New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Question for Derek - Chisels

Posts

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#51

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

david weaver

I wouldn't want to grind down and then adjust taper on a huge pigsticker. For what they cost, it would be a waste of time, and it would seriously damage the value.

In terms of the edge holding, I usually gravitate toward easier sharpening (something that will sharpen well on an oilstone), but in this case, the edge holding is so good that it ends up being extremely favorable on spectrum of sharpening minutes per use minutes, and the fact that it never gets below where a polishing stone brings it back means it's very sharp the whole time.

I don't have a whole lot of the "new and best" and derek and others can attest that my bent is to not recommend it, but this one is an exception.

Stan covington helped me get a hold of a kiyotada tataki nomi, and I have not used it yet in any heavy work (and might not, how often do you make mortises with a large chisel like that?). It's possible that it might hold an edge better than the RI chisels.

But the miyanaga chisels, which are fantastically tough compared to the reputation of japanese chisel (and by that I mean really fantastically surprisingly tough, esp. given their hardness), fare no better than the RIs and that's saying something substantial. If the discussion shifts to something more normal like the $50-$60 japanese mortise chisels that are ubiquitous over here (iyoroi, etc), the miyanaga and RI edge holding is in an entirely different class than those.

I am making no claims to persuade anyone to buy anything, and have no biases or profit motives, just simply stating that the RI chisels are one of the things out there that delivers every single thing they claim to and there is no puffery needed to make them out to be something better than they are.

I'd flip the discussion back the other way - if you haven't used the RI chisels there's really no way you can make a definitive statement about whether or not they are better. Whether or not "better" really solves a problem is another thing entirely, but on the qualities of what makes a chisel useful (proportion, geometry, edge holding) they lack absolutely nothing.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#52

Just about every...

david weaver

...new type of steel that's made is not made as a blade steel.

D2 is, in my opinion, not a very good blade steel unless the blade is allowed to be substantially blunt (over 30 degrees). This is a case where it's allowed to be substantially blunt.

It is the equal to the very best carbon steel (which isn't commonly found) in mortise chisels, and far better than most. Certainly it's not *needed* but its characteristics fit mortising extremely well.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#53

Mortise chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, these mortise chisel discussions reminds me of the double iron chats. People were full of history until you asked for documentation.Then it was mostly personal anecdotes.

Thirty five years ago, in 1979, there were two articles in Fine Woodworking about mortises, one by Ian Kirby (English) and one by Frank Klausz (Hungarian). In 1982 there was a mortising discussion by Toshio Odate (Japanese). All three of these men thought they had traditional training. All three used a chisel with a flat bevel. Even as late as 1993, Tage Frid (Danish), writing in a Taunton Press book, showed a flat bevel around 30 degrees. After 65 years in the trade, in three countries, Frid had still not gotten the memo about the traditional primary and secondary bevels.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#54

I don't know what's traditional...

david weaver

I don't know what's traditional, I just like using the long bevel better.

But I can go either way without really getting into too much trouble. I do like the long primary on something like a oval bolstered chisel because it provides more clearance.

What do you think most mortises were cut with 250 years ago, something like a smaller oval bolstered chisel profile, or something closer to what we see as a firmer without a beveled side?

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#55

Re: I don't know what's traditional...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, the 18th century mortise chisels were somewhat lighter than the late 19th century joiner's chisels. They were still much heavier than a firmer chisel, but the shank was more straight without the big flair toward the handle. Early 18th century mortise chisels actually were thinner in cross section at the bolster than at the bevel. (I am talking thickness, not width, here). It does not appear that there was a division into sash mortise and joiner's mortise chisels. This division comes after the advent of mortising machines.

