New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

"Made in China" bias?

Posts

"Made in China" bias?

#1

"Made in China" bias?

Bruce McCrory

Is it just knee-jerk reaction, or is everything I acquire that was made in China a really close step to the garbage can, recycle bin, or hospital emergency room?

I hear people say they buy from Harbor Freight for cheap, one-time-use tools. My son bought a multi-tool that played havoc with the whole circuit on the house system. His other purchase never worked.

When CFL bulbs got cheap enough, I started using them. The power company was pushing them. They are made in China and last about as long as typical incandescent. We are still using some from 15 to 20 years ago, 'Made in US'. I have some cheaper LEDs too new to assess but, yah, Made in China.

I now steer clear of LVs "no 'made in' source" (and every other "no source") products.

The emergency room is OT but far scarier than what was mentioned.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#2

Re: "Made in China" bias?

BrianMonumentCO

There are products that are made in China that are of high quality.

I own two Grizzly stationary power tools including a mill and a lathe.

The mill is of high quality and has been used many times.

It is accurate.

The lathe has not been turned on but appears of high quality.

I am sorry that I had to buy something not manufactured in the USA.

But outrageous prices kept me from doing so.

Other products may differ in quality.

There was a couple years back, an article I think in FWW magazine about items made in Taiwan I think it was.

The talk was about contractor saws. IIRC It showed that the quality varied widely based upon the distributor or "labeller" technical representative and level of inspection.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#3

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Bruce McCrory

My post was generic in nature. Highland/Woodcraft have purported success with their Wood River line (China). I still avoid the brand, simply because China has no internal controls for quality, ethics, or safety. The philosophy is "buyer beware", and "what we can get away with is OK".

Several years ago, a puppy of ours accumulated $700 in vet bills from poisoned chow made in China. We could not file for repayment because the Vet sold the product and refused to confirm. The FDA is "trying" to track down another, recent pet product that is killing animals. I suspect their inability is politically tied to Tyson pushing for human consumption chicken products to be processed (made in) China, without the "made in..." label.

I believe your Grizzly products are Taiwan made, which is not mainland China.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#4

Re: "Made in China" bias?

BrianMonumentCO

The label on the Grizzly says "Made in China" .

I think things made in Taiwan are labeled "Made in Taiwan".

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#5

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Is it just knee-jerk reaction, or is everything I acquire that was made in China a really close step to the garbage can, recycle bin, or hospital emergency room?

I hear people say they buy from Harbor Freight for cheap, one-time-use tools. My son bought a multi-tool that played havoc with the whole circuit on the house system. His other purchase never worked.

When CFL bulbs got cheap enough, I started using them. The power company was pushing them. They are made in China and last about as long as typical incandescent. We are still using some from 15 to 20 years ago, 'Made in US'. I have some cheaper LEDs too new to assess but, yah, Made in China.

I now steer clear of LVs "no 'made in' source" (and every other "no source") products.

The emergency room is OT but far scarier than what was mentioned.

Hi Bruce

As Brian noted, there are high quality goods that come from China.

My take on "Made in China" is this ..

As I write, General Motors (who make Holden, the archetypal Australian motor car brand) are ceasing production of cars in Australia. Why? Basically because we have passed our use-by-date - it is simply that we are too costly, too expensive for the profit margin that GM deems necessary to continue production in Australia. We have a minimum wage structure based on age that ensures all workers, whether qualified or not, receive a liveable wage. One might argue that the population is too small (25 million across the country) to support the industry, but there is also much of the production that gets exported, for example, to the USA. It is just not cost-effective.

Globalisation means that we can move around the world seeking the best production price. It is China today. It will be Africa tomorrow.

One of the concerns I have is how the production costs are reduced - the living conditions of the workers, the safety regulations, the wages paid - just what is done to maintain lower production costs outside of start up costs. Are we covert partners in taking advantage here by buying cheap? The other side of the coin is that we are also covert partners in creating or providing work and income where it may not otherwise be available.

The other reason why costs may be reduced in China is that the Name Brands that use them do so specifically to reduce costs. What that seem to involve (to this shrink using logic not technical knowledge in support) is that goods get built to a specification. The specification is determined by the Name Brand owner and not by the factory. Obviously, lower specs are cheaper. The factories can build to any specification requested. The responsibility for this is not the factory in China, but a Name Brand in the USA (or where ever). The chances are that name branded goods coming from China are going to be build down to a price, but that is not across the board - there are goods that will be carefully build to the same specifications are desired anywhere in the world. So, blame the Name Brand, not the factory.

