New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

Posts

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#26

Re: The baby and the bathwater

david weaver

My experience has been similar to warren's. If the double iron plane won't plane it, there has been an underlying structural issue in the woods I've planed that won't allow them to be planed or scraped nicely. The piece of cocobolo I referred to is the only piece of wood that dared to tear out, actually and only on the dead quartered face. Anything I put to it crushed some of the earlywood, scraper or plane. The smaller the shaving, the less it occurred with any plane, so it could be sanded if needed. It may have been improperly dried.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#27

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

Couple of things, you'll notice that I addressed those in the post with the picture:

* that's not intended to be a finish surface, it's intended to be what you would do practically to hit a line or remove tearout quickly without taking 1 thousandth shavings. It was quick and coarse work and there was considerable force from the cap iron because of the shaving thickness.

* if it was to be a finished surface, I would back the shaving off to something where the plane wouldn't leave tracks (the iron only has a camber enough to handle a third of that shaving or so without leaving a mark). But this board was flattened and thicknessed and destined to become sticks for doors and face frames. It won't get that final track removing pass until after it's been ripped into sticks and is ready to be assembled into something. I'll do it even though I'm sanding, so that it don't have to spend the time standing over the sander diddling away to remove those crushed areas.

* while there's a lot of virtue in avoiding tearout with final smoothing, to me this penultimate part of the process is maybe even more useful, because you can nail a thickness mark or any mark without taking little baby shavings.

* I don't know what all of the SAPFM types do. I'd like to maximize the use of the plane and minimize everything else to the extent I can. In this case, I have to sand if I want the surface finish on the ply and cabinet to match.

But the last virtue of all of this is that it works and it's free. It probably takes two weeks to master. Before any of this kato and kawai stuff was out (and I'd never had planecraft, so I had to figure it out the hard way), it took me about two weeks to figure it out and become proficient at setting the cap iron fast without having to reach for a hammer or something to tap it to final setting.

Actually, in arguing with warren about 5 years ago or so, i had already done it but I complained to warren that with the cap iron set really closely that it was similar to pushing a high angle plane. It was just a little too close. Nobody ever mentioned planecraft to me until after I started making a big deal about all of this stuff. Not all of us who started in the last decade were afforded the guidance to rely on those original texts and the original instructional books that the blogging community seems to just repeat. Thus my constant comments about going *up the ladder* to material written by masters of their trades instead of *down the ladder* to instruction from bloggers who have mastered blogging and who have no qualms with talking about all kinds of things they haven't mastered.

There is one other thing at work with the smoothers that I do that most people don't, if I am going to finish with the smoother, and that's to leave the final bevel around 35 degrees so that no part of the edge chips. If it does, i'm sure you've seen the results in raking light. I'd say that maybe you have to sharpen more often if your final bevel is 35 degrees than if it's 25 or 27, but I actually tested that years ago and the iron that chips first fails first if you count strokes, as long as every iron has at least some reasonable amount of clearance. I did not find any iron that held up well in medium hardwoods at 25 or 27 degrees, despite some advice out there to use that as a final bevel, so I set every smoothing iron at that with an eclipse guide, carbon steel or mujingfang or whatever.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#28

Re: The baby and the bathwater

david weaver

As far as the rest of those planes, I have sold a bunch of things off, but what I have now are such nice examples of craftsmanship that I am attached to them in a hoarding sort of way :)

Well, those plus the planes I've had have no real market value and I could probably get someone to give me $300 for the infill smoother that I made, but it cost me almost that much in materials.

And just the kit for the panel plane was $600. I'd probably have some trouble getting that for the finished plane.

So, I'll keep the superb examples of hand work as well as my attempts at making a tearout-proof plane.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#29

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

Thoughtful comments all no doubt.

I don't think in the world where relatively large sums of money are exchanged for one-off pieces of furniture that the plane, scrape, and sand paradigm is not still very much in play - the same one in play for the last 150 years or so, several centuries or so sans the part about sanding. I don't expect this to change, and simply because a *totally* finish ready surface is hard to produce off the plane. Sure, everybody hits the jackpot every now and then on a workpiece or two, but day in and day out- I don't think so.

I asked the question honestly, so if somebody with a recognizable name has come out on this subject then I'm happy to take it at face value.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#30

This is not the most beneficial audience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A hand tool forum is not the most fertile place to be discussing the cap iron effect. Hand tool enthusiasts have already figured out how deal with tear out issues. Fact: With the exception of the cap iron effect these solutions are not going to be adapted by the typical woodworker building furniture with typical materials, tools and techniques.

