New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

A reflection

Posts

A reflection

#1

A reflection

Ron Harper

From an old guy to relatively new hand tool users: I have way too many tools.

There, I have said it. A very recent quote from Mike Donaldson prompted this post. He pointed out that he does almost all his work with a handful of tools. Paul Sellers has mounted a crusade ( not to bash power tools, as some think) to point out that one can create gorgeous furniture with ten good hand tools. Yes there are many circumstances that make power tools highly desirable and sensible..BUT for a very large percentage of the population a small kit of good hand tools is all that you really need.

I, like Mike, do most of my work with very few tools that I reach for over and over again... My advice to the folks near the start of the journey, buy tools only as you really have need for them. I have learned recently how incredibly versatile a well tuned Stanley 4 plane can be. A marking gauge, a couple of saws, a couple of chisels, a block plane and a scraper and a 5 1/2 plane can get you a very long way down the road to beautiful furniture. Of course, not everyone will choose to work that way. The point is, you can.

Now... If you want to buy tools because you want to buy tools....let the good times roll.

Re: A reflection

#2

Re: I do, too..

david weaver

... but I like them.

It's kind of nice to not have everyone telling beginners that they need $5000 worth of planes and saws to do basic work, though.

And nice to have someone telling beginners that they can make stuff without having power tools to go along with the hand tools.

What I don't have that I would like is a next door neighbor who plainsaws entire trees like discussed below, as I've finally gotten a pile of wood all from one tree, and I don't know that I want to go back to garbage mixed-bag hardwoods that actually cost more from a retail millwork shop.

Re: A reflection

#3

I resemble that remark

Tony Wilkins

I'm able to spend a chunk of change due to a gift but I've been trying to work from the tools list in the anarchists tool chest. I'm also trying to be wise and not just get tools to get tools It's enlightening and sobering to see what can be accomplished with so few tools and skill. What I'm lacking is the last bit.

Re: A reflection

#4

I have too many hand tools, let alone

Chuck Nickerson

power tools. Then there's all the tools I bought to rehab, only to discover I don't enjoy rehabbing tools.

I am slowly weeding through them and selling off the surplus.

Re: A reflection

#5

Re: A reflection

TomD

It is true that on can get by with a few tools, but it assumes many things. Slow, you can use a number 4 for a lot of things, it just won't do them all as well; nothing ever goes wrong that needs to be ground out, repaired or modified. Furniture is simple or rustic in nature. Krenov style, that almost everyone takes a shot at, is an example of furniture that can be done with a small set of tools.

In my day, and there is a lot more info today than in the 70s. I actually got into power tools when I had to decide to make a workbench, with zero tools, nothing to hold stuff with, and poor tools all around. Or buy one, and at the time decent ones were north of 1970s 1K. Or buy a jointer planer for 895. I did the latter. Ironically when I got my wood, the guy who supplied it had final dimensioned all the wood!

I think people forget that until relatively recently people had zero choices for the basic tools that were really pro grade. I wrote Leonard Lee when he was in charge, and politely pointed out that while they sold many good tools they did not sell one saw, set of chisels, or plane that was pro grade (pretty low standard, just means gets the job done, sometimes with some laborious alterations. Though it really should mean buy it and it works). I think some considerable part of today's nuttiness on tool performance goes back to this long long period when there was a lot of interest in doing fine work, and zero tools available from the major retailers. It is as though the sport of downhill skiing existed but not a single set of equipment existed to get one down a hill.

(Timeline wise I would put this period at the point that the independence saw came out, and FK could actually go out and buy a saw that his workers could use, retail. At around the same time there was an article in FWW that had mario retoothing a gents saw to make it viable for dovetails, the sort of desperate nonsense we were stuck with. I am discounting Japanese tools, which are what I used for those years because they got dropped from the major catalogs, or were not up to quality)

Of course if one thinks of sports, people are constantly upgrading their equipment to the latest stuff, and nobody bothers to point out they could get by on 1970s skis. In reality most sportsmen would be better off sticking with familiar gear a little longer. The seconds they pick up will mean little since few of them race, or whatever. In woodworking, reducing the labour actually does pay off for us, if that were possible through new tool purchases, as it can be. So I don't know why we get so fussed about it.

