New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Comparing chisel steels

Posts

Comparing chisel steels

#1

Comparing chisel steels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Call it multitasking :) While building the current project, a blanket chest, I took the time to do a few reviews, one of which was to compare 4 different chisels .. 5 if you add in the chisel that tidied up after some of the others.

The wood used is 3/4" thick Curly Marri. This is hard - not quite as hard as Jarrah overall (although sections were very hard indeed), but i can only describe it as "chewy". That is, it is extremely interlocked and it resisted attempts to drive a chisel through it. Where Jarrah is very hard, it is also brittle and breaks away. This Curly Marri just did not let go. Firewood. Beautiful firewood.

I did not set out to compare chisels when I began dovetailing the sides. This thought occurred to me when I was into the first side. I decided to continue as I had begun: using two chisels, one for the tails, and one for the pins. The tails would be comfortably cut only by pushing the 1/4" chisel (frankly, anything wider would not penetrate the wood). The 3/4" chisel would be used with a mallet (I did persevere with pushing where possible, and now have a painful rotator cuff for my pains).

The boards are 20" across. There are 13 tails 3/4" at the baseline (the ratio is 1:6 for those curious), and 14 pins with 1" at the back and 1 1/4" at the front.


Most of the dovetail waste was removed with a fretsaw, and it was the remainder that constituted the test material ...


The chisels used (in order) were the Veritas PM-V11, Stanley #750 (which is a HCS similar to O1, but I am unsure of the specific type), Koyamaichi white steel, and Blue Spruce A2. All the bevels of the 1/4" chisels were ground and honed at 30 degrees, while all the 3/4" chisels bar the Veritas were also at 30 degrees. The Veritas was at 25 degrees (why? Because I use it that way and did not think to change the bevel angle).

Paring ended when the chisel could not easily cut and then failed a pine end grain attempt ...


All dovetails were pared half-way through one side, then the board was flipped over and the other side done. In this way a board may be said to have 26 tail and 28 pin cuts.

The tails were cut first.

Both the PM-V11 and the White Steel had no difficulty paring 26 cuts (both sides of the tails, an example is above).

The Stanley could only manage 3 cuts ...


The A2 did a little better with 7 cuts ..


With the 3/4" chisel on the pin board, both the PM-V11 and the White Steel were able to do most of both sides. 22 1/2" (out of 31 1/2") of pin length for the PM-V11 and 27 1/2" of pin length for the White Steel.

PM-V11 cleaning up ...


White Steel at work (I managed to push these, then required a hammer to continue) ...


The Stanley managed 4" in all, failing on the 5th ..


The A2 completed 7" ..


What of the fifth chisel I mentioned early on? To clean up when a chisel stopped working, I used a Funmatsu-Nezumi-Haisu (from Tools from Japan). This is a PM-HSS chisel. A right royal pain in the bottom to sharpen, but it holds an edge like nothing else ...


Summing up: The PM-V11 and the White Steel really do deliver. The gap between them and the A2 and O1/HCS is very large. There is no appreciable extra effort to hone the steels when used with modern waterstones, such as Shaptons (used here) or Sigmas.

It must be emphasised that this was about the steel, not the chisels. What do I mean by that? A chisel is not simply a lump of steel with a handle. Edge-holding is sometimes less important than balance and control and comfort when in use. The Stanley here is one of my favourite users as I customed the handles for myself. The Blue Spruce are one of the nicest chisels around, which arguably the best handles made on this planet. The Veritas handles are really excellent as well, and the balance in use is surprisingly good, and they are lighter than they look, but not as light as the BS. All good chisels. It is only when one works mongrel wood that good steel becomes a dominating factor.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#2

Re: Comparing chisel steels

Tom

+1 on that test. One of my favourite chisels is an O1 that doesn't even come up to home made temper standards. But it is just a great chisel. The edge holding is no problem in woods up to about cherry, but in hard maple it would not get reached for much if that was all I had.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#3

Re: Comparing chisel steels

Kees

Interesting Derek, a real world test so to speak.