While it may be claimed that the cap iron effect has been common knowledge, it certainly isn't common knowledge among the woodworkers that have opted to remove small increments of wood by abrasive means rather than shavings because they never had favorable experiences with shaving generation due to tear out.

To have a positive effect on hand tool usage go find someone building furniture in shop equipped with a table saw, jointer, thickness planer and a random orbital sander...... and a dusty Stanley plane sitting unused on a shelf. (You can locate lots of these people by visiting any woodworking club meeting)Teach them to easily sharpen the blade to an adequate degree and then show them how to set the cap iron. Share in their joy when they take their first tear out free shaving from the edge of a drawer divider with grain reversal.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#31

Re: The baby and the bathwater

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you are not getting the finest surface at 45 degrees or less, something is very wrong.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#32

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

It'll have to come from a different source. I'm unlikely to ever build complex furniture because I wouldn't know what to do with it even if I spent the time learning, so I am unlikely to learn who the finest builders of furniture are. Life could be long from this point, though, maybe that will change.

I am also not doing anything for money, and would assume that discerning very wealthy and very well educated customers drive what actually gets done on the best of work. Not that it has anything to do with this, but George has mentioned before to me the customers of his that are the most picky and the smartest are the ones he gets the most satisfaction from working for. I wish I had half the talent that it takes to want to do the work for the most difficult customers, but that's why george is making completely indistinguishable parts to make functional again pieces of 18th century rarities, and I am making common kitchen cabinets soley so that I don't have to pay market price for them.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#33

Re: This is not the most beneficial audience

cstanford

I'm always interested in how furnituremakers of this caliber prepare surfaces for a finish:

http://www.davidlambfurniture.com/flash/davidLamb.html

http://williamthomas-furniture.com/

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#34

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

I think you've essentially acknowledged in other threads that the standards are pretty much set by the professionals working at a very high level. I certainly think they are. Veneered work aside for the moment (for which most of this doesn't apply anyway), I'm guessing that moss is not growing on these guys' scrapers and sandpaper stores.

The old reference sources to which we all refer pretty much presented standard, professional cabinetmaking practice of the particular time period in which they were written. That's still essentially true today. When Phil Lowe or David Lamb write an article for FW they are pretty much representing how they do the work in their own shops. There aren't really two separate sets of standards, or maybe these guys don't scrape or sand - my question is still out there. That said, anybody is free to plane, for the sake of planing, every single solitary mark that would be inappropriate by today's standards on a finished piece of nice (not even necessarily 'fine') furniture. I think it's the very rare bird that does so, hobbyist or pro, and I think for very good reasons. At some point it just becomes an absurd exercise in self-flagellation or a ridiculous obsession - heaping effort on an otherwise nondescript article of woodworking. Two or three resettings of the cap iron and the piece is still tearing out, work a test board, set it again, try it again on the real project.

And what of the little bit of clean up here and there after a project is already glued up? Goodness, are you guys doing the clamp ups and consistently keeping everything clean and ready for the finish? Not a fingerprint anywhere? Nothing that needs to be hit with a little fine grit or a swipe with a fine-burred scraper? Some pencil smudges? A bit of general detritus? An incised line that the plane didn't quite take out that you thought it did? The whole notion requires perfection at so many points in the process it becomes preposterous.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#35

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

Charlie, I don't know who you're arguing against or if there has been something from someone else that was carried to here.

I didn't, in fact, take those pictures for the purpose of describing a finished cabinet and didn't intend to share them at all, I was sending them to the person who sent me something to look at as a useful bogey for performance.

At any rate, you're arguing about points that nobody is actually making here, and I can't think you're doing anything other than satisfying yourself. When nobody has made opposing points, nobody is likely to argue. Warren may have said some of this in the past (working straight off of the tool be it a plane or a skew when turning, I remember thinking it odd that warren described HSS as unsuitable for finish turning, but I get it now).

As for the rest of us, and for everything else, I think we're inclined to let you argue points with yourself and play both sides. You can be both black and white and declare checkmate whenever you'd like.

This thread is directed solely at the rash of ridiculous points that I have read lately, such as a repeated assertion that the double iron was never developed to handle difficult wood (it is unlikely it was developed for any other purpose) or that no detailed explanation about using the cap iron has ever been written.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#36

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

Wishing I could reply to all:

All of these posts seem to be suggesting, if not saying outright, that there is some sort of new paradigm in play. There is not. There's a lot of gushing and little-girl giggling, hyperbole, and a lot of Eurekas being shouted, Sturm and Drang, pendulums over-swinging, cases being overstated, new internet starts being born, and "I toldya so's" being issued.

