New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Comparing chisel steels

Posts

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#26

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

CStanford

Jesum.

David, I'm going to build something with the wood. You'll be more than welcome to evaluate the end result. And you're more than welcome to ignore the narrative that will go with. I generally don't bludgeon wood but I don't dance around, en pointe, in toe-shoes while working it either.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#27

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

CStanford

Derek, being the perfectionist he is, would probably think my edges had experienced 'failure' before I even touched them to wood.

And really, that's that point - these things are largely subjective and subject to the 'eye of the beholder.'

We'll see.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#28

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

david weaver

Certainly the description of what is sharp and what's not and what's failed and what hasn't is going to vary a lot from person to person.

I've got no interest in critiquing your work, and at the same time have no interest in seeing the typical disagreement with anything derek does just for the sake of stirring the pot.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#29

Re: Comparing chisel steels

Paul M.

Thanks Derek. That was a good user comparison. I love to see real-world examples like this one.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#30

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

cstanford

I think that Derek is well-meaning but I think the end result of a lot of these sorts of things are false dichotomies and distinctions that don't always make as material a difference as they are presented as making.

That they reinforce your consumption habits is unfortunately abundantly clear.

I fully expect to have to touch up edges a bit more often when working this wood but not compromise the quality of cut one iota. I fully expect as well, over the course of a small to medium box project, that it will add less than five minutes worth of time to the build. Actually, I don't expect it, I KNOW it. Over the course of Derek's build, I would estimate maybe 20 to 30 minutes. I don't know how long it will take him to build his blanket chest-- maybe 40 hours, probably less. So, we're talking about very, very small percentage of additional time over the course of a build to maintain cut quality of a regular run-of-the-mill chisel on a harder than average wood.

And I won't put a chisel to this particular wood that is ground and honed higher than 20*. I don't like pushing a glorified shank through wood no matter who blows fog up my butt about how 'great' a tool it is. One of these days you and Derek will discover that the extra pressure you have to use to push and hammer 30* chisels through wood is part of what's causing your problems. You can snarl, curl your lip, and spew all you want to but it won't change the truth. Warren either said it in this thread, or in one on another forum on the same subject-- all this edge 'failure' says more about the woodworker than it does the tool.

You seem like a good guy. Go buy a set of inexpensive but serviceable chisels and grind them at 18* to 20* and MAKE yourself learn how to actually use them. I promise you'll never regret it. It will open up a new world for you. There's not a dime's worth of difference in this and learning that a real golf swing is nothing more than lazily cracking a bullwhip on top of a golf ball. You're going to 'get it' one day and it's going to be a beautiful day.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#31

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

david weaver

Totally bizarre presumptuous self aggrandizement.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#32

Reconsidering chisel steels

Tony Wilkins

What does this mean to me who is so far using just walnut and cherry? I had been planning on buying more of the Blue Spruce A2 but this seems to show that in harder woods it just won't cut it (at least for very long literally). With this I might have to take a more serious look at the Veritas or some White Steel Japanese Nomi.

Bonus question: Have always thought of getting Barr Tools chisels. Being hand forged, is their steel close to Japanese white steel?

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#33

Re: Pallet Grade!


Re: Comparing chisel steels

#34

Reality check

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the grand scheme of making a chest of drawers not much time is spent chiseling the dovetails. Hence, it is not worth much to even double chisel edge life. If your chisels are multitaskers their ergonomics should trump steel, for any well made chisel has steel that is good enough. A tall, top heavy chisel that causes hand cramps when dovetailing will not get dull quick enough to allow a break.

That said, and a point overlooked by the high performance steel critics, if you are buying or making a new tool, why wouldn't one buy the tool with the best steel for the task, presuming it could be found with good ergonomics? This of course is exactly what Lee Valley did. Instead of accepting steel that had been used for decades they searched for the best steel available today.

If you are making chests, likely a rare project, you may be forced to deal with a wood that challenges edges. But it makes no sense to do so building a drawer. Pick the wood and dovetail design to make life easy.

