New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Chisel Monogamy

Posts

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#26

Re: Guruism

William Duffield

I find 5/32", 3/16", and 5/16" useful chisel and plough plane iron widths. Above that, graduations by eights, and eventually (when you approach 1") graduations by quarters is more than enough resolution. If we were natural calculators, increments by exponential factors would probably make more sense than by binary fractions, but that cognitive transition is even more difficult for mere mortals to accomplish than conversion to the totally illogical (and French) metric system. I don't know why we were "blessed" with ten fingers; eight or twelve would probably have gotten us to modern civilization a thousand years sooner.

About the only use I've found in woodworking for 7/16" is for dowel diameters for repair of late 19th and early 20th Century factory made furniture with mass produced embellishments. If you've never worked on late Victorian furniture, I would strongly advise you to avoid going there.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#27

I must be a swinger then...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I had to go check, I have something like 15 different brands of chisels, in all kinds of sizes and shapes...

I guess that makes me Casanova :D

DC

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#28

Re: Chisel Monogamy and Hero Worship.....

Steve

Though I've never seen any of Norm's shows, or Roy Underhill's, or read any books or articles or anything else by Chris Schwartz, I'd bet that none of them would just say things because it was "expected" or not "expected", or to create a little shock or stir, or to keep their profile raised. I think they write and say the things they do because that's what they believe at that point in their woodworking careers. And then things change; life and work go on. That bench that Norm thought was vital became...not so vital. I bet he just changed his mind.

That's sort of the problem any "expert" has. Especially one that teaches or announces his expertise. They're supposed to be "right." They profess what they believe to be true. But as time goes on what they thought was true turns out to be not so true. And then, I guess, they have the responsibility to openly admit that what they thought was right yesterday they no longer believe.

But, really, how many of us do that? You'd spend your life rounding up those you misled. Just to tell them you were wrong. "Hey, you know, when I told you that waterstones were the best way to sharpen, sorry, I had it wrong, diamonds are a man's best friend."

They'd probably just laugh and say "It's okay, I figured it out for myself."

It's just the nature of things and it's okay. Think of the fellow who can't admit when they've been wrong. We've all met the guy who "learned it that way", "has done it that way for years and years" and is utterly convinced of his own authority, to the extent that he cannot be swayed to see anything in a new way. What a drag.

Yeah, there's knowledge there. But who wants to pay the emotional price to get at it?

As for the web, and the profusion of writers, and bloggers and teachers, all freely offering the fruit of their investigations, examinations and tests - it's still better than it was before. Before the web, and email and text messages, before FWW, before Lee Valley, and Garrett Wade, it was damn hard to get information about woodworking, even if you were in the trade. If you wanted to read about it you might have had to spend Saturdays in the library stacks, paging through the books that have all now been reprinted. The cabinetmakers you worked with weren't necessarily into "sharing" their knowledge, especially with some youngster. It was their economic advantage and they weren't giving it away. It had taken them a long time to build those skills; they saw no particular reason to make your little journey any easier. I guess they weren't into "teaching."

The only thing to avoid now is spending so much time trying to perfect your techniques that you forget to make things. You can't get it right without making things; and, if you make things, and keep on making things, you inevitably get it right. And then, after a whole bunch of years, you too can be an expert, a master, a teacher. A well known woodworker.

You'll be able to tell people just how to sharpen...

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#29

The naive and the worldly

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



It's not so much bashing Chris Schwarz for the reason of sport, it's a matter of being a little more discriminating when choosing sources of information, especially if the objective is learning to build things with an appropriate (that's left for each person to determine) destination in mind.


Hi David

Of course people should be discriminating ... however most of the blogs are written by beginners and intermediates for beginners and intermediates.

I include my own website here. When I look over many of the articles I want to re-write them and update the techniques and information. I started that website about 10 years ago, and I would hope that I have developed my skills and insight forwards in that time.

