New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Question for Derek - Chisels

Posts

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#76

Thank goodness...

david weaver

... that link is from before when I was posting here, because there are plenty of links since then (before the last two and a half years or so) where I was arguing on the wrong side of the chipbreaker argument.

Some part of that had Larry asking Derek how he got his PhD, and it got really ridiculous. Or maybe that was a different argument, I don't know. I did like to watch Larry blow up, though.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#77

Re: Penetration and mortice chisels - non issue

TomD

Ok, I wouldn't say I disagree, since it seems like there are a lot of ways to work... But my perception is that penetration is a non-issue with mortising chisels, in the way I work anyway. In my case the it would be like taking about penetration when making a light cut on endgrain. The fibers immediately separate, so the thickness of the chisel is immaterial. But in the case of my dovetail example and special chisel, the cut is actually an endgain cut, but there is enough strength that the material will not just split out a chip, so penetration maters a lot with that chisel.

I cut my mortises without prying, though I will do some flickin. There is always clearance so penetration is a non issue. My view of bevels is that they allow one to use tradition cutting techniques in deeper mortises. If the aspect ratio was high a heavy bevel or an overly thick chisel might be difficult to work way down there.

Another reason I think that the penetration issue is a non-issue, is because I strike with a reasonably heavy hammer, so I always have penetration. Too much penetration is just another word for less clearing.

On what the chinese guy was doing, and I only looked once. Seemed his mortise was very tight, like about the section of a sugar cube. He did cut out a large haunch. Also, worth nothing his chisel wasn't like so many western ones that when they are designed for delicate work, have a spindly stock and some kind of arty weak neck. He still had a decent section at the point.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#78

Re: Thank goodness he does.

TomD

I had to hold them by the blades, or thought I did, when I started out. My teacher also said that one should sharpen the side edges of Japanese chisels. He didn't say one had to, but he thought it was better. He would not have approved of my holding the blades. But anyway, I was a bloody mess for a while back then... :)

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#79

Re: Chinese mortise chisel

TomD

Chris, thanks for the translation.

Even if the chisels we use could take the abuse, I don't see any advantage to prying. Well much advantage.

I work with Japanese tools, you can break the smaller ones with prying. I was told you don't pry. Ok, so to learn to mortise all I had to do was not pry, and I would at least be avoiding some mistakes. That seemed easy. Once one learns not to pry, it is like walking in a straight line, why would I then start weaving? The Japanese do have a chisel that is designed for prying (as do others), but for the most part that isn't because they use it cut mortises. It is used to fit the end of the tenon to the bottom of the mortise, so that one can have a structure that does not show the end grain of the tenon, and will not break out.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#80

Re: Chinese mortise chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The Japanese do have a chisel that is designed for prying (as do others), but for the most part that isn't because they use it cut mortises

Hi Tom

One of these ...



Those photos where taken by Stu (in Japan) before he sent me this chisel by Koyamaichi. I cannot fathom why it has a hoop as it is not struck, so I removed it. Any thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#81

Japanese mortise chisel

ian in Sydney

Hi Derek

my understanding is that the chisel you've shown (which Japan woodworker describes as a Sokosarae Nomi) is for leveling the bottom of a mortise, not for prying.

Again my understanding is that the Japanese ascetic requires that the bottom of a blind mortise be "perfect", European practice is for it to be functional. Perhaps the difference relates in part to the fineness of the sticks used to make shoji screens. In shape your chisel is similar to a western lock mortise chisel.

the reason for the hoop?

perhaps it's an ascetic thing -- all chisels with tangs similar to yours have hoops, even ones that are not struck.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#82

Re: Japanese mortise chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ian

Yes. I should have been more specific. I lever severed chips with the OBM chisel. I use the Sokosarae Nomi for clearing up the mortice bottom - rather than scraping with the OBM chisel, which would dull it.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#83

The hoop..

david weaver

..The hoop is probably on that chisel because the handles come from a handle maker in specific sizes, but not necessarily for specific chisels. I.e, when you make the chisel, you just order a stock chisel handle the right size for it, the maker doesn't make a specific handle in various sizes without hoops for that type of chisel.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#85

Re: Japanese mortise chisel

TomD

The chisel is used for prying in the sense that the load is perp to chisel shaft. But it isn't really accurate of me to suggest that they have some kind of Bubba prying chisel. Or to extend that to th Swan type chisel which has an aligned load path.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#86

Re: The hoop..

