Re: Don't be afraid to defy convention
TomD
I think the semantic issue here is that a narrow bench will not impede your use of it as a bench. But it is not inferior, unless there are structural, or wood movement, or flex issues, etc...
The bench could be 10 feet wide, it is just all the benchy stuff would take place towards the edges.
It is also hard to find solid pieces that are 38 inches wide, which dooms one to a butcher block. A solid piece is nice to have, but not necessary.
I think the assumption is that everyone, even large shops, have space problems so people will generally agree over more compact benches, just as money often settles an argument, since few want to waste it. So maybe we can't agree on western vs Japanese tools, but there are a lot more cheap western ones that work just fine, kind of deal.