Does this mean that the information is invalid? Should I feel a sense of shame and guilt for leading the reader along a less-than-perfect path? I have not removed or modified the articles, partly because I lack for time, and partly because there are many beginners and intermediates who have found the pictorials I provide a useful guide when building something. I expect that they will progress forward at their own pace, as I did. The bottom line is that the techniques used may or may not be the duck's nuts, but they worked well enough.

To me, an appropriate destination is something that I will look at in 20 years and not say, Gad...why did I leave all of those dovetails exposed on something that was to go in the house? My house was not built in the 1700s, and my living room is not shop space.

It's just one element of fashion - wait 10 years and you will discover the others!

I only need to go back to George's suggestion every time someone on sawmillcreek tried to design something from scratch. There are several centuries worth of good design out there, there is no reason to do anything other than possibly try to incrementally improve something that already exists, and it's very difficult in that case to do it without being at least able to copy what's already there. I went the "wing it" route at first like a lot of people do. I have, for that, throwaway items. They are tight, and I used hand tools to make them, but they're ugly.

There are so many methods, so many people or pieces to inspire - I really would not wish to limit myself to a period in the past. (And that's not aimed at George, who I respect and love, as you know). I'd love to bring to the present a notable woodworker from the past. What modern methods and tools would they want to incorporate into their repertoire? How would this affect design? What is progress and what is not?

Even if I am not building pieces to that level at this point, why should I or anyone else go down the ladder for instruction when superior information is and has been available for decades. I want my mind to be occupied with where I want to go and how to get there, there is a whole world of it available. Not general snippets from someone who hasn't mastered anything of note.

David, what this indicates is that you have reached a point where you are able to discriminate the good from the bad, the desirable from the undesirable. Of course, you need to play this game again in 10 years time. The thing is, no one forces anyone to read or believe what is on a webpage or blog. If you lack the experience with which to do so, the worst that can happen is that you learn a lesson. For every experienced and knowledgeable woodworker that rolls their eyes to the heavens when reading some poor advice, there is another inexperienced woodworker who finds it inspiring. What more can one ask?

Regards from Joburg (in transit to Cape Town)

Derek

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#30

Re: Guruism

Kees

[...] the totally illogical (and French) metric system.

Ha ha ha!

And not so much French, more like the whole world except the USA, Liberia and Myanmar. It's logical, because we are blessed with 10 fingers. :b

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#31

Re: The naive and the worldly

cstanford

Too easy to get a Hayward book (and many others) for a buck ninety-nine on Amazon or Alibris. Too easy to check out the latest posting in the Masters' Library at WK Fine Tools, too easy to take advantage of what Gary Roberts is putting up on his website and publishing, and even too easy to take advantage of what Schwarz offers when he is publishing or republishing good books (by far his most valuable contribution to the craft).

I'd rather read something written by somebody AFTER they had pretty much mastered the craft, not while they're still trying, if there is a choice between the two, and there is, the ones in my first paragraph.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#32

Re: Guruism

William Duffield

No, we're not. We're cursed with ten fingers. We'd be better off if we'd all been born with eight, or twelve, or sixteen. I'm not suggesting "changing horses in mid-stream." That's why I have a SawStop. It's also a good reason to use a turning saw or a frame saw when I might be tempted to use one of my bandsaws instead. I wouldn't suggest divesting yourself of any fingers, any more than I would suggest you dispose of most of your chisels or all of your bandsaws.

There are a few of us, who understand binary, who can count to thirty-two on one hand (and 1K on two, if we weren't holding a chisel at the same time). I'm a bit rusty at that technique, but Warren is very skilled at it, as he is with his woodworking.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#33

Re: Adam Cherubini

wilbur

"This one chisel nonsense" would be nonsense. That's not what Chris' blog post was about, however.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#34

Re: The naive and the worldly

david weaver

Derek, I've always considered your site a separate listing of articles, and not as a blog. It doesn't have the same social cliquishness and it's more straightforward.

Maybe the line isn't so clear. But, I haven't seen you get into the soft issues, either (you "must by from..." for the social good), which is good.

The past isn't limiting at all, though, and it doesn't keep people from going to the future. It just educates people so that if they want to make incremental improvement, there is some element of good taste at the starting point of the design.

