The naive and the worldly
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
It's not so much bashing Chris Schwarz for the reason of sport, it's a matter of being a little more discriminating when choosing sources of information, especially if the objective is learning to build things with an appropriate (that's left for each person to determine) destination in mind.
Hi David
Of course people should be discriminating ... however most of the blogs are written by beginners and intermediates for beginners and intermediates.
I include my own website here. When I look over many of the articles I want to re-write them and update the techniques and information. I started that website about 10 years ago, and I would hope that I have developed my skills and insight forwards in that time.
Does this mean that the information is invalid? Should I feel a sense of shame and guilt for leading the reader along a less-than-perfect path? I have not removed or modified the articles, partly because I lack for time, and partly because there are many beginners and intermediates who have found the pictorials I provide a useful guide when building something. I expect that they will progress forward at their own pace, as I did. The bottom line is that the techniques used may or may not be the duck's nuts, but they worked well enough.
To me, an appropriate destination is something that I will look at in 20 years and not say, Gad...why did I leave all of those dovetails exposed on something that was to go in the house? My house was not built in the 1700s, and my living room is not shop space.
It's just one element of fashion - wait 10 years and you will discover the others!
I only need to go back to George's suggestion every time someone on sawmillcreek tried to design something from scratch. There are several centuries worth of good design out there, there is no reason to do anything other than possibly try to incrementally improve something that already exists, and it's very difficult in that case to do it without being at least able to copy what's already there. I went the "wing it" route at first like a lot of people do. I have, for that, throwaway items. They are tight, and I used hand tools to make them, but they're ugly.
There are so many methods, so many people or pieces to inspire - I really would not wish to limit myself to a period in the past. (And that's not aimed at George, who I respect and love, as you know). I'd love to bring to the present a notable woodworker from the past. What modern methods and tools would they want to incorporate into their repertoire? How would this affect design? What is progress and what is not?
Even if I am not building pieces to that level at this point, why should I or anyone else go down the ladder for instruction when superior information is and has been available for decades. I want my mind to be occupied with where I want to go and how to get there, there is a whole world of it available. Not general snippets from someone who hasn't mastered anything of note.
David, what this indicates is that you have reached a point where you are able to discriminate the good from the bad, the desirable from the undesirable. Of course, you need to play this game again in 10 years time. The thing is, no one forces anyone to read or believe what is on a webpage or blog. If you lack the experience with which to do so, the worst that can happen is that you learn a lesson. For every experienced and knowledgeable woodworker that rolls their eyes to the heavens when reading some poor advice, there is another inexperienced woodworker who finds it inspiring. What more can one ask?
Regards from Joburg (in transit to Cape Town)
Derek