The very close settings from Kato are not really new, either. Standard cabinetmaking practices have not changed.

What's all the fuss about? Somebody planed 'a board' with 150+ year old, well-documented technology and it looked like it might not need sanding (as long as I do no more than paint it or slap some Watco on it, that is). That's pretty much where we are. Next board, please. Oops, this one isn't cooperating so well - must be the crappy kiln drying operation that ruined it for me. And damn, what am I to do with this amboyna burl material, shall I practice on it and ruin a few thousand dollars worth before giving in to reality?

Milk-painted blanket chest, anyone? Aahh, feels better already.

I wish I got a tingle up my leg as easily as you guys do.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#37

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

Charlie, if I asked you what you were thinking about, I have to think about the only way you could respond would be to quote reggie jackson.

Except you're more of a Billy Ripken.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#38

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

David, I love 'ya but I just have to tell you that your statement about planing tearout free for the last year is hard to swallow when the board you photographed for your article has obvious tearout with a plane track as icing on top.

Come back down to Earth. It's a nice place.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#39

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

Charlie, you're moving into juvenile territory. Planing a quartered board straight through with a five or six thousanths shaving and not a finishing pass is going to yield something like that. Grain that is crushed some because of a heavy cut with a chipbreaker forcing the chip back into a softer quartered surface is not tearout, nor is it a finish cut.

Nor would scraping and smashing all of the grain for the sake of dull uniformitybe an improvement over following with finish pass from a less heavily set smooth plane.

I could understand having this conversation with a beginner, but of all of the self aggrandizers, you should have enough experience to know the cirumstances and the remedy already.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#40

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

I'm really not David. But I am saying that I think results are being overblown out of enthusiasm, not out of intent to deceive.

"I haven't had tearout in a year" pleads for context. 100 bd ft? 3,000 bd ft? Two projects? Ten projects? Bookcase, blanket chest, Federal Secretary? Species? Finish schedules? Veneers used?

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#41

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

Bruce McCrory

I read some of the comments to this topic; and quite a few in other instances. I think there are at least two issues occurring relative to hand plane use and tear out.

Even though I have messed with Stanleys for over 50 years, it was only this past couple that I found a comfort level in simply using a hand plane. First is sharpness of the irons. Second, is a tool that is tuned. The chipbreaker flatness and proximity to the iron edge is part of tuning. I have a library book, first copyrighted in 1984 that advises moving the chipbreaker as close to the iron cutting edge as possible. I am sure there are earlier references. Mine have always been under .032". But I always cambered the irons, too. About that much.

I sharpened my favorite Stanley #4 every shop class, that I used it. It was still a miserable tool, but less so than others being used. I respect all the mechanically inclined who fix Stanley planes so they are usable, but I am not one of those people. My shop teacher said .031" to .063" for chip breaker clearance. Maybe, that was one of the problems.

I can sharpen blades. To. Wicked. Razor. Edges. [Almost "Feather" edge sharp.] I've done it since kindergarten. If I can't get a wicked sharp cutting edge, something is wrong with the steel in the tool. The current Tormek, etc., "wicked (crazy?) sharp" craze is just that, a craze that marketers are cashing in on.

OK, sharp tool. It does not fix the tearout problems, nor atrocious construction. (You know, every time we bad-mouth a "made-in-USA" tool, we are passing judgement on the current state of affairs ... oh, ... for the last, at least forty years. And, ourselves.) Actually, tearout reduction is incidental to proper tuning, sharpening. A tailed planer with dull knives can mangle contrary grain, in any wood. Try one with new knives.

Fix the tool so it works; know how to fix the tool. The dust won't be so thick over it. Guaranteed.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#42

Amen...


Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#43

Re: The baby and the bathwater

cstanford

Here's what Charles Hayward had to say about planing burl veneer in Practical Veneering:

"Although it is possible to plane a veneered surface, unless one has considerable experience it is a risky business owing to the liability of the grain to tear out. By setting a smoothing plane with a high-pitched cutter very fine and placing the back iron almost touching the cutting edge, some cabinet makers can clean up veneer of burr [burl] walnut, and it has the advantage of making the surface dead true..."