One of the things I have some concern about, though not enough to compromise expressing opinion, is that when I criticize something, there is perceived collateral damage, but my comments previously were not with your material in mind Derek. There are others who blog (Zach does, Adam did some at some point, though not much now) whose "making stuff" related posts I like a lot.

I guess that's the danger of posting an opinion without scads of caveats.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#35

Re: Adam Cherubini

david weaver

So be it, I'm not about to read it to find out. someone else can recite exactly whats in it.

The point was more about that I find Adam's writing to be a lot more focused and more enjoyable. That's it.

Add Zach Dillinger to the list of folks, too.

But maybe that's because Adam and Zach's focus is more about the nuts and bolts.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#36

Re: That's a good point..

david weaver

.. the publishing of other's work has been just fine, and I do have some of the texts chris has republished, and enjoy them.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#37

Re: The problem I see

Patrick Gibbons

Especially before the Internet made information more accessible, it was hard to learn woodworking. FWW, Norm, Roy came along and fueled the interest. The problem for me was the plethora of voices. This escalated with the Internet. One says one thing, Two says something else. Both say something worthwhile but not compatible. A craftsman will do things consistently in a systemized way. He'll teach someone else his way. Learning from magazines, the Internet, blogs, a beginner is exposed to many systems at the time when he's better served having one voice to listen to. If the beginner perseveres he eventually figures it out. But it does lengthen the learning curve.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#38

The twinkle in Chris's eye

Hank Knight

The twinkle in Chris's eye grows brighter as this thread grows longer. ;)

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#39

Re: Guruism

Kees

31. With 5 fingers you can only count to 31.

And no need to cut of any fingers! Just adopt to the decimal system like the rest of the world an have a happy life with all your fingers.

Kees (living in Europe and never could understand why the Americans are so stuborn in this respect).

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#40

Re: Guruism

david weaver

But we have so many rulers with inches on them already!!

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#41

Re: The problem I see

John in NM

That is true only if the beginner starts out thinking there is "one" correct answer. He gets the "one" answer from one book, tv show, or blog, and flogs away at it until he finds it doesn't work 100% of the time. He then abandons that source of info and pursues the next "one" answer, and proceeds to dismiss and disparage his old source.

I'm being hyperbolic of course, none of us do this consciously, and none of us do this in its entirety. My earlier point about magazines was that the student would get competing viewpoints from issue to issue, sometimes even in the same issue. They tended to illustrate that there is no one way in any craft or vocation.

Blogs can be very helpful to the beginner, taken with moderation. The problem I see (to quote you :D ) is when the blogger becomes "The" in the eyes of their audience. Moderation is lost and the beginners becomes blind to other possible solutions to whatever problems they face.

All pretty esoteric, eh? :D :D :D

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#42

With 40 entries and counting in this thread....

roger lance

do you think a little shock and stir was created??....add in similar threads on other forums as well....what will "The Schwarz" say next??

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#43

Re: The naive and the worldly

John in NM

The trouble is that in any discussion of this sort, the blogger, author, or personality becomes the whipping boy for the enthusiasm of their fans. It is not fair, and it is not right. Its very easy to lose perspective.

Homo sapiens love to categorize their world. We all seem to end up falling into either "fans" or "haters", especially in the overly abstracted world of the internet. Even if one doesn't see themselves as falling into either category, the discussion quickly diverges to the point where they argue one side or the other.

I think many of us who get lumped into the "haters" category are simply trying to see the question from the point of view of a student reading one of these blogs. Taking the message of the blog post in question, it was not "use only one chisel, ever", it was really what many of us here have advocated recently - "focus on work and building experience rather than acquiring every possible tool for every possible need"

I just think it is more effective to say what one means, as clearly and succinctly as possible. The blog post in question did not do that - that is my only complaint with it.

I am a bit curious whether I would have the same complaint with other posts on the same blog, or any of the popular blogs. I'm not sure I really want to know... :D

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#44

So much the better...