Today it is very different, there is tons of good stuff, and most of the nonsense is driven by a combination of consumerism, which most people like, but don't admit to liking. Or it is driven by the odd thing where people get into the craft because they think it is about being a tool tester, expert, etc... Or they just didn't get the memo, and don't realize there are adequate tools out there.

Re: A reflection

#6

Re: Amateur vs pro

TomD

Paul Seller etc... usually learned their craft in a relatively short period of time, then they got on with making a living. I am 40 years into this thing, and every few years I pick up a new craft or three. Keeps it interesting. I am diving into leatherwork at the moment, something I started with, but never really got down. Now my stuff is looking good.

One can learn a craft in a 7 year apprenticeship, and probably at least half of that time is stuff that is: time wasting; basic working skills based, like sweeping up; or has nothing to do with the skills but learning the business. One never has to learn how to draw a straight line again, or read plans, or sharpen, so many barriers are the same for new crafts. The experienced person can pick new skills up every year or two. This is what the hacks like Seller do and don't get. I'm just having fun learning new stuff. It does have spectacularly useful areas of overlap, but some of it is probably pointless also. So yeah, one should realize that the basics are chiseling, sawing, and planing to a line, but why would one want to leave it there. In 40 years one could learn at least 20 crafts to a professional standard.

Re: A reflection

#7

Re: Amateur vs pro

TomD

Put more simply, I'm a do it yourselfer. I want to make everything, non-electronic that I come across. You need a ton of tools to do that, and yes, I have too many. The definition of too many is not so much when one might get by with less, but when they stop one from doing more, rather than help one.

Re: A reflection

#8

Derek.....are you listening ???

roger lance

:D

Re: A reflection

#9

Are you serious?

Ron Harper

" hacks like Sellers ". Really?

Re: A reflection

#10

Condescending nonsense


Re: A reflection

#11

Re: A reflection

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Start building stuff and I predict the 10 tool limit will soon pass.

Re: A reflection

#12

Re: A reflection

Patrick Gibbons

Yea, it will soon pass. But those 10 will do 80% of everything you do.

Re: A reflection

#13

Michael Donaldson

Re: A reflection

Michael Donaldson

I wouldn't call anyone like Sellers a hack. There are a lot of instructors out there, some are better than others, each learned the art (or craft if you prefer) in a different way, and each presents a different view of the same solutions. I am also a do-it-yourselfer, but I find great value in the perspectives of those who have focused on a single art (or craft if you prefer). I have taken classes on subjects of which I was already considered an 'expert' (whatever that means), and I still learned something. Anyone who is helping others get into the art (or craft if you prefer) of woodworking is a benefit to all of us.

As far as tools go, I readily admit that I own tools that I have never used. In my defense, I bought all my dad's tools, so I got a package deal (still a $10,000 investment in tools). There are some tasks that I have purpose made tools for, and it is really nice to have them, but I don't need them. Even with them, I do about 90% of the work with 10-12 tools.

Re: A reflection

#14

Re: A reflection

Edward in Vancouver

One of you guys on this forum once said that a pro has the tools he needs, and the hobbyist the tools he wants.

I do have a classical apprenticeship under my belt.....

I apprenticed as a Cook in Switzerland (Luzern) from '85-'88. The Hotel I apprenticed in was built (well some parts of it) in the mid 1500's (the last addition was in the 1700's) and my Chef, who had trained countless apprentices before and after me was used to buying in salt --wet, in 50 kg plastic sacks, and having the apprentices shovel the wet salt in to shallow pans, dry it out in the ovens, chisel it out, and finally run it through the vegetable mill. Me, being an "darned foreigner" and old to boot, (19 vs the typical 15 yr old) questioned the Chef's logic, pointing out that once the salt was dried and what actually made it into the salt bin cost much more per kg than what you could buy at the supermarket in 1 kg pkgs.

