Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article
david weaver
Couple of things, you'll notice that I addressed those in the post with the picture:
* that's not intended to be a finish surface, it's intended to be what you would do practically to hit a line or remove tearout quickly without taking 1 thousandth shavings. It was quick and coarse work and there was considerable force from the cap iron because of the shaving thickness.
* if it was to be a finished surface, I would back the shaving off to something where the plane wouldn't leave tracks (the iron only has a camber enough to handle a third of that shaving or so without leaving a mark). But this board was flattened and thicknessed and destined to become sticks for doors and face frames. It won't get that final track removing pass until after it's been ripped into sticks and is ready to be assembled into something. I'll do it even though I'm sanding, so that it don't have to spend the time standing over the sander diddling away to remove those crushed areas.
* while there's a lot of virtue in avoiding tearout with final smoothing, to me this penultimate part of the process is maybe even more useful, because you can nail a thickness mark or any mark without taking little baby shavings.
* I don't know what all of the SAPFM types do. I'd like to maximize the use of the plane and minimize everything else to the extent I can. In this case, I have to sand if I want the surface finish on the ply and cabinet to match.
But the last virtue of all of this is that it works and it's free. It probably takes two weeks to master. Before any of this kato and kawai stuff was out (and I'd never had planecraft, so I had to figure it out the hard way), it took me about two weeks to figure it out and become proficient at setting the cap iron fast without having to reach for a hammer or something to tap it to final setting.
Actually, in arguing with warren about 5 years ago or so, i had already done it but I complained to warren that with the cap iron set really closely that it was similar to pushing a high angle plane. It was just a little too close. Nobody ever mentioned planecraft to me until after I started making a big deal about all of this stuff. Not all of us who started in the last decade were afforded the guidance to rely on those original texts and the original instructional books that the blogging community seems to just repeat. Thus my constant comments about going *up the ladder* to material written by masters of their trades instead of *down the ladder* to instruction from bloggers who have mastered blogging and who have no qualms with talking about all kinds of things they haven't mastered.
There is one other thing at work with the smoothers that I do that most people don't, if I am going to finish with the smoother, and that's to leave the final bevel around 35 degrees so that no part of the edge chips. If it does, i'm sure you've seen the results in raking light. I'd say that maybe you have to sharpen more often if your final bevel is 35 degrees than if it's 25 or 27, but I actually tested that years ago and the iron that chips first fails first if you count strokes, as long as every iron has at least some reasonable amount of clearance. I did not find any iron that held up well in medium hardwoods at 25 or 27 degrees, despite some advice out there to use that as a final bevel, so I set every smoothing iron at that with an eclipse guide, carbon steel or mujingfang or whatever.