New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Question for Derek - Chisels

Posts

Question for Derek - Chisels

#1

Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Hey Derek,

I really appreciated the comparative study you did on the different steels in chisels when doing dovetails (PMV-11, White Steel, O1 and A2 as I recall).

Just getting back to forums and the shop after a fairly long hiatus due to moves and new babies (wow do they ever take a lot of energy) so I just read your write-up this week.

So I just picked up a set of pig-stickers at the semi-annual Tools of the Trade antique tool meet here near Toronto. After much swearing, cursing, getting a coarser diamond plate, swearing, more lapping, I almost have one ready to go (except for needing to rehandle it of course).

So I thought to myself, bugger this, time is at too much of a premium with 3 wee ones. There is no bloody way I am spending this amount of time on chisels of marginal quality. I am going to buy net new and get myself more sawdust time.

Well a few emails later (yes the question is finally coming, I tend to ramble on), a little birdie told me that Rob & co. will be releasing Veritas Mortise chisels in PMV-11 (release date TBD).

So the question (finally), based on your experience and tests, how well do you think the PMV-11 would hold up to pounding out a mortise vs paring. I am sllightly worried about chipping. I also realize that only experience will tell for sure but I would appreciate your educated guess on the matter.

Right now I am on the fence between waiting for the LVs, ordering some Japanese Mortise chisels or ordering up some of the Ray Iles pig stickers. In all honesty, I have rather ruled out the third option as I have heard that that steel is a real bugger to flatten the back and sharpen and I am not inclined to replace my water stones. So I am inclined to wait for the LV Mortise Chisels but just thought I'd poll you on your thoughts on how the PMV-11 would hold up to serious pounding abuse.

Sorry to ramble on.

Guillaume

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#2

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Guillaume

I have no doubt that the PM-V11 mortice chisels will hold up very well. I say this although I have not used them because I suspect that mortice chisels are least affected by steel type, and the steel does not matter as much as it would for slimly built bench chisels.

I have in mind the English Oval Bolstered variety, although it probably does not matter. Mine are prepared in the traditional manner: 20 degree primary bevel and a 35 degree secondary.


I have 1/4" and 3/8" Ray Isle and a bunch of vintage chisels from the UK, mostly Ward, that I have collected over the years. These range in size from 1/8", which get a fair amount of use, to 1/2". The RI are D2 steel and the vintage are a high carbon steel ("cast steel"). The D2 steel is noticeably better but the carbon steel ones do excellent service, and I'd be quite happy with them if they were the only ones I had. Having said this, the D2 would be my choice if I was morticing every day (which as a hobbiest I am not).

I think that the reason for the carbon steel doing so much better than their O1 bench chisel cousins is that, firstly, the steel at the edge of the bevel is so much thicker and, two, the bevel angle is a high 35 degrees. One does not need an ultra sharp in a mortice chisel. The blunter edge is sufficient.

I would expect the PM-V11 steel to outlast a comparable chisel made of A2. I am not as confident of this being the case when compared with D2.

English vs Japanese? For working with our local hardwoods, the English suit me better. I had some Japanese mortice chisels and found them too short and too thick in the primary bevel (30 degrees) to work as efficiently. I think you will get others who reply that they feel differently, which just demonstrates how subjective all this is.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#3

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

wilbur

I think you will get others who reply that they feel differently, which just demonstrates how subjective all this is.

Must…keep…mouth…shut…… :D

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#4

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Heh .. Wilbur, I knew that last comment about the Japanese mortice chisels would get your attention! :)

Go on .... !

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#5

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

GD, where are you in Toronto. You don't have to go crazy on those, they are worked off the bevel, if you bought them x decades old, and nobody fettled them yet, maybe we should park the extremism from the magazines.