I think the flat bevel is helpful for mechanical reasons: registration in the cut, wedging action (you want it to move material, not just penetrate), and leverage.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#56

Re: I don't know what's traditional...

david weaver

I have seen the tapered picture you've shown before (actually, several of them). The design makes a lot of sense to me, and I'd imagine that it makes getting the business end of the chisel deeper easier without dragging the sides at full tension all the way up the mortise. It probably results in a mortise that's almost uniform thickness, anyway - that would be interesting to measure.

i've never seen one of those chisels in the wild, but we don't see much around here in the western part of PA that's really that old. there were a couple of planemakers here, but not much woodworking stuff has survived unless it's more recent.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#57

Chinese Mortising Video

david weaver

Another look at mortise chisels - chinese this time.

I have no idea if there is any uniformity among chinese woodworkers, but this man's videos show a LOT of hand tool work. Not much planing that I've seen thus far (which isn't that interesting, anyway - videos of anyone planing, that is), but a lot of chisel and saw work.

I see two interesting things about the chisel being used:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS-1-G26NBI

First, the chisel has a flat bevel, as warren prefers

Second, it looks like the cross section of it was either ground or deliberately made so that it is fairly light at the business end (relative to the rest of it) and very heavy at the shank of the chisel.

It tells us nothing at all about our chisels, but it's information to look at and a man who works at a nice rapid pace and who appears to do a lot of accurate hand sawing and accurate mortising.

I've watched about a dozen of this guy's video, and he talks continuously in all of them - it's too bad we can't understand what he's saying.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#58

Re: Chinese Mortising Video

david weaver

And another mortising video. This one the mortising starts around 6:00.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ctBg8tmZGaU

I don't normally find it much fun to watch someone else doing something I'd rather be doing myself, but I do like to watch videos of professionals because they're a lot more informative (to me) about the things that make hand tool woodworking more enjoyable (working at a good pace in a good rhythm, etc).

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#59

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

TomD

"I wouldn't want to grind down and then adjust taper on a huge pigsticker. For what they cost, it would be a waste of time, and it would seriously damage the value."

I don't know about you, but I have 5 minute. :)

I'm talking here about GD's TOTT chisels they run around 10 dollars a piece.

"I'd flip the discussion back the other way - if you haven't used the RI chisels there's really no way you can make a definitive statement about whether or not they are better. Whether or not "better" really solves a problem is another thing entirely, but on the qualities of what makes a chisel useful (proportion, geometry, edge holding) they lack absolutely nothing."

I disagree, if I owned them, there would still be no way I could make a definitive statement one way or another. My point isn't that old chisels are actually better, but that they are just as arguably better as anything else. And I mean that seriously. The old chisels are just as good as the new ones, in some reasonable set of criteria.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#60

Re:  Mortise Chisels

TomD

"I can see how a 20 degree primary with a 30-35 secondary would be easier to drive and still hold up well. Simple physics indicate that the narrower the primary bevel, the less wood you end up trying to compress and the easier it is to drive said chisel."

It's not a piton, it isn't just being driven in, it has to clear the chips. There are a bunch of ways of doing that, and there are a bunch of different aspect ratios to chisels which for better or worse affect how I approach them. Most of my mortising has been done with Japanese chisels, but as is the nature of such things they are not designed for all the work we do, I think for the most part the ones we get over here are for shoji, and small frames. I could be wrong. I think the literature I got back in the day, spoke of different bevel angles for different work.

I made one chisel a few years back that I think I showed during the great PS debates. It has like a single 3 degree bevel, and the idea is for dovetails, it just takes one cut from either side to free the waste. That is an extreme of penetration, the other extreme is like 35 degree for some mortise chisels.

So I am not sure there is one perfect bevel angle for all work. And certainly not one perfect set-up with micro bevels.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#61

Re:  Mortise Chisels

TomD

"The issue is whether it is is easier or more efficient to make a mortice in hardwood with a chisel that has a 20 degree primary bevel and a 35 degree secondary microbevel (in my case a rounded one), as is the case with what I have come to believe is traditional, versus a primary bevel of 30 degrees, which is your preference."

What is easier about it? just the penetration?

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#62

Re: Breakers

TomD

"David, these mortise chisel discussions reminds me of the double iron chats. People were full of history until you asked for documentation.Then it was mostly personal anecdotes. "

What is the story here. Are you saying there was or wasn't historical info on that. It was obvious to me there was historical precedent, but I did have more difficulty finding it that I thought I would have. Being familiar with Japanese planes that work that way, one can't avoid being aware of the fact.

