New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Chisel Monogamy

Posts

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#51

Fingers..... OT...

John in NM

I was once commuting to work with a smart guy, way more educated than I was. Or maybe about the same but he was better at paying attention :D

By the time I was in college, everything was either SI units or the dreaded "Imperial" units. No one said "avoirdupois" any more - my theory is that the metric push in the 1970's coincided with Star Wars, and no one wanted to advocate "Imperial" anything, so the metric folks called the other side Imperial :D (no, I'm not really serious :D )

So the point is, I'd never heard avoirdupois pronounced, at least not that I could recall, and as a result I couldn't pronounce it. Took one look at all those vowels and came up with something vaguely Greek sounding (I took German in HS, more comfortable with consonants than vowels :D ).

To this guy's credit, rather than laughing at me, he came up with "Bernie Avrodropolus", the inventor of the ounce. Shake his hand and you notice he's got six fingers. He always says "I don't know what everyone's problem is!"

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#52

William's post reminded me...

John in NM

A great example of exactly what I'm talking about. As usual, I'm making my illustration too complicated.

No one counts avoirdupois units on their fingers. Since it is all readily divisible by 2, they can do it right in their head. For decimal units, they may have to switch to fingers or pen and paper.

If we didn't have use for a very basic, intuitive system of mathematics, avoirdupois units never would have evolved - everything would always have been divisible by 10 rather than 2. It has nothing to do with the number of fingers, but rather the ease of conceptualizing halves and quarters.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#53

Re: The naive and the worldly

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I know you weren't referring to me when you mentioned blogs. I was just including myself here since I view my writings as similar to these blogs. I don't even write a blog, but many refer to the articles as blogs. It all gets a bit much for my tired brain.

Regards from sunny Cape Town

Derek

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#54

Re: We also still have

Kees

If the orchard would be even remotely official, they would have a scale and meassure in kgs. Otherwise you might see a sign with "fill a bucket" or something like that.

The first time I had to deal with the imperial system was when I bought an old Volvo which needed imperial spanner sizes. Each time you reach for a spanner, say a 1/2" and find it a little too small, it takes quite a bit of number crunching to come to the conclusion that you need a 9/16". (Of course my spanners are not neatly arranged on a peg board). In metric, when a 13mm spanner is too small, it's quite obvious that a 14mm one probably is the right size.

BTW, I understand that it is easy to divide an imperial meassurement in 2 or 4 parts. But how easy is it to divide it in 3 parts?

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#55

It's just what you're used to...

John in NM

As your Volvo example well illustrates, to me the sequence of imperial wrenches is just as obvious as the simple counting of the metrics. With each in this case, the real time consuming part is looking at the bolt and getting close in the first place. The learned behavior to eyeball 12mm is the same as to eyeball 1/2" (I had a 1972 Saab in HS, it had a Brit engine, so both sets of wrenches were necessary).

Division by 3 is not so hard, a lot of times it's simple, like say 18". Take 17", whose quotient by three is recurring and you know it's just a hair over 5 5/8". If you want closer than a hair, rules calibrated down to 1/64ths are readily available. Dividing 170 mm is similar, since the quotient is also a recurring decimal, at some point it becomes "just a hair" over or under a real measurement.

The point of all that is that converting any theoretical design to real measurements always involves rounding at some level - fractions, decimal inch, metric. Metric is superior for complex calculations, such as come up in the sciences (SI units technically, not quite metric) - but for our purposes as mechanics and woodworkers, it comes down to liking the one you use most.

For many in the US, woodworkers in particular, mm are simply not intuitive, thus the resistance. Tell a guy to plane a board to 19mm and you'll get a blank stare. Tell him 3/4" and he knows roughly how thick that is without even the tape measure. In the rest of the world it is the converse.

Many, even most, auto mechanics in the US are quite comfortable with both systems and have little problem with either. They've had to develop the learned memory for each and can readily switch back and forth.

Re: Chisel Monogamy

#56

Re: We also still have

William Duffield

But how easy is it to divide it in 3 parts?

Multiply by 4 and change your units from feet to inches. :D

Or, in general, the same way you do it in metric: with a calculator. If you need the result in fractions, it's a bit more difficult, but like you learned your multiplication tables in grade school, it's not difficult to memorize decimal fractions for 16ths, or even 32nds. Of course, your calculator can do that for you. After you've divided by 3, or whatever other factor you need (same as in metric), if you need a fraction, you multiply by 64, and reduce the fraction in your head. 64ths is close enough for most woodworking. If not, you shouldn't be using a graduated measuring stick, anyhow. You should be using dividers and a straghtedge, or dividers and a sector, or a story stick and a marking knife.

Another useful aid is to get yourself a digital caliper with millimeters, decimal fractions and imperial fractions, and a button that converts between the units automatically. That's what I use for figuring out size and placement of Festool Dominos. Like the calipers, I have a calculator that calculates and displays in fractions, if you want them. It also calculates and converts to and from hexadecimal, octal and binary (but not duodecimal :( ). Still it's good to be able to do it in your head, or with simple drafting tools, or even with a slide rule, because you never know when you will run out of power, and not have enough sunlight to drive the solar cell on the calculator.