But I digress.... as a professional--which I define as one who earns his sole living by one trade/profession, will buy tools I need, but not neccesarily the ones I want. I bought a 30 qt Hobart mixer, I really wanted a 40 qt with a v-belt drive, but the 30 qt was cheaper and I couldn't substantiate the cost difference, the dough being mixed don't know the difference.... Like Mr. Mick Jagger says, "I get what I need". Cooks have a fascination with knives, I have very plain Victorinox knives that I've used for almost 30 years now professionally and have absolutely no intentions of buying any fancy Japanese steel or anything nicer; when a knife gets worn out or lost, I buy the same Victorinox and get back to work..

But that's work, woodworking is a hobby. I save up my money and buy the fancy chisels, P. Sellers can out-mortise me, out-pare me, and out-chisel me blindfolded with a generic Irwin chisel, but I like my Veritas chisels.

I probably could get by with 10 or 15 basic tools, but it wouldn't be fun, and I'm into woodworking for the fun, not to make a living.

Re: A reflection

#15

Re: Sorta

Tom

Everyone is a hack at something. The guy who masters one throw, might not be that good in a gunfight. Specialization is key to commerce, but this isn't a job. I saw a fair amount of his tapes and looked through his book. It's newbie candy. And he does have a lot of cool tricks. He may well be supremely versatile, but that doesn't seem to be the sell.

When you do the DIY thing you have to have the stuff required to make everything. Eventually that adds up. Does sellers make guitars, canoes, sailboats, the hardware for all the above. Eventually you are going to need something more than a #4. Seems like most amateurs do serial projects.

Re: A reflection

#16

Re: 80% or 90%

Tom

Sure we might use the same few tools a lot, though I doubt that number a little. But that really doesn't mean anything if we still need the other tools (and I realize we may end up with a lot of stuff we don't need). It is actually worse, we need a lot of tools that we don't use much. Rather than only use a few tools that we use a lot. That is sorta the woodworking equivalent of the pathetic fallacy.

Pencil, sharpener (several), square, rule, measuring device (no one is really enough), calipers, marking gage, bevel (several), scribe/awl. That is nine.

Then go to sharpening, that is probably another ten. I can keep tools going with just a few things, but I can't get to all the tools that way. Four basic stones, pond, nagura, spritzer, jig...

Re: A reflection

#17

Re: A reflection

Kees

The problem is, good tools are too cheap. I have limited myself to 1 tool a month. After the paycheck gets in I drool over ebay and similar sites to pick up another vintage plane or saw or whatever. Apart from storage problems, cleaning and rehabbing these old tools takes time, which is always scarce.

I now have weird stuff like dado planes, chamfering planes, saws in al possible sizes, countless chisels etc. And still, more and more accumulates in the shop.

Re: A reflection

#18

Sounds like ADHD to me


Re: A reflection

#19

I think what he is trying to say...

John in NM

Is that Sellers is in a group of WW'ing authors who are not professionals at the topic about which they write. In contrast, the previous generation of WW'ing authors had mostly been professional builders in the 1960's through 1980's.

On the one hand, Tom is trolling you a bit. Choice of terms definitely has elicited a response. We all do that to varying degrees. Hard as it is, the best thing to do is ignore those who's choice of words annoys you.

On the other hand, I generally ignore the current generation of WW'ing authors for exactly the reason Tom calls them "hacks". They do not impress me with their good sense, and they do not impress me with their professional achievements outside the field of selling books and videos. I do not, however, think this makes them "hacks", just professional authors whose musings hold little interest for me.

Re: A reflection

#20

Re: Derek.....are you listening ???

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Yes dear ... :)

Ron wrote:

From an old guy to relatively new hand tool users: I have way too many tools.