For example, the English are fond of mahogany drawer fronts and white oak sides. If you accept that white oak sides make any sense (I don't) then look at the dovetail style they chose. The amount of wood removed from the soft, easily chiseled mahogany is large and the wood removed from the recalcitrant oak is tiny and removed with just a single paring cut after sawing. Even 1720 chisels hold up under this favorable situation.

Bottom line, if you like what you got there is little practical reason to look for something "better". But, if starting fresh shrink the field on ergonomics and then buy the best steel among the possibilities.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#35

Re: Barr...

david weaver

Barr's chisels are hammer forged as far as I know, but they are probably something with a little bit less carbon than white #2 or white #1 chisels. I'd be surprised if they weren't very good, though, given he's making them and they're not just being turned out blindly.

There was a squirt of time a couple of years ago where people were prasing the barr cabinetmaker chisels, but I've seen almost nothing about them since. Wouldn't be surprised if a lot of that had to do with price, or the fairly heavy look that they have because of the sockets.

As far as using O1 and A2, you use a lot of walnut and cherry, I'd think if money counts, you could just sharpen them more in the off chance that you're doing HB or through dovertails in maple or hickory or something.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#36

Re: Reconsidering chisel steels

Tom

As far a Barr is concerned, I love mine. But for the price they are the worst edge holding steel I have. They are the best chisel format I have in a western tool. I bought mine around 2000. They are O1, and I have made better O1 chisels. Some of mine were his earliest Chryo O1, but there wasn't any difference. I would buy them again, just buy one to try out and see how good the temper is. Chances are since obviously he was working at it back then that he has it nailed by now. But being O1 they are more a walnut and cherry or mahog kind of thing than for something hideous.

I have a ton of Japanese chisels. I'm guessing I would win a contest for time in shop x cost x number, most days. I think they probably win if you are into it. Best design, best execution, best steel, not even close, but I personally feel you don't get the most out of them unless you are willing to play along. I would buy some cheaper HSS Japanese chisels before most any western ones, but to get into all the mystique thing, you really need to want to hand sharpen them and use them in a Japanese way. And they cut different joints in different woods than we do. Yeah they are the best, but Bill has always had a point about his nasty steels and diamond sharpening also. I've been at it so long I am not going to stop working with Japanese tools. But it would be hard to make a purely rational case for re-upping if my shop burned down...

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#37

Re: Barr...

Tom

"Barr's chisels are hammer forged as far as I know, but they are probably something with a little bit less carbon than white #2 or white #1 chisels. I'd be surprised if they weren't very good, though, given he's making them and they're not just being turned out blindly."

He is very well regarded in the timber framing circles, or was. As you know that is mostly pine and oak, and western softwoods. They also like trad tools so they are OK with O1, which last I heard was what all Barr is.

"There was a squirt of time a couple of years ago where people were prasing the barr cabinetmaker chisels, but I've seen almost nothing about them since. Wouldn't be surprised if a lot of that had to do with price, or the fairly heavy look that they have because of the sockets."

He named them after Beckworst (sp), who I don't actually see using them any more. The heavy and sockets part is the part he absolutely got right. They look way nicer than the LN or LV, I think. But I think you are probably right that they don't have enough doo dahs, combined with crappy blade to handle jonery techniques to make most buyers happy.

"As far as using O1 and A2, you use a lot of walnut and cherry, I'd think if money counts, you could just sharpen them more in the off chance that you're doing HB or through dovertails in maple or hickory or something."

+1, keep on top of the sharpening. Keep a leather strop with diamond on it and keep the edge fresh. I have really got into that with my leather work, where, as with scythes, the tools need to be sharpened every few cuts.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#38

Re: Barr...  Drawknife

Tom

I have one, it is a favourite, an excellent tool, and the edgeholding is excellent for O1. So again, my guess is he probably has this nailed by now. I think another reason his cabinetmaking options aren't as highly regarded is that he does so well with the Timber guys, he may not have the need.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#39

Re: The Pincher school

Tom

+1 on the rest of it.

"A tall, top heavy chisel that causes hand cramps when dovetailing will not get dull quick enough to allow a break."

