New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

Posts

A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#1

A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

I've seen several mentions in the last week or two about there being no descriptive explanation of how to set a cap iron or tell if it's set properly.

It's probably a year ago or a little more now that Ellis, Steve and I teamed up to put together a comprehensive explanation of both the measurements involved and how to tell if the cap iron is actually working.

I've also seen several statements about it working 95% of the time or some other such thing, and if that is the experience that's had, then it's not being used properly. It's been a year now, and I haven't had a single piece of wood that couldn't be planed without tearout, and I would imagine that my smooth shavings since learning this have doubled or tripled in thickness until an absolute final finish is wanted.

So if you see someone who says there is no article that is thorough, numerical or any other shortcoming about setting a cap iron, please direct them to the article. Nobody got paid a penny to put the article together and we put it together so that just such an article would be available.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=newarticles&file=articles_935.shtml

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#2

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

Jerry Gibbs

Thanks. I was planing some red oak and took chunks out of the oak, not just tear out. I was using a Veritas bevel up low angle jack with a 38 degree blade. I was concentrating on having the blade sharp and protruding as little as possible and still cut. I did not pay attention to the cap iron. I also have a 25 degree blade I can use. Does this discussion apply to this configuration? Jerry

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#3

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

david weaver

Hi Jerry, bevel up planes don't have a cap iron, just a lever cap, so the discussion doesn't apply. It applies to the common bench plane styles like the old wooden planes that have a chipbreaker, the stanley pattern bench planes and japanese and chinese planes that have a chipbreaker.

You can do two things with a bevel up plane like you're using to reduce tearout in a heavier cut - steeper iron or tighter mouth. You can also twaddle with sharpening more and lessen the depth of cut, but going the extra mile with the last two is not conducive to getting very much done.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#4

Re: And an additional point about use

david weaver

One of the things that irks me a little bit about this whole discussion of chipbreakers (RANEY, you were right on your rant several years ago on woodnet that sometimes it seems like there is never any advancement of discussion), is that it is either difficult, or it requires a lot of setting and testing and examining or some other such thing. It does not, period.

People send me things sometimes and ask for my thoughts on them. I am no expert about anything, but I'm willing to provide thoughts about what I can confirm).

In examining something that was sent to me, I intentionally put the subject piece of gear in a situation where it wouldn't perform well. A heavy cut in quartered cherry. This is quartered cherry that is being used in my kitchen. Tearout is not acceptable, the point of making the cabinets is for them to look like modern cabinets. A deep smoother shaving (maybe 5 thousandths of an inch) and this is what turns up:

http://www.imagebam.com/image/c2e854266832268

This is very typical of what you'll run into taking a heavy smoother shaving (a very fine shaving to some extent would avoid it, but screwing around with 1 thousandth shavings is not acceptable if you're dimensioning a lot of wood, or removing thickness planer tearout).

I then took shavings at about the same depth with a common #4 sized plane. These are still very coarse smoother shavings about the same thickness. Ultimately, this wood is going to be sanded at the wife's request - she wants the "factory look" and the sides of the cabinets are cherry ply, so it's all getting sanded. Otherwise, I'd reduce depth and make one more pass to get rid of the fuzz (and that nasty visible track mark) that results from what is literally 20 seconds of corrective work to remove the damage in picture 1:

http://www.imagebam.com/image/9eba30266832271

I believe warren would look at both the shavings and the surface here and say, the cap iron is a little too close for a finish surface, and the evidence is in the crushed surface shown where the tearout was. That's correct, i literally took shavings as deep as my default cap iron setting would allow.

I did not fiddle with shavings, i did not reset anything, I just set it deep and planed out the tearout. Default cap iron is just that, exactly where I set it every time on the smoother.

There is *no* issue with hitting marking lines or being sparing with a surface as there is *no* constant resetting or testing of the cap iron setting UNLESS you are using a plane where the cap iron is not fastened to the iron, which while it works, is significantly less convenient than an iron where the cap iron and iron are fastened together (when we were writing the article, I played with both western and japanese planes).

I would like to reiterate as warren says, there is no testing and it's a simple matter of experience, and that if done right, you set it when you sharpen the iron and the whole apparatus doesn't come apart again until the iron is dull. There is no issue with testing or going past marking lines or anything like that, you literally plane anything with through strokes and that's it.

i have used only this smoother for the last year, and since these are kitchen cabinets, everything is uniform thickness. Five years ago I would have used a steep pitch plane plane with a tight mouth and taken longer (I don't have a decent power jointer, though I do have an accurate lunchbox planer, but the same issue exists, in cleaning up the planed surface, minimal thickness is taken off because the planer is left about a hundredth short of my target thickness).

