Re: A reflection
William Duffield
…or by the shape of the sawdust, shavings and chips on his shop floor.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: A reflection
William Duffield
…or by the shape of the sawdust, shavings and chips on his shop floor.
Re: Sellers has two pieces
Tom
That is an interesting question, People do send stuff as gifts to the White House, and other places. If it is serious enough to be worth recognizing they may get their photo taken. There is stuff of that type all over the place, like overnighting in the Lincoln Bedroom. What it means is anyone's guess. In the case of the Maloof rocker they have in their collection, I think it is probably fairly worthy, though to the extent I know that, it is because I already was aware of his reputation. So I am not sure what it really added to my admiration for his work to see him handing it off to RR or whomever it was.
More seriously, it is an open question how important any of the modern woodworkers are. People who are household names in woodworking circles rarely show up in the serious furniture journals. Some are becoming more collectible now that they are dead, which is another issue altogether. There are well known furniture designers who did not have to die to garner accolades, and I do not know enough to say what that means either.
Re: Nobody is suggesting
Tom
The go nuts and buy everything world of hand tool woodworking is pretty recent. So the idea that a few tools will get her done is nothing new. My Grandfather made a very good living, and the only "power tool" they had was a foot operated mortise machine. If you run across people who absolutely think they need the whole Hotley catalog before they can even consider starting, then you are in a position to do them a service, though I suspect they will not thank you for it, since normally they want to buy all that stuff.
I firmly believe hand tool woodworking has taken off recently because all of a sudden there is a ton of stuff to buy. Not in spite of it. I certainly agree that minimalism is an option, but it is not so much something people engage in out of personality or need as it is something they can explore once they have bought everything else. One can then can turn oneself to buying the minimal tool set also.
I always keep this list around my shop for inspiration, not that I think they can get many complex moldings out with it.
http://www.crfinefurniture.com/1pages/shopinfo/toollist.html
Re: I think what he is trying to say...
Tom
That is an interesting take too.
I was being serious, though at this point it is unfair to Sellers who doesn't probably deserve to be the focus of all this. My point is seriously that there are many pros who are good at what they do, roto rooting, or something. They aren't good at anything else. (or if they have a passion for putting ships in bottles, they don't muddy the message by telling us about it). I don't take serious direction from these know nothings on how I would best conduct my activities. I have been at this stuff about 40 years now.
Take the Krenov books. Part of what he set out was a serious treatment of the amateur in woodworking. To him there was nothing necessarily second rate about the position. Maybe Krenov was mostly interested in the freedom to do good work it accorded. People spinning a buck keeping the punters happy don't have all that much to tell this person. And it is the same with those who have some perception on what kind of tools one should have, from whatever set of assumptions. I don't think it is always the case that whatever makes a specialist is the same stuff that makes a great polymath (if there is such a thing)
Re: Sellers has two pieces
david weaver
It is nice work, but it is nothing spectacular. I would suppose that the reason it is there has more to do with relationship or salesmanship or maybe even just opportunistic circumstance.
Just my guess.
I haven't seen anything from Sellers to believe he's remotely on par with someone like George Wilson, who has a much longer list of items built or items that he's contributed part of for presidents and dignitaries.
The important point here is that I've talked to George and numerous times he's mentioned that people have asked him if he would write books, make materials or take up teaching courses, and he's always said that there are too many things that he wanted to do (and still wants to do) to have time for that. Even now, when I talk to him offline, he's hobbled by the fact that he's worn out his body, but he's brimming with things he still wants to do - and those things don't include peddling himself to beginners. Not that there's anything wrong with Mr. Sellers seeing an opportunity and taking advantage of it.
It's fine that he is accomplished, but there are many who appear to be much more accomplished, unless there is a great library of spectacular pieces paul has not shown anywhere.
It is my opinion that paul is selling a somewhat misleading notion that we'd be better off with a craft economy (we've been there, most people live in poverty), more or less criticizing the goose while allowing her to hand over the golden egg. A lot of people just eat it up, i think it's farce. You, too, can fork over a substantial sum of money (that you'd never have if you worked in a craft economy) learning a hobby (that you'd never have time for if you worked in craft economy) and achieve nirvana playing Billy Big Rigger at the bench for a little while.
Take george again as an example, ask him about life in a craft economy and see what he says. Ask him if he'd like to live in it.
PS...I do like ...
david weaver
...I do like Paul's blog when he can keep the discussion to working the wood and stay away from the woe is me stuff.
Dang it David....
John in NM
You got me to go read some of it....
right after breakfast too 
I typed out a humorous critique of the bits I managed to get through... but then erased it all, as I'm sure some would have found it offensive.
I'm going to go get some work done, wasted enough time already this morning 
Re: Sorry.....
david weaver
...you do have to choose your steps carefully. It's like walking through a pasture, easy to find stuff that stinks.
In one thread, there is discussion about tools, and in the next is a whole group of people whose lives have been saved from eternal unending discontent