Also, were the Japanese tests set up to determine how chip breakers worked, or only to quantify the parameter of a known phenomenon. It would be odd if it was mostly the former since the Japanese plane provides independent adjustment of the sub blade, and it adjusted until it makes a difference in the cut. That requires a very close setting of the blade.

It might be interesting for those who have the hunger, to look into US metal tooling which is sold with all kinds of clever chip breaking designs, and complex codes that cover the different set-ups built into replaceable cutters. Interestingly, old cutters where analogous to single blades that had strong shear properties and they were sharpened on oil stones for more cutting power. Current designs seem more oriented towards pressing in and controlling the chip. The edges are often very blunt.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#63

Re: Why does he hold it by the handle?

TomD

That is great. I would like to see more of this kind of video. Two articles in FWW made me interested in the Chinese way, And I made one of those saws, his doesn't seem to cut that fast either but it looks nicer.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#64

Penetration and mortice chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I said:

The issue is whether it is is easier or more efficient to make a mortice in hardwood with a chisel that has a 20 degree primary bevel and a 35 degree secondary microbevel (in my case a rounded one), as is the case with what I have come to believe is traditional, versus a primary bevel of 30 degrees, which is your preference.



Tom said:

What is easier about it? just the penetration?

David wrote:

I see two interesting things about the chisel being used:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS-1-G26NBI

First, the chisel has a flat bevel, as warren prefers

Second, it looks like the cross section of it was either ground or deliberately made so that it is fairly light at the business end (relative to the rest of it) and very heavy at the shank of the chisel.


Hi Tom, David and all

It is all about penetration in my view. All things held equal, narrower primary bevel will require less force and penetrate the wood more easily than a thicker primary bevel.

After David posted I did a little "research". What I wanted was to view and examine the way a mortice chisel entered the wood. The video he linked to shows a configuration similar to a Japanese mortice chisel, but note that Ge Hong has ground away some of the shaft ...


I would assume that the reason is to effectively reduce the amount of steel entering the wood.

Ge Hong works quickly, partly because he uses rapid hammer taps. He is also an experienced woodworker (I have watched him for a few years).

I next looked at someone using a English Bolstered Mortice Chisel that was set up as per the method advocated by Joel (and used by myself): 20 degree primary bevel and 35 degree secondary bevel. The woodworker here is Peter Follansbee ...

video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1bo6NVYCc0



Peter does not say what the size of the chisel is, but we know the wood is oak. The video is about demonstrating his method, which is not relevant at this time, but what we see is that he rapidly penetrates the wood. 3 or 4 blows to get down about 1" with what looks like a 16-18 oz mallet.

Next we have a video by Paul Sellers. This one was made by him to demonstrate that a simple bench chisel may be used effectively for morticing compared to a English OBM chisel (although he does state that extra effort is required to keep it square). The video is here ..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_NXq7_TILA

What was not made clear is that the primary bevel angle of the OBM chisel is 30 degrees and is 3/8" wide ...


He is also chopping onto what looks like oak. His Thor mallet (I have one similar) weighs 20 oz. He looks to be penetrating more slowly that Peter F did.

Then he switches to a blue handled Marples chisel ...


... and literally scampers through the wood.

Penetration is very rapid. Why? My interpretation is that there is little steel to hinder its progress through the wood. The 30-35 degree rounded bevel Sellers favours is small enough to compare directly with that of the OBM chisel with a 20 degree primary bevel.

Method of working, weight of mallet, density of the wood ... there are several factors that make it difficult to compare chisels directly.

