Question for Derek - Chisels
Guillaume Dery
Hey Derek,
I really appreciated the comparative study you did on the different steels in chisels when doing dovetails (PMV-11, White Steel, O1 and A2 as I recall).
Just getting back to forums and the shop after a fairly long hiatus due to moves and new babies (wow do they ever take a lot of energy) so I just read your write-up this week.
So I just picked up a set of pig-stickers at the semi-annual Tools of the Trade antique tool meet here near Toronto. After much swearing, cursing, getting a coarser diamond plate, swearing, more lapping, I almost have one ready to go (except for needing to rehandle it of course).
So I thought to myself, bugger this, time is at too much of a premium with 3 wee ones. There is no bloody way I am spending this amount of time on chisels of marginal quality. I am going to buy net new and get myself more sawdust time.
Well a few emails later (yes the question is finally coming, I tend to ramble on), a little birdie told me that Rob & co. will be releasing Veritas Mortise chisels in PMV-11 (release date TBD).
So the question (finally), based on your experience and tests, how well do you think the PMV-11 would hold up to pounding out a mortise vs paring. I am sllightly worried about chipping. I also realize that only experience will tell for sure but I would appreciate your educated guess on the matter.
Right now I am on the fence between waiting for the LVs, ordering some Japanese Mortise chisels or ordering up some of the Ray Iles pig stickers. In all honesty, I have rather ruled out the third option as I have heard that that steel is a real bugger to flatten the back and sharpen and I am not inclined to replace my water stones. So I am inclined to wait for the LV Mortise Chisels but just thought I'd poll you on your thoughts on how the PMV-11 would hold up to serious pounding abuse.
Sorry to ramble on.
Guillaume










