New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

New toothed plane blades problems?

Posts

New toothed plane blades problems?

#1

New toothed plane blades problems?

Bruce McCrory

I heard that toothed blades improved planing in contrary (wild grain) wood, eliminating tear out. In a recent blog post, the author complained that his LV plane (LA Jack, I think) with toothed blade, had a lot of tear out. The Veritas toothed blades have a 38-degree bevel, producing an approx. 50-degree cutting angle in a bevel up low angle smoother. The antique planes are set at upwards of 90-degrees.

Have people had trouble using Veritas toothed blades, and if so, was a solution found? Thanks,

(Edited for bevel error.)

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#2

When I use a toothed blade (six times this year)

Chuck Nickerson

it's always on a board that's already giving me tear-out.

When I switch to the toothed blade it always gives me less tear-out, sometimes none.

It's a great help but no silver bullet.

YMMV

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#3

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

Chuck Bjorgen

I picked up a LV BU Jack Plane off a local Craigslist that included both the toothed blade and the 38 degree a-2 blade along with the standard 25 degree PM V-11 blade. On a test piece of junk red oak pallet wood,I was getting terrible tear out with the 25 degree blade. I tried the toothing blade and it seemed to cut into the surface fairly well but obviously the surface was left rough. I then tried the 38 degree blade and it left a fairly decent surface. Not perfect but better than the standard cutter.

There's a good video from Lie-Nielsen on using the toothed blade.

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#4

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

Tom

1) The reason, AYK, that toothing reduces tear out, is that it segments the shaving. so one thing to watch out for is whether your blade projection is such that the teeth get in so far that there is a web of solid material creating a full width shaving.

2) Deeper groves will make maters better as regards 1).

3) Low bedding angles will make maters worse, as on your plane.

4) steepening the bevel will make maters worse as regards getting clearance, though as you mention it has other beneficial effects.

While obviously LV would take all this into consideration in their design, it does seem a category where the traditional system of bevel down, steep bedding, cutting angle independent of bevel angle, are going to have the advantage.

In the applications I am aware of, the uses are to prep for glueing, and to plane wood where teaspoon sized chunks can spall off. If you just want to get a smooth surface there are other techniques that will probably work more directly.

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#5

Maybe, depends....

Bruce McCrory

So far, a toother in a BU low angle plane might, could, maybe not, and depends on many factors for usefulness. The antiques bear fewer ambiguities. :\

I wonder if that thing can be adapted to a DIY woody?

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#6

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

Michael Brady

The toothed blade in my Lie-Nielsen Low angle jack plane works very well in any woods I have applied it to. It does not tear wood, however you have to be very careful when following with a smoother that the cut is just barely removing the tiny grooves left by the the toothing blade. Otherwise you are just inviting the same tearout that would occur if you had not used the toothed blade beforehand.

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#7

Worked well in crotch mahogany

Roger Myers

I used the LV toothed iron in their bevel up smoother to flatten a crotch mahogany panel that I had resawn.... This was some extremely wild crotch figure that also had black tinted epoxy filling some cracks. I went from the bandsaw to the toothed iron and then straight to a cabinet scraper. Ended up with a great surface. The cabinet scraper made short work of going from the toothed surface to a final surface.

The panel was used in the lid of my tool chest...I believe I had posted pics of that here earlier this year, and you can also see it on my website...strathamwood.com

I also have a 18th century toothing plane with iron set at near 90 degrees, but use that primarily in preparing veneers and surfaces for veneering.

Roger

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#8

Re: Worked well in crotch mahogany

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Roger. Natural assumption is that the antique is better for veneer. I'd build a beater box, use that, and display the mahogany 6-drawer if it was mine.

I remember your posting of the music stand. Beautiful work!

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#9

Re: Worked well in crotch mahogany

Brian Greene

There are (at least) two different functions for a toothed blade: preparing a surface for veneer and to flatten a board whilst minimizing tear out. For a veneer a think old planes demonstrate that a high angle was preferred. For tear our reduction on wildly figured boards, a low angle BU works fine. In both cases a light cut and a sharp iron are essential. I don't use it a lot but when I do it reduces tear out significantly.

Brian in Ottawa

Re: New toothed plane blades problems?

#10

another traditional use for a toothing iron

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

There is a third traditional use for a toothing iron. Patternmakers adapt them for use as turning tools. A traditional scraper will twist and catch when turning on a face plate due to the different speeds on the inner and outer edges of a 2" wide scraper. A toothing iron will act like several dozen micro diamond point tools held close together, safely allowing you to use a 2" wide flat scraper when turning on a face plate.

Robin