On the other, hand, the Japanese chisels are kind of pointless to buy if you don't intend on making the best of them. They mostly look set-up for Shoji type work where the mortices are shallowish, and may be flat bottomed, for which the bevels are appropriate. i started out with Japanese tools back in the 70s, or 80s. The biggest problem with them is that a lot of people use them, but it is rare to find people who use them for the work they were intended for. The larger mortises, that the Japanese cut in timber for buildings are not cut with these chisels, even though the work is in some respects stouter.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#6

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels *LINK*

Doug Trembath

Guillaume, obviously I am not Derek, but I do have an opinion, and that's what these forums are for, right?

First of all, as Derek pointed out, a mortise chisel doesn't have the same forces, and related concerns, that a bench chisel may have. I have been using a few old mortise chisels quite successfully for many years, but recently needed a size I didn't have. What to do...

I purchased a set of Narex® Mortise Chisels from Lee Valley, in order to ensure I didn't run up against this problem again (unless a client had some pretty particular needs, which I doubt will happen).

Here's a link to them below. Coincidentally, I ordered them when they were having the introductory sale, but they haven't gone up much...

Just a personal note aside from the recommendation, mortise chisels perform through brute force, cutting the fibers at the cutting edge, but tearing them along the sides. You can find a multitude of discussions regarding this process in the archives and search function on this and any other hand tool discussion website you choose. There's really no need for a mortise chisel to be absolutely flat. Sharp, absolutely yes. Flat all along the back, not so much. Using good technique in maintaining a perpendicular approach with the chisel is much more important.

The Narex chisels performed extremely well for me, right out of the box. Of course, I just HAD to fiddle with them, and got them quite a bit sharper, resulting in even better performance, but as Derek pointed out, a micro bevel of 30 to 35 degrees adds sufficient strengthening to allow you to bang away at these tools with little regard for their welfare, IMHO. They have significantly reduced the time I spend in mortising, mostly because the grinding of the sides was so precise it was easy to cut my fingers when I held them by the blade instead of the handle. Ok, I learned a lesson in using new tools instead of old ones...

'Nuff said, I guess. For what, something like $12 per chisel, you get some really nice tools. PMV-11 is really nice when you need it, but in this man's opinion, your money would be much better spent buying some really nice wood...

As I said, just one man's experience and opinion, YMMV...

Good luck with your decision.

Doug Trembath


Narex Mortise chisels

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#7

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

So when I look at those Narex chisels, they aren't inspiring. Which is just fine. But sometimes the perfect is the enemy of the good. The pig stickers already bought could be made into really functional chisels, in less time than will likely be used to buy and sharpen the Narex's. So is the real thing that the PSs are too much trouble or that one will only accept them if they look as good as a set costing 100 each. The PSs I bought at the Tools of the Trades a few years back are still just sitting there. I am going to make them up some day, when the right piece of Osage pops onto my table, and I have the time, and so forth. That works for me, since I have countless other chisels to choose from. But if I had to use them I am sure I could get them up and working in short order, but I might take a few shortcuts like epoxy for the handles. I think the overall effect would still be better than the Narex. Cast steel is better than most anything else out there.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#8

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Doug Trembath

To be honest, Tom, I'm not certain what your actual question is. If you already have enough chisels to do the work you wish to do, I'd use them, if it were me.

I don't collect chisels, I make stuff with them. I found the Narex to do exactly what I needed them to do, and they didn't cost a lot of money. Didn't take a lot of setup to accomplish the mortises I needed them for, and they outperformed the TH Witherby's I have, in my opinion, because they were set up to cut very well right out of the factory. (I didn't work the Weatherby's as much as I maybe should have, but we're talking mortises here, right? Not exactly rocket science or orthopedic surgery...)

I collect Bedrock flat side planes, instead. (Still need 603, 604-1/2, 605-1/4, 605-1/2, and 607 in case anyone has some to get rid of).

If you have some good old cast steel mortise chisels, and need some Osage Orange to handle them with, I happened to be at Rockler this week here in the Pittsburgh area, and they had some really nice boards for sale. Don't know when I'll get back there, because its about 40 miles away, but you could check the store online...