This is why people should make up their own minds on stuff. If people insist on pinching chisels where they weren't designed to be held, their mileage will vary from someone else who holds them properly. I was taught to sharpen chisels sides and hold them by the handle while whaling on them with a steel hammer. But if a person doesn't want to do it that way, they will get all bloody pinching those chisels (side sharpening didn't help me as it happens). So people may have to sort stuff out themselves. The advantage to a school of use is that everything is designed to work harmoniously. The disadvantage to the grazzing we get on the internet is that there are more ideas available which is great, but some are probably "wrong" while others don't always play together well.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#40

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

Tom

"And I won't put a chisel to this particular wood that is ground and honed higher than 20*. I don't like pushing a glorified shank through wood no matter who blows fog up my butt about how 'great' a tool it is. One of these days you and Derek will discover that the extra pressure you have to use to push and hammer 30* chisels through wood is part of what's causing your problems. You can snarl, curl your lip, and spew all you want to but it won't change the truth. Warren either said it in this thread, or in one on another forum on the same subject-- all this edge 'failure' says more about the woodworker than it does the tool."

The reality is that the standard 25 degree edge is not exactly stout. In the universe of edges it is getting towards the fine side. Knives that are hand pushed in generally softer materials are often 45 deg or higher. Generally, the universe of millions of woodworkers, over centuries, on opposites sides of the globe, in vastly different tool cultures, with different primary woods, having chosen the same edge angles, probably means more than one guy with a set of Blue Chips.

Bevel angles are about more than edge holding, which you have already pointed out is overrated. And of course you can have high edge angles and low body angles and get deep penetration anyway.

Since you have worked out what works for you, why wouldn't you also want a better club to hit it with. It's a false dichotomy to say it is either technique or tool. As you point out, it is only minutes per project, or in this case pennies per year.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#41

The school of hands on experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"their mileage will vary from someone else who holds them properly"

Your credibility as an arbiter of of proper dovetailing would be enhanced if you accompanied your pronouncements with something you recently, or ever, dovetailed, a drawer for example.


It was not hard to find pictures of famous people holding a chisel at the blade and not the handle, especially if the worker favored a short chisel that makes this position comfortable and quickest to locate the chisel in the scribe line. (It is definitely not comfortable with a top heavy chisel) I could add most of the people I have seen cut a drawer to this school and some would be names we all know.

But the bottom line is that anyone making stuff will soon discover what position is quickest and most comfortable for them and the tool they own. To say that what they discover is improper would be presumptuous, and simply incorrect in my experience, which is making stuff and hanging around others that make stuff.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#42

Re: Barr...  Drawknife

david weaver

Figured as much. I'm sure they are nice chisels, and I'm sure that O1 can't be done much better. I was thinking timber tools,too, as I wrote that, but I don't know anyone who uses them. I just know every time I've been in a store and seen the barr chisels (and especially the drawknives, slicks and stuff) in person, they have all been the timber framing chisels. Not surprised that's his market.

I'd bet their biggest hurdle (the cabinet chisels) is they're over 80 bucks per, and most everything with wide appeal is less than that.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#43

Re: Reconsidering chisel steels

david weaver

Well, you shot down my guess on them being fantastic O1.

Ditto on the sentiments about the HSS (and semi HSS) japanese chisels. They are a good dirty little secret.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#44

Re: The school of hands on experience

Tom

"Your credibility as an arbiter of of proper dovetailing would be enhanced if you accompanied your pronouncements with something you recently, or ever, dovetailed, a drawer for example."

No it wouldn't because it isn't a fundamental. I'm sure somewhere there is someone doing a cracking job with their toes, certainly with less than 5 fingers. The fact that their work in just wonderful doesn't make it the generally correct way, any more than copious amounts of name dropping.

"It was not hard to find pictures of famous people holding a chisel at the blade and not the handle, especially if the worker favored a short chisel that makes this position comfortable and quickest to locate the chisel in the scribe line."

That applies to a handle hold as well, easier to find a line with a short chisel.

Famous people have bad habits also, but there are doubtless some cases where holding the blade is better, it just seems there are a lot of current day faddists who never hold the chisel by the handle, or seem able to make a competent go of it. I am normally more convinced by people who can do, rather than those who dream up fanciful reasons for why people who do something actually can't be doing it.

