New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Question for Derek - Chisels

Posts

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#26

Mortise Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Mine are prepared in the traditional manner: 20 degree primary bevel and a 35 degree secondary

I would not call this a traditional manner, unless you are talking about some 21st Century tradition. For efficient mortising, the chisel rides on a flat bevel.


Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#27

Re: Mortise Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

With regard mortice chisels, I've taken my lead over the years from Joel Moskowitz, who has spent the time researching their history. Joel wrote:

"The historical standard on English oval bolstered mortice chisels is to grind the primary bevel at 20 degrees - this gives you penetration. Then put a small secondary bevel at 35 or so degrees. This gives you strength.

A single bevel at either will either not have the penetration or be too weak.

Typically the primary bevel was hollow ground on very large diameter wheels - but I have done it on regular 6" wheels. It all works but of course without the secondary bevel the chisel will bend or snap.

- I should mention that sash mortise chisels - which are considerable lighter in duty are mostly sharpened with a single bevel at about 35 degrees. But being sash mortise chisels they originally were designed for chopping mortises in window sashes -(shallow and softwood) - the the penetration angle isn't needed."

Link: http://www.ukworkshop.co.uk/forums/mortise-chisel-angles-t12369.html

I wonder if you are referring to sash mortice chisels? I made the point that my reference was the English Oval Bolstered Chisel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#28

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

Just drop them in a box, and send them to me, and I will run them over the 2x72 for you, done deal. I broke an ankle, well actually both of them. I could read the vibram thing on the soles of my feet without straining. It always sounds like it will be such a nothing.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#29

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

I am about 2k below where they hold that TOTT thing. But I forgot it was on this spring.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#30

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

TomD

I think it would be a fairly reasonable assumption that the tools you got are better than the RI version.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#31

Re: Mortise Chisels

TomD

That makes senseish. The long bevel would not be all that strong in a laminated tool where the tip gets pretty fragile for you guys who like to handle them like crowbars. Which leads me to case 2. All those PS chisels that have massively convex bevels, what are we to make of those? The ones I bought NOSish, don't look as though they were just dubbed by a hack, they look factory fresh.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#32

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

I suppose one could grind that out on a wheel, but it would be delicate. On a belt sander like a 2x72 there is a flat platen that allows one to grind flat. A 2x72 should be in every hand tool users armoury, but I fully understand that it is not. You could lean the point of a chisel on the 2x72, and it would disappear like a branch in a chipper. I can take a 2 inch 3/16" plane blade and put the 25 degree bevel on it by hand, in maybe 30 seconds. And I only have a 1 hp motor, it really needs a 3hp. Yet they are delicate, and do not overheat, unless you want them to.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#33

Mortise Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I suggested that the "20 degree primary 35 degree secondary" was a 21st century tradition and you backed me up with a reference from 2006. What I haven's seen is a reference from the 17th, 18th, 19th centuries that would suggest traditional use. Do you have any documentation?

A single bevel at either will either not have the penetration or be too weak.

I have used single bevel mortise chisels since the 1970's. Thousands of mortises.

Here is another historical drawing.


Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#34

Why? *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Why would one assume older chisels are necessarily better than the Ray Iles mortise chisels? D2 has very good properties and the chisels are carefully made with attention paid to the characteristics of well-made mortise chisels. Joel at TFWW gives the details of their construction.

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/dept/CRI/item/MS-MORT.XX


http://www.steelexpress.co.uk/toolsteel/D2-Steel-properties.html

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#35

Re:  Mortise Chisels

Kevin Adams

Hi Warren, approximately at what angle do you hone your mortise chisels? And a related question...I believe I've seen you write that you don't use a power grinder...so what do you use for a coarse stone if you need one?

Thanks for all of your guidance.

Kevin

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#36

Re:  Mortise Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Kevin, my mortise chisels range from about 30 to 32. A few decades ago workers were generally recommending a 35 degree full flat bevel. At one time I thought I would gradually increase mine from 30 to 35 as I sharpened them. It might be that I was just too locked in at 30, but I never got above 32 degrees and I now think 30 is fine. I get wear pattern on the edges rather than chipping or folding.