Cast steel is wonderful for woodworking tools, but I'd think that the PMV-11 the OP asked about would trump it in some instances. I just don't think a guy needs to spend that amount of money to effectively put mortises in a piece of wood. But, as I said earlier, someone else's mileage may vary, just this man's opinion...

Let me know if I missed the point of your post, Tom...

Doug Trembath

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#9

Another factor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

PM V11 is a stainless steel. So if rust is a problem in your shop it won't be with this steel. Additionally, any steel that functions acceptably chopping out dovetails is going to be more than adequate to be driven into a mortise.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#10

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

Thanks, Doug, I was just rattling on in the thread. I've got all the chisels I will even need, my point to the OP is that if the time hitch is that he needs to handle these things beautifully, rather than buy less beautiful chisels than the ones he has, why not just do an expedient slap on. I handled some files with cherry branches never bothered to upgrade them. I got your point that there are decent value chisels, I just don't really see how already having some chisels he wouldn't be better off using the ones he has. Just spend less time making them something perfect out of a CS blog. Over time he can easily upgrade them to whatever standard he wants.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#11

Re: Another factor

TomD

A lot of these older chisels, while not rated for marine use, are not as prone to rust as modern steels seem to be particularly if they are partially iron with a lamination of steel.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#12

speed lapping

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

I went through a e-bay / chisel episode a while back and ended up flattening lots of backs. Set aside the diamond stone and other lapping supplies until AFTER you use a belt sander. ~100 grit belt and a careful 20 seconds of effort will flatten most chisel backs in a big hurry. Step up grits if you want to save more lapping time to achieve a mirror finish.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#13

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Patrick Gibbons

I use 1/4" or 3/8" mortises for almost all my projects. Once the tenon is glued in, no one will ever know what size the mortise was. It would be easy to get by with just a 1/4" chisel. You already own one, I suspect, if you bought a set. Fettle the 1/4" and use it for all your mortises until you need another size. You can go through many projects before you need that next size. Something smaller can be done with bench chisels. I can count on one hand the number of times I needed a mortise chisel larger than 3/8".

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#14

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

TomD

That is pretty much my experience also. I use the heavier ones on certian projects like making planes. Though bevel chisels work fine there also.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#15

Re: speed lapping

TomD

Yeah, that is what I use my 2x72 for. No hand tool woodworker should be without one. One can use a regular hand tool type sander, but the platens normally are not flat, so the results are hardly going to be lapping.

I should have an open house since I am just down the road a bit from the TOTT, and offer free sharpening and coffee to the folks who haul stuff out of there.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#16

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

david weaver

The ray iles chisels are the best I've used for mortising, and I never had to resort to anything other than waterstones with them. They sharpen fine on the old king type stones, as well as on the shaptons.

I only have japanese mortise chisels now, but will admit that I liked the ray iles chisels better. I just got the itch to not have two sets of very nice chisels where one never got used, and I believe even at that, having a "set" of mortise chisels is indulgence to begin with. Rather having one for thin stock, one for regular 7/8 kind of stuff and a single large one (maybe not even the last) would be fine.

The other benefit of the ray iles chisels as the large oval bolstered types go is they aren't as bulky as a lot of the vintage chisels - in terms of the height of the steel cross section. It is no problem to use them to make 1" long and 1" deep types of small mortises - there is plenty of room to work them.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#17

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

Patrick Gibbons

I have a Ray Iles mortise chisel and agree with your positive comments on the tool. Mine required very little fettling, as I remember. I sharpened it to round over the bevel. Because of its' use, D2 metal, heft, etc, it seems to need honing infrequently. The edge holds up very well.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#18

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Thanks for the comprehensive reply Derek. I've started rehabilitating the pig stickers. 5 hours on the Atoms 140x diamond plate to get the 1/2 inch one reasonably flat. Next up is sharpening, then rehandling...

I will wait to see what LV comes out with to see if I want to add those or the RIs. How do you find the RIs to sharpen? I admit the thought of sharpening D2 on my Water stones worries me a bit.

