New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Chisel Monogamy

Posts

Chisel Monogamy

#1

Chisel Monogamy

Tony Wilkins

As you guys might know/have figured out/ perhaps even bemoaned, most of what I've learned apart from these forums about woodworking is from Chris Schwarz. I like the way he teaches and what he says makes sense to my wooodworkingly naive little mind.

Today's blog on Popular Woodworking took me a little aback and in his way answered my recent question about chisels.

It's here: http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/the-theory-of-chisel-monogamy

The gist of it, if I'm reading right, is that he's suggesting just using one chisel these days.

So, whatdya think?

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#2

Suck it and see ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

It all depends on the work you do. If you plan to follow in Chris' footsteps and do the same work that Chris does, then do the same as he. If you plan to do something else, you may find you have gaps. And the sizes that Chris enjoys, may or may not work for someone else. You need to try woodworking for real rather than first in theory. You cannot prepare for all eventualities.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#3

Re: Chisel Monogamy

david weaver

Anything for a blog post, I'd say.

Do what you want to do, read from the professionals, try to understand tasteful design and basic technical competence from them and from experience and ignore the bloggers.

That's my opinion.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#4

Re: Chisel Monogamy

Patrick Gibbons

I read his blog to see for myself. I understand what he's saying. I use a few of my chisels more than others. It's another iteration of the 80/20 rule. (80% of your sales, production, etc comes from 20% of your customers, machines, etc.). I still like having a variety of sizes of chisels. When I need a 7/8", I need it. I do believe that one can produce furniture with a minimum of hand tools at a low cost. I love the philosophy of this but have never met anyone who's done it. Even Chris has been selling stuff to get back to it. But he makes a valid point. The fewer tools one has, the easier it is to take care of them. My duplicates and excess are the ones that get rusty, bunged up and abused. In the past this would have not been an issue. Now we're all permeated with consumerism and don't think twice about buying tools. Buy what you need when you need it and sell what you don't use. Otherwise, enjoy your hobby and don't sweat it.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#5

Re: Chisel Monogamy

wilbur

I think that over time, woodworkers will gravitate towards a smaller tool set, simply because they are able to figure out a process that works well for them, which includes increasing familiarity with a particular tool in their tool set. In Chris' case, it's a 1/2" chisel.

I think that a 1/2" chisel is good for a lot of furniture making tasks, so it's no surprise that Chris is using his a lot. I use a 1/2" chisel a lot as well for this type of work. But if you are doing something that is different in style or construction, you may find yourself using something else. A 1/2" chisel won't help if you're making dovetails with really skinny pins. Last night I was doing a small inlay, and used a 1/4" and 3/8" chisel because that's what the scale of the inlay demanded. The projects that Chris has been making recently doesn't have much inlay or skinny pin dovetails, so it's not a surprise that he hasn't seemed to need a skinnier chisel.

Here's another example. This is a set of Japanese chisels that I saw on eBay that was used by a woodworker that did mainly carpentry work. You can see that there were some sizes in this set that were used much more than the others.


Having said all that, I think Chris' advice about buying a chisel is sound. Having fewer high quality chisels will be better than a complete set of low quality ones.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#6

Re: Chisel Monogamy

William Duffield

You want to build a Shaker table, right? (This also applies to most light single drawer table designs of the last three hundred years.) Look at the leg to bottom drawer rail joinery. You cannot cut either the mortises or the twin tenons with a half inch chisel. A quarter inch will do, or if you are building a table a bit larger and heavier, you might find a 5/16" chisel is more efficient for making a strong joint.

A half inch chisel is easier to push, and requires a smaller mallet for chopping than a larger chisel, and with skill, you can take multiple cuts and achieve a smooth surface, but a wider chisel will give you less risk of messing up a show face or a show edge.

You mentioned that you have problems with strength in your hands and arms. Because of this, you might find yourself gravitating to building smaller scale objects, for example jewelry boxes, spice chests or lap desks. These will require smaller chisels.