I use a coarse carborundim stone and Arkansas stones. I have tried a Queer Creek stone (fine sandstone) as a first stone. It is a little slower, but maybe a coarser sandstone would better.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#37

Re:  Mortise Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I suggested that the "20 degree primary 35 degree secondary" was a 21st century tradition and you backed me up with a reference from 2006. What I haven's seen is a reference from the 17th, 18th, 19th centuries that would suggest traditional use. Do you have any documentation?

Warren

This should be directed at Joel. The quote may have been made in 2006, but it is based on research that covers an early period.

What is the reference for your drawing? I do wonder how reliable a drawing is - is there text (description) to go along with it?

In my experience with local hardwoods, a 30-35 degree primary bevel would be hard work. This is the reason I stopped using Japanese mortice chisels - they were better at shallow mortices or seemed to be designed for softer woods. I agree with Joel's description - regardless of whether it is traditional as he states it is - a 20 degree primary bevel and a 35 degree secondary bevel works better for me. Obviously others also find this to be so. That it may be a "21st century" (I doubt that) phenomenon does not alter that it is a viable alternative to a 17th century choice. Progress happens.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#38

Thanks, Warren.


Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#39

Re:  Mortise Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Derek, you are the one I asked for historical reference, not Joel. I believe I once asked that of Joel on this forum and he said he had seen chisels with rounded bevels at tool sales. No history of when that was done.

My first reference was Felibien (1667). The drawing from my second post was Roubo, (1769). I don't have access to the text. I would not expect to read "We do not make a 20 degree bevel like they do in Perth."

This morning I made a nice mortise in jarrah with a 30 degree flat bevel. It was trivial. It did not damage the chisel. I have made mortises in domestic U.S. hardwoods like Maclura pomifera (osage orange) and Diospyros virginiana (persimmon), which are considerably harder than jarrah.

Here is another historic drawing.


Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#40

Re:  Mortise Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well Warren, I do not have a reference. I do not know why you persist in asking for one when my reference was Joel. I have stated this twice. What point are you trying to make?

That you can make a mortice in hardwood with a 30 degree bevel is not the issue here. That you specifically post about making one in Jarrah says that you are deliberately taking a poke at me.

The issue is whether it is is easier or more efficient to make a mortice in hardwood with a chisel that has a 20 degree primary bevel and a 35 degree secondary microbevel (in my case a rounded one), as is the case with what I have come to believe is traditional, versus a primary bevel of 30 degrees, which is your preference.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#41

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

david weaver

Better than the RI version? I doubt it. Actually, I don't just doubt it, it's no, they're not better. More attractive with vintage style and patina? Sure.

I've used some of everything, and the RI chisels hold their edges with the best japanese chisels, are probably more tolerant of abuse at the edge (no doubt more tolerant of heavy levering - which shouldn't be necessary in cutting a mortise, but in case someone does), and they cost no more than a high quality japanese chisel (and less than the super quality japanese chisels).

That said, does someone with a vintage Oval bolstered chisel need RI chisels? No. But they are one of the modern tools that does really deliver what it says it does and their cross section appears to have been very deliberately designed so they stay out of their way in small mortises and work fine in large. Some of the old oval bolstered chisels have a cross section that's a bit too thick for small mortises, at least if time matters when making them.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#42

Re:  Mortise Chisels

joel moskowitz

When does a tradition start?

The illustration Warren posted is from 1678 and in 1678 and in fact until the mid 19th century if you ground a mortise chisel at 20 degrees - even with a secondary bevel, it would break or bend as the body of the chisel was made of soft wrought iron or mild steel. It wasn't until the latter part of the 19th century that you could buy a solid cast steel mortise chisel and grind it successfully at 20 degrees. Considering a solid cast steel cost more there has to a reason why people would buy them.

I haven't checked all my 20th century catalogs but my post war marples catalog shows the surviving sized of mortise chisel at 20 degrees. I'm going to trace back. Part of the problem is that illustrations were reused for decades and a catalog from 1930 could easily have engravings made in the 19th century. But certainly we have at least one bit of documentation confirming the way I was taught.

But the real proof is in the pudding. As Derek has said the lower primary angle works better, (especially on them tough aussie woods).

So it might not be a 17th century tradition but it certainly is a 20th century one on.

Warren's comment "For efficient mortising, the chisel rides on a flat bevel." I don't understand at all. In my view and the way I was taught (The method first described in Moxon - hows that for tradition), the goal is to chop fast and deep and blow away material.