On a related note, any thoughts on jigs to hold pig stickers for sharpening? Can't get them in either my Tormek jigs or the LV ones and the eclipse has a hard time holding them, much less square...

For all other readers, I have no interest in starring a guide vs freehand holy war. With my broken wrist, free handing is out for the foreseeable future (at least one more month in a cast...aaargh)

Thanks,

Guillaume

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#19

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Hi Tom,

I'm actually in Ottawa, I just did the drive down to Pickering for the tools of the trade show. I just couldn't resist a set of four pig stickers from 1/8 to 1/2 inch for forty bucks. However the amount of sweat equity I am going to have to put in makes it not so great a deal. That being said, with the broken wrist, I'm not going to be making shavings or sawdust anytime soon so I might as well rehabilitate them (although rehandling will definitely h have to wait).

Good point about intended use for Japanese tools, I was just looking at it from the perspective of white steel being able to take substantial abuse. That being said, I do love the Japanese chisels i do own and am almost certainly not always using them as intended.

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#20

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

I've actually played with some of a buddy's Narex. They needed a substantial amount or initial fettling but were surprisingly good. However, I can't get past the ugly factor. They make my old Bluechips look downright stately and elegant. I'll just rehabilitate the pig stickers for now.

Chisels are kind of like girlfriends, you don't need the prettiest or most expensive but you do need to find them at least cute to initially take them home

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#21

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Yup, 3/8 and 1/4 are 90 percent of my mortises. I will however end up fettling all of them. Of course I started with the one I will probably never use some I figured I would start with the largest so that the job got easier as I went along.

Looks like my initial spend of 40 will require additional investments however. Seems like a belt sander is in my near future based on some previous replies...

Guillaume

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#22

Re: The Ray Iles chisels

Guillaume Dery

Dammit, now you guys have me thinking that I need to order the 3/8 RI....

I need to stop reading replies to my questions...

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#23

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Five hours??? Have you considered getting a powered grinder?

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#24

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

Guillaume Dery

Maybe I'm dense but how does a grinder help with flattening the back? Not that this is a fairly huge chisel and the back was black, oxidised, pitted, bellied and twisted and curved up at the tip (some previous owner obviously got tired of lapping and lifted the chisel as they spelled the back).

The broken wrist is probably showing me down some too...

Re: Question for Derek - Chisels

#25

Honing a mortice chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

On a related note, any thoughts on jigs to hold pig stickers for sharpening? Can't get them in either my Tormek jigs or the LV ones and the eclipse has a hard time holding them, much less square...

Hi Guillaume

I've put together a few pictures for you ...

There are honing guides that will hold the thick/deep sides of a mortice chisel, such as the Kell #1.


I have one and used it for some years even when I was freehand honing all my other chisels.

These days my preference is to freehand the mortice chisels as well, and the method I use takes little time and, importantly, allows for very easy stropping as the edge dulls.

The aim is to grind (I use a diamond stone) and then hone (I use waterstones) a rounded 35 degree bevel. Paul Sellers has provided videos on this method, which are no doubt available on Youtube. I do not use the rounded bevel for my other chisels, which are hollow ground, but the rounded bevel is perfect for a mortice chisel. Easy to do and refresh, and it creates a very strong edge for a task that involves "abuse".

The method involves pulling the chisel back at 20 degrees (the angle of the primary bevel) and, as you do so, lift the blade (while still pulling back) until it reaches 35 degrees ....


Keep a sliding bevel set at 35 degrees propped up at the near end of the stone to provide a visual guide to 35 degrees.

Here is the only photo I have of the rounded bevel. This is sharp enough to pare pine.


Stropping to refresh the edge is done on a leather strop (from TFWW) using Veritas green compound. I strop frequently. Below are images of stropping a hollow ground bench chisel. This is pulled back at an angle. The mortice chisel may be pulled straight back (no angle) (... just did not have another photo to hand).


This could keep a mortice chisel sharp for a long time.

Regards from Perth

Derek