TomD

Though as you know, those chisels usually/often aren't hooped. And they normally have the shape that one finds on some gouges and push chisels, though sized for the set. Some of those clearing chisels do had hoops and are driven, though not this one, more the barbed spear ones.

Also, I have seen expensive versions of these that were one continuous solid piece of metal, with a checkered handle. I can't say I have seen any other version of Japanese chisels that are done that way. When I say "expensive", I mean good quality chisels, where the maker offered, integral handle, or wooden handle at the same high price. Things that make you go Hmm...

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#87

Re: Japanese mortise chisel

TomD

"Again my understanding is that the Japanese ascetic requires that the bottom of a blind mortise be "perfect", European practice is for it to be functional. Perhaps the difference relates in part to the fineness of the sticks used to make shoji screens."

I think you are onto it at the end there. These M&Ts are not glued, so they are a pressure fit, and they are not wedged (might be either but not necessarily so that is a baseline). Obviously the more depth you can take them to the better . And as you point out they sections can be delicate, and the ends of the tenons are covered, so making an nice fit makes sense. If the thin piece covering the tenon where not supported it would be vulnerable.

Another example of this kind of thinking is that on some of the bench planes the mouth is very small. I am not talking about the mouth as relates to the shaving formation. But the whole thing front to back. The thing there is that the blades are stout, and they get even stouter with wear. And sometimes the blades are set much lower in angle. All this makes for a huge opening. They start to look a little crude So there is a special chisel for fitting the wood under the bevel. I don't believe this creates any functional support, though I have heard it said. For one thing the wood under the bevel is relieved so that it doesn't gain support from the work. It might damp vibe or resonant effects. But if you go to those lengths why not anything else. For a pro, these kinds of details will end up fast, very accurate, and having a specialized chisel or two is a nothing overhead.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#88

Re: Dutch mortice chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for posting your mortise chisels, Kees. Of the 80 views on this forum probably 8 were mine as I found them very interesting and wish I could try them.

Most striking is the reverse taper (smaller at the bolster). This is characteristic on English and French chisels in the 17th and 18th centuries, but then in English tools was tapering the opposite way in the 19th century. My feeling is that your chisels will have adequate strength at the bolster; you can report. The thickness at the bevel is helpful for keeping the chisel in line. As Kirby says the chisel is somewhat self jigging once the cut is under way and a thicker chisel does a better job. A firmer chisel is inadequate for this function.

The heel of the chisel is very important because we use this as the fulcrum when levering out loose chips. For shallow mortises one can lever against the end wall of the mortise, but as the mortise deepens it becomes much more efficient to have a nice heel to work against. If you are working on a mortise at 1 1/2 inches or deeper, the fulcrum is at least twice as far from the end of the chisel using the edge of the end wall as it is with using the heel. And when the mortise is deep and thus restricted, a reverse taper can travel in a larger arc than a taper down to the tip, which is helpful.

The mortise chisel is used to sever the fibers, to compress the tissue with wedging action to clear space, and to clear the chips. A very complicated tool.

I could do a much better job explaining this stuff with a blackboard (I once taught geometry, trigonometry, calculus). This format is inadequate for conveying something as complicated as mortising strategy. Best to have someone over your shoulder saying "like this, not like this."

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#89

Re: Dutch mortice chisels

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Kees,

Those are grand! Did you find them together in a single lot, or have they been collected over time? Are there markings on them--maker, size, whatever?

Are they rectangular in section, or are they relieved bit in the depth, i.e., sides angled back a little to provide clearance?

As for sharpening….if they were mine, I would not grind them back to an acute bevel like 20-25 degrees. You can always take more steel off, but you can't put it back on. I think you would be better to aim for Warren's 30-32-degree figure initially, and then go from there. There's quite a bit of metal to remove from a couple of them, so you may hollow grind, just for effective metal removal. But if the chisel is hollow all the way to the tip, it will want to wedge itself in the wood, or dive if you're 'riding the bevel'--better IMO to hone back to enough flat at the tip, so that the tool will ride the bevel, and will release after the strike without a lot of effort on your part.

I think if I were you, I would pick one of them and work with it--perfect its geometry as you figure out what procedure you wish to use--then apply the lessons learned to the rest, rather than bring all of them along together. This will avoid replicating any steps you'd like to 'undo'. In fact, those chisels are so nice, you might want to do the learning curve on a beater, and don't alter your good chisels until you know exactly what you want to do.

Congratulations on a great find!