I set the cap iron on this plane exactly the same every single time it comes off of the stones, it takes about 10 seconds more than putting the iron and cap iron togeter as fast as I possibly can.

Given that I don't have a power jointer, I don't like to sand (nor do I like to scrape if I can help it, though it's sometimes unavoidable on assembled stuff - in the case of something soft like quartered cherry, it just leaves a universally dull crushed surface), learning to use the cap iron properly, exactly as warren describes has been one of the most productive *actual woodworking* things I've learned in the last few years. It has made tearout a complete afterthought, allowed me to double or triple my smoother shavings made after a fore or heavy set jointer plane, and completely eliminated any concern about missing a mark or misorienting joined boards.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#5

Re: The Bailey Plane

david weaver

All of this experimentation has led me to believe that the bailey plane is the most perfect (or closest to perfect) mass produced plane design for several reasons, especially for a smoother where you want a stable plane body:

* it wasn't terribly expensive, and now it's dirt cheap

* the original cap iron design that bailey made is at stock profile as good as or better than any "improved" chipbreaker that has followed (in my opinion, it is better, it performs as its requred to at stock geometry)

* used correctly, it will prevent tearout in anything that can reasonably be planed. If I can't plane it perfectly with a bailey plane, none of my other planes will handle it (and the only wood that none of them handled perfectly was a piece of dead quartered cocobolo where the earlywood was very soft, literally no other piece of wood has incurred tearout regardless of the cut depth)

* the body of the plane is stable

* the adjuster is reliable even if there is some backlash (all of this blog stuff about constantly adjusting the smoother shaving thickness on the fly while working is goofy)

* coarse or fine work can be done without issue

* it's comfortable to use for a long period of time (simple paraffin and/or remembering the push the plane rather than laying on it negate any friction issues)

* there is no issue with ejecting shavings no matter how closely the cap iron is set unless there is user error in setting the frog way too far up

Having had bevel up planes, having made two very precise infill planes (fortunately, one is double iron) and a third not so precise plane (precise by most standards, though) and having had about a dozen expensive japanese planes from white steel to super blue from factory made to boutique, I can't think of another plane that can perform practically better than the bailey pattern smoother.

That was not the case when I was a beginner - I thought there were marked improvements in working and less fiddling with the premium planes, but experience has reversed that.

I was also hoping that some experience would allow me to set the double iron as quickly on the japanese planes as I can on the bailey planes, but the fact that you can't get an easy open view of the iron while you're setting the cap iron, and the fact that depth adjustment can affect the cap iron settings makes that operation a lot less simple than the very quick set on western style planes.

So, now I have a lot of very expensive planes, and when I have to make something accurately and quickly, I use only the bailey pattern plane (mine is made by millers falls) for the finish work. it is by far my cheapest plane. The one in the picture was $21 or $22 and despite the ugly picture, it is a very clean plane and was almost unused when I got it.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#6

I hope some magazine editor reads these posts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" has been one of the most productive *actual woodworking* things I've learned in the last few years. " . Those that build stuff who have rediscovered this technique would heartily agree.

The audience that would benefit from this information is 1000 times larger than the insular Forum audiences.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#7

The problem?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am puzzled that some magazine has not picked up on this "rediscovery" and promoted it, or the cap iron plane makers, for that matter, leading to a LN video, for example.

Could it be that this technique is perceive by editors as only being useful to the small audience that planes show surfaces? Editors, this is not the case. Tear out when using a plane for its more prevalent fitting tasks is as much an impediment to using a plane as in preparing a show surface. And this technique is therefore of great value to anyone using a plane for common fitting, as well as surface preparation, tasks.

As we speak I am planing drawer runners to be flush with a leg, a furniture building task commonly employed. With the cap iron set optimally I don't even bother looking at the grain orientation anymore. I am confident the plane will handle what ever the grain is doing. And, I can always plane more conveniently from the leg toward the rail, even if the grain is "wrong" in this direction.

In my case "rediscovery" of this technique has vastly increased the utility of the plane in building stuff.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#8

Re: I hope some magazine editor reads these posts

david weaver

In fairness, Bob Lang did extend an invitation to us (and I think highly of Bob), but as an amateur woodworker who is sometimes interested in productivity with hand tools (for example, building kitchen cabinets or other large items, which I do not really want to do). And sometimes not (like building tools or intentionally completely avoiding using anything but planes to finish surface a project, or using planes for play - like japanese smoothing planes). Anyway, as an amateur, I didn't feel it my place to be involved with writing a permanent paper print article.

