New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

Posts

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#51

Re: Fiddling around.

cstanford

Warren, in what styles do you typically work?

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#52

Re: Fiddling around.

cstanford

Warren, are you sure that this isn't just a case of beauty being in the eye of the beholder, your surfaces that is? One can make a plane pass and say "I'm done," but would other competent craftsman consistently agree with that proclamation?

If your surfaces are that habitually fantastic, I certainly do hope that a few of the magazines will do something more in depth on you, your work, and your technique. Yours is quite a unique accomplishment.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#53

Re: The baby and the bathwater

david weaver

0.1mm would be 4 thousandth. That would be closer than I set a cap iron. 1 1/2 or 2 times that would be the setting for the pictures in this thread. That would allow a very coarse shaving for a smoother.

For work a level coarser (warren refers to it as trying, but I use metal planes in general, so it would be a fore or a rank set jointer), the iron is back quite a bit from that, and does not eliminate tearout completely but leaves it as something that is removed by a heavy smoother pass as described in the pictures earlier in this string.

For final smoothing, I don't do anything different other than reduce the cut depth. I don't think a chipbreaker is usually doing much of anything with a 2 thousanth or so thickness shaving.

Charles hasn't really made any point, he's only repeated a point that he's said elsewhere. Apparently he had this argument with someone else not long ago, who also made no claim that they were final smoothing. We are all already aware that most furniture is scraped and sanded, that little is thickness planed by hand, and that quite often, joinery is done with modern methods and a lot of the rough work done either with precision machines or CNC.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#54

Re: Fiddling around.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I do reproduction work, restoration, carving and turning. It would be nice to work in a single style, but that is not what has kept me in business.

There were some questions earlier about veneer. I have done only a modest amount of veneer work. I have resawed and planed veneers and I have planed veneers after they were applied. I have also planed the faces of hardwood plywood. However, I don't feel able to comment much on this topic.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#55

Re: Fiddling around.

Sgian Dubh

"For someone skilled at using a double iron plane, there is no fiddling around. I use a trying plane for stock preparation, do my joinery, etc. Then just before gluing or finish I take off one or two passes over the whole surface with the smoothing plane to clean the wood. It is certainly faster than planing, scraping and sanding.

Warren, I like to think I'm pretty useful around hand planes. I've been using them for a few years now: I don't fiddle around much with them either. I get the impression from your message that a try plane is possibly your number one tool for stock preparation. I don't use try planes (or scrub planes or jack planes) for stock preparation much. Every now and then I do, but they're not really appropriate I find for processing larger volumes of rough sawn wood, which is anything over about a quarter of a cubic foot, or about 3 bd ft. I suspect you and I work on rather different scales of woodworking, and in my case to ignore scraping and sanding as a means to prepare wood for finishing after some hand planing would almost certainly lead to significant inefficiency. Slainte.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#56

Sorry, but I don't follow.

Joe shelton

Are you saying that the presence of a hook on a scraper is analogous to the precise location of the chipbreaker WRT the cutting edge?

Joe

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#57

Re: Sorry, but I don't follow.

William Duffield

Kinda. The geometry of cutting is similar. The projection of the blade in front of the blade projecting beyond the chip breaker is analogous to the hooked edge of the card scraper; the front face of the chip breaker is analogous to the face of the card scraper. Watch the Kato-Kawai video, and imagine the cutting and chip forming being done with a scraper instead of the blade and chip breaker. Everything to the left of the bifacial cutting and breaking surface is just there to provide extra stiffness, and to hold the cutter in place in the plane body.

The advantages of the card scraper are that you can dynamically vary the cutting angle and the camber in real time while you are cutting. An advantage of the plane is that there is also the front of the mouth to help with holding the chip down while the blade cuts it. There are several other advantages as well, that have less direct effect on the actual cutting.

Another advantage of the plane blade is that you can get its edge a lot sharper that you can get the hook of the scraper using a burnisher. The scraper's edge is at the mercy of the size of the individual crystals in the edge and the strength of the matrix holding them in place. They tend to break off or deform individually under the force of the burnisher, while the sharpening stones and honing compound on a plane blade cut right through the crystals, leaving them in their original matrix, so you don't get as smooth a cut with the scraper. I'm not a metallurgist, so I'm sure that's a gross oversimplification of what is actually happening, but I do know that because of the differences in the way you have to sharpen them, you can make a plane blade much harder than a card scraper blade.

You don't burn your thumbs on a plane blade and chip breaker, but the card scraper has another advantage. While the time to sharpen it and turn a hook is similar to the time to sharpen and hone the plane blade, the disassembly, reassembly and adjustment time is significantly shorter. :D You lose some of that advantage if you use a #80 or a cabinet scraper instead of a hand held card scraper.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#58

OK, Thanks for the detail...

Joe shelton

...I think I got it now. So, I went to the shop and found the Bailey smoother that you knew was there. No small matter finding it, but I really did need to move that pile of off cuts out of there, anyway. The plane is one of the English Stanley's with plastic knob and tote. It had lain idle 10 years, or more, because I'd given up on it.

I took the time to clean it lightly, then started improving it. Put in a Hock blade, and a Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker. I even iterated adjusting the frog, and I crept up on the edge with the cap iron.

And, of course, it worked very nicely on a scrap of white oak and on a piece of pine.

I still have lots to learn about the intricacies, but I owe you for finding out that my plane is a good tool, not a derelict. I'm so pleased with it that I think I'll find out if Bill Rittner has wooden furniture for it.

Thanks, Bill.

Joe