John in NM

Perhaps there is something to be learned on all sides -- isn't that what makes discussions interesting and threads long? :D

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#45

Re: The naive and the worldly

david weaver

Now we're even, I didn't read the blog post. But I did get you to read sellers blog a little, and I just went back to it today and looked, and realized the balance of the posts are designed to pull in beginners, maybe the older posts discussing the current state files and such are why I gave it credit to being useful. Sorry for sending you on that mind melter!

I guess we're not even, I'm one up, because I didn't go out and read the "one chisel" post. I did read the PW blogs earlier on, and got my fill of things and came to the same realization as with magazines - I couldn't specify what I was getting out of them, whereas the materials written by professionals (like the hoadley book), it's very easy to answer that.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#46

From the electric side...

John in NM

I just wrote a bit about the importance of editing....

That is probably why I prefer the old FWW articles, especially the black and white vintage, they were well edited. Blogs, wikis, and youtube all suffer from excessive superfluity of verbiage (as do I, apparently! :D :D :D )

Do you know, that is the very thing that got me out of academic science? Reading all those articles that were effectively self edited by the author. By and large, they meandered around, never quite getting to the point and distracting the reader with a huge number of trees rather than explaining the forest as the author had set out to do. I suspect the journal editors were in much the same boat that I was, just less inclined to accept reality :D

Of course, the other possibility is that all those articles and all these woodworking blogs are perfectly clear and concise and that I suffer from an inability to concentrate long enough to get the point. But for now I'm sticking to my first theory....

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#47

We also still have

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

bushels and pecks of produce. 4 pecks to the bushel. Based on the basket size. When you fill up that basket with apples or peaches, it's a bushel. What does a bushel weigh? Depends on whether it's a bushel of apples, mustard greens, lima beans, etc.

Talking country now; I know that Safeway sells apples by the pound. But when you get out of town, you can still buy bushels and pecks.

Nowadays, somebody actually assigned a volume in liters to it (35 and some-odd, calculated to several decimal places!).

So Kees, if you go into the country to an orchard and buy apples there, do they price them per kilogram, or is there a basket size that the farmer prices?

Wiley

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#48

Re: From the electric side...

david weaver

I think it's the first. They definitely suffer from a lack of "just the facts".

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#49

Re: We also still have

david weaver

Still bushels here, too. Not in the grocery store of course, but in any place (even suburban) that looks remotely like a farm store.

Of course, in the suburbs, farm market looking places are in affluent areas and actually cost more than a regular grocery (but they still have half bushel and bushel baskets).

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#50

Ahhh... there it is again...

John in NM

Them decimal demonizers turn up even decades later :D :D :D

(No offense intended, I have a thing for alliteration when I can pull it off :D )

The decimal system requires fairly extensive education, or at least practice, to be effectively utilized in one's head - at least for us average people. It works really well on paper, or rounded off to some manageable significant figure.

The Imperial system is intuitive, but kinda clunky on paper. It works well for off the cuff calculations, estimates, and calculation in the head. We all get half of something, and half again of that, and so on (with practice).

I suspect the difference has something to do with visual memory (mine) vs. whatever type of memory math people have. I remember that Feynman won a bet by calculating a cube root to 3 or 4 decimal places in his head faster than a guy with an abacus could do it. However his head worked, it's nothing like mine (that is also probably why many people have heard of him and I'm just another schlub on the internet :D :D :D )

What people often forget about mathematics education is that the goal in the US used to be universal proficiency to a basic level. Sure the Japanese kids could whip us on standardized tests - the tests were written to a high standard that was beyond the goal of our system. One of my grandfathers was a civil engineer, supervising concrete work at major hydro projects in the 1930's. Never graduated from high school.

Yet these days I work for engineers who quite literally cannot change a tire, or in another case jack a car up to put chains on it, thinking that keeping them from clanking at high speed (20+) is merely a matter of getting them sufficiently even and tight. A bit of experience with the world would teach the guy that they always clank if you go too fast - that is why it is "too fast"! But I sure betcha he can calculate a cube root in his head :D