Re: The Ray Iles chisels
TomD
"Better than the RI version? I doubt it. Actually, I don't just doubt it, it's no, they're not better. More attractive with vintage style and patina? Sure."
Well practically speaking there is no way of knowing since the older chisels are not of only one type, and nobody can have experience of all of them.
"I've used some of everything, and the RI chisels hold their edges with the best japanese chisels, are probably more tolerant of abuse at the edge (no doubt more tolerant of heavy levering - which shouldn't be necessary in cutting a mortise, but in case someone does), and they cost no more than a high quality japanese chisel (and less than the super quality japanese chisels)."
Me too, it is hard to know who would be able to judge, has enough experience, and doesn't have various allegiances. it is hard not to get caught up in the new. It happens here as people go weak at the knees over the latest clutter. Old stuff, often in mixed sets is not that way for me. It hangs around because it does something. I don't have matched sets by famous makers. Most of my stuff is new (if 1980 is new).
The biggest thing for me where the old stuff is superior is that it sharpens really easily and holds the edge adequately. This is something one rarely sees in modern tooling, one can almost say that it can't be commercially successful if it is balanced. It will rate low, on the boards, and in the hands of people who were brought up on a testing, not a working culture.
"That said, does someone with a vintage Oval bolstered chisel need RI chisels? No. But they are one of the modern tools that does really deliver what it says it does and their cross section appears to have been very deliberately designed so they stay out of their way in small mortises and work fine in large. Some of the old oval bolstered chisels have a cross section that's a bit too thick for small mortises, at least if time matters when making them."
To sumarize your claims, which I am willing to take on face value:
- They accept abuse, which doubtless many will find handy, as you say. Not going to do anything for me though.
- Hold their edges with the best Japanese chisels. That is a toughie because I haven't really seen that in any tests, and it is always test subjective. It is not clear it is useful in real use, which is basically pine, cherry, mahogany, and walnut. It is also not something that can only be won by a chisel with good edge durability since there are many ways of work where the easier to sharpen chisel will come out on top. It seems actually to be pretty much the way the pro world is set up. There seems to be a bias towards constant sharpening of a very fast kind vs, some process where it is done with longer intervals between resharpening. So barbering, meat cutting, woodworking, and gardening. There is no one answer.
- As cheap as Japanese chisels, that is sorta like as chaste as the happy hooker. But ok, so I could burn through like 10 to 20 oldies for what an R1 cost? This isn't a fair fight. The old stuff usually isn't even NOS, but it is also crazy cheap. If it was still being made it would be very expensive, it just happens not to be. Modern stuff has value, but I don't know that it delivers the best value.
- You raise some stuff about shape. I have a grinder, I could care less how it came out of someone's shop, over time it will be all mine, and normally that is what the people who use this stuff prefer. They aren't looking forward to a new chisel, even from a master's shop, that is more consumer thinking, not craftsman thinking.
Overall, I don't see much that is convincing there. The only really concrete one will be on edgeholding, which to me can go either way, unless the materials being cut are very aggressive on edges; the user is very careless; and depending on sharpening equipment and skill.