New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

"Made in China" bias?

Posts

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#26

Re: I Agree

Paul M.

Hi David,

"I haven't interviewed anyone in China, but my understanding of the plight of the average individual who doesn't have special papers is that factory jobs are quite a step up from what was available before them. "

The recent changes in China have been quite dramatic. Low-level government officials are taking family farms for way under their value, then using this to expand factories at their own profit via bribes from western companies. The displaced farm workers have no place to go other than work at the factories, because of the low compensation from taking their land. They wind up at places like foxcon making apple devices, and then jump from the roofs to end their misery. The response from foxcon is to install nets to protect their workers. Foxcon picture is shown below.

I personally try to avoid china made items as much as possible. The workers really have no recourse other than work in dangerous environments for way below a living wage.


img

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#27

Re: I Agree

BrianMonumentCO

Are you sure the nets are to protect the jumping workers (as implied) or the workers walking underneath the jumping workers?

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#28

Re: "Made in China" bias?

North of the Border

That made good sense. I paid much more for my Japanese car, not because it was made in Japan (made and assembled in the Ontario plant?), but because its quality can hardly be matched by other American or Korean brands. Of course, buyers be aware and prices alone are not always a reliable indicator about quality or performance.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#29

Buy local

Lars Parrington

Regardless of the quality of the item you are purchasing, when you buy Made in China or the equivalent, a small fraction of your money goes to China and the workers there. Each purchase thus slightly reduces the relative wealth of the USA compared to China. A larger fraction of your money spent goes into the bank account of an upper class American, and not much goes to middle or lower classes. Thus jobs are lost here, and there is an increase in the economic divide in our country.

The best option is to buy local. When you purchase something locally, a lot of the money stays in your community, improving the lives and finances of your neighbors. In turn, those neighbors are much more likely to turn around and support your buisness than someone who lives in china or someone who owns a import buisness.

The next best is to buy Made in USA. At least that way the money stays in our country, and hopefully a significant amount of it is going into the pocketbooks of middle and lower class Americans.

Just think of buying from China as having the same effect on your country as buying from Wallmart has had on our small towns.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#30

My closure on "Made in China" bias?

Bruce McCrory

I didn't start this post with human security, safety, or politics in mind. It was a simple "in my experience observation" and "am I alone in this premise?" A followup comment made a compelling argument for human and environmental considerations. These have always been in line with my own views. Woodnet forums has something similar going on.

Do we support regressive, oppressive, and forced child labor because the clothes are cheap, cashews that I love are cheap, cheaper, or cheapest due to cost of labor and lack of any safety or environmental protections. Do I blow off as immaterial my dollars buying bullets to kill ethnic rivals--and a diamond? Do we justify our purchase thinking it "may" lead to humanitarian improvement? We can always stuff our heads under pillows, or scream white noise, or spout moronic denials when we can't ignore a problem. Do we simply give up? This last question always reminds me of a population experiment using mice I saw 50 years ago. Toward the end subjects shut their eyes and “zoned” out.

On the other hand, when will social and environmental costs be included in the cost of production? I am paying for all these ‘hidden” and ignored costs anyway.

To blow off quality control issues as "you get what you pay for" falls under the Moronic Denial Header. My power company gave me free Low energy CFL light bulbs in a program to reduce regional power demands. I entrust the power company with the obligation to control the quality of the product they gave to me. They justified the bulb's potential value based on time in use, and then it failed far sooner due to lack of production control. I bought a $5 bulb to accomplish what a $0.50 bulb will do; plus, I will pay for its disposal and recycling at far greater cost than the $0.50 bulb—fluorescents’ are more toxic than incandescent. The cost of resources loss, disposal, recycling, and environmental/health hazards is far more significant than most professionals in the field will divulge. A free light bulb is never free.

We in the US avoid the distasteful end-of-life costs because it is cheaper to produce and buy something without those costs attached. It is, “Out of sight, out of mind”. Not oddly, the business selling me the product is smart enough to bypass safety and hazard controls by sending production to a country with no controls. A poorly manufactured product still has all of the same costs as one that is well manufactured. Plus, we were screwed over when we paid for it.

