts and fender washers. I glued up the legs and stretchers from 5 layers of 3/4" cabinet grade plywood. In the bottom of the center plywood layer, I sawed a centered 1/2" wide slot about a foot long. A couple inches up from the bottom of the slot, I excavated enough additional plywood from the inner three layers to closely encase and capture a threaded connector with a fender washer above it (to distribute the weight of the bench within the leg post). I made the excavation tight enough that the connector would not rotate. I think I excavated the slot for the fender washer with a biscuit jointer. I assembled these parts before gluing up the legs, and glued them in place, being careful not to get any glue in the threads or in the center slot. I built each jack from a foot of threaded rod, with a fender washer jammed between two hex nuts at the bottom. I do need to get down near the floor with an open end wrench to crank it up and down, but the wrench swings 360° and is easily engaged and disengaged from the upper nut. Originally, I built pads out of 4" square pieces of the same plywood, to go under each jack, but most of the time I haven't used them. Each pad has a centered stepped hole to receive and support the washer and lower nut. If I had the bench on a wood or tile or linoleum floor, instead of concrete, I would use the pads, but I might then find that I needed non-skid lower pad surfaces.

Re: Workbench Question

#41

Re: Thanks Everyone

William Duffield

Unless you have a separate assembly table (I use my table saw) you might want to consider making the bench wide enough that your bar clamps or pipe clamps don't fall over while you are trying to put a table top or panel or carcass in them. After all, since you can walk all the way around the bench, you only really have to be able to reach to its center from either side. :)

Re: Workbench Question

#42

Re: A minor detail

Hank Knight

For my bench levelers I had some 1 1/2" steel plate cut into 3 1/2" squares by my local machine shop. They turned a 1"X1" stub tenon on each one, center drilled and tapped each one for 1/2X13 heavy machine levelers with neoprene pads I ordered from MSC Industrial supply. Photos:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/DSCN0380.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/DSCN0391Small.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/IMG_4233.jpg.html][/URL]

They adjust with a wrench and have a lock nut to secure the adjustment.

Hank

Re: Workbench Question

#43

Turn it into a feature

John in NM

I made some rosewood bed bolt covers once, used magnets to hold the cover on the head of the bolt.

How about a little square peg in the adjustment hole? Ah, well, that one's been done to death :D

Re: Workbench Question

#44

Re: Thanks Everyone

TomD

Most benches are on walls, from what I see, which is another reason for the half-bench if you like. I never glue stuff up on my bench I use trestles so my bar clamps wouldn't be a factor. A bench that isn't against a wall is a better thing. Just don't have room for it.

Re: Workbench Question

#45

Re: agree

AZ in Colorado Springs

Bill, that's an incredibly large bench. When you say the benchtop is a "slab" I presume that's not a glue up, but a single board?

One thing that I haven't understood is the comments to the effect of "28 inches is too wide for a bench, unless it was to be placed against the wall." I think it was William who observed that one necessarily need reach only halfway across the bench unless it's placed against the wall. That doesn't equate to a recommendation to make a free standing bench as wide as twice your reach, but I don't get the idea that a wider bench is more useful if placed against the wall.

Re: Workbench Question

#46

Re: If you can feel the bench rock, it's significa

AZ in Colorado Springs

"If it rocks ... " , OK, I probably left myself wide open for that one. The way Craig wrote his post, I had a picture in my head of, say, a lasgana noodle draped over a crooked floor.

If the bench wobbled, I think I'd shim it (or something) pretty much immediately. It must have been a real chore to install a leveling system after the bench was assembled.

Re: Workbench Question

#47

Re: A minor detail

AZ in Colorado Springs

Hank, that looks like a well thought out, and equally well executed, leveling system. I doff my cap to you. I may have to copy that design, if it turns out that my floor is uneven, or I suppose if it becomes uneven when I put a solid bench there. It is a garage floor, but there hasn't been a vehicle in there for ten years.

Re: Workbench Question

#48

Bench width

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I think people who argue for a limited width of bench are assuming that you will work from one side of the bench at all times. From an efficiency perspective, this may be a good idea in a production setting. For the home shop - well, it would depend on your working style, including how many projects you have going at the same time.

Re: Workbench Question

#49

Correction

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One thing that I haven't understood is the comments to the effect of "28 inches is too wide for a bench, unless it was to be placed against the wall." I think it was William who observed that one necessarily need reach only halfway across the bench unless it's placed against the wall. That doesn't equate to a recommendation to make a free standing bench as wide as twice your reach, but I don't get the idea that a wider bench is more useful if placed against the wall.

Hi Andy

I think you missed what I actually wrote:

I also think that you are going to make it too wide if the plan is to place it against a wall.

In other words, 28" is OK if you work the bench from both sides. It is too wide if you plan to work from one side only.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Workbench Question

#50

Re: A minor detail

Hank Knight

Andy,

In addition to giving me the capacity to level the bench on uneven floors, my levelers give me about 4" of vertical height adjustment. It turns out that I've never used that feature. I set I the bench at 34" when I built it and it has never moved. I don't know whether I hit the "sweet spot" or whether I just got used to the bench at that height. In truth, I think there is probably a range of heights at which one can work comfortably, rather than a single golden number. In any event, if you're anxious about getting the height of your new bench right, I recommend this leveling system. It's rock solid and it gives you some options for adjustment.

Hank