Chris doesn't do Federal Period inlay and veneering, so he doesn't have need of a 1-1/4" or 1-1/2" chisel for slicing thin stock, and he has already built his Roubo bench, so he doesn't have immediate need for any chisels much larger than 1/2". He has lately been concentrating on tool chests, campaign furniture, and vernacular furniture (the Furniture of Necessity). A half inch chisel is the most useful size for the scale and style of joinery in these projects, so he can leave the rest of his chisels on the rack and still be successful. He does offer useful advise and a longer tool list in "The Anarchist's Tool Chest."

You can spot furniture from across the room that has been built by someone who limits himself to pre-surfaced dimensional lumber, because all the boards are 3/4" thick, and it thus often looks a little clumsy. Although it is less obvious, limiting yourself to a Spartan tool set also limits the artistry and proportions of the work you can do with it. It may still be completely functional, yet somehow out of balance. Of course, all the tools in all the catalogs won't guarantee finely proportioned results, so, as the others have recommended start simple, and acquire more tools after you have mastered the basic skills and those tools, and only as you need them.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#7

Chisel Monogamy and Hero Worship.....

roger lance

For some its "The Schwarz" or "Saint Roy".....for me, it was Norm....he was my role model....my woodworking guide....and I remember reading his first book where he talked about the importance of a proper woodworking bench with good vises and solid top and frame....and how a bench was vital to a woodworker....the heart of the shop (and a table saw)....and then many seasons into his show, the ww bench was replaced by a lite weight assembly table and that vital, essential ww bench was not seen again....I was perplexed....confused....sometimes things are said because that is what is expected....sometimes things are said to create a little shock and stir....keep your profile raised....sell a book on minimal tool kits....take it all with a grain of salt and get into your shop and make things..... there is where you will know if one chisel does it or you really need a few chisels....or a work bench.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#8

Re: However...

david weaver

Having one chisel only does nothing to impede writing blog posts of different sizes.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#9

Lots of good replies here...

John in NM

I could go either way really. I use my 1/2" chisels most often (yes there are two of them :D ), followed by my 1/4".

When I worked for a shop for a few years, each bench had a set of 4 chisels, supplied by the shop. The boss's bench had a set of 6 (he never built anything any more, did sales and design). I was always borrowing the 5/8" for squaring up the bed rail hardware mortises, those were 5/8" wide and it was easier to do a clean job with the correct width. I'd done them with a 1/2", and often as cleanly, but it took a hair longer that way.

I'll reiterate what others have said here. Look at the stuff Schwarz makes, look at how he works. If that is what you want to emulate, then by all means give his methods a try, though keep Williams observations in mind - a single chisel might have hindered some of Schwarz's past projects.

If you want to build other things, or build a hair faster, or simply derive a sense of pleasure from having chisels to choose from, then Schwarz's advice may not be for you. I think many of us amateurs fall in the latter category, we like having chisels (and planes :D ) to choose from.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#10

Re: Chisel Monogamy

Darren Brewster

Buy a premium 1/2” chisel from Lie-Nielsen, Lee Valley or one of the fantastic Japanese makers. Learn to tune and love that one tool. Then, when you have enough money, buy one of the other sizes that you think you might need for an upcoming project.

That is the gist of what he is saying, not that you shouldn't use more than one chisel, but to buy one nice chisel and expand your set as needed, as opposed to a big set of cheaper chisels. He does say that he uses mostly his 1/2" for everything, but he doesn't say that is the only chisel you should use too.

Posts bagging on Chris Schwarz are just spewing negativity for whatever reason, and should probably be ignored. If you like the projects he builds and the tools and techniques he uses, go for it, and enjoy every minute of it.

For the record, lately I have been using my 1/4" and 1" much more than any others, to the point that I leave them on my bench instead of putting them away, for what that is worth.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#11

Something else to consider....

John in NM

I wonder how many of us who tend to slam the bloggers started out pre-blog? I read FWW for a few years, including many back issues and the compilation books they put out of old articles.

The difference is that though it was a single source of info, it was written by many authors, so in a short time you read articles on several "competing" methods rather than a single author's single opinion of the "best" way.

