Re: And an additional point about use
david weaver
One of the things that irks me a little bit about this whole discussion of chipbreakers (RANEY, you were right on your rant several years ago on woodnet that sometimes it seems like there is never any advancement of discussion), is that it is either difficult, or it requires a lot of setting and testing and examining or some other such thing. It does not, period.
People send me things sometimes and ask for my thoughts on them. I am no expert about anything, but I'm willing to provide thoughts about what I can confirm).
In examining something that was sent to me, I intentionally put the subject piece of gear in a situation where it wouldn't perform well. A heavy cut in quartered cherry. This is quartered cherry that is being used in my kitchen. Tearout is not acceptable, the point of making the cabinets is for them to look like modern cabinets. A deep smoother shaving (maybe 5 thousandths of an inch) and this is what turns up:
http://www.imagebam.com/image/c2e854266832268
This is very typical of what you'll run into taking a heavy smoother shaving (a very fine shaving to some extent would avoid it, but screwing around with 1 thousandth shavings is not acceptable if you're dimensioning a lot of wood, or removing thickness planer tearout).
I then took shavings at about the same depth with a common #4 sized plane. These are still very coarse smoother shavings about the same thickness. Ultimately, this wood is going to be sanded at the wife's request - she wants the "factory look" and the sides of the cabinets are cherry ply, so it's all getting sanded. Otherwise, I'd reduce depth and make one more pass to get rid of the fuzz (and that nasty visible track mark) that results from what is literally 20 seconds of corrective work to remove the damage in picture 1:
http://www.imagebam.com/image/9eba30266832271
I believe warren would look at both the shavings and the surface here and say, the cap iron is a little too close for a finish surface, and the evidence is in the crushed surface shown where the tearout was. That's correct, i literally took shavings as deep as my default cap iron setting would allow.
I did not fiddle with shavings, i did not reset anything, I just set it deep and planed out the tearout. Default cap iron is just that, exactly where I set it every time on the smoother.
There is *no* issue with hitting marking lines or being sparing with a surface as there is *no* constant resetting or testing of the cap iron setting UNLESS you are using a plane where the cap iron is not fastened to the iron, which while it works, is significantly less convenient than an iron where the cap iron and iron are fastened together (when we were writing the article, I played with both western and japanese planes).
I would like to reiterate as warren says, there is no testing and it's a simple matter of experience, and that if done right, you set it when you sharpen the iron and the whole apparatus doesn't come apart again until the iron is dull. There is no issue with testing or going past marking lines or anything like that, you literally plane anything with through strokes and that's it.
i have used only this smoother for the last year, and since these are kitchen cabinets, everything is uniform thickness. Five years ago I would have used a steep pitch plane plane with a tight mouth and taken longer (I don't have a decent power jointer, though I do have an accurate lunchbox planer, but the same issue exists, in cleaning up the planed surface, minimal thickness is taken off because the planer is left about a hundredth short of my target thickness).
I set the cap iron on this plane exactly the same every single time it comes off of the stones, it takes about 10 seconds more than putting the iron and cap iron togeter as fast as I possibly can.
Given that I don't have a power jointer, I don't like to sand (nor do I like to scrape if I can help it, though it's sometimes unavoidable on assembled stuff - in the case of something soft like quartered cherry, it just leaves a universally dull crushed surface), learning to use the cap iron properly, exactly as warren describes has been one of the most productive *actual woodworking* things I've learned in the last few years. It has made tearout a complete afterthought, allowed me to double or triple my smoother shavings made after a fore or heavy set jointer plane, and completely eliminated any concern about missing a mark or misorienting joined boards.