Re: Derek.....are you listening ???
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Yes dear ... 
Ron wrote:
From an old guy to relatively new hand tool users: I have way too many tools.
There, I have said it. A very recent quote from Mike Donaldson prompted this post. He pointed out that he does almost all his work with a handful of tools. Paul Sellers has mounted a crusade ( not to bash power tools, as some think) to point out that one can create gorgeous furniture with ten good hand tools. Yes there are many circumstances that make power tools highly desirable and sensible..BUT for a very large percentage of the population a small kit of good hand tools is all that you really need......
I could make the point that experienced woodworkers, either professional or amateur, do not require many of the special tools that those starting out believe they need. Their insight guides them in understanding what they need to do and the methods they can use.
However this misses the fact that there are many reasons to be woodworking, many levels of woodworking, and many different areas involved in woodworking.
Could I get by with 10 tools? I reckon I could, and sometimes I do if this means that I just make do with the tools I have out because I am too lazy to sharpen another that is dull. Really, I do not see that having only 10 tools would be a big deal. Again, I believe that philosophies such as these miss the point.
There are two issues behind the argument to reduce the size of the tool chest.
The first is that there may be an expectation among those starting out that the work is done by the tools, and therefore you cannot build appropriately without the right tools. Of course as we become more experienced we know that it is not the tools (which nevertheless do help) but that it is the brain that controls the tool is what is important.
The second issue is that those experienced - pros and amateurs alike - develop an increasing degree of cynicism as they encounter those for whom it appears that tool ownership is more important than tool use. Collectors!!! I think that we all need to develop tolerance. I have to watch myself here as well - and I do have a large collection of tools! I can rationalise that I use them all ... or mostly ... OK some don't get used much .... BUT they are my library for reference when writing!
You see, it is easy to get petty minded and holier-than-thou.
For most of us this is just a hobby. It is meant to be fun. For myself it is an opportunity to be creative, to work with my hands, to achieve a more immediate, concrete goal than in my day job. Some act as if woodworking must follow specific rules. They prescribe the rules and they prescribe the tools to use, as if this was only one way to work.
Bottom line: everyone starts at the beginning. Some need the reassurance that comes from acquiring many tools. Others will benefit from knowing they need fewer tools to work.
Regards from Perth
Derek
p.s. Mike has a few tools to use because he was camping out, not because this is all he owns. It was a choice forced upon him.
Paul Sellers has an extensive tool collection. The fact that he pushes using a Stanley #4 and then creates a router plane with a block of wood and a chisel obscures his ownership of a great many Lee Valley planes and routers and saws ... I recall him building a tool chest to house his LV tools (which he loves). That is not to knock PS. Just that his message is being taken out of context by some. It is not about cheap tools. It is about making tools work for you.