For many of us a separate issue came to light several years ago with the Woodcraft-WoodRiver fiasco. Woodcraft employed a Chinese factory to make copies of Lie-Nielsen and Lee Valley tools (mostly handplanes, but there were others as well). There were clear issues of both trade dress violation and using original tools to create the moulds. The reason they could do this was because China does not have the same laws about copyrite. One can purchase anything from China - clothes, shoes, pens, watches, etc - all badged to represent the original and none of them linked to the original Name Brand in any way (other than as a replica). And so there is added suspicion of "Made in China".

I would trust companies such as Lee Valley, when they use Chinese factories, to have done their homework and to be making the ethical decisions for us. I am less willing to do so with a company such as Woodcraft and The Japan Woodworker (now owned by Woodcraft, I believe) since they deliberately marketed tools that were replicas of their competition, that is, they went in with their eyes open (it is only recently that WoodRiver have moved away to develop their own designs - but I am still soured by their history).

Regards from Perth

Derek (happy to purchase "Made in China" from the good guys).

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#6

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Bruce McCrory

My bad, Brian. Sorry.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#7

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Bruce McCrory

One of my Drs is Chinese. Our bureaucracy drives him crazy. :)

I think Harbor Freight has useful (in the rough) HSS bar stock. Their drill bits and brad points in HSS are pretty gravelly, but work OK for primitive projects. On the whole, I find little to recommend from China. Not even much of my computer, which is probably their better offering.

Derek, I respect your comments, however they only confirm my original opinion. Brand, specification, and oversight have limited control. Worse, wringing our hands over GM's actions only serves its stockholders greater returns. We're left poorer nations for all that digital friction.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#8

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As I noted earlier, Bruce, choose dealers you trust. It is not the Chinese factory; it is the dealers who decide the quality they wish to sell. Harbor Freight hardly has a reputation for selling quality! :D You mostly get what you pay for.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#9

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Edward in Vancouver

I do deal with mainland China on a very small scale-- custom printed chocolate packaging, for the simple reason that some items are well over 50% cheaper compared to locally (CDN) made packaging. However had to do our homework in selecting a supplier, and we have had to--on one occasion-- send back a shipment of boxes. We could have accepted the shipment, complained, got a discount, used the stuff, and blamed the Chinese for poor quality, but we didn't. And because of that refusal, we ran out of stock and had to scramble and buy at a higher price. It's small potatoes, and we are a small business, but I think it illustrates the situation.

A product made in China needs to be accepted by the receiver in N.America. If the receiver specifies garbage, or knowingly accepts garbage, demands a discount and then fobs it off, it's just as bad as the factory pumping out garbage.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Concur

Ellis Walentine

...goods get built to a specification. The specification is determined by the Name Brand owner and not by the factory. Obviously, lower specs are cheaper. The factories can build to any specification requested. The responsibility for this is not the factory in China, but a Name Brand in the USA (or where ever). The chances are that name branded goods coming from China are going to be build down to a price, but that is not across the board - there are goods that will be carefully build to the same specifications are desired anywhere in the world. So, blame the Name Brand, not the factory.

In '97, I visited Taiwan and toured dozens of factories that produce most of the woodworking machinery sold in the US -- die casters, injection molders, iron foundries, motor manufacturers, machine shops, assembly plants, etc. It was clear that you could get any quality you want, provided you specify it and insist on the Quality Control regimes necessary to make it happen. If you are a US brand, you need to have engineering and QC people on the ground, monitoring and inspecting the output at each stage of the process, or else you're going to get what they give you.

Now that much of the production has moved from Taiwan to mainland China, the same generalizations apply. They can build to spec, but you have to stay on top of QC or you can expect corners to be cut.

Ellis

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#11

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Bob Hackett

I have a digital friend who imports Anyang power hammers for blacksmithing from China. James is as honorable a person as you can find today. When I posted on the blacksmith forum (iforgeiron) about this exact subject some time ago James educated me about how China has all the technology (most of it our own that they acquired for scrap prices) they need to turn out high quality products and meet nearly any spec. His hammers are a testament to their ability.