I may be out in left field here, but I think that is part of why I tend not to like blogs - they need more perspective. Now if you could have the front page of a blog with 6 posts by 6 different people, I might like them better :D

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#12

Re: Chisel Monogamy

L Robins

I think that the type of work influences what you use. I know that on an episode of "The WoodWright's Shop" he recommends a much larger chisel (somewhere around an 1-1/2) for making (widening the knife wall on 1st class cuts.) I agree that to start you don't need a couple of dozen chisels, but having more than one is very useful.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#13

Re: Chisel Monogamy

William Duffield

Ant then there are also the "things that most people would mistake for cabinet making chisels". What I mean is the plastic-handled "sharp" objects that I use for restoring antiques that had been previously "fixed" by someone whose only tool was a hammer, for house and shop renovations, and digging "beeps" out of rough lumber before planing it, etc. No way I would use my LNs for those purposes. However, SWMBO once used an antique Greenley that I had restored as a cold chisel, to remove a frozen nut from an automobile engine. :( Even though I told her which drawer the cold chisels were in, she grabbed the first chisel she found in the tool chest, without even counting the drawers. I guess that means I have to count my cold chisels too. ;)

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#14

Re: Something else to consider....

david weaver

A lot of the early information was from professional woodworkers who took up some writing after they did a lot of woodworking rather than the converse, too. The message is too inconsistent because a lot of the bloggers seem either to not be making much or they're spending a lot of time trying to figure out what they want to do or what things they want to have. If the articles were written by professional woodworkers in the old magazines, they had already figured that out decades prior, and they didn't drag us along for the trip.

I have only been woodworking for about 8 years, and by then, it seemed like FWW was already loaded with ROS comparisons and 14 inch bandsaw tests, and the like.

I just don't remain too convinced that we are miles ahead of where we would be if the blog world instead studied furniture pieces in detail. That bores beginngers, it bored me when I was a beginner, too. Beginners drive the topics because they buy things and ask a lot of questions, so I guess that will always drive blog traffic.

That, and the blogs here and there trying to pitch classes, etc.

There was an initial explosion of interesting stuff (like konrad sauer's detailed pictures of plane building, raney nelson's semi pro and then professional building of planes and methods, etc) but most of that stuff seems to have run its course. Rob Millard had and still has an excellent blog, but it isn't a daily posting kind of thing, probably because there's really no underlying promotion or desire to have posts at all costs, etc.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#15

Re: Chisel Monogamy

L Robins

Ouch!

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#16

Re: Something else to consider....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"...where we would be if the blog world instead studied furniture pieces in detail."

Yes, sir. Great point. That is the beginning of wisdom. There isn't enough life, to do enough work, to make enough mistakes, to figure out which advice is relevant, to reinvent for ourselves what was figured out by the past masters.

Wiley

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#17

Re: Something else to consider....

wilbur

There's been negativity expressed towards woodworking blogs and Christopher Schwarz in this thread. I'd like to point out the following:

1. There isn't a good reason to distinguish between blog writing and magazine writing. There's only good writing and bad writing. You can find both in blogs, magazines, and woodworking forums.

2. It's a demonstrable fact that Chris Schwarz has studied a lot of furniture pieces. And by that, I mean that he's studied a number of pieces that are comparable to any other professional in the field. He may write more on the use of tools and technique than on the construction of pieces, but that doesn't mean that he hasn't studied furniture.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#18

Re: Something else to consider....

William Duffield

And writers for magazines have photographers and editors to fix the spelling and grammar and the stuff that doesn't quite make sense. Sometimes, they are editors. With the rest of them, we have to filter the annoyances, irrelevancies, and sometimes superfluous philosophizing, ourselves.

I agree, Chris Schwarz doesn't deserve the bashing and the attacks from trolls, but I can understand the "Wives Against Schwarz" grass roots movement. :D This may have been an attempt to appease WAS.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#19

Re: Something else to consider....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I respect Chris. My point was limited to the positive potential of David's words I quoted at the top of my post. I liked especially what Chris did with Moxon, and look forward to the Roubo (isn't he or his press involved in that translation?).

Nevertheless, returning now to David's words that I quoted, an analysis by Chris of a furniture example would be a bigger contribution to his own legacy in writing, than the piece about using a single chisel for everything. There is also the longer-term potential for collating a number of such analyses into a book which would be useful for decades to come. This is well within Chris Schwarz' considerable ability.

