New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Tool needs

Posts

Tool needs

#1

Tool needs

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

What tools are needed is a topic of great interest to someone that doesn't know and has a need. From personal experience it is easy to be led astray if the inexperienced person's motivation and/or skill differs much from the source of advice.

For building fine furniture I would argue that one needs a hand plane. For a beginner this tool can be a source of great frustration and it is easy to believe that spending more money for a plane will relieve it. I think someone like Steve Hamilton could make perfect dovetails with a hack saw. I found that the superior tacking of an expensive dovetail saw compensated for my lack of skill and experience. I find that professional furniture makers get by with far fewer tools than most amateurs. Then there are tools that are finely crafted or specifically designed for a task that can give the user great pleasure using them even if they offer little practical benefit in actually making something.

So it would seem that the novice would be faced with deciding if some tool was essential, whether paying more would yield a meaningful benefit in utility or whether a tool satisfied a higher purpose than getting product out the door. I think the novice embracing power tools has an easier time sorting through the information. But mistakes make good business for Ebay and the Classified.

Re: Tool needs

#2

Re: Tool needs

Brian from Monument

Obviously, Skill and practice are greater than any collection of tools.

A variety of tools can make work easier but the worker needs to know how to use them and be a craftsman with the tool not just a tool "hack".

Re: Tool needs

#3

Re: Tool needs

Bruce McCrory

I think one can safely recommend "basic" needs for all matters, including life needs:

Hammer, circular saw (handsaw highly debatable), tape and hard measuring rules, chisel (plane highly debatable), squares (framing and smaller), screw drivers, rotary drills/driver (tailed--no batteries), belt/disc grinder, belt sander, hacksaw, pliers (pipe and channel-locks).

I pretty much survived on the above for 50 years. A bandsaw was a treat, only because fret and thin-blades coping saws were so bad. My first tool was a pocket Barlow, and the first one I still have is a Coast to Coast brand 1" chisel I needed for a kayak I made in high school. It's about a healthy inch shorter now.

The only caveat is spell out the brand of tools. Stanley was always the costly "mistake". And do avoid naming the stupid "Fester Tools" of price gouging.

That's what I think...

PS. A good finger-size LED flashlight, too.

Re: Tool needs

#4

Re: Tool needs

Patrick Gibbons

I think that someone new to woodworking needs to buy at least one albatross to hang around his neck. I still have two of my early mistakes that faithfully remind me every time I enter the shop not to repeat their history. I have sold the others. This is also a good reason to have these. As your "hobby" progresses, SWMBO gets less and less patient with your money squandering. Having a spare, unnecessary tool to sell can sometimes mean the difference between owning a new necessary tool or not. Also, the advise one is given and the one who gives that advise is taken down a good measure when you realize how worthless the information is. I believe that lesson alone has saved me time, treasure and torment on a monumental scale. Another consideration is that there are multiple tools to do a job. I have a Yankee drill, an eggbeater, braces, awls, gimlets, tool handles, electric drills and a drill press. They all are suitable for similar jobs though their differences determine which is better for a particular use. I don't feel they're duplicating functions. But they are. When you're starting out, some things need to be experienced before you develop a feel. In the old days one developed that feel by working with someone who was not new to the rodeo. Now you have to take on the bull by your lonesome.

Re: Tool needs

#5

Who here could build this?

cstanford

See the first photo at the link below. This was built in the 1600s, without benefit of Lee Valley and Lie-Nielsen, HSS or PM turning tools, electric lathes, etc.

http://www.museum.ie/en/exhibition/list/17th-century-furniture.aspx

Trust me, you have more tools than you need.

Re: Tool needs

#6

Re: Who here could build this?

david weaver

I'd bet the shop that chair came from wasn't short on tools, just a hunch, and especially if the shop built more than just chairs.

Most people have too many bench planes and block planes and no specialty tools and no decent carving tools.

And too little access to really good wood.

(aside from the fact that I doubt those shops lacked tools, and I doubt they had gobs of bench planes, I'd also bet that they had a fair amount of shop modified and shop made tools).

But whether or not that's accurate, I don't know if we should care unless we're wearing a costume and pretending to work in the 1600s. I also don't know what the big fascination is with amatuers to play "i'm professional, I'm going to do everything just like _____", except get paid. It's dumb. If you like the tools, buy them. Weather the flurries from the internet trolling. I can't remember the last time an internet trolling session made anything productive, anyway. Bet the guys who made that chair wouldn't be running around chastising others about their tools.

I'll bet we'd also find that they'd use their own work to make their points rather than using others' work for leverage instead of showing their own.

Re: Tool needs

#7

not so

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Trust me, you have more tools than you need. "

There are tools that will compensate for lack of skill or experience, and/or improve productivity. The challenge for someone motivated to build stuff is to figure out what tools will in fact compensate for lack of skill or experience, and/or improve productivity. There would be few making furniture if we were constrained to use Period tools and methods.

It might be of interest to poll SAPFM members to see if anyone constrains themselves to Period tools and techniques. Those I have met are highly motivated to make stuff so they don't eschew modern aids. I still recall the gasps from the audience when Alan Breed allowed that a CNC machine was a great way to waste out the center field of a table with a raised carved edge.