There is a company that is re-badging what appears to be the exact same hammer to what James imports for far less. The reason they are capable of doing this is because they have greatly relaxed their specs, standards and QC. The company out of India also does not stand behind their hammers. James does. James has personally gone to China and met with the folks who make what he sells. He periodically returns to personally ensure his specs are met or exceeded. He personally runs every one of the hammers he imports and has a history of excellent customer service. James is also a very accomplished blacksmith who`s work speaks for itself. Like I said, James is an honorable man.

That being said I told James that I believe every dollar I personally spend is a vote I personally cast for the kind of world I want to see for my grandchildren`s future. As a result I will NOT support oppressive governments/ regimes or corporations (regardless of where they are based) that do not support safe working conditions, pay their workers wages that allow them to provide their families with an reasonable quality of life or who export jobs to places where uncontrolled pollution of the earth, air and water is common place and accepted.

I value my friendship with James and will support him and his work in any way I can but I will never buy one of his or any other imported machines no matter how well they are made or how much money I have on hand to spend. Not until China changes it`s views on human and worker`s rights, safety in the workplace and global pollution/exploitation of global resources.

To paraphrase a Native American saying; "We do not inherit the Earth from our ancestors, we borrow it from our children`s children".

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#12

A "Made in China" resolution

Bruce McCrory

Amen. Thank you Bob. I could not express your thoughts or convictions as well. My own expression of political humor and venom seems too crass for many, here.

I intend to grow more faithful to LN and LV manufactured goods, but still ignore Lee Valley's Christmas and Gift catalog offerings, despite Derek's assurances to the contrary.

Does that sound like a New Years resolution?

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Two separate issues.....

Jesper, Denmark

On the subject of manufactured quality, we had exactly this same discussions 20 years ago, when US woodworking machinery production was moving to Taiwan. It is the Brand owner's responsibility to ensure that the quality of the goods is what he intends to sell. NO MATTER WHERE IT IS BUILT.

The other question of whether you want to vote with your Dollars about the various human conditions at the point of manufacture is a personal and ethical or some other personal conviction question - not related to quality.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#14

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Before I inherited my uncle's Baldor bench grinder, I owned, over several years, two made-in-Taiwan grinders. One was a no-name, the equivalent of one purchased from Horrible Fright, that vibrated so much it walked across the bench. I could not keep a tool on the pitiful sheet metal rests, because they'd vibrate right off. I gave it to a friend (who is still my friend, amazingly). The other was a Delta-badged grinder, made in the early years of Delta's move to overseas production for its small machines. That one, like my uncle's Baldor, was so stable that I could use it on the bench without bolting it down.

Clearly, the difference was that Delta demanded good construction practices and quality control.

The Baldor still trumps the Delta - cast iron everywhere, much better rests, less vibration (the only ways to tell it's running are to listen for the whir and look closely at the wheels) - but if I hadn't won the Baldor in the delicate dance of dividing up my uncle's shop among six hungry beneficiaries, I'd still have the Delta, and be quite happy.

This is to concur with others supporting the argument that it's a matter of the quality control demanded.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#15

Re: Two separate issues.....

Bruce McCrory

Would no embargo against So. African apartheid have changed the political landscape in that country, from what it is now? Even if they produced fantastic gizmos, made by slaves? I find it difficult to warp ethics and values in order to justify greed, which is what a "separation" implies. My own professional experience has proven the two are inseparable, with far less technical headache. I am with Hackett, theoretically.

I did not intend to discriminate in an earlier post to the exclusion of all but LV and LN. I have tools from Czeck Edge, TFWW, even USA Stanley. My cars are from Japan, however.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#16

I don't think he's implying that at all...

John in NM

He is just saying that poor quality does not automatically follow from a poor human rights situation. They do often coincide, but one does not require the other.

For example, when Germany was split, there were two Zeiss companies, one in the west and one in the east. Although the human rights situations were vastly different, both were acknowledged as producing high quality optics.

This is not to take issue with your desire to not support Chinese manufacturing due to their political system, nothing wrong with that if you feel it is important and are able to manage it.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#17

Re:I seems to be moving on...

Tom

We aren't just supporting their slave state, we are supporting their military expansion into areas we are bound to defend with our blood.

Interesting development, if true, was the story I saw recently that said some chinese products had electronics in them that could hack into our wi-fi, and enslave our computers, whether for spam or something else. Irons were mentioned.

Without raising hackles, I think it is always interesting to note the number of people the US government has killed in various colonial wars since WWII. Numbers range from 20-30 million, but even if one takes a 80% haircut to purge the numbers of bias, it is still a lot of human deaths at 6 million. Take a 98% haircut if you feel better about 600 000, but that number is significantly below even one Admin official's estimate of the post Iraq 1.0 sanctions as they affected women and children. Killing civilian men, isn't even an issue.

