My closure on "Made in China" bias?
Bruce McCrory
I didn't start this post with human security, safety, or politics in mind. It was a simple "in my experience observation" and "am I alone in this premise?" A followup comment made a compelling argument for human and environmental considerations. These have always been in line with my own views. Woodnet forums has something similar going on.
Do we support regressive, oppressive, and forced child labor because the clothes are cheap, cashews that I love are cheap, cheaper, or cheapest due to cost of labor and lack of any safety or environmental protections. Do I blow off as immaterial my dollars buying bullets to kill ethnic rivals--and a diamond? Do we justify our purchase thinking it "may" lead to humanitarian improvement? We can always stuff our heads under pillows, or scream white noise, or spout moronic denials when we can't ignore a problem. Do we simply give up? This last question always reminds me of a population experiment using mice I saw 50 years ago. Toward the end subjects shut their eyes and “zoned” out.
On the other hand, when will social and environmental costs be included in the cost of production? I am paying for all these ‘hidden” and ignored costs anyway.
To blow off quality control issues as "you get what you pay for" falls under the Moronic Denial Header. My power company gave me free Low energy CFL light bulbs in a program to reduce regional power demands. I entrust the power company with the obligation to control the quality of the product they gave to me. They justified the bulb's potential value based on time in use, and then it failed far sooner due to lack of production control. I bought a $5 bulb to accomplish what a $0.50 bulb will do; plus, I will pay for its disposal and recycling at far greater cost than the $0.50 bulb—fluorescents’ are more toxic than incandescent. The cost of resources loss, disposal, recycling, and environmental/health hazards is far more significant than most professionals in the field will divulge. A free light bulb is never free.
We in the US avoid the distasteful end-of-life costs because it is cheaper to produce and buy something without those costs attached. It is, “Out of sight, out of mind”. Not oddly, the business selling me the product is smart enough to bypass safety and hazard controls by sending production to a country with no controls. A poorly manufactured product still has all of the same costs as one that is well manufactured. Plus, we were screwed over when we paid for it.
What does all this have to do with hand tools?
An example: I paid $8, plus shipping, for a made in China stainless steel and bubinga scaled knife that was worthless for use because the steel was soft. It cost far more in un-accounted pollution hazards, health hazards, resource waste in production, and resources waste in disposal. All this waste in order to advertise and sell a cheap knife, and I am assured that the marketer is one of the good guys. I guess LV is unable to control quality from China as well.