There, I have said it. A very recent quote from Mike Donaldson prompted this post. He pointed out that he does almost all his work with a handful of tools. Paul Sellers has mounted a crusade ( not to bash power tools, as some think) to point out that one can create gorgeous furniture with ten good hand tools. Yes there are many circumstances that make power tools highly desirable and sensible..BUT for a very large percentage of the population a small kit of good hand tools is all that you really need......

I could make the point that experienced woodworkers, either professional or amateur, do not require many of the special tools that those starting out believe they need. Their insight guides them in understanding what they need to do and the methods they can use.

However this misses the fact that there are many reasons to be woodworking, many levels of woodworking, and many different areas involved in woodworking.

Could I get by with 10 tools? I reckon I could, and sometimes I do if this means that I just make do with the tools I have out because I am too lazy to sharpen another that is dull. Really, I do not see that having only 10 tools would be a big deal. Again, I believe that philosophies such as these miss the point.

There are two issues behind the argument to reduce the size of the tool chest.

The first is that there may be an expectation among those starting out that the work is done by the tools, and therefore you cannot build appropriately without the right tools. Of course as we become more experienced we know that it is not the tools (which nevertheless do help) but that it is the brain that controls the tool is what is important.

The second issue is that those experienced - pros and amateurs alike - develop an increasing degree of cynicism as they encounter those for whom it appears that tool ownership is more important than tool use. Collectors!!! I think that we all need to develop tolerance. I have to watch myself here as well - and I do have a large collection of tools! I can rationalise that I use them all ... or mostly ... OK some don't get used much .... BUT they are my library for reference when writing! ;) You see, it is easy to get petty minded and holier-than-thou.

For most of us this is just a hobby. It is meant to be fun. For myself it is an opportunity to be creative, to work with my hands, to achieve a more immediate, concrete goal than in my day job. Some act as if woodworking must follow specific rules. They prescribe the rules and they prescribe the tools to use, as if this was only one way to work.

Bottom line: everyone starts at the beginning. Some need the reassurance that comes from acquiring many tools. Others will benefit from knowing they need fewer tools to work.

Regards from Perth

Derek

p.s. Mike has a few tools to use because he was camping out, not because this is all he owns. It was a choice forced upon him.

Paul Sellers has an extensive tool collection. The fact that he pushes using a Stanley #4 and then creates a router plane with a block of wood and a chisel obscures his ownership of a great many Lee Valley planes and routers and saws ... I recall him building a tool chest to house his LV tools (which he loves). That is not to knock PS. Just that his message is being taken out of context by some. It is not about cheap tools. It is about making tools work for you.

Re: A reflection

#21

Clint Searl

Re: A reflection

Clint Searl

The measure of a woodworker is taken by the work he does, not by the kind or number of tools he has or uses.

Re: A reflection

#22

Nobody is suggesting

Ron harper

That you should only own ten tools. The point is that you can make very nice furniture with only ten tools, meaning thst one does not have to wait till you have a bunch of money to start woodworking.

Re: A reflection

#23

Agree with Derek

Ron harper

On several levels

1). This is supposed to be fun. Do it your way..even if it means you have two barns full of tools..

2). It is alarmingly easy to justify your fifth set of chisels.

3) do read what the "experts are saying" just do not let it interfere with your woodworking.

4) yes indeedy Paul Sellers is taken out of context to argue with.... Almost as much as the Schwarz

With both individuals , I have seen scathing condemnations of their blogs and the condemner could not have read the blog he was condemning. It was a reaction to what he supposed their position would be, not at all what they actually said.

Re: A reflection

#24

Sellers has two pieces

Ron harper

In the White House collection. Moderate accomplishment?

Re: A reflection

#25

Sure, if you like...

John in NM

If it's nice furniture, I would say having built it is an accomplishment. Why would I care where it is? I've never seen any of his work, but feel free to put up some pictures if that is how you want the discussion to go.

I've yet to see much that would make me find more of Seller's writing, he strikes me as gearing it towards people who want to talk about hand tools more than use hand tools. That strikes me as a waste of time, but then a lot of what I do probably strikes others as a waste of time.