Re: The school of hands on experience
Tom
"Your credibility as an arbiter of of proper dovetailing would be enhanced if you accompanied your pronouncements with something you recently, or ever, dovetailed, a drawer for example."
No it wouldn't because it isn't a fundamental. I'm sure somewhere there is someone doing a cracking job with their toes, certainly with less than 5 fingers. The fact that their work in just wonderful doesn't make it the generally correct way, any more than copious amounts of name dropping.
"It was not hard to find pictures of famous people holding a chisel at the blade and not the handle, especially if the worker favored a short chisel that makes this position comfortable and quickest to locate the chisel in the scribe line."
That applies to a handle hold as well, easier to find a line with a short chisel.
Famous people have bad habits also, but there are doubtless some cases where holding the blade is better, it just seems there are a lot of current day faddists who never hold the chisel by the handle, or seem able to make a competent go of it. I am normally more convinced by people who can do, rather than those who dream up fanciful reasons for why people who do something actually can't be doing it.
" (It is definitely not comfortable with a top heavy chisel) I could add most of the people I have seen cut a drawer to this school and some would be names we all know."
Wow a rare opportunity to drop a name passed you by there... So why again is it that long chisels exists since they are even harder to line up when being held by the handle which is apparently not even possible with short chisels, and apparently they can't be comfortably held by the blade either?
"But the bottom line is that anyone making stuff will soon discover what position is quickest and most comfortable for them and the tool they own."
That probably isn't really true. The reality of technical stuff is that most people rapidly discover bad habits that they never overcome. And it is almost always really difficult to get them to drop them.
" To say that what they discover is improper would be presumptuous, and simply incorrect in my experience, which is making stuff and hanging around others that make stuff."
"Improper", you mean like not using the right fork, or insider trading. Or like "maybe you should hold that thing by the handle"? That does sound serious. So how do you hold a saw?