I am convinced, though, even more so now, that the information in our article here is exactly correct. It is faster (than not using the cap iron), cheaper (than resorting to specialty planes) and easier with a little bit of experience than anything else I have used short of a wide belt sander or a wide spiral headed planer - both of which are items that I do not have regular access to.

And even if sanding is the goal, one can literally sand with one grit after the planing and be done. Maybe two if a 400 grit surface or some such thing is desired.

I just have to figure out what to do with the expensive japanese planes and the infills I've made.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#9

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

John Pappas

The article is without doubt one of the most useful articles I've read. I have a piece of oak with a lot of reversing grain that I am able to successfully plane with a Bailey, a BedRock, a couple of Krenov style planes that I made, and even (take a deep breath) with a Groz plane (with a Hock iron).

I have a book, PLANECRAFT published by C& J Hampton Ltd. Sheffield England which says this about adjusting the cap iron for hard wood with irregular grain, "as close as you can get it to the cutting edge". Well, I read that about 40 years ago, but it didn't really sink in. This article made me test the concept.....and it sank in. Can't say enough about it.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#10

Re: I hope some magazine editor reads these posts

Bob Lang

The magazine world sometimes moves at glacial speed, and that is the case with an article on the cap iron setting. It is in line, but I'm not sure where it is in the process. I'll check with Glen and let everyone on staff know that you guys are getting anxious.

I would personally like to thank Warren for sharing his experience and his consistency in this seemingly endless debate. Setting the cap iron as close as I can has improved the performance of my planes immensely and I hadn't really messed with it much until Warren spanked me about it a few years ago.

Bob Lang

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#11

Yes on Planecraft

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I remember reading that, too, along with some excellent information that I did not, at the time, understand about cambering the cutting iron.

Part of the lesson for me over the years is that "as close as you can get" changes as skills improve. At first, I held the chipbreaker back a ways because trying to get it closer resulted in it slipping over the cutting edge. Getting to very, very close setting is kind of a hold-your-breath act.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#12

How much of this...

Joe shelton

...is obviated by just using a thick single iron bevel up?

Joe

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#13

Re: How much of this...

david weaver

Some but not all and it depends on what you want.

A steep bevel single iron leaves a duller finish on softer woods, and is not a very good option for heavier work (you get some tearout mitigation with a double iron, even in jack and fore plane work if you need it, and heavy jack and foreplane work is extremely unpleasant with a steep bevel.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#14

You mean like this one? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sorry, I couldn't resist.


Bevel up plane with thick iron

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#15

Re: How much of this...

William Duffield

How would you compare using a card scraper with a hook to one without a hook? The differences are analogous. Don't take our word for it. Go to your shop, find a particularly gnarly board, and do the comparison yourself. You do have a Bailey smoother in your arsenal, don't you?

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#16

Re: I hope some magazine editor reads these posts

Tom

I think you are right, though there is always the possibility that they didn't know it was news, though that goes for most everything they print anyway. It is interesting how interested people are in articles on restoring planes, reviews, when the basics are not seemingly widely known, no mater how often they appear in print. Chip breakers are only one aspect of the basics.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#17

Re: Yes on Planecraft

Tom

Yeah, and the fact that the breaker is not adjustable on the fly on most planes makes that more difficult. Doubtless someone is working on that in a way that will appeal to dial twiddlers. I think one of the ECE planes had something odd like and adjustable on the fly or at least somewhat adjustable bedding angle dial. Stuff gets tried now and then, but may or not catch on.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#18

Re: How much of this...

Tom

As Bill has pointed out, as close as one can get, changes with experience. The breaker is not really that useful for super fine shavings which look like cobwebs, so there may not be much to be said for that, when you get to that point, tune in a decade from now if people catch up. The breaker isn't that useful for a lot of work that actually gets stuff done, other than finishing cuts, the few dozen or more planes that aren't finishing planes. And the breaker isn't all that useful on certain cuts of wood that plane downhill, so to speak, or across grain. But it is useful for a lot of stuff people currently want to be able to do, or say they can do, with their planes, such as finish difficult woods right off the blade, and get a reasonable depth of cut while doing it.

Some of the above a breakerless blade is great for. Bevel up, not so much an issue.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#19

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

Cap irons do work and your before and after picture is impressive, though there still appears to be patch in the middle of the board pictured (could only verify by touch) that would still prove problematic under shellac or a varnish. Under a film finish, done well, the board in the photo would need some sanding I'd guess.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#20

The baby and the bathwater

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I just have to figure out what to do with the expensive japanese planes and the infills I've made.