There are dozens, if not hundreds, of people in the US that could reproduce that chair with the aid of modern tools, but far fewer that could do it with tools and methods as it was originally done. While the carving would be done much as it was originally, the rest would be greatly aided and simplified by modern machines and methods.

On a personal note I simply would be be building the veneered desk if I had to so it with hide glue and hammer veneering. So for me, on this job, the modern tool is a must. The alternative would be more gardening.

Re: Tool needs

#8

Re: not so

cstanford

Explain how you think modern tools make this an easier piece to build, sparing us, if you will of the notion that edge longevity would make more than a trivial difference (and it wouldn't.)

Re: Tool needs

#9

Re: not so

cstanford

I think CNC would be a great way to waste out the center on dozens of tabletops. I think it's utterly stupid if somebody only wants to build only one.

Is Alan set up to manufacture these things now?

Do you think people want 18th century reproductions done with CNC? Can't they get that now by shopping at furniture chains?

Re: Tool needs

#10

Any of us of course...

John in NM

Given the drive to do so and practice, anyone interested enough in succeeding can build that chair. Lack of confidence and the resulting lack of practice is a much bigger hurdle than the distraction of a brass tool fixation.

The question is, who would want to build that thing? It's absolutely hideous :D

Re: Tool needs

#12

Re: Any of us of course...

cstanford

Practice, hell. How about right now? I could play Rachmaninoff's 2nd piano sonata if I practiced enough (for years). Then, I might buy a Steinway. Owning it to begin with wouldn't do one much at all about the technical expertise required to execute the piece. If I played it on an upright you'd still think I was a genius. If I played it on a Steinway in an acoustically perfect room then you'd have bought a ticket to hear it.

Re: Tool needs

#13

Re: Any of us of course...

cstanford

Here's a later Georgian piece you might find more to your liking. Maybe there are some fabulously well-equipped (or modestly equipped?) Centralians knocking out this sort of stuff. If so, I'd sure love it if they would make themselves known and make their brains available for picking. David Lamb is working at this level but I don't think he's resorted to CNC yet, but I could be wrong.

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/GEORGE-III-MAHOGANY-SECR%C3%89TAIRE-DISPLAY-CABINET-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=536660&categoryid=7759

Re: Tool needs

#14

Re: Any of us of course...

cstanford

How about this very tasteful tour-de-force:

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/SET-TEN-GEORGE-III-MAHOGANY-OPEN-ARMCHAIRS-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=495960&categoryid=1362

Is Rob Lee selling this sort of staircase to woodworking heaven?

Re: Tool needs

#15

Re: Any of us of course...

cstanford

Circa 1795 my friend... in a set of 10 chairs... those boys could get orders out the door.

Re: Tool needs

#16

Another late 18th C cutie:

cstanford

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/GEORGE-III-ROSEWOOD-BONHEUR-JOUR-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=184504&categoryid=1365

Be sure to read the description as there are no photos of the interior of this 'beaut.

Fans of veneer and inlay could use this as a study piece in design and execution.

Re: Tool needs

#17

Your wife mentioned....

cstanford

... how nice it would be to have a sideboard in the dining room and wondered what the production schedule would look like on this mid-18th century stunner:

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/GEORGE-III-MAHOGANY-SIDE-TABLE-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=536201&categoryid=12636

Re: Tool needs

#18

At last, a rectilinear project

cstanford

.... but kicked up a notch or two:

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/REGENCY-BRONZE-MOUNTED-BOOKCASE-THE-MANNER-THOMAS-HOPE-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=15238&categoryid=1336

Bookcase envy, anybody?

Re: Tool needs

#19

Mother's Day gift for Mum's plates

cstanford

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/REGENCY-MAHOGANY-BOOKCASE-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=342411&categoryid=1336

Aw shucks, ain't nothing to it with enough of the right tools.... yeah, right.

Re: Tool needs

#20

Re: Mother's Day gift for Mum's plates

cstanford

Only asking a measly 100,000 pounds for this one....

Nuttin' but a Summertime diversion with L-V and L-N kit brought to bear....

Re: Tool needs

#21

For fans of surface treatments and carving

cstanford

http://www.ronaldphillipsantiques.com/CHARLES-CREAM-JAPANNED-CABINET-SILVERED-STAND-DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=6&tabindex=5&objectid=17087&categoryid=7756

Easy chit in my book, how about yours?

Re: Tool needs

#22

Re: For fans of surface treatments and carving

cstanford

Circa 1680 folks. Over 330 years ago. Read the description. More than one of these were made out of the same shop.

Re: Tool needs

#23

Re: Any of us of course...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Charles, I'm not sure where you're headed with your various examples of very complex furniture in response to John's post. I don't think he was arguing that any of us could walk out to the shop and knock out one of those chairs, or any of the other pieces you posted (I will here mention that I didn't look at all of them but am presuming that they follow the pattern of those at which I did look: technically complex and well-designed within their particular design tradition).

Indeed, the two of you seem to be making the same argument: skill is essential, and you can't buy it from the tool catalogs.

Re: Tool needs

#24

Re: You can't buy skill...

david weaver

... but you can buy Skil, only one letter away from the real thing!!

Maybe that should be their marketing strategy.

Re: Tool needs

#25

Good heavens!

John in NM

Wow, 11 replies from one guy.... might want to cut back on the coffee :D

I wonder if any are worth reading? Probably not :\