Some time ago I had a similar task at hand, making a bunch of jatoba drawers, and my first tests with my vintage English chisels and some newer Nooitgedagt's showed how difficult this was going to be. The chisels just didn't cope with the pounding. Because I was in no hurry with that project I ordered some Koyamaichi's from Stu in Japan and was very pleasantly surprised also. I gave them a quick hone on my finest stone after each drawerside and the chisels just marched on throughout the entire job.

One thing they were not doing well was morticing. In my latest project I made some 9mm mortices and the chisels chipped too quickly for my taste. So, even the best have their achilles heels. A sturdy morticing chisel is now on my wish list.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#4

Re: Comparing chisel steels

Kees

Oh, BTW, watch out with your body. Easilly damaged, hard to cure.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#5

Re: Comparing chisel steels

Tom

You probably know this, but maybe someone out there does not... Don't pry Japanese chisels. I was once at the Toronto store, back when there was only one, and I noticed a basket full of 1/8" mortising chisels, Iroyo ones. Every last one of them had snapped, where the weld meets the throat. They had experienced a 100% failure rate, on those chisels, and this was possibly around the time when they dumped almost all their Japanese tools. It was kinda shocking. Mortising chisels are a good thing, but I can't imagine getting edge chipping from bench chisels, unless there were stones in the wood, or something.

Actually, when I went to the plane making seminar around 2000, the teacher used a wide bench chisel for all his mortising. This wasn't what I expected, because when I saw the guy who came out in the 70s, he was using a railroad spike type mortising chisel, extra stout. It's the player not the tool, I guess.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#6

Re: Temper too hard...

david weaver

... on the koyamaichi chisels to do mortising unless you drive them straight in and that's it.

What makes them so great as bench chisels (vs. some of the more mediocre japanese chisels, like the entry level iyorois) is that they seem to actually be hardened about where they say they are.

A lot of the entry level chisels that claim to be 64/65 hardness are closer to 60/61.

We tested an iyoroi mortise chisel on a rockwell tester about 6 or 7 years ago and found the average of the strikes to be 61 hardness. If it was 64 or 65, as it was advertised to be, most people probably wouldn't be able to use it.

The only super hard mortise chisels I've used (or have would be more accurate) are miyanaga, but they are purpose made mortise chisels and they are expensive if you buy them new.

short story long, I'd use something else for mortises and take advantage of the hardness in those chisels for straight-in tasks in wood.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#7

Re: Temper too hard...

Kees

Yes Tom and David you are probably right. Bear in mind that I am a newcomer in handtool morticing, so I most definetely do everything wrong.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#8

Re: Temper too hard...

david weaver

Well, if you drive the chisel to the bottom of the mortise and you can't at least move the chip a little bit if it's stubborn (not by scraping, but just by levering the chisel) then it's not going to be a good mortising chisel.

For reference, you can do just about anything in the world with the RI chisels, including scrape them right across the bottom of a mortise with two hands and still have an edge good enough to do the next mortise. I don't know why anyone would want to do that, but it's safe to say you'll never have something unexpected and catastrophic occurring.

The miyanaga chisels I referenced are blue steel. They are not quite to that level, but they'll mortise a tropical wood without incident. I couldn't say the same thing about my KI dovetail chisels, but that hardness those chisels have is what makes them so great for dovetails and light anything work.

(i.e., I'd rather have a tough chisel for mortising and a hard chisel for everything else).

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#9

what was the failure mode?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Could you tell if they chipped, deformed, simply wore away??

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#10

Re: what was the failure mode?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Good question Bill. I meant to add this at the time.

Both the PM-V11 and the A2 developed fine chips. This might may suggest that the steels are a tad too hard for this activity. On the other hand they had such diverging results, one successful and the other not. The HCS/O1 and the White Steel showed rounding, that is, neither chipping nor bending.

All blades have been in use for quite some time, and reground a few times (on a Tormek).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#11

Re: what was the failure mode?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had same experience with the LV steel.

Chisels are going to fail by chipping or deformation, so it is neither a surprise nor limitation that all the chisels got dull by one mode or the other.

One presumes that with the resources LV brought to bear that the optimum hardness was achieved. Softer and deformation dulled the chisel quicker, presumably.

