New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Comparing chisel steels

Posts

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#51

Re: Pincher

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am saying that if you hold the chisel in such a way that you have little control, it is more likely to flop around and beat up the edge.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#53

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

david weaver

Agree completely re: the angles, etc. Setting up chisels 2 degrees above where razors are ground certainly has never been described anywhere as "the right way" or any of this other goofiness about how folks will come to once they know the secret in the dirt.

Sounds like there is either:

* a detachment from reality

* a poor estimate of what the angle really is

* pee taking for the sake of forum fun

Given that the rest of us don't "have lots of problems with our chisels", I have to assume it could be a combination of 1 and 2, or it's entirely 3.

Otherewise it's only all of history to argue against.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#54

Totally agree!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

An excellent comparison, and I appreciate the time he took to document the test. The PMVII and Koyama-ichi white steel horse race is interesting. (I sometimes wonder why white and blue steel are not imported as specialty steels here.)

Wiley

As a minor footnote, I think it's worth distinguishing between high carbon steel (HCS) and O1. In context, I understand why Derek lumped them, since who knows exactly what Stanley used, and the differences do not figure in his results or main points.

HCS would be exemplified by 1095 or W1 or vintage steel. Or indeed, the white steel used in his comparison! O1, on the other hand is alloyed with carbide formers such as chromium (0.4 to 0.6%), tungsten (0.4 to 0.6%), and in some formulations vanadium (0.3%).

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#55

Chisel wiggling

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

This business of the chisel edge moving laterally under mallet blows is an interesting observation! And makes sense.

I have an acquaintance whose handtool skills I highly respect, and who is a student of the fine points, swears that the best way to prepare a mortise chisel is to put a slight back bevel on it, to balance the lateral forces a bit. Not a heavy bevel, just a swipe or two on the final stone. He was all "you gotta try this!" I never did, because I just hate to mess with the back of a blade, but am reminded of his recommendation by Warren's observation (though I'm not equating what Warren is saying with the back bevel recommendation).

Wiley

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#56

Your engineering, and assumptions, are flawed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"You don't get bending (or chipping) without sideways force." This statement is incorrect.

Load a rectangular beam and it deflects. It deflects even if the force is perfectly orthogonal to its long axis and top. That's why flanged I-beams were invented. Ditto for a point. If the force on the point exceeds the strength of the metal supporting it it will deflect or chip. (Actually, I prefer the word "crumble" to describe the result of stressing a chisel tip that is insufficiently hard. see Picture, Sorby chisel after dovetailing walnut)


To presume that holding a chisel close to the wood surface while establishing the first cut along a scribed baseline results in lack of control is similarly flawed. The fastest way to precisely locate and control the chisel in the scribed line is with a grip close to the wood and hand supported on the wood. The tiny taps used to establish the initial shoulder along the scribe line do not result in lack of control for even the moderately practiced user. Given the number of picture references to this grip, as well as personal observations of experienced woodworkers, this conclusion is not unique to my way of doing things.

By analogy, if the task was to stick a piece of wire into a tiny hole on the surface of aboard, which would be most reliable? Grip the wire 6" from the end and poke at the hole, or grip the wire at its end with hand on the board and slide it to the hole?

However, in situations where locating the chisel tip is easy, for example once a shoulder is established or when a guide block is employed ( a crutch I find unnecessary) and/or more robust whacks are employed (mortising) a handle grip becomes preferred, if not essential.

Hence, the preferred grip depends on the competing challenge of quickly and precisely locating the chisel tip and better control while whacking. Depending on many variables the woodworker may at times prefer one over the other, guided by their experience.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#57

Re: Pincher

Alex Y

I hold a child by the handle


Must be an Aussie expression; we just say "hold a child by the hand" over here :)

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#58

Orthogonal to the axis

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Orthogonal, eh? Orthogonal to the long axis meant perpendicular to the axis when I was in engineering school.

Chisel crumbling from dovetailing walnut? You are bolstering my argument.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#59

Re: Pincher

david weaver

I want a child handle, there are times I could use one to keep my daughter going in the right direction when we're out.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#60

Re: Pincher

Tony Wilkins

Another one wanting a child handle over here. I need plans pronto to control my five year old!