According to the CIA, over 1 million people are enslaved in the US today. Pre-civil war, it was 4 million, so that's encouraging.

The US has 25% of the world's prisoners, and 5% of it's population. Their inmates contribute nearly all the assembly labour in some industries, and they pull down 3% of minimum wage.

There are presumably good arguments for all of the above, but it does suggest the human rights playing field is difficult to gauge, even with one of those clever inclinometers.

On the quality of goods, I got most of my asian stuff from Taiwan, and it has held up well for 30 years. I more recently invested in metal working gear, and I bought cheap stuff from the 30s and 50s in the US. When you get into metal working you develop an interest in metal, and it becomes rapidly clear that the quality of metal in chinese goods is dire. The machines can give good service though, but then I am using machines that give relatively food service despite the possibility they were run 24 hours a day during the war years. With chinese tools you are lucky to make it through the return period.

But there are certain things that are pretty good. Stubs of HSS are good quality, taps and dies are good quality (at grade) but the holders break, sometimes explosively.

Quality control is key, and that really means someone on the ground to look at each piece that comes off the line. They will sneak parts in on you, particularly electronics, that will ruin your reputation, even if you make it perfectly clear what you expect. You have to be there. Of course the QC process is the process of telling them all the secrets, and we are able to do it because we have 50 something folks who know how it was done.

There is a bit of a loop. I bought a dovetail tool rest for 65 bucks that can cost thousands in the US version. That works for someone who sees value in having that kind of tool rest to use a few hours a year, or lightly. So it is kinda an educational feedback loop to the US. We bomb most of our industry into the ground, and we teach them how to do it, but they send us a ton of cheap tools and we learn something by bringing them up to some kind of working order, but you can't do on those tools what you could do on real ones.

Of course the chinese also have their indigenous tool makers, that make some interesting stuff.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#18

Re: "Made in China" bias?

Tom

"This is to concur with others supporting the argument that it's a matter of the quality control demanded."

But it flows through from the customer. So the ultimate demandee is the amateur US client, and they don't actually know what they could get or want. That is a generalisation, woodworkers have pretty high standards but for oddball stuff like roughing planes that cut like a smoother. One thing I find pretty weird, is that at least in my day the asians never came out with a good woodworking lathe. There may be one now, like who makes the powermatic, but a bowl lathe should have been something that falls right into their area of expertise, which is overbuilding, without the precision.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#19

Acupuncture!!

Bruce McCrory

Didn't work for me, but some swear by it. :D On, to the next fray.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#20

Re: "Made in China" bias?

BrianMonumentCO

In terms of the "alleged" human rights issues (I use alleged because I know not of it by my own contact.) it is hard to separate the purchase of a needed tool at a substantially lower price vs paying 4 to 5 times the unt for one made in the USA. If I could have found one made in Switzerland ,Germany, or Sweden etc, I would have taken it. Personal experience here tells me that a Grizzly Mill at about $5000 was the only real choice I had in the area of Mills as the equivalent mill from a copier of the Bridgeport was running $25000 and up.

And I felt I needed a mill for my gunsmith shop.

I wonder how the Chinese people feel about how they are treated. If they have been in those conditions for a very long time such that many of the earlier dynasties did the same thing why would they view it as anything other than the state of being Chinese. Perhaps I am trying to identify that not all people are residents or subjects of countries where all people are created equal. The ideals embodied in many of the US founding documents are more utopian than practical or universal. Same point about the middle east and democracy.

Not many countries in the middle east are democracies as known in the USA.

(Although USA is technically a republic. Definitions state that a republic is form of democracy.)

In a way I am trying to say 2 things;

1. human rights appear not to be a practical way to select where to buy an item from

2. I personally am not wrapped up in this "use our money to help reshape other countries ways of doing things". I really don't want them trying to change our country either.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#21

For me it`s pretty simple

Bob Hackett

If I wouldn`y want to see my own children working under the conditions that a corporation expects their workers to tolerate then I don`t give them any of my money. Buying their product supplies the motivation to perpetuate those working conditions, plain and simple.

Just because those conditions are taking place half a world away where you don`t have to see them shouldn`t make them any more tolerable IMO. Overall quality of the product is only part of the equation. Quality of life for all the people who produce that product should also be a factor when we reach for our wallet and support a company.