" (It is definitely not comfortable with a top heavy chisel) I could add most of the people I have seen cut a drawer to this school and some would be names we all know."

Wow a rare opportunity to drop a name passed you by there... So why again is it that long chisels exists since they are even harder to line up when being held by the handle which is apparently not even possible with short chisels, and apparently they can't be comfortably held by the blade either?

"But the bottom line is that anyone making stuff will soon discover what position is quickest and most comfortable for them and the tool they own."

That probably isn't really true. The reality of technical stuff is that most people rapidly discover bad habits that they never overcome. And it is almost always really difficult to get them to drop them.

" To say that what they discover is improper would be presumptuous, and simply incorrect in my experience, which is making stuff and hanging around others that make stuff."

"Improper", you mean like not using the right fork, or insider trading. Or like "maybe you should hold that thing by the handle"? That does sound serious. So how do you hold a saw?

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#45

Re: Your picture is hilarious x 2

Tom

I just noticed the picture you have there. For one thing it is Becks using the Barr chisel we are discussing, did you know that? If so I missed the joke on the first go around.

On the other hand, you picked a picture of a guy who is famous for advocating tails first dovetailing, that he started with because it ticked off his dad! So yeah, maybe his mom told him he had to hold chisels by the handle... Then along you come and stumble right into it!

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#46

If you prefer Two Cherries

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


FWW #192 page 28

BTW, for anyone interested I ran across a good article on dovetail making titled the "Dovetail Doctor" FWW #201 page 76. It was an article on ergonomic issues that help with this joint.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#47

Pincher

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, if you hold the chisel like a pencil, it is no wonder that you need a short handled chisel to avoid cramps. And it is no wonder that your edges are getting chipped and bent no matter what exotic alloy is used. You won't find an 18th century illustration of a worker holding a chisel in such a manner. Even the Romans knew how to hold a chisel.

.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#48

Re: Pincher

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, if you hold the chisel like a pencil, it is no wonder that you need a short handled chisel to avoid cramps. And it is no wonder that your edges are getting chipped and bent no matter what exotic alloy is used.

Hi Warren

I am curious how holding the blade this way will cause it to chip? Will you please explain.

I hold a child by the handle, and this is supposed to cause the blade to chip as well.

Is there another way?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#49

Re: Pincher

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Derek, you recently wrote:

If an edge is too brittle, it will chip.

If an edge is too soft, it will fold over.

If an edge is just right, it will wear to a round.

This suggests that the temper has to be just right to avoid folding and chipping. Certainly a tool that is tempered too much will fold easily and one that is tempered not enough will chip easily. However, I have changed the temper on tools and not had problems with either temper.

I think technique has a lot to do with these problems. Give a beginner a chisel and he will beat up the edge even if you watch him like a hawk. Using a short chisel or holding the chisel like a pencil leaves you with little angular control, no leverage to hold the angle steady. So the chisel is flopping around with every blow of the mallet. If the wood is at all hard, the fragile edge is wiggling in a very constricted place. You don't get bending (or chipping) without sideways force.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#50

Re: Pincher

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, you recently wrote:

If an edge is too brittle, it will chip.

If an edge is too soft, it will fold over.

If an edge is just right, it will wear to a round.

This suggests that the temper has to be just right to avoid folding and chipping. Certainly a tool that is tempered too much will fold easily and one that is tempered not enough will chip easily. However, I have changed the temper on tools and not had problems with either temper.


I also wrote, "The A2 chipped quickly. The Veritas chipped eventually. It is quite likely that LV/Veritas got it just right (as hard as possible for the longest duration)."

I could add that the White Steel and the O1 did not chip at all.

I think technique has a lot to do with these problems. Give a beginner a chisel and he will beat up the edge even if you watch him like a hawk. Using a short chisel or holding the chisel like a pencil leaves you with little angular control, no leverage to hold the angle steady. So the chisel is flopping around with every blow of the mallet. If the wood is at all hard, the fragile edge is wiggling in a very constricted place. You don't get bending (or chipping) without sideways force.

So what you are saying, Warren, is that you have the touch and we others do not. :\

A few too many assumptions there I would think ...

Regards from Perth

Derek (The Flailer of Chisels)