Tool needs
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
What tools are needed is a topic of great interest to someone that doesn't know and has a need. From personal experience it is easy to be led astray if the inexperienced person's motivation and/or skill differs much from the source of advice.
For building fine furniture I would argue that one needs a hand plane. For a beginner this tool can be a source of great frustration and it is easy to believe that spending more money for a plane will relieve it. I think someone like Steve Hamilton could make perfect dovetails with a hack saw. I found that the superior tacking of an expensive dovetail saw compensated for my lack of skill and experience. I find that professional furniture makers get by with far fewer tools than most amateurs. Then there are tools that are finely crafted or specifically designed for a task that can give the user great pleasure using them even if they offer little practical benefit in actually making something.
So it would seem that the novice would be faced with deciding if some tool was essential, whether paying more would yield a meaningful benefit in utility or whether a tool satisfied a higher purpose than getting product out the door. I think the novice embracing power tools has an easier time sorting through the information. But mistakes make good business for Ebay and the Classified.