What does all this have to do with hand tools?

An example: I paid $8, plus shipping, for a made in China stainless steel and bubinga scaled knife that was worthless for use because the steel was soft. It cost far more in un-accounted pollution hazards, health hazards, resource waste in production, and resources waste in disposal. All this waste in order to advertise and sell a cheap knife, and I am assured that the marketer is one of the good guys. I guess LV is unable to control quality from China as well.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#31

Re: I Agree

david weaver

Do we really think such things didn't happen to some extent here and in England?

The change will come from within when there is some economic mobility, and it already is to some extent.

For us to expect that working in a factory there and living there should be just like it is here, but the people look different, is naive.

My mother, who is an avid NEA card carrying "everything should be single payer and the government should control all businesses to make sure nobody gets rich" advocate loved the idea of China until she went there, but I think she was also being naive thinking that it would be her idea of utopia (their guide told them that she was in jail over papers - she had permission to be in an urban area but was walking without her papers and got thrown in the clink for a while after a random search).

I wonder what we would think of the conditions cutlers and foundry men worked in here if we had a chance to see it. There are plenty of videos on youtube of folks working in factories in china, and they do not appear to be staged - not foxconn, but places like rocket stove factories, etc, where the folks in general don't appear to be rushing from one place to another counting their breaths until the last one.

Change takes time. Cutting off everyone is not the answer, in my opinion. Perhaps it can be effected more quickly if support of the better places in china is done.

Personally, i have more ire for the retailers who mark things up by a factor of 10 and drop quality US made goods because not only is the money involved in the china goods a fraction of first world goods, but the margin is that much better, too. That's basically what's happened that I can see with most mail order suppliers - they can't resist removing good items and putting tool-shaped objects and knock-offs in their stores and catalogs. If they were passing along the savings, it would be different.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#32

Re: Buy local

North of the Border

Unfortunately, many items these days we need or want are only available from China or Asia, because we no longer make them (TV sets for example).

Visit not just Walmart, but Sears, Target and you name it...everything that is affordable is not locally made or made in the US. Heck, even some less affordable things are made in China or Asia, too (because the importers want to keep the profits).

But then, if we stopped buying things from China and China had no foreign reserve to spare, who is going to buy the US gov't issued debts? Chicken and egg... (Don't rely on Japan...it has its own share of economic problems.)

Even in Canada where we don't have to rely on China for its money, many Chinese state-run companies are investing in us...and the profits made by these Canadian companies (owned partly by China) or Chinese companies operating in Canada will see the money go back to China. Can we stop it? No, unless the global trading system is replaced by something else. This is a problem (or is it?) that no one can figure out a solution.

It is easy to say buy local...only if we can produce goods competitive enough. Veritas is a good example of that.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#33

Re: Alibaba Express

david weaver

One last comment from me. There are plenty of things that I like to get from china, aside from the cuisinart crap and other such things a lot of us get (actually, some of their items have served us well, despite their origin).

But what I like tends to float over into the tool, sharpening stone, gadget world and I've purchased from the source several times on the alibaba express site or whatever it's called that lets you make individual purchases. If they could get their postal system in order, they'd have a real killer setup.

I've purchased two things from woodwell and three sharpening stones in the last year, and a bunch of stuff from individuals in china on ebay, and in all cases, what I ordered got here. Strangely enough, the only thing I'm missing is a marking knife that never got here from an ebay seller in japan named Tomonori Nakaoka (330mate). I guess I'll probably never see it. Plenty of things i have ordered from him did come through.

In a case where I can go direct to china and avoid someone marking something up 14 times here, or go direct to china for any less at all and put the money in the hands of the people there who are making or distributing things, I will. I don't know if it's making any difference, but I don't set out to change the world or pretend that I could sum up what would bring nirvana there, and I think it's naive for anyone to think they can or could.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#34

Re: Wal Mart

david weaver

I'm always curious as to why wal mart is the butt of everything. We had kmart and every other discount retailer trying to do the same thing, they just weren't very good at it. It's not as if we'd have lovely main streets if walmart didn't exist, but I guess we'd have everyone setting up to shoot barbs at someone other than walmart. We don't shop small town or main street, people have more exposure.