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#61

Re: Pincher

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Interesting slip of the finger, as my mate Sigmund would have said. Child = chisel, of course. Why did I type child? "By the hand" = By the handle. I'll have to work these out. More therapy?

The alternate explanation is that I misspelt "chisel" and "handle", and the computer corrected these automatically.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#62

Re: Chisel wiggling

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



This business of the chisel edge moving laterally under mallet blows is an interesting observation! And makes sense.


Hi Wiley

All edges will move in a direction that is guided by the bevel angle. Equalize the angle on both sides of the blade, and the direction it travels will change. This is well illustrated when mortising, and quite graphically by the behind-the-glass demonstrations at recent WIA shows.

How does this effect the chiseling of dovetails, and does it cause extra stress on the edge of the blade?

Definitely yes to the first. That is the reason why many, specially those starting out, use a guide block to ensure the base lines are chiseled both straight and square. The fence forces the chisel to cut in a perpendicular direction. That could create undue stress. I (and others) do something similar - Undercut the baseline so that there is a fence for the chisel back to rest against. This ensures a straight baseline, but it does not prevent the direction the blade is traveling in (so I doubt there is extra stress), and one tends to end up with a slight undercut, which is fine.

So, is there extra stress on the edge blade? By logic (I am not an engineer), I think that harder woods will "trap" the edge more than softer woods, and this will could cause deformation. So it would come down to how well the steel can cope with flex. Harder steels may be less elastic and thus may cope less well than softer steels? The question is, as Warren implies, that this is user driven, that is, it is induced by the hand of the chisel user. I am not so sure about that being avoided by anyone. How much movement is needed? Holding the chisel low vs high could have an effect on stability. How one stands over the chisel and pushes it .. ? The type of hammer used - soft vs hard head ...?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#63

Re: Pincher

roger lance

maybe you are holding your hands incorrectly when you type....just sayin.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#64

Re: Pincher

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

It can also be the iPad I sometimes (have been) using. Keystrokes are not completed, and then the computer fills in the missing part. Of course, it would help if I checked what I wrote before I pressed "send"! Or is that too logical? :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#65

Re: Pincher

roger lance

Derek.....I'm very glad we have an "edit" option here because I'm using it on just about everything I post (what might Sigmund say about that?) :\

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#66

If any doubt remains....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

or if onlookers are uncertain of the chisel holding position I use for dovetailing you may consult either the Rob Cossman or Frank Klause video on dovetailing or the Ian Kerby book, page 90. I may have learned it from one of these sources, or Buddy Floyd, or just picked it up, for it seems a natural position for the task.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#67

I'm in good company

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Should I be in Rome I will do as the Romans do but for the here and now I will continue to do what Rob Cossman, Frank Klause and Ian Kirby do ( and a host of others ) and hold the chisel by the blade when locating the edge in dovetailing. Ian's book page 91-91 illustrate the technique well. I am not advocating that this is the only way, just that it is a common way among experienced woodworkers.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#68

Lee Valley data refute this hypothesis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The photomicrographs of dulled edges from using their chisel dulling machine, which would not involve the proposed wiggling involved in holding a chisel by the blade, match those I have made on similar metals. Again, wiggling isn't a requirement for crumbling or chipping. Compressive force will do the job.

Alan Batty, the English trades person, described to me drawer building in the factory he worked at. The tails in the white oak sides were pared after most of the waste was removed by three saw cuts. Tools were sharpened during mid day break and evening with stropping done during work. Chisels held up to the white oak and paring may be the key.

We need someone with metallurgy expertise for this discussion. It may be that the forces that crumble or chip depend on the rate the force is applied. A smart whack may apply more of these forces than a slow pare for the same amount to travel through the wood.

That said, everyone I know whacks dovetails, so a more robust steel remains beneficial.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#69

One of Murhpy`s laws is...

Bob Hackett

"If it looks stupid yet works, it ain`t stupid".

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#70

Re: It may seem...

david weaver

...more obvious at first to pick a chisel up by its blade, but in the long term it is much less fatiguing and at least as fast (or faster, and much less annoying) to learn to dovetail or make any cut in any line by holding a chisels by its handle.

It also works well no matter your orientation to a board.