Hi David

Did these planes suddenly stop working? :)

Thank you for including my piece of research among the links in your article. In re-reading it I think it would be good to re-write some sections - perhaps clarify a few points more clearly. It also struck me that this is somewhat similar to the situation at hand, that is, looking back it is always easier to evaluate something with the wisdom of hindsight.

I recall reading the Kawai and Kato research on Steve Elliott's website several years ago. I clearly did not understand it at all since my conclusion was that the chip breaker only made a difference when placed at a tiny distance from the edge, but what this "difference" referred to was not clear, and the distance seemed impractical. Consequently it was consigned to the ledger of evidence against the use of a chip breaker!

It was only through your perseverance in testing out and practicing the method involved, then reporting on Warren's advice that we began to look afresh at the K&K research. As we began to understand exactly what was going on at the chip breaker face, so we began to break down entrenched beliefs and open ourselves to something new. That certainly was the case with me. My small contribution was to attempt to determine whether I could measure an optimum distance for the chip breaker when it included different bed angles. This helped me realise that there are several factors involved in preventing tearout - the chip breaker is but one of these.

One conclusion I reached (and reported in that thread) was that the chip breaker appeared to add the equivalent of 10 - 15 extra degrees of cutting angle. This was later agreed by Deneb Puchalski from LN. In other words, a common angle Stanley (45 degree bed) acted like it had a middle- to half-pitch bed (55-60 degrees). However I also found that the combination of a common angle Stanley plus chip breaker had an upper limitation on some woods I used. The result was improved, however, when a higher bedded plane (such as a LN bench plane with a 55 degree frog) was combined with a closed up chip breaker. In other words, there was an additive effect.

Since completing these tests I have repeated the results on a number of occasions in a practical setting, that is, building furniture. Note that I rarely use softwoods (or softer woods), and my findings are best seen as related to West Australian hardwoods. I believe that soft- to medium hard woods are more likely to be the ideal beneficiary of the chip breaker on a common angle plane. This cutting angle is just too low for some of the wood I am using. The effectiveness of a closed up chip breaker is not in question, witnessed by the fact that my LN #3 with the 55 degree frog gets a lot more use now compared to a few years ago.

For all this, my high angle BD and BU planes continue to be the mainstays of my tools for smoothing. They are simply easier to set up. The BU planes, with their low centre of effort, are just less effort to push. Plus, on my hard woods, I just do not see any of the anticipated smoother surface expected from lower cutting angle planing. I get a reflective enough surface with high cutting angles. Again, I would consider this more of a softer wood area.

Lots of options before. A few more now.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#21

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

There also appears to be a pretty bad plane track in the upper 3rd of the photo, a scratch right in the middle of one of the ribbons of grain.

Just sayin'

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#22

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

If you read Planecraft they recommend a 32nd for the jack plane (half the setting David used in his "before" photo in the article he wrote), a 64th for "regular planing" of hardwoods, then the "as close as you can get it" statement for "hardwoods with difficult grain." Following the progression implies a setting down to at least 1/128th, or closer, which is obviously a setting only really doable by eye.

NOTHING NEW UNDER THE SUN.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#23

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

cstanford

I've yet to see a true finish ready surface off the plane. I understand Warren is able to achieve it, but is anybody willing to do French polish (well, of course) right off the plane? Has anybody actually done it? More than once? Repeatedly? To an extremely high and consistent professional standard? The old guys used burlap, brick dust, scrapers, shark skin, and probably dozens of other products permanently lost to history.

Have any cabinetmakers of note (David Lamb and that ilk - the real deal) come out and said they haven't used a scraper or paper (or combination of both) in ages?

It's a good technique but do we not need to keep it in perspective?

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#24

Re: The baby and the bathwater

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Derek, I will tell you what I told you years ago. If you are not getting better results from a double iron plane than a high angle plane, then something is wrong. The double iron plane far exceeds any upright whatsoever.

Re: A friendly reminder - the cap iron article

#25

Re: The baby and the bathwater

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, I will tell you what I told you years ago. If you are not getting better results from a double iron plane than a high angle plane, then something is wrong. The double iron plane far exceeds any upright whatsoever.

Hi Warren

But I did report better results with the double iron over a high angle plane. It is there in the link supplied by David:

45 degree Stanley #3 + closed up chip breaker = poor surface quality

55 degree LN #3 (pulled back chip breaker) = poor surface quality

62 degree LV SBUS = good surface quality

55 degree LN #3 + closed up chip breaker = better surface quality than LV SBUS on the test board.

Cutting angle clearly plays a factor here.

Regards from Perth

Derek