Re: Disagree
Tom
"Recently began to play a guitar. Takes a little bit of manual dexterity and some desire. The same two ingredients required to become a cabinet maker. Want to and the perserverance that want to produces are the keys to both."
That over simplifies. Some activities are dumbed down, T-ball for instance. Hitting a moving ball sent by a great pitcher is harder. It is just a fact that woodworking is an activity designed for the masses. Maybe working high steel is a thing not everyone can do, but most construction labour is something anyone with an able body could do. To be a combination of a great maker and Sheridan, might be a little more difficult, but they sensibly separated out those two classes of work. Woodworking is for dummies. Art is a matter of communication not just notching out the end of a board. If your current guitar skills are at a level where diligent application was the only thing that mattered, then you either aren't very good, or you are very gifted. Everything seems equally easy to the extremely gifted.
It should be pointed out that hobbies are often nothing more than someone else's low level job done by an amateur in their spare time. Consider hunting (actually very difficult in many situations). But every pre-literate shlub had to hunt. But it is an interesting activity when undertaken part time by a better educated kind of person, who can structure it with rules, and recite poetry and driking songs etc...
You can make hunting pretty difficult, but at the end the animal dies and it's over. Trophy hunting harder still. There isn't any limit to how good a song you can play, it is open ended. In theory woodworking could be open ended, but there is always someone like Bill (whose current level of play is actually pretty fancy), prattling on about how they have to make a buck, or how the seats on the chairs shouldn't slope so steeply that people slide off them. Economic, class, and style conventions seriously restrict what can be done.
"There is a level that cannot be learned. It is achieved through pure talent. A good coach can produce very good basketball players out of young men with some desire. Only God can produce LeBron James."
You are making my point. If B ball were dumbed down to the point where it involved either team taking turns carrying a ball to a pail and dropping it in, no extreme skill would make any difference. That is basically woodworking. The extreme level at which B ball is actually played is only possible for those with many different gifts. Startling size is an advantage for many, ability to read play, etc...