By the way the traditional way of making a mortise in the United States from about 1850 onward was by using a mortising machine*. - Everyone picks and chooses their traditions and methods of work depending on how they were trained, where they were trained, and what aspects of the work they find important. In my view the only way to avoid this is to look at many techniques and try understand their engineering, their advantages, their learning curve, and their disadvantages.

*I'm not kidding about this - American catalogs from the 19th century show lots of mortising machines and few entries for mortise chisels. This is totally different than how similar stuff was made in the UK.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#43

Proof in the pudding

Warren in Lancaster, PA

So the proof is in the pudding? Your method is more efficient? Just how long does it take you to make a mortise 5/16 wide, 1 1/2 inches long and 1 1/2 inches deep in oak?

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#44

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Well, those $40 dollar pig-stickers are starting to add up.

Tom, I had thought about a belt grinder a while back but promptly forgot about it (I ended up with a Tormek dirt cheap).

I am now thinking that I may want to revisit this and would welcome any recommendation you may have on a 2X72. Is yours shop built or purchased? I don't have a desire for a dry wheel grinder as I can live with the speed of the Tormek (which can also live in my shop as it doesn't spew metal dust) but I am thinking that a belt grinder may be jsut the thing to keep on the garage workbench.

Any thoughts or advice appreciated.

Guillaume

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#45

Re: Proof in the pudding

joel moskowitz

Warren,

I am assuming that since you do this a lot more than I you are a good bit faster (I certainly hope so). I'm guessing about 90 -120 seconds + 30 seconds for paring the sides, but I will trot out some maple (sorry I don't have any oak) and give it a shot as soon as I can.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#46

Re:  Mortise Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Just as a point of interest (not trying to feed the trolls) the 4 pig stickers I bought (cast steel), which I would guess date back to about 80 years (not carbon dated) all have a 30 degree flat bevel. I believe that this is as shipped from the factory as the level of oxidation on the bevel is identical to that on the sides of the chisel.

I can see how a 20 degree primary with a 30-35 secondary would be easier to drive and still hold up well. Simple physics indicate that the narrower the primary bevel, the less wood you end up trying to compress and the easier it is to drive said chisel.

The sparring may resume, just thought I'd throw in a factual observation as a point of datum.

As an aside, historical references and when a practice came into effect are of secondary importance to whether or not the practice works and is actually beneficial. In the case of bevel angle on pig stickers, my gut tells me that Derek's practice would ease the work with no ill effect. I will actually test this out once my wrist heals and I am done rehabilitating the pig stickers. I will use the 1/2 inch chisel (as it requires the most effort) and do up a sample board of hard maple (sorry, no Jarra here) then do a test mortice with both a flat 30 bevel and then a 20 degree primary with 35 micro. Test mortice will be 2 inches deep and 2 inches long and naturally the width of the chisel.

Will compare the following elements:

-Depth of cut

-Speed to complete full mortise

-Quality of mortise

-How the chisel edge held up

Won't be for at least another month until I get out of the cast but should prove interesting to compare the 2 methods (my gut tells me that the lower primary bevel will prevail).

Guillaume

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#47

long shallow primary

david weaver

I've always liked the long shallow primary better both for speed in the mortise and due to the ease of sharpening. with a good quality chisel, one can literally keep up the edge on a long shallow with a rounded secondary using only a finishing stone.

When I still had the RI chisels, a single 8000 grit waterstone and about 5 swipes after each mortise kept the chisel at shaving sharp at all times. It made for very pleasant mortising.

When I sold the chisels, I hadn't used a few of the ones I bought, but even the ones I did buy had embarrassingly little wear because i never did anything but swipe them on a polishing stone after they were initially prepared

Once I sold them (a problem of excess and I decided they'd go because they were the most marketable mortise chisels I had), I have been using japanese mortise chisels with a full bevel since. They are slower. Or at least at this point I am slower with them. Not excrutiatingly slow, but it was easy to notice that with the same mallet, the RI chisels went through wood more easily than the japanese chisels. The japanese chisels I have are miyanaga chisels, so there is no question about their fitness for use (miyanaga makes extremely durable tools when he uses blue steel).

I'm inclined to go back to oval bolstered mortise chisels at some point, but since I don't use artificial stones anymore, I will probably look for vintage chisels that have similar proportions to the RI Chisels.