Wiley

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#90

Re: Dutch mortice chisels

Kees

I think I understand what you mean Warren. Never thought about it like that, but it is quite logical in fact.

I am building a couple of windows at the moment, so I can give the largest one a workout. I don't have a great amount of experience mortising yet, so I am more learning then testing for a while.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#91

Re: Dutch mortice chisels

Kees

Hi Wiley,

Three are from Nooitgedagt, like almost all my old tools, it seems. They were a very prolific manufacturer for a long time overhere. The fourth is German, gebruder Lim or Sim or something like that. So the shape is not just Dutch, more like central Europe at that time. I bought the three Dutch ones at the same time, the German one is an older purchase.

Sizes are 6,5mm 7mm 8,5mm and 9.5mm. They taper in all directions! That means they will get narrower as they are sharpened over time, but they will last my time.

Like I answered to Warren, I am making some windows at the moment, so I will use the largest one for this job. I always need a good excuse to finally bring a tool back into shape. They are not bad luckilly.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#92

Re: Whither the path we tread

Guillaume Dery

Well, at the very least we have had some interesting discussion here. I never thought I'd initiate such a lengthy thread.

At any rate yes, it is all about what is best for the job and what new technologies can bring to bear for improvements.

So I am still waiting to see what LV will come up with for mortice chisels. It should prove interesting as the only known bit of info (by myself anyway) is that they will be with their new steel (PMV-11). This I like because I don't feel like re-equipping myself with new waterstones to handle tougher steels. It seems that the PMV-11 holds up much better than A2 or O1 but falls between the 2 for ease of sharpening. This to me is a big win.

I am curious to see what LV will come up with, will they follow one of the traditional patterns and tweak it? Will they re-invent (somewhat) the mortise chisel pattern? I am very curious to see what will come out of their shops and fertile minds and how it will perform in the wild.

That being said, I am going forward with the rehabilitation of the pig-stickers. I have flattened and polished 2 of the 4 backs (the Atoma 140 was too slow so I finally invested in some 40 grit PSA AO sandpaper which considerably speeded up the process). As soon as the cast comes off, I will go onto re-handling and fixing the bevel.

Now that I have gotten some cleaning and rehabilitation done on the chisels, they are:

Parkin & Co

Cast Steel

Does anyone have any info on this maker and/or their provenance? At any rate, this seems to validate my educated guess that they were around 80 years old as, in the new world, cast steel gave way to new cheaper processes for edged tools around 1925 (to the best of my knowledge)

A side note to this, I love the Atoma diamond stones for flattening my waterstones. I have a DMT Diasharp which gave me fits due to stiction whenever I flattened my stones. So, as a side note, I cannot say enough nice things about the Atoma vs the DMT DiaSharp.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#93

Parkin & Co.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Guillaume and all,

Here is an excerpt from a book (scanned by Google) on early steel manufacture in America. Parkin & Co. appears to have been located in the Pittsburgh area. Read down and find that many of the early steelworkers came across the water from Sheffield, bringing English expertise to the US.

http://books.google.com/books?id=Nfk8AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA16&lpg=PA16&dq=Parkin+%26+co.+cast+steel&source=bl&ots=ezvMX4uYvH&sig=0dnVl6KQHzHRL2Fk1TwA2DS-TcQ&hl=en&sa=X&ei=jjxXU5OBEaXIsASti4HYBQ&ved=0CCYQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=Parkin%20%26%20co.%20cast%20steel&f=false

Wiley

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#94

Re: Parkin & Co.

Guillaume Dery

Thanks Wiley. I never thought to search Google books and got lost searching the interweb. Can't wait to see how they work out

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#95

Re: Thanks Wiley..

david weaver

..I'd assumed looking around that it was a sheffield brand, and sitting here in Pittsburgh - right in the middle of town where there used to be mills and coke batteries (now it's financial, health care and tech related stuff down here - like everywhere I guess) - I've never seen anything pittsburgh used at a flea market.

Tool and die ruled the post-steel era (there are some mills near here still, but not many), so there are a lot of boxes of worn out files and milling bits, etc, at flea markets. But no pittsburgh woodworking tools. At the history center in town is a nice case full of planes from the two most prominent makers here (I can't remember their names) in the 1800s, but again, never saw one anywhere else other than in that collection.

This city has had a history of throwing away its past, whether it's architecture or businesses or shipbuilding...or whatever else - just tear it down and build something else. Not much lasts too long.