Over this past weekend I was demonstrating at the Perth Tool Event (run by LN). I chose to build a night stand/bedside table as this contained mortices, tenons, sliding dovetails, dovetails, etc. Since it was just a demo I used pine. There were 6 mortices 3 1/2" long x 1" deep. Using a Ray Iles 1/4" OBN chisel and a 38 oz mallet, it took 1 blow to reach full depth. Frankly one could have used anything to make these mortices. The same mortices into a hardwood such as Jarrah would have taken 3-4 blows. In the past, when I used Japanese chisels (with a 30 degree primary bevel) it took longer. Longer here is not about time, but about more blows and a greater amount of effort. The Pine and the Jarrah represent two extremes. I imagine most other woodworkers would be somewhere between. The harder the wood, the more you may notice if you used these chisels side-by-side. The softer the wood, it would likely not make that much difference.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#65

Re: Breakers *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

These mortise chisel discussions are like the double iron discussions in that people make up alternative histories with no documentation and deny history with plenty of documentation. As Todd Hughes said in 2007:

So we are being asked to believe that it is easier to make a cap iron and hardware and slotted blade as it is to make a single iron and to believe that for hundereds of years double iron planes were made but they were never popular and no one wanted them and the only reason they are so common today is because they were not as good and didn't get used up by all the people that bought them but didn't want to....OK think I got it .......Todd


Woodcentral 2007

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#66

Whither the path we tread

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, these mortise chisel discussions reminds me of the double iron chats. People were full of history until you asked for documentation.Then it was mostly personal anecdotes.

Warren, I fear that there are two conversations going here, and this is creating a situation of conflicting ideas.

The original question was directed at myself and asked "how well do you think the PMV-11 would hold up to pounding out a mortise vs paring". To which I replied that I believed that mortice chisels seemed less influenced by the type of steel used since they were honed at a high 30-35 degrees at the cutting bevel.

This is where you picked up on my using "traditional" (when I described how I prepared oval bolstered mortice chisels), and argued that this use of the term was incorrect. Joel pointed out that "traditional" was relevant for different eras, it could equally apply to the 17th-18th century as to the 19th/20th century. With steel changes the way was opened to design changes.

I do not believe anyone is arguing with you about history or even what constitutes the archetype design.

The original question was inquiring about the future. Personally, I am also interested how mortice chisel design may be improved (using all current technology), and how to get the best out of a mortice chisel in the work we do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#67

Re: Thank goodness he does.

david weaver

Being late to the game of woodworking, I saw a lot of people using chisels by holding them near the business end. So I did that. It always made my fingers hurt (mild arthritis).

Then about 4 or 5 years ago, someone put up a picture of tommy mac's logo tools and a fight broke out about whether or not the graphic was made by a "dumb marketer" or something, because the guy on it was holding the wrong end of the chisel (he was holding the handle while striking the chisel in the picture). I didn't join the argument, but recall warren mentioning that the handle was the "proper" end to hold. I recognize the wood doesn't know why it got severed, and either way works, but my fingers have been better ever since then because I only hold chisels by the handle.

I don't move them to the mark as fast as that guy, though - wish I could!

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#68

Chris Scholz

Chinese mortise chisel

Chris Scholz

In the video here, Mr. Ge Hong posted another video where my all-time favorite master woodworker choppes a few mortises.

http://youtu.be/QajzESMK8JI

He sure loves to talk, and has a very strong accent to boot, so I understand very little of what he says.

Somewhere he says that the wood he uses sinks in water. This of course only means the wood is dense not necessarily hard (although high density and hardness are often related).

The chisel with the funny shape: in another video he talks about a chisel that looks very similar to the one in question. He says he has no idea why it has this shape, but her bought it for 1 yuan ($0.20).

In contrast to Mr. Follensby's technique I noticed how little he scrapes with his chisels. My impression is that scraping dulls chisels really quickly, maybe not an issue any more with the super duper alloys y'all are using these days?

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#69

Chris Scholz

Re: Chinese mortise chisel

Chris Scholz

One more thing:

He started his apprenticeship when he was 17. He has one (?) apprentice. In some of the videos his apprentice and some of his former apprentices pop in to help with the assembly of a table that barely fits into his workshop.

Ge Hong is the fellow who posts the videos on Youtube, no idea if he is related to the master in any way, maybe he is just relaying the videos (a big thank you that he is doing it!)