Nice piece of work. Anyone not wedded to 1922, or earlier, technology will benefit from your observations.

BTW, you need to spend more money on wood and less on steel..... :)

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#12

Re: Temper too hard...

Tom

With a mortising machine of the 19th century type the chisels work exclusively up and down, and rotates through 180 degrees. That is the mechanical model of a zero pry system. Since it works efficiently and has been cast in iron, it is obviously an option.

I won't pry a japanese chisel under any circumstance, it is among other things a good way to teach oneself technique. I don't see a cutting difference between chopping dovetails, say, and mortising. Mortise chisels are stouter, and that is probably intentional, but a fair amount of the geometry is actually to work the cut, The stout bevel works the edge in the direction you want it to go. If one takes it merely as an invitation to do bad things, I think that is a mistake.

Japanese chisels are stout, but not all that strong in the direction of the pry. There is a bad stress raiser where the hard steel ends, which is were all the chisels I saw broke, notwithstanding being maybe 3/4" Thick.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#13

Re: Comparing chisel steels

cstanford

Marri images:

http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=marri+wood&qpvt=marri+wood&FORM=IGRE

Looks to be a pretty popular wood for furniture.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#14

Re: what was the failure mode?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If a chisel fails by chipping or deformation, there is something very wrong with the chisel or the worker.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#15

Marri specifications

cstanford

...can be found here (for anybody interested):

http://www.woodsolutions.com.au/Wood-Species/marri

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#16

Re: Comparing chisel steels

cstanford

I'm sure these guys mostly work it with power tools:

http://www.valleyfurniture.com.au/

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#17

Re: Comparing chisel steels

cstanford

Forest Products Commission, Western Australia:

http://www.fpc.wa.gov.au/content_migration/plantations/species/native_forests/marri.aspx

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#18

Re: Marri specifications

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Charles

Marri is a very popular timber for furniture in Western Australia. I cannot say that I like it much. The deep gum veins need to be filled with resin. It has become a common wood for the cheaper, mass-produced furniture. This is how it is commonly used ...


This one sold for $14000 (can you spell "over priced"? :O ) ...

http://www.boranupgallery.com/jarrah-furniture/dining-boardroom-tables/marri-single-slab-table/

Another - just too busy for my taste ...


The wood I am using is Curly Marri. Marri, but with an embedded curl, and much more interlocked grain. Here is an example off the internet ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#19

Re: what was the failure mode?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

For reference, the chisels took thin slices, around 1mm (or less). Mostly - where possible - chisels were pushed.

Note that the Veritas 3/4" was ground and honed at 25 degrees, while the others were 30 degrees. However, I have noticed fine chipping on these chisels as their typical form of failure. Is this a bad thing? Keep in mind that they do hold an edge a long time, and as a result did a lot more work than the A2 and the O1/HCS chisels. The A2 chipped quickly. The Veritas chipped eventually. It is quite likely that LV/Veritas got it just right (as hard as possible for the longest duration).

I plan to obtain a few good Butchers, and make some comparisons.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#21

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

CStanford

I've become intrigued by the talk about 'edge failure,' etc. EBay (the Australian iteration) has several jewelry box lots available and I've put out some feelers for shipping costs to the U.S. I'd like to get a little smidgen and see what I can cobble together with my meager kit of tools.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#22

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

CStanford

One man's 'edge failure' is another man's "I know this bloody thing will last to morning break."

So, we shall see.

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#24

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

CStanford

Fantastic. I'll be happy to do the same with a North American species. Just let me know. I think I have a few boards of tiger maple sitting around.

CS

Re: Comparing chisel steels

#25

Re: Power tools? You think so? 

david weaver

It won't bear any relevance to the test unless you use the same criteria. Anyone can smash a chisel into wood long after the edge begins to chip, but the parameters shown in this case were ability to pare. Not ability bludgeon.

Why wait for something from australia (which will cost half of a mint to ship), just one up it a little bit with some cheap hickory or pecan.

What would be much more impressive would be pictures of warren's chisels, where he's attested his ability to drive them without edge failure for quite a long time, and without reliance on uber hardness or powder metals. That would be much more instructive for the rest of us.