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#44

Re: The baby and the bathwater

Sgian Dubh

Debates of this nature are always interesting for the fine differences in points made between participants, but in the end I find most of what's been discussed here of academic interest only. Yes, I've known for decades how to set up a plane to cope with difficult wood and how to do so to avoid tearout, etc. The solution is a well set up plane, a very sharp iron, and if needed set the cap iron as close as you dare to the cutting edge, and close the mouth up. It works, and if I'm ever in the mood to spend what would probably feel like a lifetime to get a piece of furniture polish ready straight off the plane I could probably do so - although what the client might think to the huge bill they'd have to pay for all my efforts doesn't bear thinking about.

The reality is that my planes work well, extremely well indeed some of them, but I just haven't got the time to fiddle about with them to the point they are capable of taking perfect shavings from every bit of wood, particularly that wood on the money side, that's put into a piece of furniture. For those bits of wood that do tear out thereby being less than perfect for polish there's always the scraper and abrasive papers. I've said it before, even perhaps here, but I can't think of any working furniture maker of my acquaintance doing fine work (as opposed to the rustic rough and ready look for example), and I know many, that polishes wood straight off a plane. We all use scrapers and abrasive paper in final prepping.

The point I'm making is that of course I want hand planes to work as well as possible within reason, with as little tearout and other faults as possible and, amongst other things, a close set cap iron can help, but there comes a point where chasing that elusive perfection in performance is not cost effective, whereas resorting to scrapers and abrasives is cost effective. Slainte.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#45

Re: The baby and the bathwater

cstanford

Totally agree.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#46

Re: The baby and the bathwater

david weaver

Actually, nobody made this a "finish off the plane" discussion other than charles. As charles usually does, he's creating an argument that nobody else brought up here, and then pretending that the rest of us have picked sides.

Nobody else brought up veneer, nobody brought up paying customers, it was strictly an instructional reminder for what most people seem to be less than competent with, especially people who think that in order to take a coarse shaving, you have to have a bag of expensive tricks.

Other than to remind people (who have said that there is nowhere that describes setting up a cap iron thoroughly) that there is a reference, none of the other items were brought up by anyone except one self-aggrandizing individual whose fine work seems to be indefinitely absent, but whose trolling never is.

What the reason for that is, I don't know, but I'd imagine it's clinical in nature.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#47

Re: The baby and the bathwater

cstanford

David, you claim to have not had any tearout in a year. You regularly sing the praises of Warren Mickley who claims to have given up scrapers and sandpaper three decades ago and make statements to the effect "my experience is just like Warren's" in fact I think you've said that in this very thread.

Are you finishing off the plane or not? If not, why hell not?

Can't have it both ways.

I asked you how much wood you processed during year you went 'tear out free.' Can you tell us?

On what sort of work was this remarkable result achieved?

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#48

Re: The baby and the bathwater

cstanford

Here's one quote of yours:

"My experience has been similar to warren's. If the double iron plane won't plane it, there has been an underlying structural issue in the woods I've planed that won't allow them to be planed or scraped nicely. The piece of cocobolo I referred to is the only piece of wood that dared to tear out, actually and only on the dead quartered face. Anything I put to it crushed some of the earlywood, scraper or plane. The smaller the shaving, the less it occurred with any plane, so it could be sanded if needed. It may have been improperly dried."

"Only piece of wood that dared tear out." My goodness. I hope you spanked it and made it stick its nose in the corner for the rest of the afternoon.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#49

Re: The baby and the bathwater

Sgian Dubh

David, if you're setting up a hand plane with the cap iron placed about 0.05 or 0.1 mm behind the edge of the cutting iron are you not setting it up to take very fine shavings, the sort you might take in the wood prepping phases prior to applying polish? I've never found this sort of set up conducive to ripping heavy shavings off wood, which is what you tend to do if you're perhaps squaring up rough stock to PAR (planed all round, i.e., square). For that you set the cap iron further back and open up the mouth of the plane, and you inevitably get some tearout with this kind of setting, even on cooperative easily planed wood.

Whether or not you like the direction Charles has taken this thread I do think he has made some interesting points. Slainte.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#50

Fiddling around.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For someone skilled at using a double iron plane, there is no fiddling around. I use a trying plane for stock preparation, do my joinery, etc. Then just before gluing or finish I take off one or two passes over the whole surface with the smoothing plane to clean the wood. It is certainly faster than planing, scraping and sanding. If you do this and the surface is not better than a sanded surface, something is not right with the plane. I can see that someone not used to working this way would fiddle around, but with experience one knows just where to set the cap iron and how heavy a cut to take. No fiddling around.

We are not constrained to limit our techniques to those of one forum member's acquaintances.