Anyway, I think joel is correct that the long primary and small secondary moves through wood more easily (and thus removes wood more easily).

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#48

Roll your own grinder *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

From Shank Custom Knives comes a prettty decent tutorial on making your own grinder, one that will be very similar to what TomD has.

How about talking Matthias into making one and posting a how-to?


Shank Custom Knives grinder

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#49

Re: Why?

TomD

Generally because it helps to be prejudiced in favour of the stuff one already has. New stuff generally disappears in short enough order anyway. Remember Shaptons, and bevel up, when they were all you should have. The alphabet wars of various HSSs.

The vast majority of the very best work ever done in the Western idiom was done by the old tools. D2 was not designed for the manufacture of hand tools, the first 20 popular uses I googled up were "dies" of different types. Many of the modern flourishes like milling planes or chisels flat were only done recently. Having started with the Japanese tools, I was never an old tool crank like say Michael Dunbar. But when I got a few of these tools, often hideous tools in poor condition, they rapidly became favourites though I am not inclined to antiques or other romantic aspects of old tools. Purely practically they are good. Conversely, few new tools make the cut, not for lack of trying over 35+ years.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#50

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

TomD

"Better than the RI version? I doubt it. Actually, I don't just doubt it, it's no, they're not better. More attractive with vintage style and patina? Sure."

Well practically speaking there is no way of knowing since the older chisels are not of only one type, and nobody can have experience of all of them.

"I've used some of everything, and the RI chisels hold their edges with the best japanese chisels, are probably more tolerant of abuse at the edge (no doubt more tolerant of heavy levering - which shouldn't be necessary in cutting a mortise, but in case someone does), and they cost no more than a high quality japanese chisel (and less than the super quality japanese chisels)."

Me too, it is hard to know who would be able to judge, has enough experience, and doesn't have various allegiances. it is hard not to get caught up in the new. It happens here as people go weak at the knees over the latest clutter. Old stuff, often in mixed sets is not that way for me. It hangs around because it does something. I don't have matched sets by famous makers. Most of my stuff is new (if 1980 is new).

The biggest thing for me where the old stuff is superior is that it sharpens really easily and holds the edge adequately. This is something one rarely sees in modern tooling, one can almost say that it can't be commercially successful if it is balanced. It will rate low, on the boards, and in the hands of people who were brought up on a testing, not a working culture.

"That said, does someone with a vintage Oval bolstered chisel need RI chisels? No. But they are one of the modern tools that does really deliver what it says it does and their cross section appears to have been very deliberately designed so they stay out of their way in small mortises and work fine in large. Some of the old oval bolstered chisels have a cross section that's a bit too thick for small mortises, at least if time matters when making them."

To sumarize your claims, which I am willing to take on face value:

- They accept abuse, which doubtless many will find handy, as you say. Not going to do anything for me though.

- Hold their edges with the best Japanese chisels. That is a toughie because I haven't really seen that in any tests, and it is always test subjective. It is not clear it is useful in real use, which is basically pine, cherry, mahogany, and walnut. It is also not something that can only be won by a chisel with good edge durability since there are many ways of work where the easier to sharpen chisel will come out on top. It seems actually to be pretty much the way the pro world is set up. There seems to be a bias towards constant sharpening of a very fast kind vs, some process where it is done with longer intervals between resharpening. So barbering, meat cutting, woodworking, and gardening. There is no one answer.

- As cheap as Japanese chisels, that is sorta like as chaste as the happy hooker. But ok, so I could burn through like 10 to 20 oldies for what an R1 cost? This isn't a fair fight. The old stuff usually isn't even NOS, but it is also crazy cheap. If it was still being made it would be very expensive, it just happens not to be. Modern stuff has value, but I don't know that it delivers the best value.

- You raise some stuff about shape. I have a grinder, I could care less how it came out of someone's shop, over time it will be all mine, and normally that is what the people who use this stuff prefer. They aren't looking forward to a new chisel, even from a master's shop, that is more consumer thinking, not craftsman thinking.

Overall, I don't see much that is convincing there. The only really concrete one will be on edgeholding, which to me can go either way, unless the materials being cut are very aggressive on edges; the user is very careless; and depending on sharpening equipment and skill.