Wiley

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#20

Re: Comparison is Relative

david weaver

It's not so much bashing Chris Schwarz for the reason of sport, it's a matter of being a little more discriminating when choosing sources of information, especially if the objective is learning to build things with an appropriate (that's left for each person to determine) destination in mind.

To me, an appropriate destination is something that I will look at in 20 years and not say, Gad...why did I leave all of those dovetails exposed on something that was to go in the house? My house was not built in the 1700s, and my living room is not shop space.

I think it's equally important to make note that negative opinions of relatively poor comparative sources are not necessarily a bad thing, especially if you can describe the reason for the negative opinion.

I only need to go back to George's suggestion every time someone on sawmillcreek tried to design something from scratch. There are several centuries worth of good design out there, there is no reason to do anything other than possibly try to incrementally improve something that already exists, and it's very difficult in that case to do it without being at least able to copy what's already there. I went the "wing it" route at first like a lot of people do. I have, for that, throwaway items. They are tight, and I used hand tools to make them, but they're ugly.

Even if I am not building pieces to that level at this point, why should I or anyone else go down the ladder for instruction when superior information is and has been available for decades. I want my mind to be occupied with where I want to go and how to get there, there is a whole world of it available. Not general snippets from someone who hasn't mastered anything of note.

It's true that there can be good and bad writing anywhere. In comparison to most of the well respected texts that are out there now, nearly all of the blogging is very substandard when it comes to content in general, and especially on the balance of sense, taste and proportion vs. tool acquisition and lifestyle type themes.

To the extent that magazines have followed into chasing blog type content around for half of their material, that's too bad. I subscribed again to PWW because I was so pleased with how meagan has hit the street to do a good job, and I still think she has, but I have to admit I have spent a total of about 30 minutes in the 3 or 4 issues that I've received, and I'm sorry I did. I'll bet I've spent 10 hours reading Hoadley's Wood alone. I'll be referring to it for years, I'm sure.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#21

Popcorn??.....


Re: Chisel Monogamy

#22

Re: I hope not!!

david weaver

It would be nice in this case if instead of "my team vs. your team", as Chris has a lot of "fans", if it was "why do other people favor going elsewhere for information".

There is a lot to learn from the latter. I think almost every woodworker will get to the latter if someone leads them in the direction of good taste. It might be as simple as going to established texts and bouncing ideas off of Warren, George, Rob Millard or anyone else who is on the forums, who has been there and done that, and though I have not talked to Rob Millard about anything, I've never seen Warren or George provide an answer without being able to describe a reason from experience. And with someone like george, the level of detail for the "why" is as deep as you want to go as long as you don't bore him with sharpening questions (i don't ask those, anyway) or questions like "which tool should I use".

But the former, and without reason? Not much is learned.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#23

Re: Comparison is Relative

cstanford

That's a fantastic post David. "Go down the ladder..." Why, indeed?

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#24

Guruism

Tony Wilkins

A lot of interesting points here and a lot of response. I wasn't necessarily asking this for myself; though I started out with his previous advice of getting a 1/4" and 3/4" to start, I'd already decided to go on from that. I'm discovering just how useful and powerful a tool a simple chisel can be.

I think some of the points go to something I'd been considering - what advice do you follow? Me as a very newbie woodworker (and one who has done more 'virtual' woodworking through study and forum than I'd like due to physical constraints) is seeking out places to learn. I am trying not to be a 'fan' (in the pejorative) of Schwarz even though he is prolific in print and on the net and I often like his point of view. It seems very easy to become a disciple of a particular net-centric wood personality - whether it's Schwarz, Cosman, Sellars, or Wilbur (yes I read your blog). I think the challenge for me (and probably other new woodworkers) is to broaden our views and tests those of the teachers we like against our own nascent experience and other sources.

That's part of the reason I started this thread; what he was suggesting was moving away from what I was thinking and learning elsewhere.

BTW, my current chisel guru - Adam Cherubini - just ordered a few 16th sizes of chisels after reading a blog he wrote many months ago.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#25

Adam Cherubini

david weaver

I find a lot of adam cherubini's stuff pretty thoughtfully written.

He does like his chisels though. In comparison to this one chisel nonsense, Adam's viewpoint could be summarized as all of the chisels instead of one.