Walmart is the butt of all of it, but have any of us looked at any of the clothing retailers? Furniture retailers? It's the same thing.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#35

Re: "Made in China" experience....today....

roger lance

I've recently taken up shooting handguns for recreation....bought a couple of Smith & Wesson revolvers.....and being a combat Vietnam vet, I'm interested in being able to "field strip" (at least) these weapons for cleaning. So I need some small hollow ground screwdrivers and I just bought a set of Wheeler screwdrivers from my local firearms dealer. Wheeler is suppose to be a good name in gunsmithing....owned by Midway USA....another good name company. Got the Wheelers home....found the correct fitting screwdriver....began to carefully back out the screw....and the tip of the screwdriver broke. I start inspecting the packaging and find a "Made in China" label.....tomorrow, I'll take this product back to the store to see if they will stand behind it and return my money. If not....life goes on. Before this, I was looking at some small screwdrivers from Starrett and will go back there when this is resolved.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#36

Re: I Agree

BrianMonumentCO

You are entitled to your opinion.

Just don't call people naive.

Because that may in fact be naive as well.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#37

Re: Wal Mart

BrianMonumentCO

It makes it easier when wally world claimed many products made in USA.

Now it is hard to find anything in wally world that is made in USA short of food.

I think is just the swing from USA to China that makes wally world (wal mart) the target.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#38

We Gunsmiths use magna-tip from brownells

BrianMonumentCO

Buy the magna-tip products from brownells.

They work. They fit most every screw on any gun.

And they used to warranteed against breakage.

I Don't know if they still are.

And unlike my views on made in china if these bits were made in china I would still buy them.

They are the best.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#39

Re: We Gunsmiths use magna-tip from brownells

Bruce McCrory

"And unlike my views on made in china if these bits were made in china I would still buy them.

They are the best. "

Until the Chinese company sending them to Brownells subcontracts the production to the outfit producing for and supplying to Horrific Fright. 8)

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#40

Re: We Gunsmiths use magna-tip from brownells

BrianMonumentCO

Perhaps, I should have said as long as the quality remains the same, I will continue to buy them.

Also I currently own several sets.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#41

Re: "Made in China" experience....today....

Tom

I bought a set of chapman replaceable tip gunsmith screw drivers, say, back in the 70s. The tip on one of them broke in a screw. Not the first time I used it. Chapmans were the virtually the first replaceable tip screw drivers, and probably the first gunsmith set. Made in USA.

With your Smiths, there may even be a set of Brownell magnatips that you can get specifically for that revolver, or class of revolvers. These babies need to be hard, and fit is important. Of course also important for the screw that the bit fits well also.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#42

Re: Wal Mart

Tom

I think it is nothing more complicated than that they have had the success they have had. Not merely envy, but they have become essential to many people so their performance matters. For instance I read an article that said they were failing to get the stuff that arrives at the stores onto the shelves and for sale, because they had cut back on staff so heavily. One can imagine various agendas that could be behind such a critical article, but I had noticed that one had trouble navigating my store for all the unopened cartons in the aisles, yet the product isn't on the shelves... So whether someone is pushing an article like that for political reasons, or competitive ones, it still speaks to my experience in the store.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#43

Re: Buy local

Tom

This stuff is well above my pay grade, but most people don't understand trade or comparative advantage. When I worked at the securities association, we had visits from the trade office asking us what we wanted from various ongoing negotiations. We had access to very sophisticated economics and finance professionals, and yet it was clear they didn't understand the questions being put to them well enough to formulate an ask.

I also wish I understood better the meaning of buying a ton of goods from someone paying in US dollars they fully intend to destroy the value of. One thing a dollar bill is not, is a guarantee of the future value of goods it can purchase. This is looking like the best deal since the purchase of Manhattan.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#44

Re: I Don't

Tom

"Do we really think such things didn't happen to some extent here and in England?"