Youku is where our master hangs out (youku is sort of the same as youtube, since our Chinese brethren are sitting behind the "big firewall" I am not sure they can access youtube.). You address a master as shifu (used for master craftsmen, as opposed to laoshi, that is reserved for masters of the intellect),

The master's website is "xue mu gong" ( literally "learning woodworking" http://www.xuemugong.com

That's all I know folks.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#70

Re: Chinese mortise chisel

david weaver

I went to his website - it's interesting in that a lot of it is a woodworking forum, and google translate will attempt to translate it to some extent (but not always do too well).

I've read before that some of their tools tie japanese and other aspects together, and the socket chisels look to do just that.

I saw the table you referenced in another video. It is pretty much a huge piece of joinery, with bits and bends everywhere underneath the top, all joined. It's an impressively large piece to fit in his small shop - there's a video where it looks like he's either showing it, or the buyer is looking at it.

As you say, he doesn't do any heavy prying or scraping, and peter may get away with that because he's working with wood that's green or partially green. on KD wood, I've never had a chisel edge last long (at least not at appropriate sharpness) when scraping the bottoms of mortises. The woodworker in these videos appears to only lever and flick the chisel once he has something he knows will come out of the mortise - a lot like japanese mortising videos, but I like the size of the chisel he's using better than the japanese mortise chisels (which are what I generally use).

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#71

Re: Penetration and mortise chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Derek, you want to claim that your chisel configuration is traditional and historic. Yet you continue to give 21st century examples. You want to claim that your configuration is the most efficient, yet when I asked you some time ago how long it took to make a mortise an inch and a half long and an inch and a half deep in oak, you did not answer.

For the record, I can easily make a mortise in kiln dried oak in less time than Peter Follansbee does in the video. I use a chisel with a 30 degree full flat bevel. I could not do it as fast as Peter does with a chisel like you recommend.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#72

Re: The profile

david weaver

I assumed that the profile ground away on that chisel, which we don't know if the guy did that or not...but anyway, I assume that the profile was ground away not for speed in removing chips, but because it provides additional room in small mortises. Longer or shorter, if there's room for the chisel, I don't know that the length of the primary bevel will make much difference, but I've never done anything to compare.

A huge cross section like the rest of the GE hong chisel has would present a problem in a small mortise that had any depth, though.

Chris Scholz said somewhere, i think in another post on here, that the person using the chisels mentioned one of the chisels was bought by him in the condition it's in (it might be that one) and he didn't know why it's like that but it was only about 20 cents in our dollars.

I haven't had sufficient time to really make a decision about flat bevels. I'm used to the long primary and was faster with that, but I've made many more mortises that way than I have with my smaller miyanaga mortise chisels. In my head, I think ti's the large flat primary, but I think in reality, it might have to do with the chisels being smaller and I haven't adjusted to them yet.

I was fairly abusive to my RI chisels in the name of speed, and they tolerated it. I have been less abusive to my japanese chisels and probably need time for technique adjustment.

I have no doubt, either way, that a more experienced woodworker would be able to use a chisel either way and trounce a less experienced woodworker using the other type.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#73

Part of the trouble...

david weaver

...having used the long primary for a while and switched only because I switched chisels, part of the problem with this whole discussion is that both methods will work fine to cut mortises.

It seems like any time we have two methods that work well, there's an argument, it's unending. I don't mind unending arguments, just pointing it out.

And to cut a mortise (i'll have to time), if a 1.25x1 inch mortise was taking me 2 minutes before, it might be 2 1/2 now, so the flat bevel speed difference I've mentioned isn't enough for me to conclude that it's not just due to a need for familarity more than anything.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#74

Dutch mortice chisels

Kees

Here's a picture, you might be interested in. My recently acquired Dutch mortice chisels, somewhere late 19th century and a very standard item back then. They still have the tapered shape, narrower near the bolster.

As you can see, they still need some attention from me. I am reading this thread in the hope to find out how they should be sharpened.....


img