Hard to reach and influence the thought processes of those who believe "The bottom line is the dollar sign" throughout the spectrum. That won`t (nor should it) keep people of conscience from bringing it into the light where everyone can see it and know it exists.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#22

Re: "Made in China" bias?

wilbur

“Is it just knee-jerk reaction, or is everything I acquire that was made in China a really close step to the garbage can, recycle bin, or hospital emergency room?”

Substitute the word “cheap” for “China”, and you’ll have a more accurate statement.

It is true that many cheap, poorly made things are made in China. It is also true that many high quality items are made in China as well. Those items carry a price tag to match, for the reasons already stated in this thread. My guess is that the common denominator for the things that are not serving you well is not the country of origin, but the price that you were willing to pay for them.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#23

Re: For me it`s pretty simple

BrianMonumentCO

You sir are entitled to your opinion. AS am I.

From my perspective;

1. It is not a matter of conscience it is a matter of belief that my purchasing or lack of purchasing will actually have an impact upon the human rights activities in a corporation, state, country or region.

2. It is also a practical matter of obtaining the best item at the most appropriate price that I can afford for the function to be performed.

3. It is naive to believe that the Chinese government will change because some Americans or others will not buy a product.

4. The chinese companies that make a product may be the only ones making it due in part to a lack of environmental regulations, copyright/patent type enforcement and other economic considerations including wages.

This discussion reminds me of an encounter I had with a fellow at the opening of a Woodcraft store.

The fellow said that he would not buy a Norton stone because Norton also made weapons of war.

His logic appeared to be the same that the lack of purchase of a non-weapon of war would make this company that made items of war to change their principles and make only items of peace.

Needless to say I bought the Norton stones as I viewed that logic as flawed.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#24

Re: I Agree

david weaver

I haven't interviewed anyone in China, but my understanding of the plight of the average individual who doesn't have special papers is that factory jobs are quite a step up from what was available before them.

They may not be to our spec, but I would leave it up to the residents in China and the political bodies to decide that stuff. At this point, when they are trying to make the transition from third to first world, cutting off the money supply really isn't going to help them make their case either.

I don't recall our transition from second/third to first world being fought on our behalf by other countries, and I'd imagine that if our tooling and trades and unskilled workers had been cut off in the 1800s because customers didn't see their work conditions as suitable compared to developed countries, those doing the work and relying on a paycheck wouldn't have tolerated it.

I personally would rather support global products in general, and in developing countries, purchase the products that look to be decent quality. Putting everyone in china back to a sixth of an acre isn't going to help.

As far as quality, a friend of mine who does a lot of purchasing of special items (heavy forgings, customized machine parts, etc) said about 6 or 7 years ago that if you can break through the local folks in charge (and get them to change their attitudes) *and* keep someone on the floor at a production place (someone else here said implementing a QC regime) that you can get quality goods. If you are absent and just buying, you'll probably be spending your time fighting about what's good enough and what's not.

That will change over time if it hasn't already. In the last 10 years, the muscal instruments that come out of china have increased significantly in quality, though there is an enormous problem with branded fakes coming from there, too.

Re: "Made in China" bias?

#25

Re: Low quality isn't the problem

Tom

- Well sure quality is a problem, but they are buying enormous amounts of the CNC, and other productive machinery in the world. What happens when the quality is better, as with the Japanese car industry at one point.

- My sources tell me the products in the range we buy are sold at 5% retail. Anyone know better? Of course there are tons of costs that go with those low prices, but that is what is driving this stuff.

- One of the problems of not buying Chinese is how much stuff is actually chinese anyway. One guy I know who deals over there was walking down a street and came across a bunch of high end fly fishing stuff. He bought it and brought it home. I was a well known small brand. He knows the business and believed it was production not knockoffs. Other friends were over there at a giant cycling show, and saw the frame for a well known German bike maker that claims to make everything in house. Of course the legal definition of what constitutes made in the US an be pretty loose.

- The other thing about buying non-chinese is sometimes you just can't. When my kids were young 15 years ago we never bought chinese. It isn't impossible I guess, today, but you couldn't buy anything kids want for xmas.

- There are places like the Marinas, that could tag Made in USA, but imported large amounts of chinese labor, and paid well under minimum wage, etc... That situation is supposed to be changing, but I hear stories of a lot of lobbying going on.

- There are a ton of industries I wouldn't want my kids to work in over here...