If we are talking about a different time period, I would be unimpressed since I think there is a huge difference between having seen this film before, and not. Put it this way, I will excuse their ignorance of where all this leads, and relevant moral issues to the extent they also are willing to pass on ripping off all our other knowledge also. If they don't want the pollution info, great, you don't get any of our machinery, or electronics inventions either. Of course they are free to take what they want, and more. So I feel free to think about it exactly as I please. There is apparently a race for the bottom on ethics, and race for the top on economics.

"For us to expect that working in a factory there and living there should be just like it is here, but the people look different, is naive."

But it would be naive to believe it is some kind of perfection that has been arrived at also. It is what it is, just as everywhere else, and it is subject to criticism, helpful and otherwise. Weakening chinese soft deplomacy would seem to be to our advantage.

I would like to believe there is actually a strategy somewhere. Human rights and pollution arguments are mostly just carrying water for some other policy. Nobody seriously cares about that stuff. In the long run damage to the chinese population might be to our advantage. It is hard to see how fighting over air defence zones, who gets our silent props, what aircraft carrier they have launched, whether they stole the 400 billion design of the F35, etc... is consistent with a worry over whether conditions for chinese production could be improved.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#45

Re: "Made in China" experience....today....

BrianMonumentCO

Screwdriver bits need to be hard but not at the limit of steel.

It must be tempered back from "glass hard".

IE it must have a toughness.

For a gunsmith to use it the blade must also be hollow ground.

And due to the variances in gun screws the blades must come in a variety of thicknesses and also a variety of widths.

The Brownells sets come in those variations and include Torx, phillips, and some other special bits.

By the way the term Smith allegedly comes from an old language word Smyte which means to hit.

So there are BlackSmiths that hammer black metal, WhiteSmiths that thammer white metal (tin, silver).

And there are Gunsmiths that hammer well guns. We don't let customers see this.

Smith is a broad term......

There is even a magazine woodsmith implying that wood is hit with a hammer.

I thought only nails would be hit with a hammer in woodworking.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#46

Cool lesson!

Bruce McCrory

"By the way the term Smith allegedly comes from an old language word Smyte which means to hit.

So there are BlackSmiths that hammer black metal, WhiteSmiths that thammer white metal (tin, silver). "

Thanks for the hit lesson. I do wish that my brain had a dictionary, rather than words spontaneously dropping from somewhere; then, having to check for meaning.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#47

Any feedback on Grace USA screwdrivers?

roger lance

My gun store did allow me credit toward another purchase in exchange for return of the Wheeler set. There is a company that sells gunsmithing screwdrivers called Grace USA.....LV offers some of their screwdrivers that are made for woodworkers....any experience with this brand??

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#48

Re: Any feedback on Grace USA screwdrivers?

BrianMonumentCO

I have a set.

But I rarely them except for sacrificial needs.

I still recommend the magna-tip from Brownells.

By the way they package sets for different guns.

And make a package for the NRA.

Still your best bet.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#49

More feedback on Grace USA screwdrivers?

BrianMonumentCO

One or two more thoughts.

While I don't favour those screwdrivers, They don't come in enough widths and thicknesses.

That is what leads to buggered screw slots.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#50

Re: More feedback on Grace USA screwdrivers?

roger lance

Brian.....I appreciate your advice and will be looking at the magna-tips gunsmithing screwdriver set from Brownells.....especially if I develop a greater interest in firearms beyond revolvers.

However, I did get a seven screwdriver set from Grace USA for two reasons. First, they make a set specific for revolvers (S&W, Ruger, & Colt). Second, as it turns out, Grace is located in my home state of Michigan.....and we use to make some fairly good things here once upon a time.....and if I gave a chance for some guys in China to make a living with that Wheeler set, why not give a guy in Michigan a chance to do the same?

The screwdrivers ran from 0.02" to 0.04" in thickness at the working ends and they easily removed the screw that broke the Wheeler driver. Furthermore, Grace claims they will make you a screwdriver to fit any screw on a firearm for $10 which includes shipping to you....that's a pretty good deal.

The connection to this forum for Grace is that they also make screwdrivers for woodworkers/cabinetmakers.