Re: The Ray Iles chisels
david weaver
I wouldn't want to grind down and then adjust taper on a huge pigsticker. For what they cost, it would be a waste of time, and it would seriously damage the value.
In terms of the edge holding, I usually gravitate toward easier sharpening (something that will sharpen well on an oilstone), but in this case, the edge holding is so good that it ends up being extremely favorable on spectrum of sharpening minutes per use minutes, and the fact that it never gets below where a polishing stone brings it back means it's very sharp the whole time.
I don't have a whole lot of the "new and best" and derek and others can attest that my bent is to not recommend it, but this one is an exception.
Stan covington helped me get a hold of a kiyotada tataki nomi, and I have not used it yet in any heavy work (and might not, how often do you make mortises with a large chisel like that?). It's possible that it might hold an edge better than the RI chisels.
But the miyanaga chisels, which are fantastically tough compared to the reputation of japanese chisel (and by that I mean really fantastically surprisingly tough, esp. given their hardness), fare no better than the RIs and that's saying something substantial. If the discussion shifts to something more normal like the $50-$60 japanese mortise chisels that are ubiquitous over here (iyoroi, etc), the miyanaga and RI edge holding is in an entirely different class than those.
I am making no claims to persuade anyone to buy anything, and have no biases or profit motives, just simply stating that the RI chisels are one of the things out there that delivers every single thing they claim to and there is no puffery needed to make them out to be something better than they are.
I'd flip the discussion back the other way - if you haven't used the RI chisels there's really no way you can make a definitive statement about whether or not they are better. Whether or not "better" really solves a problem is another thing entirely, but on the qualities of what makes a chisel useful (proportion, geometry, edge holding) they lack absolutely nothing.










